Showing posts with label Economic inequality in the United States. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economic inequality in the United States. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 27, 2017

"Wealth Effect" = Widening Wealth Inequality

Authored by Charles Hugh Smith via OfTwoMinds blog,


Note that widening wealth and income inequality is a non-partisan trend.


One of the core goals of the Federal Reserve"s monetary policies of the past 9 years is to generate the "wealth effect": by pushing the valuations of stocks and bonds higher, American households will feel wealthier, and hence be more willing to borrow and spend, even if they didn"t actually reap any gains by selling stocks and bonds that gained value.


In other words, the mere perception of rising wealth is supposed to trigger a wave of renewed borrowing and spending.


This perception management only worked on the few households which owned enough of these assets to feel wealthier--the top 5%, the top 6 million out of 120 million households. This chart shows what happened as the Fed ceaselessly goosed financial assets higher over the past 9 years: the gains, real and perceived, only flowed to the top 5% of households earning in excess of $200,000 annually.


Spending by the bottom 95% has at best returned to the levels reached a decade ago in 2007.



By focusing on boosting financial assets to the moon as a means of goosing spending, the Federal Reserve has widened wealth and income inequality to the breaking point. Perception management doesn"t actually boost the inflation-adjusted wages of the bottom 95%, which have stagnated for decades. Nor does boosting assets do much good for the vast majority of households which have modest holdings of stocks and bonds, usually in IRA or 401K retirement accounts they can"t touch without paying steep penalties.


As the charts below illustrate, the Grand Canyon between the top 5% and everyone else is widening. Let"s say a househould has $12,000 in retirement funds and $5,000 in a savings account. (Many households have less than $1,000 in savings, so this example-household is doing pretty well to have $17,000 in cash and financial assets.)


Thanks to the Federal Reserve"s Zero Interest Rate Policy (ZIRP), savers have lost ground after adjustments for inflation. The stock market has more than doubled, and most bond funds have appreciated, but precious metals and other commodities have not performed as well. So let"s say the household"s retirement portfolio rose by a hefty 75%, or $9,000, to a total of $21,000.


Does this modest gain actually change the financial foundation of the household to the point that the household can now afford to buy a new vehicle, college tuition, etc.? The short answer is no; the gains are simply too modest as a percentage of income to make any difference.


Compare this to a top 5% household with hundreds of thousands of dollars of financial assets: gains registered in the hundreds of thousands do indeed move the needle on household wealth and perception management. The top 5% haven"t just reaped outsized gains in Fed-goosed assets; they"ve also reaped the vast majority of any wage gains generated in the past 9 years of "recovery."


As this chart shows, the bottom 90% lost ground, and the really substantial gains have accrued only to the top 1%.



Note that widening wealth and income inequality is a non-partisan trend. The political and financial elites have feathered their own nests while the bottom 95% have lost ground.



The Federal Reserve"s perverse policy of perception management has exacerbated wealth and income inequality: "wealth effect" = widening wealth inequality.


*  *  *


I"m offering my new book Money and Work Unchained at a 10% discount ($8.95 for the Kindle ebook and $18 for the print edition) through December, after which the price goes up to retail ($9.95 and $20). Read the first section for free in PDF format. If you found value in this content, please join me in seeking solutions by becoming a $1/month patron of my work via patreon.com.









Saturday, December 16, 2017

Four Charts Prove The "Economic Recovery" Is Just A Fed-Induced Entitlement Program For The Wealthy

"Economic recovery" in America no longer means what it used to mean.  Historically "economic recovery" was largely characterized by job and wage growth, distributed across the income spectrum, and a rebound in GDP growth to north of ~3%-5%.  These days, the notion of "economic recovery" has been hijacked by the Fed and bastardized in such a way that they celebrate "asset bubbles" rather than real growth in economic output.


Presented as "exhibit A", here is the Fed"s modern-day definition of "economic recovery" (chart per Bloomberg):



Of course, digging a little deeper you quickly realize that the problem is even worse than what the data in the chart above might suggest.  While overall average wage growth has been anemic since 2009, to say the least, it has been almost nonexistent for those on the bottom end of the income spectrum.








Soaring markets helped the top 1 percent of Americans increase their slice of the national wealth to 39 percent in 2016, according to the Fed’s Survey of Consumer Finances. The bottom 90 percent of families held a one-third share in 1989; that’s now shrunk to less than one-quarter.


 


The current one has helped millions of people find work; it’s also benefited asset-owners far more than people who trade their labor for a paycheck. Income distribution, already the most unequal in the developed world, is getting worse. And that’s starting to influence everything from America’s spending habits to its elections.




In fact, those in the bottom quintile of wage earners in the U.S. basically haven"t experienced wage growth, on a real basis, since the late 1970"s whereas those in the top quintile have nearly doubled theirs.



Of course, none of this should be particularly surprising to those who are paying attention as the top quintile of earners are the only ones financially positioned to benefit from Yellen"s economic recovery asset bubbles...



Meanwhile, the growing wealth disparity has seemingly put America on a collision course with political chaos as fringe candidates on both the Left and Right increasingly promise to have an "easy" solution for the seemingly inescapeable economic plight of the poorest households. 


Unfortunately, the sad truth just might be that there is no solution, absent some transformational technological advancements, and that the U.S. has just reached the maturity phase of it"s "business cycle"...and while the Fed may try to cover up that fact by repeatedly blowing assets bubbles, per the charts above, they"re only making the problem worse with each successive iteration.









Friday, November 10, 2017

Three Americans Now Own More Wealth Than Bottom Half of US Combined: Report

Authored by Jake Johnson via TheAntiMedia.org,


“The elite ranks of our billionaire class continue to pull apart from the rest of us,” a new Institute for Policy study analysis finds.



In the United States, the 400 richest individuals now own more wealth than the bottom 64 percent of the population and the three richest own more wealth than the bottom 50 percent, while pervasive poverty means one in five households have zero or negative net worth.


Those are just several of the striking findings of Billionaire Bonanza 2017, a new report (pdf) published Wednesday by the Institute for Policy Studies (IPS) that explores in detail the speed with which the U.S. is becoming “a hereditary aristocracy of wealth and power.”


“Over recent decades, an incredibly disproportionate share of America’s income and wealth gains has flowed to the top of our economic spectrum. At the tip of that top sit the nation’s richest 400 individuals, a group that Forbes magazine has been tracking annually since 1982,” write IPS’s Chuck Collins and Josh Hoxie, the report’s authors.


 


“Americans at the other end of our economic spectrum, meanwhile, watch their wages stagnate and savings dwindle.”



Collins and Hoxie are quick to note that the vast gulf that currently exists between the rich and everyone else is not the product of some inexplicable “natural phenomenon.” It is, rather, the result of “unfair economic policies that benefit those at the top at the expense of those at  the bottom.”



Based on data recently made public by the Forbes 400 list and the Federal Reserve’s annual “Survey of Consumer Finances,” Billionaire Bonanza examines in detail the principal beneficiaries of America’s “deeply unbalanced economy”: the mega-rich.


“The wealthiest 25 individuals in the United States today own $1 trillion in combined assets,” the report notes.


 


“These 25, a group equivalent to the active roster of a major league baseball team, hold more wealth than the bottom 56 percent of the U.S. population combined, 178 million people.”



The top 25 list features billionaires who have attained their vast riches through a variety of means, from inheritance to investing to founding a corporate giant like Amazon or Google. What unites these enormously wealthy individuals—aside from the fact that they are all white—is that they just keep getting richer, decade after decade.



Average Americans, by contrast, have not fared nearly as well: a significant percentage of the U.S. households “have no savings at all or owe more than they own,” making them residents of what Collins and Hoxie term “Underwater Nation.”


“Excluding the value of the family car, 19 percent of U.S. households have zero or negative net worth,” the report notes.


 


“Looking at this trend through the lens of race reveals that 30 percent of black households and 27 percent of Latino households have zero or negative wealth.”



In order to get a broader sense of the size of the chasm between rich and poor in the U.S., Collins and Hoxie place the net worth of the top one percent and the bottom one percent side by side.


“All combined, households in the bottom one percent have a combined negative net worth of $196 billion,” the report finds. “For comparison, the top one percent, a category holding the exact same number of people, have positive $33.4 trillion in combined net worth.”



Even mainstream institutions like the International Monetary Fund have acknowledged that such vast disparities of wealth and income are not sustainable, politically or economically. But as Billionaire Bonanza notes, the Trump administration—with the help of the GOP-controlled Congress—appears bent on making these disparities worse by slashing taxes for the wealthy while gutting programs that primarily benefit low-income and middle class Americans.


So the first priority, Collins and Hoxie note, is to “reject tax and other federal policies that will add oil to the inequality fire.”


In terms of going on the offensive once the “do no harm” principle is observed, the report makes several suggestions, including:


  • Enacting higher marginal tax rates on individuals earning above $250,000 and $1 million;

  • “Addressing the problem of hidden wealth,” which often leads to an underestimation of the level of wealth inequality;

  • Instituting a tax on Wall Street financial transactions, which could bring in an estimated $350 billion in federal revenue over a decade;

  • Eliminate the carried interest loophole, which allows hedge fund managers to “reclassify wage income as capital income” and pay less in taxes as a result; and

  • Bolstering, rather than eliminating, the estate tax, which only affects a tiny number families.

As “the elite ranks of our billionaire class continue to pull apart from the rest of us,” the report notes, many Americans—including students saddled with loan debt, workers suffering from stagnant wages, and families who have seen “their wealth and savings evaporate”—are revolting against the system that allowed the richest to accumulate such wealth at the expense of so many.


“A century ago, a similar anti-inequality upsurge took on America’s vastly unequal distribution of income and wealth and, over the course of little more than a generation, fashioned a much more equal America,” Collins and Hoxie conclude. “We can do the same.”









Saturday, October 28, 2017

"If You Want To Get Rich...Climb Into A Time Machine"

Authored by Charles Hugh Smith via OfTwoMinds blog,


There"s a profound difference between assets that produce no income and those that produce net income.


To those of us nutty enough to pore over dozens of pages of data on wealth and income in the U.S., the Federal Reserve"s quarterly Z.1 reports and annual Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF) are treasure troves, as are I.R.S. tax and income reports.


Allow me to share a few observations on family wealth and income drawn from my review of these documents:


Changes in U.S. Family Finances from 2013 to 2016 (42 pages)


Financial Accounts of the United States (198 pages)


Corporate profits clock in at $2.135 trillion annually, around 11% of the nation"s GDP (gross domestic product). (Page 10 of Z.1) This has changed very little over the past few years; corporate profits totaled $2.140 trillion in 2014.


Most people who follow financial matters closely probably know corporate profits have been around $2 trillion annually for awhile.


But how many know that proprietors" income from small businesses ($1.375 trillion) and rental income of persons--i.e. not corporations--($740 billion) together equal corporate profits? ($2.115 trillion for small biz/rentals, $2.135 trillion for corporate profits.


How many financially savvy people know that proprietors" income and private rental income rose by $189 billion since 2014, while corporate profits flatlined?


Clearly, the families that own the proprietorships and rentals pulling down $2.1 trillion in annual profits are doing a bit better than OK.


As the charts below reveal, most of this profitable business equity is owned by the top 10% of families. There are a few clues that suggest that family-owned business equity is distributed along a power-law curve, i.e. the majority of wealth and income is held by the top and the rest is distributed over the rest of the owners.


On Page 28 of the Survey of Consumer Finances (SCF), we find that the business equity owned by families in the bottom 50% of family incomes has a mean value of $208,000, up marginally from $204,000 in 2010, the business equity held by the top 10% of families rose from $2.265 million in 2010 to $3.3 million in 2016--a gain of over $1 million.


As always, I want to stress the profound difference between assets that produce no income and those that produce net income. This excludes hobby businesses that lose money or tax shelters that are intended to lose money. I"m talking about businesses that generate revenues in excess of all expenses: net profit that is taxable.


Owning a vacation home that is rented out a few weeks a year is one thing, owning a rental property that"s rented out 50 weeks a year is considerably different. The first is an expense, the second generates net income.


Somewhat to my surprise, almost 14% of households own some residential property equity other than their primary residence (page 18 of the SCF). Unfortunately, the Fed lumps second homes and vacation properties in with rental properties of up to 4 units, while rentals with 5 or more units are lumped in with farmland and commercial properties in equity in nonresidential property.


Only 6% of households own any equity in nonresidential property, a category of wealth that gained 72% from 2013 to 2016. Interestingly, the percentage of families owning this form of wealth actually declined from 7.2% in 2013 to 6.2% in 2016, suggesting to me that the corporations and hedge funds snapping up multi-unit residential properties are buying properties from families.


Based on my previous surveys of I.R.S. income tax data, much of this small-business equity and family owned-rental property is owned by the top 4% to 5% of families, with the majority owned by the top 10%, as shown in the chart below.


The number of families with business equity has been declining, eroded by recession and stagnation, despite the recent bounce higher.



Most of the biz-equity is owned by the top 10%:



While the financial media focuses on billionaires and hedge fund managers playing for billions, much of the wealth and income of the nation is firmly in the hands of families that own proprietorships and rental properties.


These assets have risen sharply in value, and they"ve also generated gains in income.


If you want to get rich, you can climb into a time machine, return to 2010 and buy a couple thousand bitcoin for $1 each. Alternatively, you can marry extremely well. If neither of these options is available, then starting a profitable proprietorship that enables the purchase of rental properties is another option.


*  *  *


If you found value in this content, please join me in seeking solutions by becoming a $1/month patron of my work via patreon.com. Check out both of my new books, Inequality and the Collapse of Privilege ($3.95 Kindle, $8.95 print) and Why Our Status Quo Failed and Is Beyond Reform ($3.95 Kindle, $8.95 print, $5.95 audiobook) For more, please visit the OTM essentials website.









Saturday, October 7, 2017

5 Charts Highlight The Growing Wealth Inequality In America Over The Past 50 Years

Americans across the income spectrum have generally grown wealthier over the past 50 years but those at the top (A.K.A. the "millionaire, billionaire, private jet owners" to use the parlance of our times) have made out much better than the rest of us.  As the Urban Institute pointed out today, in 1963, families in the top 90th percentile of household wealth had roughly six times the wealth of families in the middle. By 2016, that had doubled to 12 times.


Here"s how that evolution of wealth distribution looks graphically:



Of course, part of the problem is annual household income distributions.  As the charts below reveal, the gap between real earnings of the top and bottom 10% of households in the country has nearly doubled over the past 50 years with 90th percentile families today making 13x more than the families at the bottom of the income spectrum, compared to 7x in 1963.



Meanwhile, the Urban Institute figures the growing wealth gap is at least partially attributable to homeownership rates for minorities being persistently stuck ~20 points below those observed among Whites.





Blacks and Hispanics are less likely to own homes, so they more often miss out on this powerful wealth-building tool. Homeownership makes the most of automatic payments—homeowners must make mortgage payments every month—to build equity.



In 1976, 68 percent of white families owned their home, compared with 44 percent of black families and 43 percent of Hispanic families. By 2016, the homeownership gap had narrowed slightly for Hispanics but widened for blacks. Black and Hispanic families were also less likely to own homes than white families with similar incomes.




And while they didn"t cover it, we"re going to go out on a limb and suggest that the growing wealth divide might have something to do with the Fed"s decisions to do this...



...which resulted in this...


S&P


Of course, only the people who were already wealthy were able to take advantage of the Fed"s "official" policy decisions designed to inflate one massive asset bubble after another over the past 35 years.

Friday, October 6, 2017

Goldman Raises December Rate Hike Odds To 80%

Having pointed out a glaring error in today"s payrolls report, which indicated that there was at least one math error in calculating the average hourly earnings number, and as a result casts doubt on every other piece of data released by the BLS, we urge algos and the handful of carbon-based traders, to take anything released by the BLS with a boulder of salt, especially data on wage inflation, until the BLS provides an explanation for what is going on.


Until then, here is Goldman methodically going "by the numbers", and validating the market"s reaction that sent December rate hike odds to the highest in one year, as moments ago Goldman chief economist, Jan Hatzius, revised his odds of a December hike from 75% to 80%.





Nonfarm payrolls fell 33k in September—considerably below expectations—however, we believe temporary hurricane effects likely explain all or most of the weakness. In fact, the employment report appears strong on net after taking into account hurricane effects, given the drop in the unemployment rate to a new cycle low and the upward revisions to average hourly earnings. We increased our Fed probabilities, with subjective odds of a December hike at 80% (vs. 75% previously).



And the breakdown:


  1. Nonfarm payrolls fell by 33k in September—113k below expectations—and growth in prior months was revised down by 38k on net. However, we believe temporary hurricane effects likely explain all or most of the weakness. We had previously estimated a drag of 125k from hurricane effects, and it appears to have been even larger: the BLS commissioner reported “a sharp employment decline in food services and drinking places and below-trend growth in some other industries likely reflected the impact of Hurricanes Irma and Harvey” (food service employment alone fell by 105k). Gauging the magnitude of the impact is difficult, but given the commissioner’s statement and given the sharp rise in the household “not at work due to weather” series, our working assumption is that all or most of the weakness was hurricane-related—and likely transitory. The state-level payrolls data released October 20th will provide substantial clarity on the magnitude of the impact. By industry, goods-producing industries added 9k jobs in September reflecting a rise in construction employment (+8k). Private service-providing employment fell 49k, as a 111k drop in leisure and hospitality payrolls was partially offset by growth in education and health (+27k) and trade, transportation, and utilities (+26k) jobs. Government payrolls rose 7k. The breadth of job gains weakened likely due to hurricane effects, with the payrolls diffusion index – the net share of industries adding jobs during the month – falling to 55.7% from 60.2%

  2. The household measure of employment was very strong, rising 906k in September following the 74k decline in September. The 939k gap between employment growth in the household and payroll reports was the largest ever excluding months with level adjustments to population controls. Household employment on a population- and establishment survey-adjusted basis rose only 7k, as the numbers of workers on unpaid leave from their jobs—which are included in household employment but not in establishment employment—rose by 908k (SA), presumably largely driven by the hurricanes. The unemployment rate fell in September to 4.22% from 4.44%, as the surge in household jobs more than offset the increase in the participation rate to 63.1% (from 62.9%). While the unemployment rate may in principle have been pushed down by hurricane effects (for instance if the response rate drops more among unemployed), we think this is unlikely because the BLS noted that “there was no discernible effect on the national unemployment rate” and because historically natural disasters have led to moderate increases in the unemployment rate. Another reason to doubt that the decline in the unemployment rate was due to the hurricanes is that household employment was strong (as opposed to the labor labor force being weak). The broader U6 underemployment rate fell 3 tenths to 8.3%, as the shares of marginally attached and the U3 rate fell.

  3. Average hourly earnings increased by a larger-than-expected 0.45% in September (mom), and a significant upward revision to July growth (+0.2pp to +0.5%) resulted in the year-over-year rate increased to +2.9% from a previously reported pace of +2.5% in August. While the composition effect due to the decline in the share of low-wage leisure and hospitality workers may have boosted September earnings, the upward revisions in prior months were large. Average weekly hours held steady at 34.4.

  4. Our preliminary wage tracker—which distills signals from several wage measures—shows 2.4% for Q3, up from +2.2% in Q2.

  5. We believe the headline payrolls miss is considerably less important than usual for the monetary policy outlook, because hurricanes clearly affected the data, other US growth data has been firm, and there are two more employment reports between now and the December meeting to make up for the weakness. We actually think the most important takeaway from the report was the upward revision to average hourly earnings, with wage growth now reported at just below 3%. Given this and given the drop in the unemployment rate to a new cycle low, we increased our Fed probabilities, with subjective odds of a December hike at 80% (vs. 75% previously).

Of course, if the BLS" wage growth calculation is wrong, everything changes. Until then, here"s a look at where the market-implied odds of a December hike are: not surprisingly... right at 80%.



Tuesday, October 3, 2017

The Globalists Are Systematically Destroying America's Middle Class

Authored by Michael Snyder via The Economic Collapse blog,


When people are dependent on the government they are much easier to control.



We are often told that we are not “compassionate” when we object to the endless expansion of government social programs, but that is not how the debate should be framed.


In America today, well over 100 million people receive money from the federal government each month, and the number of Americans that are truly financially independent is continually shrinking.  In fact, only 25 percent of all Americans have more than $10,000 in savings right now according to one survey.  If we eventually get to the point where virtually all of us are dependent on the government for our continued existence, that would give the globalists a very powerful tool of control.  In the end, they want as many of us dependent on the government as possible, because those that are dependent on the government are a lot less likely to fight against their agenda.


Back in 1992, the bottom 90 percent of American income earners brought in more than 60 percent of the country’s income.  But last year that figure slipped to just 49.7 percent.  The wealth of our society is increasingly being concentrated at the very top, and the middle class is steadily being eroded. 


Surveys have found that somewhere around two-thirds of the country is living paycheck to paycheck at least part of the time, and so living on the edge has become a way of life for most Americans.


Earlier today, I came across another article that was bemoaning the fact that the U.S. economy seems to be rather directionless at this point…


  • We do not have a real plan for health care, and costs continue to gobble up American wages.

  • We do not have a plan for dealing with globalization and economic change, but that change continues to shape our economy.

  • We don’t have a plan to update our decrepit infrastructure.

  • The one plan we did have — the Federal Reserve’s post-financial crisis program — is about to be unwound, marking the end of the last clear, executable plan to bolster America’s economy.

Ultimately, the truth is that we don’t actually need some sort of “central plan” for our economy.  We are supposed to be a free market system that is not guided and directed by central planners, but many Americans don’t even understand the benefits of free market capitalism anymore.


However, that article did make a great point about globalization:





Most people don’t realize that our economy is slowly but surely being integrated into a global economic system.   This is really bad for American workers, because now they are being merged into a global labor pool in which they must compete directly for jobs with workers in other countries where it is legal to pay slave labor wages.



Even down in Mexico, many autoworkers are only making $2.25 an hour…





Most of the workers at the new Audi factory in the state of Puebla, inaugurated in 2016 and assembling the Audi Q4 SUV, which carries a sticker price in the US of over $40,000 for base versions, make $2.25 an hour, according to the Union.



Volkswagen, which owns Audi, started building Beetles in Puebla in 1967 and has since created a vast manufacturing empire in Mexico, with vehicles built for consumers in Mexico, the US, Canada, and Latin American markets.



Volkswagen, Ford, GM, or any of the global automakers, which can manufacture just about anywhere in the world, always search for cheap labor to maximize the bottom line.



Would you want to work for $2.25 an hour?


Over time, millions of good paying jobs have been leaving high wage countries and have been going to low wage countries.  The United States has lost more than 70,000 manufacturing facilities since China joined the WTO, and this is one of the biggest factors that has eroded the middle class.


In a desperate attempt to maintain our standard of living, we have gone into increasing amounts of debt.  Of course our federal government is now 20 trillion dollars in debt, but on an individual level we are doing the same thing.  Today, American consumers are over 12 trillion dollars in debt, and it gets worse with each passing day.


The borrower is the servant of the lender, and most Americans have become debt slaves at this point.  This is something that Paul Craig Roberts commented on recently…





Americans carry on by accumulating debt and becoming debt slaves. Many can only make the minimum payment on their credit card and thus accumulate debt. The Federal Reserve’s policy has exploded the prices of financial assets. The result is that the bulk of the population lacks discretionary income, and those with financial assets are wealthy until values adjust to reality.



As an economist I cannot identify in history any economy whose affairs have been so badly managed and prospects so severely damaged as the economy of the United States of America. In the short/intermediate run policies that damage the prospects for the American work force benefit what is called the One Percent as jobs offshoring reduces corporate costs and financialization transfers remaining discretionary income in interest and fees to the financial sector. But as consumer discretionary incomes disappear and debt burdens rise, aggregate demand falters, and there is nothing left to drive the economy.



This debt-based system continuously funnels wealth toward the very top of the pyramid, because it is the people at the very top that hold all of the debts.


Each year it gets worse, and most Americans would be absolutely stunned to hear that the top one percent now control 38.6 percent of all wealth in the United States…





The richest 1% of families controlled a record-high 38.6% of the country’s wealth in 2016, according to a Federal Reserve report published on Wednesday.



That’s nearly twice as much as the bottom 90%, which has seen its slice of the pie continue to shrink.



The bottom 90% of families now hold just 22.8% of the wealth, down from about one-third in 1989 when the Fed started tracking this measure.



So how do we fix this?


Well, the truth is that we need to go back to a non-debt based system that does not funnel all of the wealth to the very top of the pyramid.


Unfortunately, most Americans don’t even realize that our current debt-based system is fundamentally flawed, and it will probably take an unprecedented crisis in order to wake people up enough to take action.


*  *  *


Michael Snyder is a Republican candidate for Congress in Idaho’s First Congressional District, and you can learn how you can get involved in the campaign on his official website. His new book entitled “Living A Life That Really Matters” is available in paperback and for the Kindle on Amazon.com.

Monday, September 11, 2017

"Solid Footing"... How Is The Average Joe Really Doing?

When some think of the economy, they think of GDP. When I think of the economy, I try to visualize the average Joe and how he or she is doing.


According to Federal Reserve Governor Lael Brainard:





Overall, the U.S. economy remains on solid footing, against the backdrop of the first synchronized global economic growth we have seen in many years and accommodative financial conditions.



This benign outlook is clouded somewhat by uncertainty about government funding and the fiscal outlook, and geostrategic risk has risen ….. Of course, the likely economic effects of Hurricane Harvey raise uncertainties about the economic outlook for the remainder of the year.



Yes, employment seems to be improving (I look at employment-population ratios) – although it remains far from excellent.



And average wages (blue line in graph below) seem to be improving (really difficult to monitor median incomes in real time). It’s all good if you have a job.


Indexed Real Wages and Salaries (Q1 2008 = 100) Per Employee



The red line on the above graph is real median household income which lags over one year.


But the chart which concerns me is consumption versus spending.


The ratio of spending to income has been very elevated since September 2016. There have been only three extended periods in history where the ratio of spending to income has exceeded 0.92 (the months surrounding the 2001 recession, from September 2004 to the beginning of the 2007 Great Recession, and since September 2016).


Seasonally Adjusted Spending’s Ratio to Income (an increasing ratio means Consumer is spending more of Income)



And personal savings rate nears historic lows.



Seems to me the average Joe is living from hand-to-mouth with little left over.


This kind of trend increases financial inequality – and tends to create a big brother government which assists the average Joe to survive.


The American middle class has been rotting away for decades..




The Top .01% is not sharing the wealthy with the bottom 50% income earners, which has produced massive wealth inequality gaps. Such gaps usually happened around an economic and social crisis.



Saturday, September 2, 2017

Why We're Doomed...

Authored by Charles Hugh Smith via OfTwoMinds blog,


The point is the present system cannot endure.


Despite all the happy talk about "recovery" and higher growth, wages have gone nowhere since 2000--and for the bottom 20% of workers, they"ve gone nowhere since the 1970s.



Gross domestic product (GDP) has risen smartly since 2000, but the share of GDP going to wages and salaries has plummeted: this is simply an extension of a 47-year downtrend.



Last month I posted one reason Why We"re Doomed: Our Economy"s Toxic Inequality (August 16, 2017). The second half of why we"re doomed is stagnant wages. Why do stagnating wages for the bottom 95% doom our status quo? As I noted yesterday in Why Wages Have Lost Ground in the 21st Century, our system requires ever-higher household incomes to function--not just in the top 5%, but in the top 80%.


Our federal social programs--Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid--are pay-as-you-go: all the expenditures this year are paid by taxes collected this year. As I have detailed many times, the so-called "Trust Funds" are fictions; when Social Security runs a deficit, the difference between receipts and expenses are filled by selling Treasury bonds in the open market--the exact same mechanism ther government uses to fund any other deficit.


The demographics of the nation have changed in the past two generations. The Baby Boom is retiring en masse, expanding the number of beneficiaries of these programs, while the number of full-time workers to retirees is down from 10-to-1 in the good old days to 2-to-1: there are 60 million beneficiaries of Social Security and Medicare and about 120 million full-time workers in the U.S.


Meanwhile, medical expenses per person are soaring. Profiteering by healthcare cartels, new and ever-more costly treatments, the rise of chronic lifestyle illnesses--there are many drivers of this trend. There is absolutely no evidence to support the fantasy that this trend will magically reverse.


Costs are skyrocketing and the number of retirees is ballooning, but wages are going nowhere. Do you see the problem? All pay-as-you-go programs are based on the assumption that the number of workers and the wages they earn will both rise at a rate that is above the underlying rate of inflation and equal to the rate of increase in pay-as-you-go programs.


If 95% of the households are earning less money when adjusted for inflation, and their wealth has also declined or stagnated, then how can we pay for programs which expand by 6% or more every year?


The short answer is you can"t.


The budgets of state and local governments also expand every year as citizens demand more services, infrastructure requires costly maintenance and upgrades, and the overall costs of providing government services rises (soaring healthcare premiums are a major driver of higher government expenses). How can households pay higher property and sales taxes if their incomes are going nowhere?


Stagnant wages = stagnant income tax revenues.


Then there"s the consumer economy that depends on ever-higher consumer spending. If wages are stagnant, how can households spend more money? The conventional answer is: we"ll blow asset bubbles in stocks, bonds and housing, and households can spend this newfound wealth.


Nice theory, but only the top slice of American households own enough of these assets to matter. Feast your eyes on these two charts of skyrocketing income and wealth inequality. This chart shows that the majority of income growth is now concentrated in the top 1/0th of 1%, and most of what"s left has gone to the top 5%. This is the only possible outcome of financialization and central-bank inflated asset bubbles.



Here"s another look at the same dynamic, but excluding capital gains, which flow to those who own most of the assets, i.e. the top 1%: the bottom 90% lost 10% in the decade 2002-2012, the top 5% gained 6% and the very top of the wealth-power pyramid, the top 1/100th of the 1%, gained 76%.



The conclusion is sobering: wages/salaries are no longer an adequate means to distribute income or paid work. Our system is broken at the deepest levels--not just economically broken, but socially broken as well. Clinging to this broken model and filling the widening gap between the super-wealthy and everyone else with more debt will doom the system.


This is why I"ve proposed a new way to organize production, consumption, work and income in my book A Radically Beneficial World: Automation, Technology & Creating Jobs for All.


The point is the present system cannot endure. Borrowing trillions of dollars to paper over this failure won"t work for much longer. We need a new system, or we"re well and truly doomed.

Sunday, July 30, 2017

Illinois Had The Worst Personal Income Growth In The U.S. Over The Past Decade

Submitted by Austin Berg, of IllinoisPolicy.org


Illinois’ jobs growth was worse than every neighboring state, and half the neighboring state average from June 2016 to June 2017, according to a new report. Data released July 27 by the Illinois Department of Employment Security, or IDES, reveals Illinois’ jobs growth from June 2016 to June 2017 was 0.9 percent, compared with a national average of 1.5 percent.



The greater Chicago area fared far better than the rest of Illinois with 1.2 percent jobs growth, but still lagged behind the national average. The rest of the state saw just 0.2 percent jobs growth.



The new IDES release also contained data by metropolitan statistical area, or MSA. Of Illinois’ 14 MSAs, eight saw jobs growth of less than 1 percent. Only five of Illinois’ MSAs saw jobs growth higher than the national average: Springfield, Kankakee, Lake County-Kenosha County, Bloomington and Carbondale-Marion.


The Decatur MSA experienced no jobs growth over the year. Rockford and Danville each lost 200 jobs over the year, on net.


The IDES data underscore a lack of economic reforms in the budget passed by state lawmakers earlier this month, which included the largest permanent income tax hike in state history.


Take Decatur, for example. Moody’s Analytics revealed earlier this year that the former manufacturing titan was one of four Illinois metro areas where the recession recovery was at risk of “coming undone.” Researchers also included Danville on that list.


Decatur residents are in dire need of healthier incomes. Even the hope of decent jobs growth would be a vast improvement.


Instead, the tax hike will force the average Decatur resident to send $580 more each year to state government, according to the Decatur Herald & Review. That’s money that could have been spent locally at struggling small businesses, put toward college savings or spent on household essentials. Instead, it will vanish into Springfield’s sinkhole of debt.


Illinois’ sickly economy doesn’t just show itself in poor jobs numbers, but in paychecks as well. The Land of Lincoln is home to the worst personal income growth in the United States over the Great Recession era.



Illinois’ lawmakers have failed to pass the pro-growth reforms from which neighboring states are reaping benefits. Take property taxes, which are higher in Illinois than in every state with no income tax at all.


Neighboring Wisconsin’s property taxes as a percentage of personal income are the lowest the state’s seen since the end of World War II. Illinois property taxes are nearly triple those in neighboring Indiana. But reforms to address the cost-drivers of Illinois property taxes have been stonewalled in the General Assembly.


Illinois is also home to the costliest workers’ compensation system in the region, yet serious efforts at reform have gone untouched by legislative leaders. And as neighboring states such as Missouri are on the path to income tax cuts, Illinois lawmakers passed a 32 percent income tax increase.


Until lawmakers get serious about economic growth, don’t expect Illinois’ jobs trend to diverge from the weak path it’s been treading for years.

Monday, July 10, 2017

The Number Of Young Men Not Working Has Doubled In 15 Years

Authored by Robert Donachie via The Daily Signal,


Young men are working less and playing video games more, according to a National Bureau of Economic Research study published Monday.



Men ages 21 to 30 years old worked 12 percent fewer hours in 2015 than they did in 2000, the economists found. Around 15 percent of young men worked zero weeks in 2015, a rate nearly double that of 2000.



Since 2004, young men have increasingly allocated more of their free time to playing video games and other computer-related activities, according to the study.


Thirty-five percent of young men are living at home with their parents or a close relative, up 12 percent since 2000.


The results of the economists’ research are interesting, considering there are 10 million American men ages 24 to 64 that have completely dropped out of the workforce. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics reported in June that there were nearly 6 million jobs waiting to be filled. The U.S. job market has consistently posted gains around or above 200,000 new jobs per month in 2017.


The results of Monday’s study could suggest that, instead of actively seeking work in an economy with millions of open jobs, young men are choosing to stay at home and play video games.


Which might explain the soaring popularity of socialist politicians around the world...


Thursday, June 8, 2017

Household Net Worth Hits A Record $95 Trillion ... There Is Just One Catch

In the Fed"s latest Flow of Funds report, today the Fed released the latest snapshot of the US "household" sector as of March 31, 2017. What it revealed is that with $110.0 trillion in assets and a modest $15.2 trillion in liabilities, the net worth of the average US household rose to a new all time high of $94.835 trillion, up $2.4 trillion as a result of an estimated $500 billion increase in real estate values, but mostly $1.78 trillion increase in various stock-market linked financial assets like corporate equities, mutual and pension funds, as the stock market continued to soar to all time highs .


At the same time, household borrowing rose by only $36 billion from $15.1 trillion to $15.2 trillion, the bulk of which was $9.8 trillion in home mortgages.


The breakdown of the total household balance sheet as of Q2 is shown below.



And the historical change of the US household balance sheet.



And while it would be great news if wealth across America had indeed risen as much as the chart above shows, the reality is that there is a big catch: as shown previously, virtually all of the net worth, and associated increase thereof, has only benefited a handful of the wealthiest Americans.


As a reminder, from the CBO"s latest Trends in Family Wealth analysis, here is a breakdown of the above chart by wealth group, which sadly shows how the "average" American wealth is anything but.



While the breakdown has not caught up with the latest data, it provides an indicative snapshot of who benefits. Here is how the CBO recently explained the wealth is distributed:


  • In 2013, families in the top 10 percent of the wealth distribution held 76 percent of all family wealth, families in the 51st to the 90th percentiles held 23 percent, and those in the bottom half of the distribution held 1 percent.

  • Average wealth was about $4 million for families in the top 10 percent of the wealth distribution, $316,000 for families in the 51st to 90th percentiles, and $36,000 for families in the 26th to 50th percentiles. On average, families at or below the 25th percentile were $13,000 in debt.

In other words, roughly three-quarter of the $2.4 trillion increase in assets went to benefit just 10% of the population, who also account for roughly 76% of America"s financial net worth,


Even worse, when looking at how wealth distribution changed from 1989 to 2013, a clear picture emerges. Over the period from 1989 through 2013, family wealth grew at significantly different rates for different segments of the U.S. population. In 2013, for example:The wealth of families at the 90th percentile of the distribution was 54 percent greater than the wealth at the 90th percentile in 1989, after adjusting for changes in prices.


  • The wealth of those at the median was 4 percent greater than the wealth of their counterparts in 1989.

  • The wealth of families at the 25th percentile was 6 percent less than that of their counterparts in 1989.

  • As the chart below shows, nobody has experienced the same cumulative growth in after-tax income as the "Top 1%"


The above is particularly topical at a time when either party is trying to take credit for the US recovery. Here, while previously Democrats, and now Republicans tout the US "income recovery" they may have forgotten about half of America, but one entity remembers well: loan collectors. As the chart below shows, America"s poor families have never been more in debt.





The share of families in debt (those whose total debt exceeded their total assets) remained almost unchanged between 1989 and 2007 and then increased by 50 percent between 2007 and 2013. In 2013, those families were more in debt than their counterparts had been either in 1989 or in 2007. For instance, 8 percent of families were in debt in 2007 and, on average, their debt exceeded their assets by $20,000. By 2013, in the aftermath of the recession of 2007 to 2009, 12 percent of families were in debt and, on average, their debt exceeded their assets by $32,000.



The increase in average indebtedness between 2007 and 2013 for families in debt was mainly the result of falling home equity and rising student loan balances. In 2007, 3 percent of families in debt had negative home equity: They owed, on average, $16,000 more than their homes were worth. In 2013, that share was 19 percent of families in debt, and they owed, on average, $45,000 more than their homes were worth. The share of families in debt that had outstanding student debt rose from 56 percent in 2007 to 64 percent in 2013, and the average amount of their loan balances increased from $29,000 to $41,000.




And there is your recovery: the wealthy have never been wealthier, while half of America, some 50% of households, now own just 1% of the country"s wealth, down from 3% in 1989, while America"s poor have never been more in debt.

Saturday, June 3, 2017

"It's Not Just Wages" - Workers Without College Degrees Face "More Instability"

If you believe San Francisco Fed President John Williams, the US labor market has almost never been ore robust than it is today. Of course, middle- and working-class Americans who are struggling with levels of financial uncertainty that would be unfamiliar to their parents’ generation don’t necessarily care that the official unemployment rate is 4.4%. They’re too busy struggling to make ends meet when real wages have been stagnant for decades and economic growth is expected to slouch along at 2% for the foreseeable future.


While researching their new book “The Financial Diaries,” Jonathan Morduch and Rachel Schneider followed more than 200 working and middle-class families around for a year and tracked “every dollar of their financial lives." They found that millions of workers without college degrees, especially those who are paid hourly, or who are paid by commission, experience what they call call income variability - when their pay fluctuates by 25% above or below their average. One of Murdoch and Schneider"s subjects, a truck mechanic named Jeremy, even quit his job to take a lower paying job with a steady salary.


They discussed their findings during an episode of Bloomberg"s "Benchmark" podcast.






“When we first met him, his weekly paychecks were very variable. And he was bearing all that risk. At the end of the year, he quit his job for another job with lower pay that was more steady. ”






“On average, we’re seeing households spend about five months of the year where their income was 25% above their average or 25% below their average. So income insecurity wasn’t about ‘am I going to lose my job,’ it’s about ‘how am I going to navigate the ups and downs in my given job.’”



The pair also found that existing financial services don"t adequately serve the needs of workers struggling with income variability. Schneider discussed how one subject whom she called Jane intentionally placed obstacles to withdrawing money from her savings account.





“Often the strategies they were using to make that money stretch show gaps in how financial services are or are not serving them. For example, we tell the story in the book of a woman called Janice who has a savings account and a checking account but she cut up her checkbook for her checking account and she cut up her ATM card. She has those accounts in different institutions and the savings account is an hour’s drive from her home.”



“A bank might say she’s not using those products right, she’s paying check cashers and fees on money orders to pay her bills she’s using it wrong. But I look at it the other way she actually wants some wall between herself and her spending or savings. She cut up the check book because she doesn’t want temptation to take out payday loans which she’s had trouble with in the past.”



Regardless of race, workers without degrees are stuggling "in a lot of ways."





“One of the things that we see is that today workers without college degrees are struggling in a lot of ways. We see that in the labor market in terms of wages and what our data and related data are showing is it’s not just average wages they also are facing much more instability than other workers."


"The economic backlash is being felt by lower class workers, regardless of race, because the system isn’t working for the poor.Black workers have a hard time and white worker as well are living very precarious lives. Even though they have jobs there’s economic anxiety in America even for people with jobs. And that’s the big puzzle in America. That people are trying to sort out what the big answer is but you spend time and follow people month to month you see exactly why there’s so much anxiety in a sense because the system really isn’t working for them.”
 


Friday, May 26, 2017

As Markets Hit Record Highs, Stock Ownership Is Down (Except For Old & Rich People)

Gallup released a poll Thursday showing that overall stock ownership among US adults remains 8 percentage points below its pre-crisis level. But even as the crisis appears to have scared many Americans away from owning stocks, there are two demographic subgroups where ownership has held firm: Adults aged 65 and older and those with an annual household income of $100,000 or more.


The data is from Gallup’s annual “Economy and Personal Finance” survey, which asks US adults whether they personally or jointly have money invested in the stock market, including in individual stocks and stock-market funds such as 401(k)s and individual retirement accounts (IRAs).


Before the crisis, 62% of US adults said they owned stocks. As of April, that number has dropped to 54% - which is higher than last year’s reading, 52%.


That’s bad news for millennials and Gen Xers, because even though the main indexes halved in value during the aftermath of the crisis, they have since more than made up for those declines by rising to record highs. The S&P 500 is up more than 102% since the day Lehman Brothers declared bankruptcy.



The implications of the data are clear. Here’s Gallup:





“The stock market has performed well in 2017, but proportionately fewer Americans are benefiting from today"s bull market than did so in bull markets before the financial crisis. The gains in stock values in recent years seem to have done little to persuade people who may have divested themselves of stocks to get back in the market."



“Nor has the recovery encouraged new investors to join the market. Although young adults are understandably less likely than their elders to own stocks, the percentage of 18- to 29-year-olds investing is down 11 points since before the financial crisis.”



While the poorest Americans have definitely borne the brunt of rising inequality, they aren’t driving the decline in stock ownership because equity ownership among low-income people has been low for years.


Instead it’s the middle- and upper-middle-income households that have largely driven the decline.


The aftermath of the crisis also appears to have had a lingering impact on Millennials and Gen Xers, who’ve had to grapple with tepid employment and a student debt load that ballooned to more than $1 trillion during their prime working years.


Rising equity valuations, which have been spurred on by the Federal Reserve and its unprecedented monetary stimulus, have certainly played a role in driving up income inequality in the U.S.


But Gallup noted that the aging of the baby boomer demographic may have also contributed to the disparity in ownership rates. Older workers were in their prime during the boom years of the 1980s and 1990s so it"s more likely they had 401(k)s at work, leaving them with above average stock ownership. 


Here’s Gallup’s data.