Showing posts with label Chicago Board Options Exchange. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chicago Board Options Exchange. Show all posts

Monday, December 18, 2017

Bitcoin Futures Open Above $20,000... Then Dump

Both CME and CBOE Bitcoin Futures contracts opened above $20,000 this evening (with Bitcoin spot hovering around $19,000). However, as soon as trading started, Bitcoin futures got hammered lower.



 


Those expecting a surge in futs volumes on the CME vs the CBOE will be disappointed:



In fact, spoting actual trades in the first few minutes of trading is not heavy to say the least. Obviously Jan is seeing all the volume...



And March not so much... (let alone the $1200 bid-offer spread)



The lack of trading will likely be a surprise to those who were expecting a more "vigorous" futures launch on the CME, such as Brooks Dudley, vice president of risk in New York at ED&F Man Capital Markets who told Bloomberg that "CME’s bitcoin contract may not be first, but they are a larger futures clearinghouse and we are looking forward to our clients trading their product on Sunday evening. Not all market participants have been able to short the Cboe bitcoin futures. We have allowed our clients to go long or short to take advantage of dislocations between the futures and the underlying spot market.”


For now, nobody appears to be taking advantage of anything.


Incidentally, here is the (declining) Cboe XBT futs volumes in the first week of trading.



Finally, for those who missed it, here is JPM"s take on CME vs Cboe futs:


  • With CME Bitcoin futures set to begin trading on 18th December, there will be competition between the two exchanges to attract volumes. Similar to the CBOE contract, the CME futures are cash settled, and after reviewing the initial margin requirement ahead of launch the CME raised it this week from 35% to 47% for speculative accounts, modestly higher than the CBOE’s
    44% initial margin requirement.

  • There are some differences in the contracts worth noting, however. The settlement price of the CME futures will be based on a weighted average of prices from several exchanges (including Bitstamp, GDAX, itBit and Kraken), rather than a single exchange. The settlement dates of the CME futures will also extend further ahead to March, June, September and December. These factors, along with the fact that the CME is a larger exchange, could give it an advantage in terms of attracting trading volumes.






Monday, December 11, 2017

CBOE Website Crashes As XBT Trading Begins, Bitcoin Price Surges

The CBOE’s website crashed within minutes of the CBOE open on Sunday – which also marked the launch of the first bitcoin futures to trade on a major exchange... 



... while the price of a bitcoin spiked 10% in five minutes as the new contract with the ticker XBT fluctuated wildly.



The embarrassing crash happened as the entire financial world was closely watching the first historic institutionalization of bitcoin:



Shortly after the initial snafu, the CBOE tweeted that "visitors to cboe.com may find site is performing slower than usual and may at times be temporarily unavailable" due to heavy traffic adding that "all trading systems are operating normally."



"Given the unprecedented interest in Bitcoin, it’s vital we provide clients the trading tools to help them express their views and hedge their exposure," said Ed Tilly, chairman and CEO of CBOE Global Markets, in a statement earlier this month. Trading in Bitcoin futures will be free through the end of December.


Despite the surging interest in what was taking place on the CBOE, a little over an hour after the launch, some 555 XBT jan 2018 futures contracts had traded - equivalent of roughly $9 million notional... 



... and while futures market depth was virtually non-existant in early trading, the bid/ask spread in the orderbook has since shrunk as depth increased, and is now "only" $50.



Indeed, as the tradestation tick chart below shows, as we expected, today"s launch is hardly euphoria bonanza some had expected.



Going further out on the curve, just one March 2018 contract has traded one hour into trading.



What is also notable, is that while at least in early trading, bitcoin futures appeared to be trading with a premium as much as $400 above cash, according to Jared Bilkre, the XBT future was trading around fair value, the Friday Gemini Index close, off of which the futures are priced.



Still, it remains to be seen if the futures and spot prices will converge, with the spread still will in the hundreds of dollars.



Meanwhile, the price of spot Bitcoin surged immediately after the 6 p.m. open, climbing about 10%, or $1,500 on GDAX to over $16,200, before giving back much of the early gains...



... as the excitement over this historic moment slowly fades away.


 


And while for at least one person today"s first day of trading will never be forgotten, the first documented trade appears to have been a short.



To which there was a caveat...








Sunday, October 8, 2017

The Last Time The Market Did This Was After Kennedy's Assassination

Via LPLResearch.com,


There have only been eight moves of at least 1% for the S&P 500 Index so far this year - the least since 13 in 1995. The all-time record was an incredible three in 1963.


What about a big move? The last time the S&P 500 moved at least 4% was nearly six years ago.


In fact, the S&P 500 had four consecutive days with 4% (or greater) changes in August 2011. Other than 2008 and the crash of ’87, that is the only other time since the Great Depression to see four consecutive 4% changes.


That isn’t anything like today’s action...


As the chart below shows, so far in 2017, big moves have been nonexistent; and even 1% changes have been rare.



Per Ryan Detrick, Senior Market Strategist,





“If you had forecast that the 11 months after the 2016 U.S. presidential election would be one of the least volatile periods ever, you would be in the minority.



Then again, the last time we saw a streak of calm like this was the year after John F. Kennedy was assassinated in November 1963.



Once again proving that the market rarely does what the masses expect and usually surprises us.”



And as LPL Research additionally notes, as equity markets continue to move higher, and as a result, several long streaks are taking place. Per Ryan Detrick, Senior Market Strategist,





“This is the Frank ‘The Tank’ market, as multiple streaks have taken place recently that are in the history books, with some being the most impressive ever.”



Here are some of the notable recent streaks:


  • Yesterday ended a streak of 17 consecutive closes for the S&P 500 Index within 0.5% of its previous closing price – the longest streak of small daily changes since 1969.

  • The S&P 500 Index has closed higher 8 days in a row for the first time since 2013 and has closed at all-time highs 6 days in a row for the first time since June 1997.

  • The S&P 500 has been up 8 consecutive quarters for the fifth time ever.

  • The Russell 2000 Index recently closed at a new all-time high eight days in a row.

  • The Euro STOXX 600 recently closed higher nine days in a row—the longest streak in more than two years.

  • The CBOE Volatility Index (VIX) yesterday closed at 9.19, its lowest close in history. It also closed beneath 10 for 7 consecutive days for the second time ever. Last, it averaged only 10.94 in the third quarter which is its lowest quarterly average ever.

  • The Russell Microcap Index recently closed at a new all-time high 12 out of 14 days.

  • The S&P 500 has closed higher a record 11 consecutive months on a total return basis (i.e., including dividends). Since 1950*, that has only happened two other times, with both instances taking place during the bull market of the 1950s. Be aware though, neither of those made it to 12 months.

Now That’s a Win Streak



Frank “The Tank’s” run through the quad and into the gymnasium eventually ended - and these long market streaks will eventually end as well. It is important to remember that daily streaks of new highs can’t go on forever, and that increases in volatility aren’t necessarily something to be overly concerned about; pullbacks are a regular part of investing.


In fact, the latter stages of the economic cycle have historically seen relatively more volatility, and we expect it to pick up in the fourth quarter and as we head into 2018.

Monday, September 4, 2017

VIX Set For Lowest Annual Average Ever, But...

While intra-month the CBOE Volatility Index reached its highest since November, before plunging back to earth into the end of the month, VIX is still on track to post its lowest annual average on record.



Bloomberg notes that in the past decade, VIX gains in August were followed by September declines in all but one instance.


While VIX has collapsed so far this year, it may not last.


Though VIX ended up paring its August gain to 3.2% - a gauge tracking longer-term wagers posted its biggest increase since January 2016.



In fact, after last month’s 11 percent gain, the CBOE S&P 500 3-Month Volatility Index has reached its highest level relative to the VIX since Aug 2012"s European credit crisis.



The September Federal Reserve gathering and debt-ceiling discussions are among events that could lead to increased market volatility at a time when the S&P 500 Index trades near a record high.

Tuesday, July 11, 2017

Retail Investors Are Piling Into "The Most Dangerous Trade In The World"

It shouldn"t be too surprising that the XIV exchange-traded note - which is designed to deliver the inverse performance of the well-known CBOE Volatility Index (or the VIX) on a daily basis - is attracting fresh attention after surging as much as 87 percent this year.



But, as CNBC notes, some caution that investing in the exchange-traded product now could be deeply risky.





This could be "the most dangerous trade in the world," according to macro strategist Boris Schlossberg of BK Asset Management.



"It"s already had a massive runup because we"ve had very low volatility," but at this point, "it"s very likely that volatility is going to increase," Schlossberg said Thursday on CNBC"s "Trading Nation."



The rise in this product hasn"t escaped traders" attention. In terms of the dollar value of shares traded, the short-VIX-futures XIV has actually surpassed the long-VIX-futures VXX.


"We think it"s especially interesting that there is now more XIV trading than VXX, perhaps pointing to the growing interest in shorting volatility among retail [investors] and others who are not specialists in volatility trading," Pravit Chintawongvanich, head of derivatives strategy at Macro Risk Advisors, wrote in a Wednesday note to clients.




As for Schlossberg, his warning about the product is based on his view that volatility is set to rise from its current, ultralow levels.





"It"s simply a dangerous trade from a macro point of view," he said Thursday. "As central banks begin to increase rates, we"re going to see more volatility, and this [product] is going to show some very negative days."



In fact, "negative" may be putting it mildly. On a day when the VIX and the VIX futures double in value (perhaps due to bad news out of Freedonia), the VXX could easily double as well, while the XIV could perform the inverse move.





"One big thing that we"ve been highlighting is that this product can actually go to zero," Chintawongvanich said Thursday on "Trading Nation."



"Right now the VIX is around 12 -- just think of a scenario that takes the VIX from 12 to 20-plus in a single day. It"s not impossible. In that case the XIV could easily go to zero," which is something "many investors in this product may not be aware of."



Those who buy the XIV with money they cannot afford to lose, then, could be putting their portfolio in great danger indeed.


And while shares outstanding in the "bearish" VXX has exploded (as shares outstanding in "bullish" XIV), adjusted for the endless decay in price, the trend is clear - forget hedging, forget fear, sell VIX!!



What could possibly go wrong?

Thursday, May 25, 2017

Another Rigged Market: Scientific Study Finds Systemic VIX Auction Manipulation

To the list of "rigged" markets (e.g. Libor, FX, Silver, Treasuries...) we can now add VIX (which explains a lot) as two University of Texas at Austin finance professors find "large transient deviations in VIX prices" around the morning auction, "consistent with market manipulation."



As Bloomberg reports, in addition to being an index that is much quoted in articles about market complacency, the VIX is used as a reference price for derivatives: If you want to bet that stock-market volatility will go up, or down, you can buy or sell futures or options on the VIX. These products are cash settled: The VIX is not a thing you can own, so if your option ends up in the money you just get paid cash for the value of the VIX at settlement.  


CBOE gets an official settlement level of the VIX based on a special monthly settlement auction of S&P 500 options. The auction runs from 7:30 a.m to 8:30 a.m., Chicago time. Traders submit bids and offers for S&P 500 options, the auction matches buyers and sellers to find clearing prices, and the prices of those S&P 500 options are used to compute the official settlement level of the VIX.


Guess what?





At the settlement time of the VIX Volatility Index, volume spikes on S&P 500 Index (SPX) options, but only in out-of-the-money options that are used to calculate the VIX, and more so for options with a higher and discontinuous influence on VIX.



We investigate alternative explanations of hedging and coordinated liquidity trading. Tests including those utilizing differences in put and call options, open interest around the settlement, and a similar volatility contract with an entirely different settlement procedure in Europe are inconsistent with these explanations but consistent with market manipulation.



That"s from this paper by John Griffin and Amin Shams of the University of Texas, who find a lot of trading in the S&P 500 options underlying the VIX during these settlement auctions, trading that pushes the settlement price of the VIX up or down. So for instance in months where the trading pushes the VIX up, the prevailing price of the VIX-influencing options will jump during the auction, peak at around 8:15 a.m. (the deadline for VIX-related bids in the auction), and then drop seconds after the auction ends when the options start trading normally:



The blue line there is a measure of the indicative prices of VIX-influencing options, spiking at 8:00 a.m. and peaking near 8:15. (If you ignore the numbers on the axis, you can almost think of it as being a chart of the VIX price.) The red dot is the trading price of those options about 25 seconds after the auction finishes.


The average effect is something like 0.31 VIX points, sometimes up and sometimes down, depending on the month.


 What is going on? Usually when you see patterns like this, the innocent explanation is hedging. But Griffin and Shams consider and reject that notion here, noting for instance that traders don"t seem to be closing out existing hedge positions but instead adding new ones. They argue that it"s more likely to be explained by attempts to move the VIX: If you are a dealer who is long (short) VIX futures, you can push up (down) the VIX at settlement by buying (selling) some deep-out-of-the-money S&P 500 options.


That is generically true in any derivatives market: If you are long a derivative, you can buy the underlying and push up the derivative price. But Griffin and Shams give a list of reasons why you"d almost expect the VIX to be manipulated:





First, the upper-level VIX market is large and liquid, enabling a trader to invest a sizeable position in VIX derivatives. In contrast, many of the lower-level SPX options, where the VIX values are derived from, are illiquid.



Griffin and Shams calculate that "the size of VIX futures with open interest at settlement is on average 5.7 times the size SPX options traded at settlement, and it is 7.3 times for VIX options that are in-the-money at settlement."



So if you are a trader who owns a lot of the market in VIX futures, you could push around a large dollar value of futures by trading a small dollar value in options. This is particularly true because the S&P option volume is divided among many strikes, and the illiquid deep out-of-the-money S&P 500 options have a big influence on the VIX: You can move the price of those options a lot with relatively small trades, and those price changes have a disproportionate effect on the VIX.





Second, the VIX derivatives are cash settled. Therefore, if the VIX settlement value deviates from its true value, the VIX position will automatically be cashed out at the deviated price.



If cattle are trading at the wrong price when your cattle futures settle, that doesn"t matter so much, because you just get the cattle. But you can"t just get the VIX: You get cash, so if the VIX is at the wrong price at settlement, that"s the price you get.





Third, the settlement occurs within a short period of time based on the SPX options pre-open auction.



You don"t have to intervene over some long period to keep options prices up; you can just submit bids in the pre-opening auction once a month and move the settlement price for that month.


There is a sort of hierarchy of manipulability in markets. At the top is Libor manipulation: Trillions of dollars of derivatives settled based on Libor, but Libor was calculated by essentially asking banks "what should Libor be?" The banks didn"t even have to do any trading in order to push the number around; manipulation was, in effect, costless. (Later, with the fines, it was costly.)


At the bottom is, like, manipulating the price of a stock by trading that stock. There are cases of it! It"s a thing. But it is a dumb thing; it really shouldn"t work. If you buy a stock, you will push the price up, sure. But to make any money you then have to sell the stock, which should push the price right back down.


But if you are going to manipulate a tradable market -- as opposed to a made-up one like Libor -- then VIX looks pretty tempting.





The product that you trade (S&P 500 options) is different from the product where you make your money (VIX futures and options), and the trading market is in the relevant sense smaller than the derivative market: You can move a lot of value in VIX products by trading a small amount of value, in a confined period of time, in the underlying market. So you can cheerfully lose money executing the manipulation -- trading the S&P options -- and make back more in the derivative.



If Griffin and Shams are right that there"s manipulation, there"s no particular pattern to it: Sometimes VIX gets anomalously pushed up during the settlement, sometimes down. That"s consistent with, for instance, a story of big dealers adding up their positions before each monthly settlement, realizing that they"re net long (short), and trying to push VIX up (down) to help out their positions. It would be like the kind of Libor manipulation that banks did to help out their trading books (which was up or down depending on their positions) -- not the kind of Libor manipulation that banks also did to disguise their funding costs (which moved Libor systematically down).


Finally, The Wall Street Journal notes that it is, of course, tough to rule out the possibility that something more benign is going on. For example, investors who had used the expiring derivatives to protect themselves could be seeking replacement protection when they participate in the auction, some say. Messrs. Griffin and Shams believe it’s not hedging activity due to the trading patterns they observed.


Full Study below:

Thursday, May 18, 2017

US Volatility Spikes To 21-Month Highs (Relative To Europe)

Today"s sudden "Minsky Moment" in markets has pushed US equity risk perceptions to their highest relative to Europe since August 2015, back to old "norms".


As Bloomberg notes, U.S. politics are taking center stage as risks recede in Europe following the French presidential election. With Donald Trump facing the deepest crisis of his presidency, the CBOE Volatility Index surged on Wednesday, while Europe’s VStoxx Index rose less than 5 percent.



Volatility expectations for the S&P 500 Index are near their highest since August 2015 relative to the Euro Stoxx 50 Index.


And it is starting at the short-end of the VIX curve (i.e. this is systemic and not an event-timing risk issue).




And has pushed Equity risk back to its old pre-Trump "norms" against bond risk...


Wednesday, February 8, 2017

The S&P Has Now Gone 36 Days Without A 1% Intraday Move: The Longest Streak In History

Heading into Monday"s session, the S&P had gone for 34 consecutive trading sessions in which it hadn"t experienced an intraday move greater than 1%: according to the WSJ"s Market Data Group, this was the longest such streak going back over two decades, to 1995. And, following the Monday close, the market made history when it ended yet another day by being confined to a 1% trading range. This made it 35 consecutive sessions without an intraday move of 1% or more. With Tuesday"s somnolent market action and virtually unchanged close, the streak extended to 36 consecutive sessions - the longest streak in history.



For those who have followed the market, the boredom - at least on the surface - is palpable, despite what RBC pointed out last week when it said that "it is CRAZY what is going on “under the hood,” when on the index level, it’s so optically calm.” However, with most market watchers looking simplistically at aggregate level data, the S&P gives a sense of calm that is at odds with the recently documented surge in political uncertainty. 


The recent calm is a sharp contrast with what was taking place in the market just a year ago: on this week in 2016, oil was $26/bbl, the HY spread was 900bps, the S&P was 1810, EPS was negative, inflation expectations were 1%, VIX 30. Today, oil is $54/bbl, the HY spread 400bps, and the S&P is just shy of 2300, EPS positive, inflation expectations are 2%, and VIX 11.


Some observations: the average daily range between a session’s intraday high and low over that stretch, dating back to Dec. 14, is just 0.54%, according to FactSet. That compares to the S&P 500?s average daily trading range in 2016, which was 0.96%.



As the WSJ further notes, despite the lack of sharp moves, the stock market has mostly been levitating higher "even though the daily moves have been soporific." Since the streak began in December, the index has climbed just 1% in total, but it’s still managed to set a new all-time highs along the way, most recently this week. Still, uncertainty about the future of Trump administration policies have worked in concert with record high valuations and the wait-and-see approach on the part of the Federal Reserve about when next to raise interest rates to hold stocks in check.


“The market is bobbing and weaving around new highs,” wrote David Rosenberg, chief economist, and strategist at Gluskin Sheff.


That’s a sharp contrast to how the S&P behaved just three months ago, in the immediate aftermath of the surprise victory of President Donald Trump on Nov. 8, when the S&P 500 shot up 6.2% from Election Day to Dec. 13, just over a month later.


Furthermore, the absence of a one-day move in the S&P 500 is consistent with other readings of ultra-low volatility. The historical volatility of the SPY ETF, a measure of how volatile that S&P 500 has been over two months, sits at 6.5, the lowest in at least two years, according to CBOE Livevol. Ninety-day historical volatility is barely higher at 8.1, also the lowest in two years.


Expectations for future prices swings in the S&P 500 over the next 30 days are scarcely higher. The VIX has been depressed to near record lows since the election. The VIX is currently at 11.3, well below its long-term average near 20.


Still, the doldrums may be ending soon. As Jason Goepfert at SentimenTrader, quoted by Art Cashin, notes the market is showing little enthusiasm to the upside despite the record highs in the S&P:





Negative momentum is picking up under the surface. Even as the major stock indexes hit all-time highs, or were close to them on Friday, stocks in the S&P 1500 index weren"t showing as much enthusiasm. Gauged by the Relative Strength Index, an abnormally low number of stocks have seen extreme positive momentum, and a rising number are seeing extreme negative momentum.



Indecision after a buying thrust. Friday"s surge at the open left an unfilled gap, as prices never neared Thursday"s closing price during the day. Then on Monday, traders showed indecision with an inside day, a lower high and higher low than Friday"s session. That has led to subpar returns, even during this bull market.



Ultimately it will be up to traders to force a break out to a new trading range, and since they have been unable to do so for nearly two months to the upside, perhaps it is time to revisit what a market drop actually means.