Showing posts with label Options. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Options. Show all posts

Monday, December 4, 2017

Eric Peters: "Today"s Central Bank Vol Suppression Will End In Spectacular Fashion"

After his provocative admission published earlier that he now checks "Breitbart daily and InfoWars too... You can no longer understand America unless you do", One River"s CIO Eric Peters published the following anecdote revealing an earlier moment of his life, when as a currency trader, he learned a valuable lesson following the spectacular blow up of Europe"s Exchange Rate Mechanism, or ERM, and why the lesson from some 25 years ago, leads Peters to conclude that "Today’s central bank volatility suppression regime resembles it, and will end in spectacular fashion".








Anecdote:


 


“Let’s step into my office,” he said. So I did. He was my boss. “The firm’s most important client needs help.” I listened, uninterested, unconcerned about clients, their problems. Barely cared about my boss. I had a game to play, solo sport, and loved it to the exclusion of all else.


 


“They need to do a very large trade.” A twenty-six-year-old proprietary trader’s mind is rather primitive. Which is good and bad. Being young and dumb allows you to see things elders can’t. And take risks one rarely should. In 1992, I’d done both. “They need to buy three hundred million Mark/Lira.”


 


Europeans established a mechanism to lock their exchange rates into narrow ranges to reduce market volatility and promote economic convergence. In theory it worked, in practice it didn’t. Politicians named it the ERM.


 


“What would you like to do?” he asked, calm. I stood there, processing. Such a sum was extraordinary even before the ERM blew up, which it just had. For months, I’d bought options in anticipation of its demise. Honestly, it was obvious.


 


The ERM encouraged speculators to build massive leveraged carry positions, discouraged corporations from hedging exchange rate risk, suppressing volatility and interest rate spreads everywhere. The process was reflexive.


 


Today’s central bank volatility suppression regime resembles it, and will end in spectacular fashion. All such things do.


 


“I want to buy more!” I answered. My foreign-exchange options left me long the exact amount our client needed to buy. No other bank would sell them such a large sum. So naturally, I wanted more.


 


“You should sell them your whole position,” he told me, firm. I couldn’t understand, it made no sense. “Big customer orders like this usually mark the highs - never forget it,” he said. I left his office angry, irate, sold my whole position. And he was right.










Thursday, November 30, 2017

"Gold is in a Bear Leg..with an $1800 Target"

originally posted by the Soren K. Group on marketslant.com


Moor Report Summary:


If the title confuses you, do not be fooled. There is a short term outlook, that can change from day to day, an intermediate outlook that can change week to week, and a long term one. This changes month to month And they are not contradictory.


  • Short Term -  refers to daily outlooks here. It is choppy with repeated failures to pierce $1300. This calls for trading counter trend with a downward bias intraday Sell rallies, buy dips.... in that order.

  • Intermediate Term- We do not like trading week to week and have no feel for this time frame. To us, if the short term makes money, then take it home and see if it continues intermediate term.

  • Long Term- Buy it, buy it again, and keep buying it unleveraged with money you do not need for current cash flow or expenses; and hold it for 12 to 18 months with a target of $1700 plus. The only thing to  consider is if you buy more on any dip above $1245 (Fund  Finder level) then $1229 (Moor Level) and $1192, (from VBS). Then decide if you add on a break  above $1338. The macro is lined up. We seek the micro to start the ball rolling to add or pare positions.

Slow Rally Kills Shorts


We are in a limbo area right now, where a short term bull leg is triggered with a decisive penetration above $1294.50. And any settlement below $1292.20 is a short term bear leg. Accumulators buy while shorters seek weakness to push lower. Physical  accumulators  do not chase. It is the shorts who will ignite this if it is to accelerate  to the upside. We"d  prefer a slow melt up to $1338 so no hot money buys, and shorts can delude themselves


Michael"s analysis echoes what we see longer  term. Specifically, in 9-12 months he sees an upward  move bringing us to $1400 minimum,  and over $1800 maximum. This all happens as long as the market withstands any pressure down to $1229.


Our own  analysis remains unviolated adn fully intact. Funds are buying dips above the  12 month moving average, Volatility in the short term is starting to percolate, and long term volatility is flatlining. The low long term volatility implies the next move in Gold is not to be faded if  accompanied by  newly expanding long term volatility.


Simply put:


  1. SKG Fund Finder: Patient Long above the 12 month MA with a sell stop on a  monthly settlement below $1245

  2. Moor Analytics: Traditional Analysis says a long bias is in order with the ability to swing trade in either direction as described in the levels below

  3. Echobay"s VBS Macro: Explosive volatility on a move above $1338 or below $1192 in either direction. implying a $200 move in either direction if triggered

SKG Fund Finder - the 12 month MA said to buy in July/August on a settlement above the yellow line. Our refinement says now is when to buy based on line slope and risk /reward


?


 


Moor Analytics Weekly


GC (G)


On a short-term basis:


I cautioned that an area of possible exhaustion for the move up from 12628 came in at 13077-81.
We rejected $43.9 from this, but this is now on hold. The trade above 12896 (-1 tic (10 cents) per/hour) put us above a small
formation that projects this upward $5.5 minimum, $14.5 (+) maximum. We have seen $9.4 of this so far. This will come in at
12881 (-1 tic (10 cents) per/hour starting at 6:00pm). If we break back below, look for profit taking to come in. The trade
above 12925 brought in $6.5 of the strength warned about above before rolling over. Decent trade below 12792 (+.3 of a tic
(3 cents) per/hour starting at 6:00pm) will project this downward $20 minimum, $24 (+) maximum; but if we break below here
decently and back above decently, look for decent short covering to come in. A maintained gap lower tomorrow will leave a
short term bearish reversal intact above that will warn of decent pressure, likely for days. Trade above 12990 is a sign of
renewed strength.


On a macro basis:


We broke above a well-formed macro line in the week of 8/7 that came in at 12629. The break above here
projects this upward $174 minimum, $493 (+) maximum—the maximum to be attained likely within 9-12 months. This line
comes in at 12294 this week, and rolls into (G).
This is off hold, or you could wait for a decent break above the 12947-54 area
mentioned below for added confirmation. Within that we rallied up to a macro resistance line on 9/11 at 13522 that I said we
are looking for a multi-week smackdown from-- we were seeing some of this as we have come off $89.4, but this is on hold.
We left a medium term bearish reversal intact above on 9/18 that also warned of continued pressure in the days/weeks ahead.
We have seen $48 so far. This too is on hold. Within the bearishness I noted that a possible area of exhaustion for this move
down from 13624 comes in at 12732-644. We basically held this, but with a $1.6 violation, and rallied to 13084 before rolling
over and rejecting from it again. Decent trade below 12682 will project this downward $31 minimum, $97 (+) maximum based
off a well-formed formation. Decent trade above 12950 will project this upward $23 minimum, $47 (+) maximum based off an
‘ok formed’ formation; but if we break above here decently and back below decently, look for decent profit taking to come in.


Email Michael for subscription info : Michael Moor



VBS MACRO


Volatility Cycles more cleanly than price. it could stay low for months, but is far less likely to give false  signals. 


?


In Gold and Silver, we use 1.5 STD on BBands and relationships not shown here between historical and implied that corroborate or negate a signal- SK


Good Luck


Dear Readers:


"Day job" obligations are making it difficult to expend resources toward writing original pieces consistently. We do not have a Soren K. site but wish to continue writing. To do so we will need to incur expenses. Marketslant is kind to post our work and the work of others here. We hope to be setting up a Soren K. Group Patreon page in the next weeks to continue giving our original work, as well as proprietary research for Precious Metals traders. Anytng offered will be greatly appreciated. 


We  also hope to do the following for readers


  1. weekly settlement price competition for token prizes - Silver Eagles etc.

  2. opportunity to guest post under SKG and on zerohedge where we write and  post under Vince Lanci"s Blog

  3. Ability to  place  your own editorials on Kitco if they accept as relevant to the market. 

Finally we are in the process of raising capital for a fund and are speaking to seeders in that pursuit. Between our SKG members we have  65 years trading experience in PM, Energy, and Equities. Among our group are algo writers, analysts, $BB Fund partners, lawyers, Wall Street bank executives, and other complementary minds. Trade ideas we execute when up and running will be shared with site Patrons as investors permit. 


If you have an opinion, interest or wish to write please contact us at


Sorenk@marketslant.com









Wednesday, October 25, 2017

BofA: "The Market Implies There Is No Way A Shock Can Happen"

For today"s moment of volatility zen, we go to BofA"s Nikolay Angeloff who drew the short straw to be the (un)lucky pundit whose comments on record complacency, low volatility, etc publicized.


Angeloff starts with pointing out what we noted over the weekend , namely that we have now recorded 334 days without a 5% or more pullback (and 335 after today"s close), the fourth longest period on record since 1928.



In another market distortion, whether due to ETFs or central banks, equity vol has fallen so far in October, historically the most volatile month of the year, and if it continues at this pace, it will be the least volatile October in history...



... and third least volatile month ever.


Looking at the above two charts, it is no surprise that at this 30yr anniversary of the ’87 crash, the BofA analyst concludes that "the market seems to currently imply there is no way a shock can happen. However, in part due to today’s low realized volatility creating a steep implied term-structure, along with higher fragility driving steeper skew across tenors, the entry point for “S&P fragility hedges” in the form of put ratio calendars has never been more attractive."


We"ll have more to say on his (costless) hedge recommendation tomorrow, but first here is some more on what the ongoing market distortions mean in practical terms:








Markets mark the 30Y anniversary of Black Monday midst chatter of fragility. On 19-Oct-1987, the S&P 500 experienced its worst day in history (since 1928) when the index plummeted 20.5% in a single trading session. The total loss over the month leading to and including the market crash amounted to 27.6%, a 6.6-sigma event.


 



 


Counter to many peoples’ common belief, a shock of this magnitude would be unprecedented today. Our previous work has shown that there is historically a limit of how large shocks can be based on the prevailing realized volatility. With today’s much lower levels of realized vol, a 6.6 sigma event would correspond to a lesser monthly selloff of only 11.5%



Well, as long as it is "only" 11.5%, one can probably count the number of central banker suicides on "only" one hand as these central-planning mandarins watch the fruit of their centrally-planned labor go up in smoke.


Angeloff"s conclusion:








"generally, the longer time passes without an abrupt market correction, the higher the likelihood of it happening. Markets pricing very little potential for a shock seems at odds with still elevated geopolitical and policy risk globally. Additionally, some have increasingly refocused on quant fund positioning risks, and as we have argued previously CTA and risk parity flows (and the fear of them) can add fuel to (but not cause) a potential sell-off. Notably we see their equity allocations likely at a high (for CTAs this is due to the coincidental occurrence of a strong trend in performance and record-low vol). Thus, an equity sell-off or an uptick in volatility could cause these portfolios to de-lever their equity allocations and so could exacerbate an equity market correction (Charts 14 & 15). However, we still do not believe they would be the sole drivers of an ’87 style crash.




* * *


Two final observations:


For Oct-17, the VIX settled at 10.53, which is 10.6 points below the 2004-2016 October average of 21.2 (less than half). This is the greatest difference between a monthly settlement and monthly average so far in 2017. For comparison, Sep-17’s settlement of 9.87 was 9.82 points below the September average, the second largest discrepancy so far this year. What’s more, on an absolute level October has the second highest monthly settlement on average (21.2), second only to November (22.0). Regardless, Oct-17’s 10.53 was the second lowest monthly settlement realized thus far in 2017.



In stark contrast with historical trends, realized volatility on SPX has dropped in the month of September and if volatility does not pick up materially from here, the month of October will mark the second monthly drop in a row. Indeed, realized volatility in the month of October thus far is 3.5 vol pts. If realized volatility remains flat for the remainder of the month, this would be the third lowest monthly volatility in the history of the index, which realized less volatility only in Feb-64 and Aug-65. Historically SPX realized volatility tends to drop in the month of November. However, this year may witness a break of that pattern given the likely low level for the month of October. In addition the real battle over tax reform will likely start in early November and that the process from here will neither be pretty or smooth...










Monday, October 23, 2017

It"s Time To Take Central Bankers" "Calm Assurances" With A Pinch Of Salt

"It could be time to fire up your engines," suggests former fund manager Richard Breslow, urging some life back into the seemingly oblivious markets...



Via Bloomberg,


There’s a lot of uncertainty out there and the response to it shouldn’t be an inability to trade. How about a little frenetic back and forth?


We could use some of the good kind of noise, as in, let’s show a little life. Markets are inching toward some really interesting levels and it’s time for them to show a little spirit and giddy up.


For once, try taking central bankers at their word that tapering and, eventually, rates, are on the move. And take all of these blithe assurances that everything during the process will be calm, cool and collected with a grain of salt. We need to stop saying global economic growth and trade are showing meaningful strength and then agree that everything is still horrible and we can’t afford to change.


 



 


Do you know why there’s no inflation? We measure it incorrectly. I can assure you it’s more expensive to live than it used to be. Which is the simplest and truest definition. Why isn’t wage growth higher? Because we’ve utterly skewed the relative bargaining power between capital and labor. Monetary policy will never be able to fix that. Nor the masses forever soothed by rolling out another reality show.


 


No matter who is selected as the next Fed Chair, rates are likely going up in December and will be in play for March. Tapering is beginning. The BOE is looking to pull back some stimulus and the ECB wants to as well. Even the BOJ has begun to include warnings about investor complacency in their comments. Yesterday’s Japanese election may seem like a strong endorsement of the status quo, but it has also changed the underlying discussion on a number of topics in a meaningful way. The Bank of Canada may be on pause, but they are among a number of banks waiting to pull the switch.


 


At whatever point along the Treasury yield curve you look, the charts suggest we have crept up to important pivot points. And it’s going to be even more apparent if the recent mini bounce in its steepness can generate some momentum. What a difference it will feel like if the 10-year can break above 2.40%. Not a big ask given we sit so close below. Yet, if it was so easy, we wouldn’t be having this discussion. Twos and fives are right where they will have to decide whether to fish or cut bait. Where they go from here matters. And if I wanted to be a starry-eyed optimist, I’d point out that while it remains low, option volatility has traced out a nice floor since July and has been trying to push higher in the last week.


 



 


The dollar, too, is showing some signs of life, even though the majors continue to see volatility selling. The dollar index traded at 94 this morning and if it can eke out another half-percent, there’s going to be a different narrative circulated.


 



 


Which countries’ set of woes will take center stage? Or to put it another way, how much of whose bad news is already priced into prevailing levels?



As Brewslow concludes, "I hope this all leads to something interesting... Because who wants to sit around watching the paint dry some more."


In any case, at these prices, you definitely have something well worth watching. Volatility pricing can be backward looking as well as prescriptive.









Thursday, October 12, 2017

"Black Swan" Anxiety Has Never Been Higher

The Fed"s Williams warns that they "don"t want there to be excesses in financial markets... "


Two quick things...


The market has almost never been this expensive...


As Peter Boockvar warns: "Almost there. S&P 500 price to sales ratio is just 4% from March 2000 peak."



And investors have never been more concerned about "black swans"...


As Bloomberg notes, concern is building that years of record-setting gains for U.S. stocks may give way to a market plunge, according to Jim Paulsen, Leuthold Group Inc.’s chief investment strategist. In a report Monday, he cited the Chicago Board Options Exchange’s SKEW Index, which shows the perceived risk for a so-called black-swan event that’s reflected in S&P 500 Index option prices.



Trade accordingly...

Sunday, October 1, 2017

A Market In Which "Shocks No Longer Shock": Deutsche's Kocic Explains How To Trade It

Back in June, one of Wall Street"s more philosophical derivatives strategists, DB"s Aleksandar Kocic looked at the state of the market and postulated that far from "stable" the existing risk  "equilibrium" is one which can be described as "metastable", the result of widespread complacency, and which he compared to an avalanche where "a totally innocuous event can trigger a cataclysmic event (e.g. a skier’s scream, or simply continued snowfall until the snow cover is so massive that its own weight triggers an avalanche." Putting it in his usual post-modernist style, Kocic said that "complacency encourages bad behavior and penalizing dissent – there is a negative carry for not joining the crowd, which further reinforces bad behavior."





This is the source of the positive feedback that triggers occasional anxiety attacks, which, although episodic, have the potential to create liquidity problems. Complacency arises either when everyone agrees with everyone else or when no one agrees with anyone. In these situations, which capture the two modes of recent market trading, current and the QE period, the markets become calm and volatility selling and carry strategies define the trading landscape. But, calm makes us worry, and persistent worrying causes fear, and fear tends to be reinforcing.



Kocic framed the current state of the market as follows:




Unfortunately, the relentless grind ever lower in volatility, which as reported yesterday has resulted in both the lowest average September VIX on record...




... as well as the lowest September monthly settlement on record and only the second sub-10 monthly settlement... 



... appears to have finally unsettled Kocic" expectations, even if ever so tacitly implied, for a spike higher in suppressed vol, and as he writes in his latest ruminations on volatility, "as volatility continues to be unfazed by what lies ahead in the near term, short of surprises in inflation, we are likely to linger at low levels."


Following up to his note from last week, which explained how the Fed"s fake "transparency" killed long-term investor, Kocic writes that "as transparency became the word of the decade, by its very nature it created the forces that push everything to the surface. Things exist thanks only to the attention they produce. There is no room for ambiguity." 


Which ties in to the current news cycle, a relentless barrage of flashing red headlines, one scarier than the other, yet which on aggregate have zero adverse impact on volatility, and certainly on risk assets, which on Friday spiked to a new all time high following the latest last-second VIX-smash. Or, as Kocic puts it, "although shocks (political and other) keep arriving in the market, they seem to be appearing at what looks like predictable time intervals (usually, on Fridays). Practically every week, there is a new issue that eclipses the previous one, and we lose interest in past issues, before there is any semblance of resolution."


And with traders" attention spans already severely lacking, this habituation to hyperbolic, staccato newsflow means that not only is the market not discounting the future as Matt King postulated several months ago, but it is no longer able to even respond to the present, to wit:





Shocks, if they are predictable, lose their spell and gradually become facts of life. Predictable political shocks feed back into their source. Due to their antagonistic character, they gradually erode the ability to make consensus and reduce the ability to legislate, making further reforms at least questionable, if not highly unlikely. The market “euphoria” (aka the Trump trade) that followed immediately after the elections is being perceived as increasingly remote. Despite all the promises of reflation of the economy, fiscal stimulus, expectation of economic turnaround, no change is on the horizon. We are stuck with the status quo, albeit a noisy one.



So what does this mean for risk assets, and markets? According to the Deutsche analyst, "despite all the distortions and disruptions introduced by the central banks’, which has created a semi-permanent state of exception, markets have not lost one main characteristic, their adaptability. As the markets are getting inoculated against event risk, volatility continues to be under pressure. While we are distancing ourselves from the idea of political change, the Fed is seen, once again, as the main source of volatility. However, the Fed’s position is an uncomfortable one. The main problem it faces is the balance between preventing inflation from becoming a risk while at the same time not causing a rapid and substantial rise of rates. This requires a high level of fine tuning. It means that the Fed has to continue with rate hikes, but the hikes have to be done carefully without triggering the bond unwind."


The implication for vol traders is that contrary to warnings of market "metastability" and "suppressed cataclysmic vol events", Kocic - in many ways pulling a Hugh Hendry of his own - comes to the admission that fighting the Fed"s control over vol has become a futile pastime, and even though further complacency is in the cards, "continued vol selling" is encouraged.





... the market gradually, and reluctantly, trails behind the Fed, one hike at a time, and adjusts expectations on the go, without taking a longterm view on the Fed. It is difficult to see how this can lead to any excitement capable of inspiring higher volatility. As long as things evolve according to this scenario, everything shoiuld remain “predictable” with occasional noise that the market has learned to ignore. This is an environment that is bearish for volatility. It fosters further complacency and encourages continued vol selling.



Finally, Kocic takes a "Greek" detour and asks whether in this environment, in which every shock is ignored by a market now programmed to sell vol no matter what, "there is hope for Gamma?" Here is his answer:





In our recent publications, we have extracted one possible measure of liquidity from the volume data of Treasury futures. This measure quantifies sensitivity of the price to changes in trading volume. The liquidity index is expressed as a negative log of this sensitivity, so that large sensitivity corresponds to low liquidity and vice versa. The figure shows the (smoothed) liquidity (on the inverted axis) overlaid with the 3M10Y– low vol goes hand in hand with high liquidity.





Liquidity has a logical connection with volatility. This starts at the very short end and propagates across the term structure: By making a price, market makers are implicitly short volatility for which they are required to allocate risk capital and the bid/ask spread (which is an indirect measure of liquidity) is the compensation they receive for this risk exposure. All else equal, the ability to hedge an option is a function of liquidity of the underlying, and the option prices should reflect that. From the figure, we note that post 2004, with the disappearance of mortgage negative convexity hedging and the growth of  volume on the exchanges, liquidity has been providing a lower bound for gamma – whenever gamma reached this lower bound, it has been pushed up. Also, the departures from that lower bound have been increasingly rarer and short lived. This holds not only for rates, but for equities as well.



As volatility continues to be unphased by what lies ahead in the near term, short of surprise in inflation, we are likely to linger at low levels. In that context, liquidity constraints are going to define the lower bound on gamma.



As a reminder, none of this is new: those who have traded this market (for more than just a few years) instead of merely commenting on it, will recall all those vol traders who lost their jobs in early 2007 when vol crashed so hard, there literally wasn"t a swaptions market. If Kocic is right, vol traders in 2017 (and perhaps 2018) will suffer the same fate. Of course, the 2007 episode is best remembered not for the the vol linked pink slips, but the explosion in VIX shortly thereafter and the resultant near collapse of the US financial system. Despite the Fed"s relentless pressure, trillions in liquidity injections and vol selling, we see nothing that has changed since then, and no reason why this time will be different.

Tuesday, September 12, 2017

SocGen: "Now Entering Dangerous Volatility Regimes"

With the VIX back to a 10-handle and eagerly eyeing single-digits once again, commentary on market complacency and the low VIX, which was blissfully gone for the past month when the VIX surged valiantly if briefly only to be smacked right back down, has returned. In a note from SocGen"s Praveen Singh, the French bank analyst boldly goes where so many prognosticators have gone before, and looking at the evolving cross-asset volatility trends, warns that the market is "now entering dangerous volatility regimes."


Hardly stating the unknown, Singh writes that "expected volatility has been falling consistently. Over the last year, expected volatility has been falling on a consistent basis. When we look at equity and  government bonds, the current  level of volatility is well below long-term average volatility. Falling volatility normally means stable environment for risk assets."



So time for some (familiar) numbers: the current low level of volatility happens less than 2% of the time for equities. In the following chart, SocGen plots the distribution of equity volatility based on data since 1994. The bank"s analysis suggests that average equity volatility has been above the current level 98% of the time. This means that volatility is more likely to go up than fall further from current levels... at least in theory, of course. In practice, what it means these days is that some central banks unload a few thousand VIX contracts to prevent any vol spike at just the right time.



Undeterred, SocGen presses on and warns that - central banks aside - in the past, equity volatility has bottomed at around current levels and rose subsequently. Volatility has a strong mean-reverting tendency.





"Hence, we observe that periods of particularly low volatility are often followed by periods of relatively higher volatility."




Of course, It"s not just equities: The low level of volatility is pervasive across asset classes and as Singh shows in the chart below, "we compare the current level of volatility with the historical range. We find that for most asset classes the current level of volatility is near the lower end of its long-term range."



Again, none of the above is new, and it goes to one fundamental theme involving vol: mean-reversion, a phenomenon which always happens, yet which has been sorely lacking in the space for a long, long time. As such, all SocGen is saying is that "it"s time"... but is it? Many traders have been crushed betting on an imminent vol surge, which never materialized. Why will this time be any different? Here"s SocGen"s rationalization:





How long can volatility stay this low? In the past, when equity market volatility was around the current level, it went on to rise by 3 points in the subsequent 12 months. In the below charts, we show evolution of equity volatility between 2007 and 2009. We note that:


  • Equity volatility troughed in February 2007, around eight months ahead of the US equity market peak. The current level of equity volatility is very similar to what we saw in February 2007. Equity market volatility started to rise in the subsequent months.

  • We note that the dislocation in equity market volatility is much greater than the dislocation in government bonds.



Finally, does SocGen"s concern mean investors should get out of stocks? Well... not really. As Singh concludes, the current low level of volatility makes equities our preferred asset class as risk-adjusted return is higher. However, a subsequent rise in volatility means: i) Balanced asset allocation, i.e. 50% equity and 50% fixed income, is better than a more dynamic (higher equity) allocation. ii) Equity re-allocation i.e. avoid areas where risk-adjusted return is deteriorating (US equity allocation has been reduced in our latest Q-MAP balanced portfolio). iii)  Increase cash allocation (our cash allocation has been increased from 5% to 10%).


So after predicting that a 2007 vol episode may be imminent (as a reminder, back then the VIX briefly tagged 80 in the process destroying all vol sellers), SocGen"s brave reco is to increase cash from 5% to 10%. One may just buy bitcoin instead.

Thursday, August 24, 2017

The Cost Of Market Crash Insurance Just Hit A Record High

With the VIX surging, and then quickly getting pummeled on two occasions in the past three weeks, dizzy traders could be forgiven to assume that any latent "risk off" threat, whether from North Korea or the US political front, has been taken off the table. However, a deeper look inside the vol surface reveals something very different: with increasingly more analysts and traders warning that volatility is set for a sharp return this fall, equities have already been adjusting to the increased probability of a "tail event." However, instead of buying VIX futures, call or ETPs, they have been doing so by bidding up the price of OTM equity put options, or equivalently, by steepening the S&P 500 put skew and.


As a reminder, a put skew shows how much more expensive it is to buy deep OTM puts vs puts that are in the money or in other words, a levered bet on (or hedge against) a market crash.


 And as the following chart from Bank of America shows, the S&P put skew is now at the highest level on record, making the relative price of tail hedges the highest in 13 years as traders are quietly bracing for a sharp market crash.



While not new, Bank of America again underscored the potential risk in the coming months to actively managed portfolios from a possible volatility flaring event, primarily impacting risk-parity portfolios. This is what the team of BofA Benjamin Bowler wrote in an overnight note:





Both equity and bond valuations are high. In a report from last week, our equity strategists pointed out that the S&P 500 forward P/E expanded in July and hit its loftiest level since the Tech Bubble. Even at these elevated levels, equities look attractive relative to bonds whose risk premium is more than 50% above its long-term average. This is clearly a concern for portfolios that invest in both classes (risk parity). A significant risk for multi-asset managers going forward is a breakdown in the diversification between stocks and bonds in which we see simultaneous declines in both asset classes similar to the ‘Taper Tantrum’ in May/Jun-13 or to a slightly lesser extent the risk-off event from Aug-15 two years ago. It may be surprising to an equity investor, but for a multi-asset manager these two declines were the largest since 2008 and equal to 50% of the drawdowns from the GFC. With multi-asset vol so low, for those managers who use leverage, the leverage levels may be high and therefore their portfolios may be more sensitive to a breakdown in correlation.



Bank of America then writes that with both rates and equity volatility at historically low levels, however with correlations between the two rising, going into the fall - even if equities and rates remain range-bound - an uptick in volatility could lead to outsized jumps in a cross-asset vol pair trade.





Interestingly, for most of this year an increase in equity volatility has tended to coincide with an increase of rates volatility. The payout is dependent on rates going higher and equities falling from current levels, so it is implicitly short equity/rates correlation. This correlation has had an increase over the past month and provides for an attractive entry point (Chart 11)."



Indeed, while many traders point out that intra-equity correlation has dropped to near all time lows, traditionally a welcome sign for active investors as it provides return dispersion and alpha creation abilities that are detached from broader macro conditions, looking at cross-asset vol shows a very different picture. As the following two charts show, correlation between rates and equity volatility, or MOVE and VIX, shows a sharp spike in recent weeks. In fact, as Chart 10 shows, the correlation is now the third highest on record. Confirming this troubling observation, Chart 11 shows that the correlation between the underlying asset classes has also soared in recent weeks, after plumbing near record lows just weeks ago.



To explain the surge in put skew, below we present several observations from BofA on why the recent period of record low volatility appears to be coming to an abrupt end.


1. The S&P recorded three moves of at least +/- 1% within a six days span, the first time this has occurred since September 2016. In fact, prior to the 1.48% loss on 10-Aug, SPX hasn’t moved morethan +/- 0.3% in a single day since 19-Jul.





"These larger one-day moves are evidence that the record-low vol we’ve seen throughout the summer may be starting to come to an end. As we’ve noted recently, seasonal trends and a fall which encompasses numerous catalysts (including the debt ceiling deadline, the September FOMC meeting, and political reform negotiations) suggest that the extreme quiet may not last much longer."




2. Last week, the VIX recorded +30% spikes twice in a six day period (10-Aug, when the VIX jumped 44.37% and 17-Aug, when the VIX jumped 32.45%). This is only the third time ever that we’ve seen two such drastic moves occur in that short a period of time.


"Notably, the only other two times this has occurred were early August 2011, immediately following S&P’s downgrade of US government debt, and August 2015, when markets were rattled over fear of slowing growth in China. The seasonally low vol environment typically seen during late summer may be a contributing factor to these occurrences as each has happened during August."



3. On 8-Aug-17, the total number of VIX call options (including all strikes and all expiration dates) was 1,994,418, an all-time high, as investors piled into long call options amid the rising tensions with North Korea. The amount of options traded surpassed other notable highs on 3-Feb-2014 and 13-July-2015, when 1.85mn and 1.93mn call options were traded, respectively. "The former period saw investors buying VIX calls due to a global selloff sparked by concerns over Asia and EM, and the latter period saw purchases on the back of Grexit fears."



4. On 17-Aug SPX fell 1.5%, the second largest decline YTD since the 17-May 1.8% drop and similar to the 1.4% sell-off on 10- Aug. However, in one regard this sell-off was remarkably different.





"Specifically, markets this time around appeared to have made little distinction between different pockets of the market. For instance, the underperformance of cyclical sectors vs. defensives was less pronounced in the latest sell-off. Consequently, also the relative moves in volatility were not as significant as in the past two largest sell-offs YTD. This could signal the beginning of a new narrative whereby market participants are more skeptical about the prospective of a pro-business agenda being pushed forward in Washington; as such they stop differentiating between potential losers and winners from the aforementioned agenda."



Monday, August 7, 2017

Elevated 2018 Estimates Widen Gap Between GAAP & Non-GAAP Earnings

Via Hedgopia.com,


As of last Thursday, a little over four-fifths of S&P 500 companies reported 2Q17 results.  Of the 422 companies, 70.1 percent beat on operating earnings, 20.6 percent missed and 9.2 percent met, as per S&P Dow Jones Indices.


In the latest week (through Thursday), 2Q17 estimates went up by $0.33 week-over-week to $31.03.  When the quarter came to an end, estimates were $30.97.  Going back many quarters, actual earnings have come in lower than expected at the time of the quarter-end.  From this perspective, the hitherto 2Q17 trend is an improvement, although one-fifth are yet to report.


The increase in 2Q17 estimates also helped push up 2017 estimates by $0.13, to $127.64, even as 2018 went down by $0.40 to $144.77.  More important perhaps is the revision trend, which is down.


In January last year, 2017 was expected to come in at $141.11.  In January this year, 2018 estimates were $147.21 (Chart 1).


The downward trend in 2017/2018 estimates is nothing new, considering how 2015 and 2016 fared.  In both those years, actual operating earnings were substantially less than the sell-side’s original estimates.


As things stand, 2018 expectations look way elevated.




There is a tight correlation between GDP and corporate profits.


U.S. corporate profits adjusted for inventory valuation and capital consumption peaked at $2.23 trillion in 4Q14, with 1Q17 at $2.11 trillion.  Since that peak, profits fell year-over-year in five quarters and rose in four, including gains of 3.3 percent in 1Q17.


Growth in real GDP peaked around the same time – in 3Q14, when the economy expanded at a 5.2 percent annual rate.  In 2Q17, it grew 2.6 percent.  This was higher than the post-Great Recession average of 2.2 percent, but much lower than the long-term average of 3.2 percent going back to 2Q47.



The economy is in its ninth year of recovery.  Expecting it to accelerate at this time is probably a risky bet.  That said, 2018 earnings estimates probably do exactly that.


Valuation multiples are priced off of these estimates.  Stocks are at/near all-time highs, with elevated multiples.  Using trailing 12-month numbers as of 1Q17, the S&P 500 traded at 21.3 times operating and 23.6 times reported earnings.


Hence another equally important question, how clean are these estimates?


Chart 3 plots both operating (non-GAAP) and reported earnings (GAAP) of S&P 500 companies going back to 4Q10.  (Except for the lighter-shade bars within the blue box, these are actual numbers.)



One distinct trend in particular since 4Q14 is that the gap between the two is widening.


Companies are required to report GAAP earnings, not non-GAAP.  Non-GAAP numbers are reported by the reporting company, but they do reconcile the two.


There are times companies have perfectly good reason to request/ask analysts/investors to ignore certain items.  Irregular or non-cash expenses or one-time charges, for example.


Restructuring expenses, stock-based compensation, goodwill amortization are some of the non-GAAP exclusions.  In general, this does tend to smooth out earnings volatility.


The problem arises when this becomes a permanent fixture.  Stock-based compensation among many tech outfits, for example.


Chart 4 subtracts operating earnings of S&P 500 companies from reported earnings going back to 1988.



The difference was minuscule at the beginning.  It began to grow circa 2000, and has stayed.  In both 2002 and 2008, GAAP took a massive hit, as assets got impaired, so both these years are more of an outlier.  But even excluding these, the trend is not getting better.  The discrepancy between GAAP and non-GAAP is not narrowing.


This raises questions about the quality of non-GAAP earnings, which is what the investing community in general focuses on.  This gap is easy to ignore in good times, but maybe not so when bad times hit.

Thursday, July 13, 2017

Someone Just Made An "Unprecedented" Bet On An Imminent Surge In Bond Volatility

Step aside "50 cent", there is a new mystery vol trader on the block, one who is certain that a vol quake is about to strike US Treasurys.


According to Bloomberg, which first spotted the trade, someone just bet that bond volatility is about to soar. The unknown trader bought $10 million in out-of-the-money puts and calls on 10Y Treasury futs (a strangle). The outsized trade was spotted as it involved huge block sizes of about 63,500 on either side: "a strangle of that magnitude is rare, and possibly unprecedented" according to several rates traders who spoke to Bloomberg.



But just as notable as the size is the timing: the strangle expires July 21, giving the trade a shelf life of under 10 days before it expires worthless. Which means that the trader is confident enough about not only the size of the upcoming price swing to bet $10 million on it, but also when it will strike.  According to Bloomberg calculations, the theta on the trade is so high that just to recoup the premium, the yield on the 10Y would have to rise or fall about 10 bps from 2.38%, and preferably very soon.


Once the 10Y moves beyond 10bps, gains are unlimited, and the trader "stands to gain about $50 million on a quarter-point move in either direction from the starting level, which would involve approaching this year’s highs and lows for 10-year yields."


Briefly this morning, the trade seemed like slam dunk when Yellen"s "dovish flip" sent the 10Y tumbling 6 bps before it stabilized around 2.32%.


But it"s not over yet: as Bloomberg observes there are enough potential catalysts in the coming week to send the 10Y surging... or tumbling:





The calendar over the next several days presents ample opportunities to rekindle volatility. In the U.S., political drama aside, the Labor Department releases consumer price index data Friday, which could influence the Fed’s timing for rate hikes and balance-sheet reduction. Retail sales data come out the same day. And, the day before the position expires, the European Central Bank announces a policy decision.



Backtesting the trade does not give high odds of success: not only has MOVE (the Tsy vol index) plunged alongside VIX, suppressing price swings but the 10Y yield has risen or dropped by more than 10 basis points just four times this year on a weekly basis, compared with 10 times in the same period of 2016 according to Bloomberg calculations. Then again, lightning may be about to strike twice: at last check, the MOVE was trading at levels just before the 2013 Taper Tantrum. We all know what happened to bond volatility after.


What about the mysterious trader"s counterparty - are they, inversely, betting that vol remains subdued for the next 10 days? This time the market maker appears to not be convinced that the prevailing lack of volatility will persist, and as Bloomberg concludes, "the total volumes traded in the two options Tuesday exceeded the open interest change" suggesting that the other side of the trade was likely hedged.


Finally, what is perhaps also notable is that while the trader has a very high conviction on a surge in rates vol, there was no comparable bet on exploding vol in any other asset classes, which may be an option for anyone wishing to piggyback on the trade, as such a sharp move in US Treasurys will certainly reverberate not only in US equities but in bonds around the globe.

Sunday, June 11, 2017

Hedge Fund CIO: "$100BN Of Tech Stocks Got Sold And The S&P Was Unchanged. Not Sure How That Happens"

The start of another week is upon us, which means it is time for choice excerpts from the latest letter to clients by One River Asset Management CIO Eric Peters, who today writes about Brexit, the "new generals" in the market (more in a later post), rising populism in a world of tech "monopolies", modern day robber barons, and much more.


We will have more from today"s letter shortly, but for now here is Peters on a topic on everyone"s minds, volatility, and what Friday"s Nasdaq "air pocket" means:





Beep Beep



“Volatility didn’t really move,” said Roadrunner, following the Nasdaq’s Friday afternoon air-pocket decline.



“There were no real flows, no one was buying options,” continued the market’s biggest volatility trader. “I’d expect this to continue for a bit at least.” These kinds of things don’t usually end in a single day.



“$100bln of tech stocks got sold and drove the Nasdaq 100 down 4% with the S&P 500 and Russell 2000 unchanged. Not sure how that happens,” said Roadrunner. “But summer is here, people leave at noon, and liquidity is thinning out.”




“The idea of a ‘new normal’ in volatility markets is utter nonsense,” continued Roadrunner. “There is never anything new when it comes to markets.”



We are just at that point in the cycle where volatility collapses - at the end, it always does. “We’re late in a bull market, and like every bull the scariest moves are to the downside.”



Nivida ($89bln mkt cap) fell 15% on Fri from intraday high-to-low, which left it +4% on the week and +46% on the year. He glanced quickly left, right, up. “And in bear markets, the most frightening moves are to the upside.”


Friday, June 2, 2017

Sterling 'Risk' Spikes To Post-Brexit Highs Ahead Of UK Election

The premium to bet on the pound’s volatility in the next two weeks relative to one-month wagers has surged to the highest level since the aftermath of the Brexit vote ahead of next week’s U.K. snap election.



As Bloomberg notes, even though polls suggest Prime Minister Theresa May remains on track to increase her parliamentary majority...




But, so-called butterfly options...



Show the pound’s moves in the next two weeks could be the largest since the currency’s flash crash in October, when it dropped 6 percent in just one minute.

Monday, May 22, 2017

Markets Face A Brutal "Margin Call" If Trump Loses Any More Credibility, Deutsche Warns

It took the Fed several long years to discover just how reflexive and circular the relationship it had established with the stock market had become. The Fed"s Catch-22 was first observed back in September 2013, when as the Fed was still debating whether to taper or not caught in a vicious cycle where any hint it would ultimately end QE would be met with a prompt selloff, Deutsche Bank explained how it had found itself in such a reflexive mess:





Another theme arising from their decision to hold fire was their worry that financial conditions had tightened over the past few weeks. If this is the case then the path of tapering is going to be tough because every time the market thinks they are going to taper, yields will likely rise and conditions will tighten. However the Fed"s guidance is becoming confused enough now that you couldn"t rule out another change of emphasis, especially as the composition of the Fed will change notably over the next few months. So markets are underpinned by liquidity for now but it’s a fluid situation and it strikes me that the Fed do not have a clear direction at the moment which makes them difficult to second guess.



Three years later, the Fed found itself in the same bind, eager to hike rates but very much unwilling to suffer the risk asset consequences this would entail, i.e., worried about a market selloff. And, as we discussed last October, in the Fed"s Minutes, for the first time we observed a Fed that appeared to have become self-aware, and had grasped just how reflexive the nature of its "communication strategy" with the market has been all along. To wit:



Over half a year later, we again go back to Deutsche Bank in general, and its most whimsical and metaphysical of strategists, Aleksandar Kocic, who first highlighted the reflexive nature of the Fed four years ago (and who recently has been more vocal on political topics such as the failure of globalization as the culprit behind Trump"s victory, and the backlash against populism), and who over the weekend extended the familiar circular frame established between the Fed and the market by one key player, layering in the the US presidency as a critical participant in the "communication channel" the Fed had established with the market. In other words, the "Fed put", which Yellen et al financed "option by selling an (out of the money) option on their credibility" was being supplanted by a "Trump put."


There are several major problems associated with that.


As Kocic warns, the introduction of this particular "irrational" actor into a long-running, game-theoretical setup which has become quite familiar to both the market and the Fed  - as Kocic puts it "the Fed could tailor its exit in an optimal way, while the market could voice its view at each step of that process so that both sides are happy at the end. Because of that, it was not in the market’s interest to challenge Fed’s credibility" - would jeopardize the fluid equilibrium between the Fed and the stock market.


Furthermore, "in contrast with the Fed whose communications with the markets reduced volatility, the new political transparency, as communicated through presidential tweets and political discourse, has been generally volatility increasing." Said simply, blame Trump if volatility explodes in the near future, at least according to Deutsche.


Finally, there is the issue of the market being shocked by a brutal "margin call", as the pre-implied political "consensus", similar to that between the Fed and markets, fractures resulting in a marketwide "margin call", which would be most disruptive for equities while pushing VIX higher, creating a destructive feedback loop in which crashing confidence in the "Trump put" translates into a further market selloff, which in turn further impairs confidence in not only the Trump, but also Fed put, in the process potentially unwinding years and years of artificial market levels as not only Trump, but the Fed also lose their credibility.


For the sake of completeness and coherence - because nobody can do Kocic justice by expounding on his thoughts, and it is best to leave to Kocic to say what Kocic meant to say - here is his full essay from this weekend.





Approaching a margin call: Politics and policy behind the fourth wall



For a good part of the last 5-6 years, the Fed had made a point of establishing an open channel of communication with the markets. We have viewed this phase of market introspection as a maneuver equivalent to the removal of the fourth wall in the theatrical context: The audience (in this case the markets) is no longer a passive spectator, but assumes an active role in shaping the script (policy). In consulting the markets, the Fed has retained an option to be flexible and act in the market’s interest without disturbing it. They have financed that option by selling an (out of the money) option on their credibility. This is a tradeoff that worked for everyone. The Fed could tailor its exit in an optimal way, while the market could voice its view at each step of that process so that both sides are happy at the end. Because of that, it was not in the market’s interest to challenge Fed’s credibility.



With the arrival of the new President, there appears to be some coordination between politics and monetary policy in their communication channels. The Fed communications with the markets gave way to presidential tweets, press briefings and general media appearances, which took center stage as another form of shaping the narrative jointly with a wider audience. So, while the Fed’s fourth wall had to be reinstated, another fourth wall came down. It makes perfect sense for the two communication channels not to coexist at the same time -- removing two walls at the same time would have produced two parallel narratives resulting in a significant “cognitive draft” and potential loss of coherence of the resulting script.



The two communication modes of removal of the fourth wall, while on the surface similar, have (at least) one notable difference. When expressed in options language, the Trump put has the same decomposition as the Bernanke put during the QE period. Effectively, this is a supply of equity vol to the market financed by “selling puts” on President’s credibility. However, in contrast with the Fed whose communications with the markets reduced volatility, the new political transparency, as communicated through presidential tweets and political discourse, has been generally volatility increasing. This communication caused volatility is the main difference between politics and policy. Originally, the market has been willing to accept this volatility because the promises at the end look attractive (tax cuts, deregulation, fiscal spending,…). But, this volatility presents the key risk for the President’s brand. The collateral asset behind president’s “credibility put” is his ability to pass the promised reforms, which is conditioned on his ability to form consensus within the party, the House and the Congress. Excessive volatility erodes the value of this collateral and increases the risk of a “margin call”.



This was highlighted by the last week’s events: The latest political developments outlined the lines of fractures in the political consensus and the market’s reassessing of the probability of a “margin call”. As a consequence, volatility sellers were caught off guard as gamma rebounded. The awareness of this possibility alone is likely to provide a lower bound for vol – as long as political uncertainty prevails, vol is  unlikely to be pushed to new lows. As the Trump trade took the center stage by the end of the last year, the highest level of uncertainty was perceived to be in the FX channel and the lowest in the risk assets, with rates market somewhere between the two. In itself, the political “margin call” would be unwind of this mode and, as such, most disruptive for equities pushing VIX significantly higher, as it means withdrawal of convexity from that market, and somewhat less supportive for rates and FX vol.



To all this we can only add, that it would be doubly (if not triply) ironic that Trump - who less than a year ago accused Yellen of blowing a "huge market bubble" - then a few months ago changed his tune, and started grading his presidency by every uptick in the S&P while praising Yellen and low rates, were to be left holding the bag as the president who unleashed the biggest market crash of all time, in the process wiping out the Fed, whose "market put" is now all in, as is its reserve currency-defining credibility.


Actually scratch that, the correct word we are looking for is not "ironic"... it is "planned."

Tuesday, May 9, 2017

Trader: "It's Going To Zero"

Authored by Peter Tchir via Brean Capital,





Momentum Trader: It’s going to zero!



Sales: Protection is worthless.  Why pay up for protection, it always turns out worthless?



Quant Trader: The skew and relative steepness makes timing critical on any purchase.  The theta decay is virtually impossible to overcome.



Desk Head: Why aren’t we selling more?



Bear Trader: Because we are at all-time tights and there is no #*#*!@$ value!  This is just #@*($& stupid.



Risk Management: I can’t let you sell more than you already have.  I’ve already increased limits and I’m extremely uncomfortable increasing them again.



All: Oh shut up!



Desk Head: You and your stupid risk limits are why we are all here in the first place! Had you let us sell more 2 months ago we wouldn’t all be here stuck trying to figure out what to do – we’d be sitting on great P&L and could relax, but no, now we are behind and have to sell as much as we can at the lows.



Bear Trader: This can’t possibly continue.  It’s already overdone and when it reverses, it is going to be UGLY!



Sales: All I’ve got is sellers.  No one wants or needs protection.



Quant Trader: It doesn’t even have to go lower, so long as it just sits here, the theta decay coupled with the funding arbitrage performs well.



Technical Trader: All support is broken, we are in uncharted territory.  This could continue.



Risk Management: I will concede that several new products seem to have changed the landscape and may have reset the boundary conditions.  I will review again.



Desk Head: Good!



Bear Trader: This is going to end badly.



All: It might, but not any time soon!



While this is a fictitious conversation, it is largely based on conversations I was part of in the spring of 2007 around CDS Indices.


Any similarity to conversations surrounding VIX yesterday are purely coincidental.


The sense that risk assets can only grind higher and that the value of any protection is useless, really seemed to reverberate throughout Wall Street yesterday as the S&P 500 hit all-time lows on 10 days realized volatility.


The types of conversations reminded me a lot of what was discussed in the Spring of 2007 – though who was right and who was wrong depended heavily on whether those conversations were had in late April or early June.


*  *  *


With stock turbulence evaporating further, betting on market swings has become cheap -- for real.


As Bloomberg details, for the first time since November, the S&P 500 Index’s one-month implied volatility has dipped below the gauge’s actual price moves from the previous 20 trading days, as VIX sank to its lowest close in more than two decades.



S&P 500 implied volatility was higher than realized for 108 straight days, the longest run since the 132 days ended Feb. 27, 2007... and most know what happened next.

Monday, April 24, 2017

FX Volatility Crashes As Traders Unwind "Existential Euro" Hedges

Heading into today"s vote, FX options markets had seen massive demand for downside protection against a result that threatened the euro"s existence. That didn"t happen and so those hedges are being unwound en masse with the biggest drop in EURUSD implied vols in history...




Close up, 1mo EURUSD vols erased all the damage from the last few weeks" fears...




And Risk-Reversals (which measure the skew or relative demand for downside protection over upside), have spiked back to near "normal" levels...




Notably EURJPY (which was one of the biggest movers tonight) has begun to fade quite significantly...




Retracing 50% of its spike as the world wakes up to debt ceiling concerns and what the ECB will do...