Showing posts with label Economy of Chicago. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Economy of Chicago. Show all posts

Monday, December 18, 2017

Bitcoin Futures Open Above $20,000... Then Dump

Both CME and CBOE Bitcoin Futures contracts opened above $20,000 this evening (with Bitcoin spot hovering around $19,000). However, as soon as trading started, Bitcoin futures got hammered lower.



 


Those expecting a surge in futs volumes on the CME vs the CBOE will be disappointed:



In fact, spoting actual trades in the first few minutes of trading is not heavy to say the least. Obviously Jan is seeing all the volume...



And March not so much... (let alone the $1200 bid-offer spread)



The lack of trading will likely be a surprise to those who were expecting a more "vigorous" futures launch on the CME, such as Brooks Dudley, vice president of risk in New York at ED&F Man Capital Markets who told Bloomberg that "CME’s bitcoin contract may not be first, but they are a larger futures clearinghouse and we are looking forward to our clients trading their product on Sunday evening. Not all market participants have been able to short the Cboe bitcoin futures. We have allowed our clients to go long or short to take advantage of dislocations between the futures and the underlying spot market.”


For now, nobody appears to be taking advantage of anything.


Incidentally, here is the (declining) Cboe XBT futs volumes in the first week of trading.



Finally, for those who missed it, here is JPM"s take on CME vs Cboe futs:


  • With CME Bitcoin futures set to begin trading on 18th December, there will be competition between the two exchanges to attract volumes. Similar to the CBOE contract, the CME futures are cash settled, and after reviewing the initial margin requirement ahead of launch the CME raised it this week from 35% to 47% for speculative accounts, modestly higher than the CBOE’s
    44% initial margin requirement.

  • There are some differences in the contracts worth noting, however. The settlement price of the CME futures will be based on a weighted average of prices from several exchanges (including Bitstamp, GDAX, itBit and Kraken), rather than a single exchange. The settlement dates of the CME futures will also extend further ahead to March, June, September and December. These factors, along with the fact that the CME is a larger exchange, could give it an advantage in terms of attracting trading volumes.






Monday, December 11, 2017

CBOE Website Crashes As XBT Trading Begins, Bitcoin Price Surges

The CBOE’s website crashed within minutes of the CBOE open on Sunday – which also marked the launch of the first bitcoin futures to trade on a major exchange... 



... while the price of a bitcoin spiked 10% in five minutes as the new contract with the ticker XBT fluctuated wildly.



The embarrassing crash happened as the entire financial world was closely watching the first historic institutionalization of bitcoin:



Shortly after the initial snafu, the CBOE tweeted that "visitors to cboe.com may find site is performing slower than usual and may at times be temporarily unavailable" due to heavy traffic adding that "all trading systems are operating normally."



"Given the unprecedented interest in Bitcoin, it’s vital we provide clients the trading tools to help them express their views and hedge their exposure," said Ed Tilly, chairman and CEO of CBOE Global Markets, in a statement earlier this month. Trading in Bitcoin futures will be free through the end of December.


Despite the surging interest in what was taking place on the CBOE, a little over an hour after the launch, some 555 XBT jan 2018 futures contracts had traded - equivalent of roughly $9 million notional... 



... and while futures market depth was virtually non-existant in early trading, the bid/ask spread in the orderbook has since shrunk as depth increased, and is now "only" $50.



Indeed, as the tradestation tick chart below shows, as we expected, today"s launch is hardly euphoria bonanza some had expected.



Going further out on the curve, just one March 2018 contract has traded one hour into trading.



What is also notable, is that while at least in early trading, bitcoin futures appeared to be trading with a premium as much as $400 above cash, according to Jared Bilkre, the XBT future was trading around fair value, the Friday Gemini Index close, off of which the futures are priced.



Still, it remains to be seen if the futures and spot prices will converge, with the spread still will in the hundreds of dollars.



Meanwhile, the price of spot Bitcoin surged immediately after the 6 p.m. open, climbing about 10%, or $1,500 on GDAX to over $16,200, before giving back much of the early gains...



... as the excitement over this historic moment slowly fades away.


 


And while for at least one person today"s first day of trading will never be forgotten, the first documented trade appears to have been a short.



To which there was a caveat...