Showing posts with label Economy of the European Union. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economy of the European Union. Show all posts

Monday, November 27, 2017

Which Europeans Carry The Most Cash?

How much cash do you have in your wallet right now?


Historically, it has been found that the amount of cash people carry is a key indicator of their use of cash. According to research from the European Central Bank, people in the eurozone carried an average of €65 in their wallets in 2016.


Infographic: Which Europeans Carry The Most Cash? | Statista


You will find more statistics at Statista


As Statista"s Niall McCarthy notes, on a country by country basis, Germans tended to carry the most cash on average, €103.


People in Luxembourg had an average of €102 in their wallets while Austrians had €89.


People in France and Portugal had the least on average with €32 and €29 respectively.









Thursday, October 26, 2017

ECB Preview: Here"s What Draghi Will Announce On Thursday

Thursday"s ECB meeting is expected to be one of the most important in recent years: Mario Draghi has signaled, and is widely expected to announce a blueprint of what the central bank"s QE tapering will look like beyond 2017, and while no actual tightening will be implemented - either via rates of asset purchases - the ECB is expected to announce it will cut its €60bn/month bond purchases in roughly half starting in January 2018 and lasting for the next 9-15 months.



Courtesy of RanSquawk, here are the key parameters of Thursday"s meeting:


  • Rate Decision due at 1245BST/0645CDT and Press Conference at 1330BST/0730CDT

  • The ECB is widely  expected to keep all rates on hold, with rate hikes not expected until after conclusion of current QE programme

  • The ECB is expected to unveil a road-map for reducing the pace of asset purchases given rhetoric from Draghi at the previous press conference

  • Consensus far from clear on how much the ECB will reduce purchases by and how long they will be extended for 

RATE/ASSET PURCHASE EXPECTATIONS


  • DEPOSIT RATE: Forecast to remain unchanged at -0.40%. The rate was last adjusted in March 2016, when it was cut by 10bps.

  • REFI RATE: Forecast to remain unchanged at 0.00%. The rate was last adjusted in March 2016, when it was cut by 5bps.

  • MARGINAL RATE: Forecast to remain unchanged at 0.25%. The rate was last adjusted in March 2016, when it was cut by 5bps.

  • ASSET PURCHASES: Views on this front are particularly wide-ranging. A Reuters poll suggests that the ECB will start trimming monthly asset purchases to EUR 40bln from current EUR 60bln in January. Views are mainly split on  whether this will be via a 6- or 9-month extension. However, Bloomberg News reports that the Bank will half purchases to EUR 30bln (a view backed by recent source reports) while extending the programme by 9-months in order to take the total size of purchases to around EUR 2.5trl; a level seen by some as their maximum purchase limit. (Discussed in greater detail later on in the report)

CURRENT ECB FORWARD GUIDANCE


  • RATES: “We expect [rates] to remain at their present levels for an extended period of time, and well past the horizon of our net asset purchases.” (ECB statement, 7/Sept)

  • ASSET PURCHASES: “Net asset purchases, at the current monthly pace of EUR 60bln, are intended to run until the end of December 2017, or beyond, if necessary” (ECB statement, 7/Sept)

  • GROWTH: “The risks to the growth outlook are broadly balanced.” (ECB statement, 7/Sept)

  • INFLATION: “While the ongoing economic expansion provides confidence that inflation will gradually head to levels in line with our inflation aim, it has yet to translate sufficiently into stronger inflation dynamics. Measures of underlying inflation have ticked up slightly in recent months but, overall, remain at subdued levels. Therefore, a very substantial degree of monetary accommodation is still needed for underlying inflation pressures to gradually build up and support headline inflation developments in the medium term.” (ECB statement, 7/Sept)

POTENTIAL ADJUSTMENTS TO ECB FORWARD GUIDANCE


  • RATES: Expected to stick to current rhetoric with any adjustments on rates not expected until QE unwind as part of their ‘sequencing’ efforts.

  • ASSET PURCHASES: This will hinge on what action the ECB will take. (Expectations for this are discussed below).

  • GROWTH: No change to guidance expected on this front. RBC states there has been little in the way of economic data flows to materially alter the economic backdrop.

  • INFLATION: Similarly to the growth story, little has changed on the inflation front to require any adjustment to current guidance. 

FUTURE PATH OF QE PROGRAMME


Background:


Despite inflation in the Euro-area (1.5% Y/Y headline) still short of the ECB’s ‘close to but below 2%’ target, the Bank has

found itself under pressure to set out a road-map on how they will curtail purchases. This is a by-product of a pick-up

in Euro-area sentiment and growth expectations but more pertinently, the concerns on the governing council surrounding the

Bank moving ever closer to their alleged self-imposed purchase limit of around EUR 2.5trl (set to reach EUR 2.28trl by yearend)


Expectations for such a blueprint were stoked by comments from ECB Draghi at his most recent press conference stating that very

preliminary talks had begun on asset purchases with discussions based on the length of the programme and size of the

purchases. Draghi then went on to add that the ‘bulk of decisions will be taken in October’.


Since then, rhetoric from the Bank has done little to pull-back expectations of a major announcement this month. However, many

members appear to be trying to soothe markets by not being too bullish in the desires to remove accommodation with the likes of Draghi, Praet and Hansson all opting to use the phrase ‘recaliberation’ instead of ‘taper’ when talking about unwinding

purchases. Furthermore, even some of the more hawkish members such as Weidmann have tried to reassure markets by stating

that policy will remain accommodative even after QE exit, with his German counterpart Lautenschlaeger suggesting that current

downward forces on in inflation are merely temporary. As such, this suggests that any action taken by the bank will likely be mindful

of any market backlash by being too aggressive with members stressing the need for patience and persistence. However, there

has been little communication by policymakers on the specifics of what to look out for and as such, unless there are any

further developments heading into the meeting after this report has been published, consensus will likely be far from

clear.


Current expectations:


Overview: Expectations for the Bank’s future plans focus on two key aspects of the programme; it’s size and it’s duration with purchases currently running at EUR 60bln a month and due to expire in December of this year. For the reasons stated above, the current size is expected to be reduced from its current level with the programme to be extended in order to avoid any type of ‘taper-tantrum’.


Source reports: In the immediate aftermath of the previous press conference, source comments suggested the Bank could cut asset purchases to EUR 20 or 40bln a month, with extension options including 6- or 9- months. Given the wide range of potential future purchases from these source reports (EUR 120-360bln), markets have been struggling to get a gauge on where the balance of views at the Bank lies. As such, source reports have been one of the main tools used by the market to gain consensus. The most recent of these reports suggested that the Bank could cut purchases to EUR 30bln with a 9-month extension due to fears regarding limits on available purchases. The same sources also reported that EUR 25bln for 9 months could be a more secure approach to avoid falling short of available bonds. That said, the report highlighted that no key decision have yet been made and as such, the decision taken by the bank could be one that goes right to wire. Given the lack of market consensus, it is plausible that the ECB could release further source reports in order to communicate their potential decision  ahead of the event.


Newswire polling: Given the lack of clarity in market expectations it is useful to look at newswire surveys given they typically highlight where the balance of views lie in the market. However, even on this front, major vendors report differing views on what action the ECB could take. A Reuters poll suggests the ECB will start trimming monthly asset purchases to EUR 40bln from current EUR 60bln in January. Expectations were, however, relatively wide-ranging with expectations of cuts between EUR 5-40bln. Fourteen of 32 surveyed (who expect a fixed end-date) think the programme will run for a further 6-months from January, thirteen of 42 look for an extension to September (a view backed by recent source reports) and the remainder expect it to run until December 2018. Note, some also hold the view that the ECB could leave the programme open-ended in order to not cause too much of a stir in the market via a ‘taper-tantrum’. Separately, Bloomberg News reported that the consensus is for asset purchases to be cut to around EUR 30bln and extended by 9-months which would take the bank’s total size of purchases to just over EUR 2.5trl; the bank’s alleged self-imposed bond-buying limit.


 



Market reaction:


 The market reaction to this week’s meeting could carry a lot of volatility given the lack of clear consensus. As such, to help

clients we have referenced Rabobank’s, BofA"s and Citi"s cheat sheets to depict what could be interpreted as ‘hawkish’ or ‘dovish’ reactions. Note, a

hawkish reaction would typically lead to (all things equal and in very basic terms), appreciation of the EUR, downside in equities

and fixed income markets. A dovish reaction would be the converse of these moves. Note that the below categorizations are based

on views provided by Rabobank and not out own. Furthermore, the values stated below refer to what the pace of future purchases

would be, not the size of the cut.


Here"s Rabo:


  • Very hawkish: EUR 20bln and a 6-month extension

  • Hawkish: EUR 20bln and a 9-month extension or EUR 30bln and a 6-month extension

  • Neutral: EUR 20bln and a 12-month extension or EUR 30bln and a 9-month extension

  • Dovish: EUR 40bln and a 6-month extension or EUR 30bln and a 12-month extension

  • Very Dovish: EUR 40bln and a 9-month extension or EUR 40bln and a 12-month extension


Alternatively, here is Bank of America"s Matrix...



... and Citigroups.



Below are Citi"s conclusions:


  • For 10yr Bunds, yields fall around 25bp in the most dovish scenario (€40bn x 12mth) and rise around 24bp in the most hawkish scenario (€20bn x 6mth). Figure 1 above summarizes the full set of results for Bunds.

  • The most market neutral scenarios, according to the model, are €20bn x 12mth, €30bn x 9mth and €40bn x 6mth.

  • This is broadly consistent with the Reuters poll (taken 11-14 September) which suggested the consensus amongst economists was for €40bn (range €30- 50bn) over 6mths (range 3-12mths).

  • Cross-checking the model output (based on policy signals) with the total size of APP extension shows a clear relationship (Figure 2). The model therefore assumes that there is less of a role for the ‘intensity’ of purchases.

  • The market neutral size for APP upsizing appears to be around +€250bn

  • The Citi house view is for an extension in the form of an ‘envelope’ (without specifying a monthly purchase rate) of €150bn (with upside risk of €210bn). That could lead to a near-term sell-off of around 15-20bp.

  • The scenarios presented assume deliverability. But, the most dovish options undoubtedly would be more challenging to implement (see below) given scarcity constraints. In terms of likelihood, we would put less weight on these scenarios which skews the risk towards a bearish reaction on 26 October.

Finally, a breakdown of expectations by bank:


  • Barclays - Think that QE will be extended for a longer period (nine months) but at a lower pace of EUR 30bln per month, and do

    not rule out a 12-month extension at an even lower pace of EUR 20-25bln. Do not expect the ECB to commit to tapering towards

    zero at the end of the extended programme as the GC will likely want to keep all options open in case economic or market

    conditions deteriorate in the meantime.

  • Deutsche Bank - Now expect a larger reduction in the pace of QE – from EUR 60bln to EUR 30bln (not EUR 40bln). To

    compensate, expect (i) a longer extension of QE – nine months rather than six months – (ii) a commitment to not changing the

    sequencing of exit and (iii) the introduction of conditionality into the definition of “well past” within the rates guidance.

  • HSBC - Expect six months of asset purchases at a reduced pace of EUR 40bln per month to start in January. Although, it is hard to

    have huge conviction given the near infinite possibilities. Do not think the ECB will set an end-date for purchases given concerns

    that underlying inflation pressures are still insufficient.

  • IFR - Central scenario is for the ECB to buy EUR 20bln per month over 12-months. The most important element to the ECB’s exit

    strategy is not QE but sequencing of when rate hikes will happen.

  • ING - Expect the ECB to announce a ‘lower for longer’ tapering, as in December 2016, reducing the monthly QE purchases to 25bn

    and extending them until the end of 2018. Expect Draghi to emphasise ‘sequencing’, i.e. the fact that interest rates will remain low

    (far) beyond the end of QE which should help to anchor interest rate expectations. Such a strategy would also help to immunise the

    ECB’s monetary policy against further exchange rate fluctuations.

  • Lloyds - Forecast an announcement of a reduction in monthly purchases to EUR 30bln from the current pace of EUR 60bln, but

    an extension of the programme to at least September 2018. The ECB is likely to maintain its flexibility, keeping open the option to

    increase monthly purchases, should it be needed.

  • Morgan Stanley - Have slightly amended their call and now expect the central bank to announce that the APP will be extended up

    to September 2018, or beyond if necessary. But, from January onwards, the pace of purchases will likely be lowered to EUR 30bln

    per month.

  • Nordea – Expect an extension of the asset purchases by at least six months, by reducing the monthly net purchase volume from

    EUR 60bln per month to EUR 30bln, effective from January 2018. This would be in line with the need for further substantial

    monetary accommodation, while at the same time reflecting bond scarcities and the ECB’s confidence that ongoing growth above

    potential should drive core inflation further up over time.

  • Pictet – Expect the ECB to announce a 9-month extension of asset purchases, until at least September 2018, at a monthly pace of

    EUR 30bln. The ECB’s emphasis on “patience and persistence” means that an even longer QE extension is possible, e.g. at EUR

    20-25bln for 12 months.

  • Rabobank – Believe that QE will be wound down in three steps of EUR 20bln, bringing purchases to zero in H2 2018. Rabo admit

    that their scenario is on the more hawkish side of the tapering spectrum. If the ECB opts for such an exit, this could lead to a

    negative market reaction in the short-run. However, they would argue that ultimately the flexibility given by this approach could

    actually help stabilising yields in the long run (and so limit sharp movements).

  • RBC - Look for a reduction by at least EUR 30bln in net terms, possibly even more. The duration of the programme is likely to

    remain open ended with an initial date set at least 9 months from the current end date, i.e. in Sep 2018. Forward guidance should

    be strengthened and re-iterated in the press conference and Q&A – particularly the sequencing element.

  • SocGen - Expect the ECB to extend QE for nine months, at a monthly pace of EUR 25bln. Expect the ECB to keep the door open

    to more QE thereafter if needed. Maintain their view of rate hikes in March and June 2019 to put an end to the negative deposit

    rate.

  • TD Securities - look for the ECB to announce QE at EUR 30bln/month for 12 months. Recent ECB communication has suggested

    that emphasis will be on the duration of QE rather than the pace. This longer extension of QE should be coupled with unchanged

    forward guidance, where Draghi will emphasise that purchases will continue through December 2018 “or beyond, if necessary” and

    will remain firm on sequencing, with rates not rising until “well past” the end of QE. This should see any expectations for rate hikes

    pushed back into the second half of 2019.

  • UBS - Expect the ECB will cut its monthly asset purchases from EUR 60bln to EUR 30bln as of January, with a commitment for

    nine months, i.e., until end-September 2018. UBS think the ECB will leave open whether it will extend QE after September and hint

    that this decision will be taken in a data- dependent fashion, closer to the time.






Thursday, October 12, 2017

Why The European Union Is Doomed To Fail

Have you ever heard of Deutsch Jahrndorf? No? I don’t blame you. The tiny Austrian village, which is situated four miles from the Danube, is utterly unremarkable, except for the fact that it sits on the border of three countries. To the east is Slovakia. To the south lies Hungary. As such, within shouting distance of one another, live three peoples speaking completely unintelligible languages. Austria belongs to the West Germanic language group, Hungary to Finno-Ugric and Slovakia to West Slavic.


I thought about the exquisitely rich tapestry of European languages, cultures, customs, and nationalities as I watched the sad spectacle of Spanish riot police and Catalan separatists confronting one another on the streets of Barcelona. How on earth can the European Union unite that which history forced asunder?



The Folly of the EU


The European Union, French President Emmanuel Macron has recently declared to almost universal acclaim, needs more unity, including the creation of “a eurozone budget managed by a eurozone parliament and a eurozone finance minister”.


The need for the centralization of power in Brussels is, apparently, the lesson that the EU establishment has learned from the outcome of the British referendum on EU membership. Meanwhile, in Catalonia, millions of people have set their sights on independence from Spain. Foremost among their complaints is that the Catalan budget is influenced by Madrid.


Independence, the Catalans feel, will rectify a grave injustice occasioned by the French capture of Barcelona in 1714. The conqueror, Duke of Anjou, became the first Bourbon king of Spain under the name of Philip V. His descendant, Philip VI, is on the throne today. In Europe, ancient lineages last as long as ancient resentments.


Therein lies the conundrum of European unification.





On the one hand, people throughout much of Europe desire greater autonomy. Madrid has the vexing problem of the Basque Country to worry about as well as Catalonia. In Italy, Padania and South Tyrol in the North don’t feel like they have very much in common with the Mezzogiorno in the South. Corsica does not want to be French and Britain has only recently revisited a territorial arrangement that dates back to 1707.


 


On the other hand, every separatist movement in Europe declares its support for the project of European unification. But, how likely is it that people annoyed by Madrid, Rome, Paris, and London will be happy to have their affairs decided upon in Brussels? Will the Catalans, resentful of subsidizing farmers in Andalusia, quietly have no problem with subsidizing Polish peasants in Lower Silesia?



How Did It Go So Wrong?


Speaking of Brussels, it is both the seat of the increasingly dysfunctional EU and the capital of Flanders, which wants to separate from Belgium. It’s complicated.


Years from now, when the EU is either reformed beyond recognition or gone, historians will debate what went wrong and when. The Maastricht Treaty of 1992, which reinvigorated the British Eurosceptic movement that ultimately delivered Brexit, will be one of the obvious culprits. But I think that the problems of European integration are of an older vintage. Perhaps because it was signed by none other than Margaret Thatcher, the Single European Act of 1986 does not get the attention it deserves. Yet it was SEA that eliminated the national veto in a number of crucial policy areas and replaced it with qualified majority voting (QMV). Thatcher acceded to this new arrangement, for it was meant to break down intra-European trade barriers and transform the fledgling “common market” into a freer “single market”. Unfortunately, the introduction of QMV also meant that, occasionally, individual nation states got outvoted on issues they cared deeply about. Accusations of “meddling from Brussels” grew.


To make matters worse, the SEA engorged the powers of the Commission. That proved to be a double-edged sword. On the one hand, the Commission went after the anti-competitive practices of nation states with gusto. On the other hand, it used its new powers to start over-regulating economic activity. The regulatory and protectionist impulses of the nation states, in other words, were replaced by regulatory and protectionist impulses at the pan-European level and Europe became less competitive vis-á-vis the rest of the world. Maastricht and the Lisbon Treaty sped up the excessive centralization of power in Brussels that was already underway and transformed the European Economic Community into the EU with its own flag, anthem, and currency.


To those symbols of statehood, President Macron now wishes to add a financial transfer union, which, he feels, is necessary to make a success of the single currency. On a continent inhabited by a multitude of diverse peoples with no shared identity, Macron’s proposal, if implemented, will surely prove to be the EU’s undoing.


Sunday, October 8, 2017

Schäuble: Another Financial Crisis Is Coming Due To Spiraling Global Debt, "New Bubbles"

Following the disappointing for Angela Merkel and her CDU German election results, which propelled the populist AfD into Germany"s political establishment with 92 members of parliament, the first casualty was Germany"s finance minister, Wolfgang Schäuble, who in a few days will relinquish his long-held post and move on to the ceremonial role of Bundestag president. As part of his farewell tour, Schäuble - like so many other former members of the establishment- took a parting shot at the system he helped create and warned that "spiraling levels of global debt and liquidity", as well as "new bubbles" present a major risk to the world economy.


Speaking to the FT, the Europhile beloved in Germany for successfully steering one of the world’s largest economies for the past eight years, and who nearly led to Grexit in the summer of 2005, said there was a danger of “new bubbles” forming due to the trillions of dollars that central banks have pumped into markets. Confirming another fear widely propagated by the Putin propaganda alternative media, Schäuble also warned of risks to stability in the eurozone, particularly those posed by bank balance sheets burdened by the post-crisis legacy of non-performing loans, something we have warned about since 2012, and an issue which remains largely unresolved.





A strong advocate of fiscal rectitude and debt reduction, Mr Schäuble dominated Europe’s policy response to the eurozone debt crisis and has been vilified in countries such as Greece as an architect of austerity. But he will mainly be remembered as the most ardently pro-European politician in German chancellor Angela Merkel’s cabinet, skilled at selling the benefits of the euro and of deeper European integration to an often sceptical German public.



To underscore his point, Schäuble said that the Brexit vote last year had demonstrated how “foolish” it was to listen to “demagogues who say . . . we’re paying too much for Europe”. “In that respect they made a great contribution to European integration,” he said. “Though in the short term that doesn’t really help Britain.”





Ahead of his last finance minister meeting on Monday, Schauble "sought to reassure Germany’s allies that the AfD’s surprise success would not in any way affect the country’s commitment to liberal democracy."



“There’s no chance Germany will ever relapse into nationalism,” he said. The AfD’s voters were dissatisfied, felt excluded, were angry about perceived injustice and worried about how the world was changing. “But there’s no reason to believe that democracy and the rule of law are in danger,” he said.



However, taking a broader swipe at the current financial regime, Schauble warned that the world was in danger of “encouraging new bubbles to form”.


"Economists all over the world are concerned about the increased risks arising from the accumulation of more and more liquidity and the growth of public and private debt. I myself am concerned about this, too," he said echoing the concern voiced just one day earlier by IMF head Christine Lagarde, said the world was enjoying its best growth spurt since the start of the decade, but warned of “threats on the horizon” from “high levels of debt in many countries to rapid credit expansion in China, to excessive risk-taking in financial markets”.


Schäuble also echoed the latest warning from the BIS, which last month said that the world had become so used to cheap credit that higher interest rates could derail the global economic recovery.


Meanwhile, Schäuble defended austerity, saying the word was, “strictly speaking, an Anglo-Saxon way of describing a solid financial policy which doesn’t necessarily see more, or higher deficits as a good thing." The soon to be former finance minister also took a pot shot at the UK:





“The UK always made fun of Rhineland capitalism,” he said, contrasting Germany’s consensus-driven, social market model with Anglo-American free markets and deregulation. “[But] we have seen that the tools of the social market economy were more effective at dealing with the [financial] crisis . . . than in the places where the crisis arose.”



Of course, Germany"s success - almost entirely a function of the common currency which has effectively kept the Deutsche Mark from soaring - has come at the expense of crisis after crisis among Europe"s southern states. Unfortunately it has resulted in an entire generation of unemployed youth in countries like Greece, Italy and Spain.


Still, in keeping with his dour image, Schäuble"s last words were pessimistic:


“We have to ensure that we will be resilient enough if we ever face a new economic crisis,” he added. “We won’t always have such positive economic times as we have now” concluded the jolly 75-year-old.



Perhaps Wolfi is worrying too much: after all, according to Janet Yellen, "we will not see another crisis in our lifetime." And if we do, well central banks are primed and ready to injects trillions more to keep the artificial "recovery" and market "all time highs" can kicked just a little bit further.

Friday, September 29, 2017

Does "More Europe" Mean More Government?

Authored by Daniel Lacalle via The Mises Institute,




“And I will pray to a big god, as I kneel in the big church” 


—Peter Gabriel



Imagine for a moment that you are a British citizen with doubts about Brexit. 


You turn on the television and listen to the President of the European Commission, Jean-Claude Juncker, state the following:


  • That the 27 countries of the Union should adopt the euro and be in Schengen by 2019.

  • That “we are not naive defenders of free trade”.

  • That Europe needs a European superminister of Economy and Finance who is also Vice-President of the Commission and President of the Eurogroup.

  • That a European Monetary Fund should be created

Probably, at that moment, many doubts will dissipate. Unfortunately, for those who would like the UK to remain in the European Union, in the opposite direction of their wishes. You would probably think “thank God we are out”.


Juncker’s speech on September the 13th did not seek to find elements for an agreement with the United Kingdom, but to strengthen the current model of the Eurozone at all costs. It was presented as an opportunity to remind us all of his real project for the European Union, clearly based on the French interventionist economic and financial “dirigisme”, and very far from the UK, Finnish, Irish or Dutch open model of economic freedom.


That is the big problem. The message of “more Europe” is always oriented towards “more interventionism” .


A few weeks ago we questioned in this column the triumphant message of the European Commission affirming that “Europe has left the crisis thanks to the decisive action of the European Union“. With Juncker’s speech we can say that the slightest hint of taking advantage of Brexit to improve in freedom, flexibility and dynamism disappears.


Instead of reflecting on the reason why the hyper-regulated and massively intervened Europe has taken more than three times as other countries to emerge from the crisis, we are faced with the classic response of bureaucratic power.


According to Juncker and others’ in Brussels, one could think that if Europe grows less, creates less employment and comes out of the crisis later, it is not because of excessive bureaucracy, but because there is not enough.


The EU runs the risk of falling into the glorification of centralized planning first and foremost, absolute uniformity, and obsolete interventionism that has nothing to do with the plural, free and diverse United States of America and which shows too many coincidences with the Soviet Union dependent on the politburo.


Juncker’s call for efficiency can be interpreted as a breath of fresh air, but it contrasts with reality.


According to the Intelligent Regulation Forum and with the official data of the European Union for 2015, the member countries are subject to more than 40,000 rules by the mere fact of being part of the EU institutions . In total, including rules, directives, sectoral and industrial specifications and jurisprudence, they estimate that there are some 135,000 obligatory rules.


A European Monetary Fund is clearly a subterfuge to give free rein to the uncontrolled financing of white elephants to greater glory of governments and rent-seeking sectors. Faced with the evident failure of the already forgotten “Juncker plan”, no one seems to consider the failure of constant wastefulness in industrial and stimulus plans that have led the European Union to overcapacity of more than 20% and huge financial holes. According to Transparency International, in the European Union, between 10% and up to 20% of all public contracts are lost in excess costs and 5% of the EU’s annual budget is not accounted.


No one thought about it before… A mega Monetary Fund that finances megalomaniac projects with no real economic return with unlimited funds paid with taxpayers’ money, and a superminister that joins to the other superministers and the national and supranational superstructures. A strategy that has worked perfectly … never.


An incorrect model


The fundamental problem of these proposals is that they push forward an incorrect model, which could be improved by learning from those that this “more Europe” message intends to ostracize, be it the British, Finnish, Irish or Dutch.


That none of Juncker’s advisers and assistants have questioned the convenience of including the following phrases is revealing: “We are not naive advocates of free trade”, “We propose a new community framework for the control of investments”.


But no. It is not a question of correcting the evident errors of interventionism. It is not a serious debate on why Europe does not have a Google, an Amazon or an Apple while maintaining dinosaur conglomerates. It is not about improving in openness so that the investment comes to Europe. It is about imposing “dirigisme” above all, whether it works or not. It is about creating a sanctuary of adoration of bureaucracy at all costs, and covering it with unnecessary expenses and burning the printing machine when the evidence of stagnation is imposed after minimal rebounds.


The worst thing is not that the British citizen thinks “it’s a good thing we’re out.” The worst thing is to ignore a part of the European Union that does not want a photocopy of French interventionism.


When Brussels equates more Europe to more interventionism, the EU runs the risk of being less. A lot less.



 









Monday, September 25, 2017

The ECB's Target2 Lies - Exposing The Real Capital Flight From Italy & Spain

Authored by Mike Shedlock via MishTalk.com,


The ECB claims that Target2 does not represent capital flight. Evidence says the ECB is wrong, especially for Italy and Spain.


I have discussed this previously, but let’s recap Target2 before taking a look at new charts.


Project Syndicate writer, Hans-Werner Sinn, explains why the ECB’s asset purchases and Target2 imbalances constitute “Europe’s Secret Bailout”.





Under the ECB’s QE program, which started in March 2015, eurozone members’ central banks buy private market securities for €1.74 trillion ($1.84 trillion), with more than €1.4 trillion to be used to purchase their own countries’ government debt.



The QE program seems to be symmetrical because each central bank repurchases its own government debt in proportion to the size of the country. But it does not have a symmetrical effect, because government debt from southern European countries, where the debt binges and current-account deficits of the past occurred, are mostly repurchased abroad.



For example, the Banco de España repurchases Spanish government bonds from all over the world, thereby deleveraging the country vis-à-vis private creditors. To this end, it asks other eurozone members’ central banks, particularly the German Bundesbank and, in some cases, the Dutch central bank, to credit the payment orders to the German and Dutch bond sellers. Frequently, if the sellers of Spanish government bonds are outside the eurozone, it will ask the ECB to credit the payment orders.



In the latter case, this often results in triangular transactions, with the sellers transferring the money to Germany or the Netherlands to invest it in fixed-interest securities, companies, or company shares. Thus, the German Bundesbank and the Dutch central bank must credit not only the direct payment orders from Spain but also the indirect orders resulting from the Banca de España’s repurchases in third countries.



The payment order credits granted by the Bundesbank and the Dutch central bank are recorded as Target claims against the euro system.



For the GIPS countries [Greece, Italy, Portugal, and Spain], these transactions are a splendid deal. They can exchange interest-bearing government debt with fixed maturities held by private investors for the (currently) non-interest-bearing and never-payable Target book debt of their central banks – institutions that the Maastricht Treaty defines as limited liability companies because member states do not have to recapitalize them when they are over-indebted.



If a crash occurs and those countries leave the euro, their national central banks are likely to go bankrupt because much of their debt is denominated in euro, whereas their claims against the respective states and the banks will be converted to the new depreciating currency. The Target claims of the remaining euro system will then vanish into thin air, and the Bundesbank and the Dutch central bank will only be able to hope that other surviving central banks participate in their losses. At that time, German and Dutch asset sellers who now hold central bank money will notice that their stocks are claims against their central banks that are no longer covered.



Target2 Liabilities



A quick perusal of Target2 Balances for January shows capital flight has largely stabilized but the imbalance in Spain hit a new record.


ECB’s Story on Target2 Doesn’t Add Up


Financial Times Alphaville guest writer Marcello Minenna makes a case in pictures for what I have long stated.


It’s interesting to note that Minenna is the head of Quantitative Analysis and Financial Innovation at Consob, the Italian securities regulator.


Minenna says the ECB’s Story on Target2 Doesn’t Add Up


Mienna compares France with its stable Target2 balance to Italy and Spain.


France Target2 Over Time



The red line with dots represents the imbalance. As of July France had a Target2 liability of 12.2 billion. France shows no correlation to ECB asset purchases.


Germany Target2 Surplus



Italy Target2 Liability



Spain Target2 Liability



Mienna goes over what various colored bars represents and concludes “For Italy and Spain, the QE programme has facilitated capital outflows by domestic investors. Elsewhere, it has not.”


This is what I concluded long ago. For discussion, please see Target2 and Secret Bailouts: Will Germany be Forced Into a Fiscal Union with Rest of Eurozone?

Sunday, September 17, 2017

Why Quantitative Easing In The Eurozone Will Be Extended

The staff of the European Central Bank has now released the new macro-economic projections for the Eurozone and whilst the introduction sounds optimistic about an ever-increasing GDP and a relatively stable GDP growth rate, reading between the lines suggests we could see an extended Quantitative Easing program.


The ECB is probably correct when it claims the economic recovery will remain ‘robust’, but it also mentions the ‘favorable financing conditions’ as one of the main drivers of this economic recovery. This is quite the ‘catch 22’ scenario. The economy is recovering due to the low interest rate policy of the ECB, but without this ‘easy money policy’, the recovery would be either much slower or non-existing at all. Whilst we have heard several voices from ECB committee members the central bank is getting close to the point it will start to increase the interest rates again, the working paper from the ECB staffers is pretty clear on the need for continuous (monetary) support to protect the current economic recovery.



Source: ECB paper


What’s even more intriguing is the fact the ECB’s assumptions are taking an even LOWER interest rate into account. The study was based on the market circumstances and market expectations as of half August, and back then, the market was taking an average 10 year government bond yield of 1.3% in 2018 and 1.6% in 2019 into consideration. However, this has now been revised downward with approximately 10-20 basis points. This could indicate the market has started to price in a longer period of easy and free money.


And that’s an important starting point. As the loans to businesses (and individuals) are priced based on the anticipated ‘risk-free’ interest rate of a government bond, the lower expectations for sovereign debt yields will trickle down to the ‘real’ economy (underpinning the growth expectations), but it’s unlikely this effect will still be noticeable should the ECB reduce its QE program. That’s probably why the market is now expecting the three month EURIBOR interest rates to continue to be low, and even lower than when the previous quarterly survey was completed.



Source: ECB Paper


As you can see on the next image, even keeping the Quantitative Easing program unchanged, the GDP growth rate will slow down whilst the anticipated inflation rate will decrease as well to less than half of the ECB’s desired 2% rate.



Source: ECB Paper


The ECB comments this is due to a lower oil-related inflation impact and it expects the underlying inflation rate to increase again from 2019 on, but we do not necessarily agree with that view. After all, the weaker than expected US Dollar might increase the impact of the low oil price and extend the period wherein this impact will be felt.



Source: Danske Bank


Whilst most eyes have been on the Federal Reserve lately, the upcoming decision of the European Central Bank in October might be even more important. Several executive committee members have claimed the Eurozone is strong enough to sustain the recovery on its own, but we think it might be too soon for the Eurozone to stand on its own legs.


A reduction of the size of the Quantitative Easing program is definitely a possibility but this isn’t Utopia. The continuous support of the Central Bank is still needed.


Would you like to maintain your purchasing power? Read our Guide to Gold right now!

Friday, September 15, 2017

New York Fed, Atlanta Fed, & Goldman Slash Q3 GDP Forecasts

As "hard" economic data in America crashes to its weakest since Feb 2009, so The New York Fed has slashed its economic growth forecasts for Q3 and Q4 dramatically.



The drivers of the collapse are hurricane-impacted data from Industrial production and Retail Sales this morning...



For those hoping for a "broken window fallacy" rebound in Q4, forget it!



source: NYFed


And now The Atlanta Fed has joined the downgrade party...





The GDPNow model forecast for real GDP growth (seasonally adjusted annual rate) in the third quarter of 2017 is 2.2 percent on September 15, down from 3.0 percent on September 8. The forecasts of real consumer spending growth and real private fixed investment growth fell from 2.7 percent and 2.6 percent, respectively, to 2.0 percent and 1.4 percent, respectively, after this morning"s retail sales release from the U.S. Census Bureau and this morning"s report on industrial production and capacity utilization from the Federal Reserve Board of Governors.



From 4% a month ago to just 2.2% now!!



source: AtlantaFed



Putting the recent data in context, here is the "Hard" economic data surprise index.




And then, the cherry on top came from Goldman Sachs which just slashed its hurricane-impacted Q3 GDP forecast from 2.0% (it was 2.8% just one week ago) to 1.6%. To wit:





Industrial production fell sharply in August, but the report explicitly indicated that Hurricane Harvey likely contributed the bulk of the decline. University of Michigan consumer sentiment declined a bit less than expected in the preliminary September report, and the survey’s measure of longer-run inflation expectations moved back up to 2.6%. Taken together, today’s real activity data represents strong evidence that hurricanes have significantly reduced the pace of US growth in the third quarter. Accordingly, we revised down our Q3 GDP tracking estimate by four tenths to +1.6% (qoq ar), on top of the -0.8pp revision we made last week. 



We believe today’s weaker-than-expected retail sales and industrial production data increase the likelihood of a meaningful drag on August economic activity from Hurricane Harvey. And given the possibility of sustained weakness in September due to Hurricane Irma, we now expect an even larger drag on growth in the third quarter. We are reducing our tracking estimate for Q3 GDP by four tenths to +1.6% (qoq ar), on top of the -0.8pp revision we made last week in anticipation of Hurricane effects. We expect some of this weakness to reverse in the fourth quarter as economic activity rebounds in storm-affected regions.



So - NY Fed Staff Nowcast Q3 2017: 1.34% (Prev. 2.1%); Q4 2017 at 1.83% (Prev 2.6%)


Which means that, if NY Fed is correct, and one adds the actual GDPs of 1.2% in Q1 and 3.0% in Q2, full year 2017 GDP Growth wil be just 1.8%! 


Just blame it on the hurricanes.

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

Draghi's Dilemma - Why Is the Euro Still Gaining Against the Dollar?

Authored by Daniel Lacalle via The Mises Institute,


The primary purposes of the incorrectly named “unconventional monetary policies” are to debase the currency, stoke inflation, and make exports more competitive. Printing money aims to solve structural imbalances by making currencies weaker.



In this race to zero in global currency wars, central banks today are “printing” more than $200 billion per month despite that the financial crisis passed a long time ago.


Currency wars are those that no one admits to waging, but everyone wants to fight in secret. The goal is to promote exports at the expense of trading partners.


Reality shows currency wars do not work, as imports become more expensive and other open economies become more competitive through technology. But central banks still like weak currencies —they help to avoid hard reform choices and create a transfer of wealth from savers to debtors.


The Euro Rallies


So how must the bureaucrats at the European Central Bank (ECB) feel when they see the euro rise against the U.S. dollar and all its main trading currencies by more than 12 percent in a year, despite all the talk about more easing? The ECB will keep buying 60 billion euro a month in bonds, maintain its zero interest-rate policy, and keep this “stimulus” as long as it takes, until inflation growth and GDP growth are stable.


Contrary to the wishes of the ECB, however, a strong euro is justified for several reasons.





The European Union’s trade surplus is at record highs, and, 75 percent of Eurozone trade happens between Eurozone countries. Higher exports and the continued recovery of internal demand in European member countries strengthen the euro.



The perception of weakness of the U.S. government and its inability to push through key reforms. This has weakened the dollar and by definition strengthened the other two large trading currencies, the euro and the Japanese yen.



And another important factor is the relief rally after the French and Dutch elections. The fears of a Euro breakup have been eliminated, or at least delayed, as pro-EU political parties won.



The Problems With a Strong Euro


However, a strong euro has very significant implications for the EU economy and the ECB’s policy.


The strong euro puts exports to its main outside trading partners - the United States (20.8 percent of exports in 2016) and China (9.7 percent) - at risk. Despite the ECB’s extreme monetary policy and a euro trading almost at parity with the dollar, exports to non-EU countries have stalled since 2013. GDP growth estimates for 2018 are falling due to a lower contribution of net exports.


The currency also has a high impact on tax revenues in Europe. The correlation between the euro–dollar exchange rate and the earnings estimates of the largest multinationals represented in the Stoxx Europe 600 Index is very high.


According to our estimates, a 10 percent rise of the euro against the dollar is equivalent to an 8 percent drop in earnings and leads to lower corporate tax revenues. From an investment perspective, as earnings drop, the European stock market goes from being relatively cheaper to becoming more expensive.


Investors and economists need to pay attention to these factors. If the euro continues to strengthen, the EU economic recovery is at risk. So the Eurozone is stuck between a rock and a hard place. It cannot stop the stimulus because deficit spending governments cannot live with higher financing costs, and increasing the stimulus to weaken the currency simply doesn’t work anymore.



The only way out is structural reforms, but most governments are afraid of them even in good times, let alone when the going gets tough.

Wednesday, September 6, 2017

EURUSD Dumps'n'Pumps After ECB QE Decision Delay, Inflation Cut Leaks Reported

Last week Reuters provided the outlet for leaked comments from The ECB (regarding QE) that sparked chaos in EURUSD. This week it is Bloomber who reports sources suggesting The ECB will cut inflation outlooks (pouring cold water on Draghi"s "reflationary forces" hoopla) and seemingly confirming The ECB will kick the can on the decision to taper QE into 2018.


As Bloomberg reports, ECB Governing Council has been presented with documents outlining multiple scenarios for adjusting quantitative easing, according to euro-area officials familiar with the matter.


  • Papers were put together by the ECB’s technical committees for the two-day meeting that starts Wednesday, and include different combinations for the size and duration of asset purchases, the people say

  • Documents don’t identify a preferred scenario and aren’t intended as formal policy proposals, people say

  • A decision doesn’t currently look likely before the Governing Council’s Oct. 26 meeting, people say

  • Governing Council will also look at the parameters of QE, including constraints dictated by European law and the ECB’s self-imposed choice of asset classes, to gauge how much room they have for purchases, people say

  • Officials may also talk about altering their forward guidance on interest rates, one person says

  • Draft economic projections show 2017 growth forecast revised up, 2018 and 2019 inflation forecasts revised slightly lower, separate euro-area official says, citing document distributed to national central banks

  • ECB spokesman declines to comment

  • People ask not to be named because the Governing Council’s deliberations, documents are private

The reaction was a swift plunge to the day"s lows followed by a surge to the day"s highs, and then retracement...




Once again, it appears The ECB is strawman-ing the market"s response ahead of the statement tomorrow... and for now, EURUSD is entirely unimpressed.

Monday, September 4, 2017

Bill Blain: "It Looks Like North Korea Is No Longer Playing To The Chinese Script"

Submitted by Bill Blain of Mint Partners


What we don"t know about Korea and China?





“The Chinese use two brush strokes for “crisis”. One brush stroke stands for danger, the other for opportunity.”



Everyone is guessing about North Korea! Who knows what happens next… Probably less than markets fear.. but that won’t stop us worrying about it…


The reaction of markets (on a US holiday) might mean the antics of the Hermit Kingdom are losing some of their capacity for immediate shock and destabilisation. Are markets becoming blasé about the repeated threats? Probably not - the pressure on asset prices and price volatility remains high as participants anticipate a wide range of outcomes.


What’s the right asset positioning? Risk on/off? What are the dangers in terms of the liquidity/return/safe-haven equation? Do nothing and hope it all plays out positively? (Hope is never a strategy.) How contained will it be? Take a defensive stance and miss upside if/when its resolved? Or buy the dips because the risks are massively overstated and its “opportunity”!


Either you know… or you are guessing.


Smarter political minds than I might be able to work out scenario probabilities on how this plays out.


I buy into the current impasse as a China story: To what extent can/might China exercise guidance and control? It rather suited them to watch Trump fulminating and leave him embarrassed. That may no longer be true. It rather looks like the North Koreans are not playing to the script – clearly catching China as surprised and angry as the rest of us at a hydrogen blast 10 times more powerful than Hiroshima. The potential for China to lose patience with N Korea adds a new factor.


Initially it looked like China would be the likely winner, playing the blessed peacemaker role in its own backyard. We were trying to figure what potential upside for China of scoring geo-political points if Korea goads Trump into doing something “hasty” might be? And, what would be the figurative and literal fallout if the Americans lose patience.. (pretty much a worst case scenario)? 


The current what-ifs could change in an instant… I read a number of analysts making contrarian calls about the opportunity to buy cheap Korean stocks and go long the Won. Perhaps it changes the China equation – especially if there is a flood of refugees from the North as some analysts suggest?  Putting China under pressure immediately ahead of the Peoples National Congress in October (picking the next leaders) is an “interesting” shot across the bow.


The other big known unknown this week will be the ECB meeting - and in this case I confidently expect market disappointment.  Draghi will wait before giving any definitive guidance on the direction and scope for further asset purchase schemes. In other words it will be more uncertainty about when the ECB starts to tighten (for that is what a taper effectively is.) We won’t know till later this year.


The big question is the Euro – at what stage does the ECB start to signal its “concern” about the strength when inflation remains weak and the fledgling recovery is still taking hold. Or does the market decide for them? No sign of weakness from a market still convinced Europe is a big recovery story. That could change. 


I continue to harbour suspicions on just how papier-mâché the European façade is. Last week I was reading through the lists of eligible ECB bonds - it’s a pretty complete list of every bond deal ever launched. We know what, but not how much, they buy of that list.


Based on a hint from the excellent Marcus Ashworth of Bloomberg, one issue that got me thinking is the stack of European Sovereign and Agency bonds the ECB holds: there is a letter from Draghi on line confirming the ECB holds no EIB bonds.


So what do they hold in that Euro 180 bln SSA portfolio?


There is a long list of eligible European agencies and banks with government support, ranging from French railways to Landesbanks, to Italian savings banks to Portuguese agencies.. Not saying - not for one moment - that these are tat issuers… but they are sovereign obligations with sovereign ratings for a reason..…

Tuesday, August 8, 2017

King Dollar creates bullish reversal pattern at support

King Dollar creates bullish reversal pattern at support kimble charting solutions post


King Dollar hasn’t had much to brag about the past 6-months, as it has decline nearly 10% this year. The decline took it down last week to test a potential dual support point, that could be important. See support and reversal point in the chart below-



US Dollar Weekly Kimble Charting Solutons


CLICK ON CHART TO ENLARGE


Last week King$ found itself testing potential dual support at (1). While testing this potential support point, it created a “bullish wick/reversal pattern.” While support was being tested at (1), weekly momentum was oversold, hitting a level not seen in years. The Euro also found itself at an interesting price point, as bullish sentiment in the Euro was hitting levels, not seen many times over the past decade. Chart from Sentimentrader.com


Euro sentiment, chris kimble post


CLICK ON CHART TO ENLARGE


While the US$ was weak, the Euro has been strong this year. The rally in the Euro has it testing old support as new resistance at (3). At the same time the Euro could be testing resistance, is is now pretty easy to find investors bullish the Euro at (2). A few times in the past when bullish sentiment towards the Euro was high at each (1), the Euro was closer to highs than lows.


Due to the support test, momentum being oversold and Euro bulls easy to find, Premium Members took a position in this space last week, that is going against the crowd with a tight stop.





from Kimble Charting Solutions.  We strive to produce concise, timely and actionable chart pattern analysis to save people time, improve your decision-making and results


Send us an email if you would like to see sample reports or a trial period to test drive our Premium or Weekly Research



Website: KIMBLECHARTINGSOLUTIONS.COM




Questions: Email services@kimblechartingsolutions.com or call us toll free 877-721-7217 international 714-941-9381

Monday, July 31, 2017

"The Euro Crisis Is Not Over" Former ECB Chief Economist Urges "Greek Sabbatical From EU"

Otmar Issing, former Chief Economist and Member of the Board of the European Central Bank and the German Bundesbank, brings back the specter of Grexit scenarios, demanding a Euro-sabbatical for Greece.



KeepTalkingGreece.com reports that, uin an interview with business news magazine Wirtschaftswoche, Issing warned of a new flare-up of the euro crisis.





“The euro crisis is not over yet,” said the economist, one of the architects of the Euro.



Issing called on a policy that would include EU treaties allowing the possibility of temporary withdrawal from the monetary union.





“States like Greece would do well with a Sabbatical outside the monetary union. However, it should be accompanied by massive aid from other countries and a growth-oriented economic policy. And one would have to make re-entry into the euro zone dependent on fundamental reforms, ” Issing said.



Issing no longer relies on the Stability and Growth Pact, a core element of the economic and monetary union. “I would not have considered the dimension of its dismantling by the governments”.


Otmar Issing lashed out at the Greek government saying “the government is still in an anti-growth policy.”


He also criticized Italy saying





“It also did not seize the opportunity. The country has saved tens of billions of interest without using the leeway. ”



The Wirtschaftswhoche article has the title “Economist demands Euro-sabbatical for Greece.”



I don’t know exactly what institutional role 81-year-old Otmar Issing currently has other than sitting at a dusty desk as president of the Center for Financial Studies (CFS) at the Goethe University in Frankfurt am Main since 2006. He is also Goldman Sachs adviser etc etc etc.


He has been calling for Grexit since 2010 saying Euro exit would be good for Greece at least once a year… Leaving the euro might help struggling Greece, German chief economist, euro architect and former European Central Bank (ECB) board member Otmar Issing told CNBC on Tuesday.





“The euro is irreversible – but if it is irreversible for every country has become an open question,” Issing told CNBC.



Then, Issing told CNBC in September 2015...





“For Greece, there are very good arguments that it would do well outside the euro area for some time to come, but it all depends on the Greek government’s reactions”



What he does not say it that the “massive aid from other countries” that will accompanie the Euro-Sabbatical or Grexit would be one more bailout.


If I remember well, Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble had estimated a total of at least 50 billion euros for a 5-year- euro sabbatical. Schaebule offered Varoufakis & Co a temporary Grexit plan in March 2015, as part of the European lenders blackmail towards Greece.


*  *  *


What we learned from Issing’s interview is that we now have a political correct term Euro-Sabbatical that sounds not so scary as Grexit.

Sunday, July 30, 2017

A Stronger Euro Will Ruin The QE Taper Plans

Just like any good (or mediocre) telenovela, the plot twists at the central banks all over the world aren’t only very predictable, it’s also laughable how the presidents and chairman of the respective banks try to ‘guide’ the market by using specific words.


In just the past few months alone, we have seen several central banks making bold statements only trying to walk them back a few weeks later. An example? The Fed which was expected to hike the benchmark interest rates once again in September and to reduce the size of its balance sheet by winding down the trillions of ‘investments’ in securities.


The ECB followed suit, and Mario Draghi sounded extremely ambitious as he was already hinting at ‘normalizing the interest rates’ and to reduce the buyback rate of the securities. However, the recent ‘crash’ of the US Dollar versus the Euro might have some serious consequences for the Eurozone, and more specifically for the ECB.



Source: stockcharts.com


In 2010, the OECD published a report discussing the impact of several economic (mini-) shocks on the GDP levels of several first-tier economic countries and areas. Based on the evidence from the next three charts, we would argue the ECB is still lightyears away from hiking the benchmark interest rate to a ‘normalized’ level.


Argument 1: the stronger Euro. In its 36-pager, the OECD has investigated the impact of a 10% depreciation of the US Dollar. According to its calculations, the recent 10% depreciation would have an impact of 0.1% on the inflation rate in the first year, increasing to 0.3% from Y3 on.



Source: OECD


Argument 2: A sustained increase of 1% of the US benchmark interest rate (which has almost been reached) would only have a minimal impact on the inflation rate in the Eurozone. Whilst a negative impact of 0.1% might indeed seem to be negligible, but a 0.2% reduction of the Eurozone’s GDP is nothing to sneeze at either.



Source: OECD


Argument 3: an increase of the Eurozone’s interest rates would only make things worse. The impact on the Eurozone GDP would be -0.7% from year five on, and the inflation in the Eurozone would actually DECREASE, as more people will want to save cash to take advantage of the higher interest rates. In fact, we would think this effect might even be underestimated because then the OECD made its calculations, it didn’t take into consideration consumers would be coming out of a prolonged period of NIRP and ZIRP policies. This could result in consumers being relieved to receive ‘anything’ on their savings accounts, further building up their equity to get a decent interest income.



Source: OECD


So, taking all these parameters into account, there’s only one parameter the ECB has an influence on and that’s its own benchmark interest rate. It won’t really be able to actively steer the Euro-Dollar ratio (not unless it pumps more cash in the system) and it definitely won’t be able to do or say anything to rewind the rate hikes of the Federal Reserve.


The three parameters currently on the table would reduce the inflation rate by 0.6%, and have a negative impact on the GDP of approximately 1.6%. This could be dramatic as it’s could reduce the GDP growth rate of the Eurozone to zero.


>>> Click HERE to read our Guide to Gold <<<

Tuesday, July 25, 2017

The Crowd Sometimes Gets It Right

Authored by Kevin Muir via The Macro Tourist blog,


https://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/themacrotourist.comLadderJul2417-5aa420dd4db447752ec98a1875401d3dccaa47d6.png


Over the past quarter, the Euro currency has rallied a little more than 9%. It’s been a steady slog higher, with barely a pause.


https://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/themacrotourist.comEURJul2417-09dc83458e7c1920da6f468b9b7dcca591845962.png


Have a look at the ranking of the major currencies’ performance against the US dollar over the past few months.


https://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/themacrotourist.comRankJul2417-34819fa30311cddf9964f9534a31fc72b3f6e283.png


It’s all Euro (or pseudo-European) currencies at the top.


And this hasn’t gone unnoticed by traders.


https://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/themacrotourist.comEURCFTCJul2117-f57a584b727fa76ef0bf4bad2972494fcf7ac77f.png


Back in April, speculative traders were leaning short the Euro. But that’s changed, and now the net spec position of Euro currency futures traders at the CME is sitting at the highest level since 2010.


It’s suddenly de rigueur to be all bulled up about the Euro.


And I am sure you can see where I am going with this… After all, something is straight up on a stick, speculative positioning is at extreme levels - of course I am going to be an idiot and try to short it.


Yet, as some of my more astute readers have correctly noted, just because the Commitment of Traders (COT) report is showing extended speculative positioning, doesn’t mean they will be wrong.


https://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/themacrotourist.comWillJul2417-8e554e59d363a08a5c0122099372d75ee2e319c9.png


Yeah, can’t disagree. Shorting something because it has risen a long way is just plain amateur hour, even if the trade appears crowded. Sentiment extremes only matter at turning points. During the meat of the move, the specs often get it right.


Or at least that’s what we’ve been taught. Yet, I can’t forget all the times over the past few years when I let a good trade (that happened to be crowded) “cook” because of this wisdom, only to find it fall back in my face. If we are indeed at the start of a major EUR move, then I concede that the EUR will become technically overbought, the specs will get long (and only become longer) as the trade relentlessly rises.


But I am not so sure we are about to embark on such a prolonged bull market. I think it is much more probable that the US dollar chops around in the next few months. And if that proves to be the case, then this scenario offers a compelling short opportunity.


Especially when you consider that the EUR currency seems to have run ahead of one of my favourite measures, interest rate differentials.


https://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/themacrotourist.comEURvsSpreadJul2117-d4a7039db957d51dc0e71180dd13c6f02c72e67e.png


The German 10 year bund/US T-note spread has recently been tracking the Euro currency quite closely. But that relationship has bent a little during this recent period of EUR strength.


As many of you are aware, one of my favourite trades is short German bund futures/long US t-note futures. The yield spread has risen from the absurd 235 basis points to 172 bps, but I think it still has some room to run.


I am combining these two trades, shorting EURUSD into this spike, but also adding to my short bund/long T-note position.


If you have a look at the regression analysis over the past couple of years, the EUR overvaluation becomes obvious.


https://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/07/themacrotourist.comRegressionJul2417-a8ac12147574cb5afc16b1b87d8d5777af3cfc7f.png


There is nothing saying this relationship cannot change. If we are about to enter into a secular monster EUR bull market, then this spread will most likely blow out. But again, I am betting we aren’t about to experience that sort of dramatic shift (at least not yet).


I was looking for an excuse to add to my short bund/long T-note position, and shorting Euro against it looks like the perfect reason. Now maybe I am getting too cute. Maybe I will get my ass handed to me fading this sort of strength. But I just can’t help it. I hate crowded trades, and when I see a chance like this, I need to write some pink tickets.


When the EUR continues to rally in my face, feel free to remind me that the crowd sometimes gets it right.

Monday, July 24, 2017

Why A Dollar Rebound May Be Imminent Even As Crash Insurance Costs Hit Nosebleed Levels

Is the bottom in for the dollar yet?


After hitting a 14 month low, the Bloomberg Dollar Index saw a modest gain of 0.1% as markets awaited this week’s FOMC meeting and kept a wary eye on Capitol Hill hearings which involve close members of the Trump administration. Quoted by Bloomberg, traders described flows as modest amid the elevated event risk we laid out earlier this morning. Besides another potential surprise from the suddenly dovish Fed, traders were keeping a weary eye on Capitol Hill hearings Monday and Wednesday that include Jared Kushner, Donald Jr and Paul Manafort, and what these could mean for Trump"s fiscal agenda. At the same time, the Fed is expected to keep rates and policies on hold, though it may elaborate on balance-sheet reduction or the timing of any future rate increases.


To be sure, negative sentiment against the dollar has been pervasive, and as we noted yesterday when looking at the latest CFTC Commitment of Traders update, net specs are now the most short they have been the USD doing back to 2013.



Worried that the decline in the USD may continue, Bloomberg writes this morning that FX traders are now paying the most in since October 2009 for options to protect against an extreme decline in the dollar against the euro over a six-month period: the 10-delta risk reversal, an indication of trader bias in the options market, reflects expectations that any move in the euro would be dramatic.



Additionally, traders are also piling into options contracts in anticipation of big moves in the euro-dollar exchange rate, eyeing the critical resistance level, the $1.1714 high from August 2015. According to Bloomberg calculations, traders bought more than $6 billion in options to sell dollars and buy euros on July 20 and 21, and an additional $3 billion to sell the greenback against the yen, according to DTCC data.


However, a more nuanced look at who is trading the dollar, suggests that the plunge may be ending.


Citi"s FX quant desk writes that as real money became strong net sellers of USD, hedge funds became aggressive net buyers for the first time in months "a sharp increase in conviction over previous weeks." Looking at the 1-month cumulative investor flow, shown on the right hand side, this divergence became clear in the ladder half of last week, following the EURUSD reaction to the ECB meeting.



Some more context: USD is currently the second largest short position among real money investors in G10 overall, with both 1-week and 4-week net flow decidedly negative. So far in July, real money clients have been net sellers on 80% of days, a continuation of the long-term bearish run for the greenback.


On the other side of the real money, hedge funds were net buyers of USD last week, mostly due to a large amount of buying in response to USD depreciation in the immediate aftermath of the ECB meeting last week. Hedge fund flow on the day of the meeting was sharply against the EURUSD move, with hedge funds strong buyers of USD and sellers of EUR on the day.  Looking at current 4w aggregated flow, leveraged investors are likely long USD and short EUR, a sharp contrast from the significantly short real money positioning. 


According to Citi, "this divergence between leveraged and real money flow opens up the possibility that real money will follow, and we could see USD appreciation in the coming weeks."


* * *


Finally, here is Bloomberg commentator Marc Cudmore, predicting that a Dollar bounce is imminent.





It’s the question on every trader’s lips because the answer influences the price of almost all other financial assets: When is the dollar bouncing? I see it making a short-term base this week.


Financial assets rarely sustain a straight line move even when it appears fundamentally justified. And dollar depreciation is certainly logical.



However, the last leg down has mainly been driven by the latest political turmoil and that’s a problem for bears. Apart from the macro consequences of Trump’s fiscal program being priced out (which already happened months ago), the direct impact of U.S. politics on markets this year has only ever been fleeting. So the latest ructions change little apart from negative headlines.



Euro strength has facilitated the broader dollar depreciation trade but that theme is also looking vulnerable in the short-term. Consensus has suddenly turned bullish on the euro at a time when the ECB just sounded unexpectedly dovish and EUR/USD is facing multi-year resistance at $1.1714.



For the Bloomberg Dollar Spot Index, both daily and weekly RSIs are looking stretched on the downside as we enter a week with an obvious potential catalyst in the FOMC meeting. Profit-taking will surely be too tempting especially as we get deeper into summer holiday territory.



A bounce of a couple of percent won’t derail the long-term macro downtrend that started in January. The U.S. still has a current-account deficit combined with a large debt pile that’s backed by negative real yields. And the currency remains expensive based on PPP metrics.



But those are long-term structural issues. For the next couple of weeks, the vulnerable side will be for dollar strength.