Showing posts with label S&P/ASX 200 VIX. Show all posts
Showing posts with label S&P/ASX 200 VIX. Show all posts

Wednesday, November 29, 2017

VIX - From Fear Index To Greed Index

Authored by Peter Tchir via Forbes.com,


We have all heard the VIX or volatility index referred to as the Fear Index or Fear Gauge.  Rising VIX was meant to signal fear in the markets.  That is how most investors have historically thought about VIX and traded it (directly or through Exchange Traded Products).


I have gone back in time and combined the total assets under management of XIV and SVXY (two short VIX products) and UVXY and VXX (the two largest long VIX products).  There are others and it doesn"t account for the fact that UVXY incorporates leverage, but the point is the same.


The funds that in theory helped investors "hedge" their portfolios went from being the dominant species to those that enable investors to sell volatility.



Short VIX Funds are Larger than Long VIX Funds (source Bloomberg)


This has rarely been the case.


Typically investors had more interest in hedging their portfolios despite the evidence that the long VIX ETFs and ETNs had to continually perform reverse splits as their share prices drifted lower (some would argue "raced" lower is a more accurate description).


While the products looking to benefit on a volatility spike still attract inflows (otherwise their assets under management would be even lower), they have lost the competition to the VIX sellers.


The only other gap of similar size and duration was in late August 2015 - AFTER the market sold off and volatility spiked.


This time, it is occurring as stock markets are near all-time highs and VIX is still close to the all-time low it set just a few weeks ago (VIX is only calculated since 1990).


Whether this has finally reached a stage of complacency is anyone"s guess, but the "Golden Goose" of selling VIX that I wrote about in March of this year - is clearly not a secret.


I"m not overly concerned about complacency, it is after all, a slow and typically low vol period for domestic markets, but it is something that investors need to focus on.


A spike in volatility could be far more problematic than the market is prepared for as even a small spike could turn into a larger problem with so many people positioned the other way.









Sunday, November 26, 2017

Muir: "People Are Going To Be Wiped Out" By Short-VIX ETFs

Back in August, we highlighted a story in the New York Times about a former manager at Target who decided to try day trading with $500,000 he had saved up. Over the following years, he turned that into $13 million by following one simple strategy: Shorting volatility every time it spiked.


As MacroVoices host Erik Townsend points out, that strategy has worked for many retail investors over the past eight years. And in a brief “postgame” interview with the Macro Tourist Kevin Muir following a longer interview with Francesco Filia, a fund manager at Fasanara Capital, the former explains how many investors don’t understand the risks associated with shorting volatility, as well as the possible repercussions if exchanges and brokerages don’t take the appropriate steps to limit this.


Townsend begins the discussion by asking Muir about a chart he created of the VXX - the long-VIX ETF - which, because of the low-volatility environement, has repeatedly split leading to unbelievable wealth destruction.



Going back to 2009, the price of the ETF has gone from $120,000 a share to just $35. And while a sudden spike in volatility could see it surge, with so many investors on the other side of the trade, it"s worth considering what might happen if they couldn"t pay.


It’s frightening. And I don’t think enough people are – well, there are some – but I don’t think that enough people are really considering all these things. And I think that guys like the Interactive Broker chairman, that are taking proactive steps to make sure that there’s enough margin, we need to see more of that. We need to see more people saying, hey, wait, this is actually a very, very scary instrument that has a lot of risk in it.


 


I watched a Real Vision interview with John Hempton from Bronte Capital, and he talked about phoning up the infamous Target salesman guy, the fellow that quit his job as a Target manager to trade XIV and all the VXX products, and he turned his 1/2 a million bucks into 13 million bucks. The part that really scared me about it was that John phoned him up and he was expecting to talk to this very sophisticated guy, and his basic takeaway was that, although he had a lot of buzzwords, and he understood kind of what the products represented, he didn’t really understand his true risk.


 


And I think that there’s just a myriad of people out there that are trading these things that don’t understand that. The more people that wake up and realize this, and stop playing this game, the better off we’ll be, actually.



Brokerages have caught on to this, Muir says. Interactive Brokers, one of the largest online brokerages, is now asking retail investors to post between 300%-400% margin when they short certain VIX contracts – because brokerages recognize that one sharp drawdown in the S&P 500 could blow millions of short traders out of their positions, potentially leaving thousands of customers with massive negative balances that could threaten the brokerages’ existence.


Erik, you’re absolutely correct. And Interactive Brokers, one of the largest electronic brokers out there, realizes the risk. If you look at the way that they’re margining these products, they’re margining them completely different than what the exchanges and everyone else say is the proper amount.


 


So if you look at the VIX futures, the front month is $6,200 – the exchange minimum is $6,200 – which works out to roughly 50% of a contract. The next month is $4,000, which works out to 30% of a contract. And the far months are $2,500, which works out to 17% of a contract.


 


But if you go to Interactive Brokers and you want to sell this VIX contract short, you have to put up 300%–400% of the contract. Because they’ve looked at it and they’ve realized that if the S&P has a 10% down move, which isn’t out of the realm of possibility, that the VIX could spike up to 37 really easily. And people are going to be wiped out if that happens.



Should the VIX suddenly spike, the repercussions of such a move would be further complicated by the billions of dollars sitting in various VIX-linked ETFs. Because individuals sellers would probably disappear from the market in such a situation, the ETF market makers would find it nearly impossible to hedge their positions, potentially triggering the dissolution of the funds, or even the collapse of some of these firms.


There’s $1.2 billion of the XIV, which is the short ETF. There’s $1.3 billion of the SVXY, which is another short one. These are staggering numbers.


 


In my days, when I was on the institutional desk, we had this big – I did index arbitrage, and we used to go out and buy the baskets and sell the futures. One day the risk manager came to me and said, if you had to take this position off (because we had accumulated this big position) how long would it take you? And who would do it?


 


And I said, the reality is that there’s nobody. You know, we were the biggest player in the market and there was nobody that was going to take this off of us. The only way was to go all the way to expiry.


 


Well, the reality is that these numbers are way bigger than any market player can absorb. And, if we get a situation where – as Francesco says, all it’s going to take is a return of the VIX from its current level of 10 to its average level of 18 or 19 to wipe out these products.


 


I guess that’s the point that I want to make: If you’re actually owning these things, you should be aware that all it will take is a move of 80% and then they’re going to wind down these products. So the XIV, when it moves up, if all of a sudden VIX goes from 10 to 18 in a day, they’re going to wind down that product.


 


And what’s going to be really scary is the amount of VIX futures that is going to have to be bought, because they’re short all those VIX futures and they’re going to have to buy them back.


 


And I just don’t know who’s going to sell it to them. For the first time – for a long time, I didn’t view this VIX as that big a deal, and there were some smart guys like Jesse Felder that were going on about it – I just think that it has been taken to a level that is becoming increasingly worrisome. And it actually could create a market dislocation in itself.


 


And what is it Warren Buffett says? What the wise man does in the beginning the fool does in the end. Well, VIX, at this point, we’re hitting a point where if you’re actually continuing to bet on it you’re going to be in the fool category.


 


Because it’s not going to take much to have a big spike that wipes a lot of people out. And it’s actually very, very worrisome.



Of course, it would take a large intraday move to trigger a truly catastrophic spike in the VIX. But at least one analyst, Bank of America’s Michael Hartnett – whose work we have cited here – believes there could be a 1987-style crash in the early months of 2018. Hartnett’s reasoning? The bearish positioning seen at the beginning of 2017 has completely flipped. Investors’ long positions are larger than they’ve been in years.


And as we’ve repeatedly pointed out, with volatility and volume so subdued, hedge funds have remained overwhelmingly short vol, fearful of missing out on even one tick of the torrid rally for fear of pissing off their clients.


One things for certain: Given the market’s already dramatically overextended rally, the day of reckoning is coming. The only question is will it be a steady decline, or will it happen suddenly?


Given the incredibly stretched nature of positioning, the latter scenario, Muir and Co. believe, seems far more likely.


* * *


Muir"s discussion begins just after the hour mark:



 









Saturday, November 25, 2017

"You Are Here": Citi"s Stunning VIX Chart

Something snapped in the VIX complex, seconds after Friday"s early close, sending it to a new record low of 8.56 at 13:00:14 ET...



... which as we showed yesterday, was less than 10% of the all time VIX high of 89.53, hit on October 24, 2008.



However, while the Friday VIX snap - which is still on the feeds and thus wasn"t a fat finger error - is yet another indication of just how broken, and/or how overrun by vol sellers the market is, below we present two even more striking, longer-term perspectives on the VIX courtesy of Citi.


As Citigroup notes, even after the recent backup, the VIX index is in its 0.5th percentile – that is, historically it has been wider than currently on 199 out of every 200 days. In other words, the "you are here" on the chart below has never been more to the left.



But it is not just a question of having reached this low level of implied volatility. As much as anything it is about the extended period of time we seem to be spending there.


Which brings us to one of the most striking VIX charts we have seen: as Citi"s strategists note, over the last six months, VIX has spent more than 40 days below 10. Putting this staggering outlier in context, the index has never managed to accumulate more than 6 days that low, measured over the same time interval, over the last 30 years. Or, as today"s central bankers would say after one look at the chart below which they have created "perfectly normal."



Commenting on the above charts, Citi, which has turned increasingly bearish on credit in recent weeks, says that "implied vol is, in other words, sailing in the same unchartered waters as corporate credit", and concludes sarcastically, "why buy vol if you believe that any selloff is impeded by a central bank backstop?"


Why indeed?


So keep selling vol until one day vol finally explodes as CBs lose control, wiping out trillions in fake wealth in the process; just please don"t use the words "market" and "price discovery" until that happens.









Saturday, September 9, 2017

For The First Time Since January 2016, The Market Volatility Regime Finally Snapped

  • August 17 marked the first time since January 16 when global equity, rates, commodity and FX vols all moved in the same direction. 

  • At the same time, short-dated cross asset correlation continued to rise reaching a level of 50%, its highest level in over 1y.

For months on end, traders, analysts and pundits have been pointing to record low implied vol as a sign of pervasive complacency (and in some cases, "trader paralysis") in response to a market that made no sense, and where the only permitted direction was "up." That may finally be ending, and not just based on references to seasonal patterns that have zero relevance in a "new normal" driven by central bank asset purchases, but because the market"s artificial sense of calm is finally starting to crack, as observed by the recent surge in 20-day S&P realized vol.



And when realized vol starts rising, implied vol promptly follows, and when implied vol rises, it creates a feedback loops in which vol sellers are forced to cover, raising realized vol even more, pushing implied vol higher, and so on, as the current cycle of unprecedented volatility selling eventually ends, with either a bang or a whimper (spoiler alert: the former).


Meanwhile, as both volatility metrics rise, cross-asset volatility - traditionally an indicator of latent market stress - follows. And in what may come as a surprise to some, while most have been lamenting the blanket of broad market complacency in the past year, which in recent months have been validated by near record low global cross-asset implied volatilities....



... Bank of America points out that short-dated cross asset correlation has been rising over the past few months and currently stands at 50%, its highest level in over a year. Meanwhile, the correlation of cross asset vols may have also reached a turning point: August has been the first month in over a year to witness a simultaneous rise in global equity, rates, commodity and FX volatility. In fact, August 2017 marked the first month since January 2016 in which all cross asset risk measures rose modestly over the month, even if they still remain in significantly benign territory.



To BofA"s derivatives strategist Benjamin Bowler, this suggests that various pockets of the market are finally beginning to agree on the presence of risk, albeit to varying extents.


More ominously, on a consolidated basis as noted above, in August short-dated (3-month) cross asset correlation continued to rise reaching a level of 50%, its highest level in over a year. Historically there have been 3 distinct cross asset correlation regimes since 1995.



Interestingly, the broad upward trend started in Oct-03, well before the Lehman bankruptcy in Sep-08. This is related to the liquidity driven crush in asset risk-premia that helped drive investment leverage higher. Long-term correlation established a new regime starting some time in 3Q13, similar to the ’03 to ‘08 correlation environment. With the recent surge in cross-asset vol, that regime may now be ending too.


The good news, as BofA also points out, is that the uptick in volatility and credit spreads in most cases was modest in magnitude, leaving global cross asset risk metrics well within benign territory amid a backdrop of rising geopolitical tensions on the Korean peninsula. This means that it is still historically cheap to purchase efficient hedges ahead of what is already proving to be a catalyst-rich fall.


As a final observation, BofA then lays out the cheapest derivatives across the entire global derivatives universe, in other words, those which have the highest upside in case of a crash.


The chart below shows crash returns of different assets during historical tail events per unit of current OTM option implied volatility. Ranked by the average, the screen shows that the hedges which are most underpricing historical drawdowns are: US & EU IG credit payers, Gold calls and RDXUSD (Russian equity) puts: US & European IG credit payers still rank as the best value hedges across all assets in our universe followed by Gold (and Gold ETF) calls. In equities, RDXUSD (Russia), NIFTY (India) and TWSE (Taiwan) puts screen as top hedges while puts on NASDAQ (US Tech), Top40 (S. Africa) and ASX200 (Australia) rank as the most expensive.


Finally, those who want to hedge against a crash may want to avoid buying USDJPY puts: USDJPY puts once again are at the very bottom of BofA"s screen (most expensive tail hedge) as the ongoing geopolitical risk flare on the Korean peninsula has likely increased demand for JPY as a risk-off asset. In contrast, Nikkei puts, while belonging to the same region, currently rank as the cheapest DM equity hedge.


Sunday, August 13, 2017

Morgan Stanley: "Well, That Escalated Quickly"

"Well, that escalated quickly."


That"s how Morgan Stanley"s chief cross-asset strategist Andrew Sheets summarizes events in the last week in his latest Sunday Start note, in which he describes how following one of the calmest stretches for stocks since the 1960s, an escalating war of words with North Korea hit late summer markets priced for relatively little vol with the result sharp and sudden: a 70% rise in the VIX index over three days, a 2% drop in global equities, and more than a few holidays disrupted. Fear not, though, because according to Morgan Stanley, whose outlook on the S&P is one of the most bullish on Wall Street, views last week"s events "as a standard equity correction within an ongoing bull market." With volatility bearing the brunt of the repricing over the last several days, that’s where some of the most interesting changes lie.


And while Sheets lays out his reasons why the bank"s advice to clients is just to BTFD - or in the context of N. Korea, BTFAONW - Morgan Stanley does caution that things could get serious if the one scenario many - most recently Jeff Gundlach - have been dreading, namely the rise in volatility, becomes self-fulfilling, with investors selling as volatility rises and markets move lower, driving more of both. As Sheets writes, "for this risk, I’d be watching if new lows in the S&P 500 are confirmed by new highs in the VIX. This scenario is also scarier if realised volatility can stay near implied (if it doesn’t, implied volatility can fall, reversing the cycle). As of noon Friday, 3m S&P 500 was priced for a daily move of 0.8% and EuroStoxx was priced for a daily move of 0.9%."


Finally, while the bank remains optimistic on equities, it adds that there is an exception: "we would not ‘buy the dip’ in US credit, where [we] see more risks, given weaker fundamentals, expensive pricing and limited upside in exchange for swimming against the recent tide."


Here is Sheets full Sunday Start note:





Well, That Escalated Quickly



Following one of the calmest stretches for stocks since the 1960s, an escalating war of words with North Korea hit late summer markets priced for relatively little vol. The result was sharp and sudden: a 70% rise in the VIX index over three days, a 2% drop in global equities, and more than a few holidays disrupted.



While the ‘why’ is worth discussing, the more pressing question is what happens next. For several reasons discussed below, we’d view this as a ‘standard’ equity correction within an ongoing bull market.


With volatility bearing the brunt of the repricing over the last several days, that’s where some of the most interesting changes lie.





Drawdowns happen. Since 1929, there’s always been a 30% chance that a 5%+ drop will occur at some point over the following three months. The S&P is off less than 2% from its all-time high, and (still) hasn’t seen a 5% correction since mid-2016, the longest such streak since 2004. Whether you’re bullish or bearish, I’d imagine there’s wide agreement that something like this would happen eventually. The bigger question is what’s driving the move. We don’t see it driven by a shift in fundamentals.



Let’s start with growth. Our economists continue to see solid global growth (4.3%Q SAAR in 2Q), which we believe will help to boost global equity EPS by double-digits this year. These views didn’t change in the last week, where, if anything 2Q DM earnings continued to surprise to the upside. If that’s right, it represents a key difference from the larger August drawdowns of 2011 and 2015. Watch China industrial production on Monday, where Morgan Stanley expects 7.5%Y versus consensus at 7.1%Y.



Policy also remains supportive, with real policy rates across the G3 still deeply negative. While there’s always a risk that the Fed’s upcoming conference in Jackson Hole will have a hawkish tone, that’s not our expectation and, if anything, our economists think the risk is tilted to Draghi sounding mildly dovish, given recent EUR strength. We forecast inflation to stay well below target across the G3 for another 4-5 months on our forecasts, providing flexibility to move policy slowly. Bigger risks loom next year, when higher inflation may take away this optionality.



Geopolitics is also fundamental. Relative to the five-year average, Korea CDS is 3bp higher while KRW is 3% lower. Korean stocks remain up 16% YTD, although volatility has almost doubled. These indicators are worth watching, but in aggregate it is hard to say they’re discounting an alarming scenario.



So, if it’s less about fundamentals, maybe recent moves are more technical. August is a month when more investors are out (or about to be out), lowering risk appetite and thinning markets. Even if more people were in, Korea is a legitimately hard risk to discount. And, as noted by Christopher Metli, in our Institutional Equity Division, there was an unusually high number of volatility shorts in the market heading into this week, which may help to explain (some of) the large swings in VIX. These moves have pushed the S&P 500 skew to its steepest levels on record.



That leaves two paths. One is that the rise in volatility becomes self-fulfilling, with investors selling as volatility rises and markets move lower, driving more of both. For this risk, I’d be watching if new lows in the S&P 500 are confirmed by new highs in the VIX. This scenario is also scarier if realised volatility can stay near implied (if it doesn’t, implied volatility can fall, reversing the cycle). As of noon Friday, 3m S&P 500 was priced for a daily move of 0.8% and EuroStoxx was priced for a daily move of 0.9%.



The other path, more likely in our view, is that this turns out to be a more ‘normal’ correction. The Morgan Stanley Global Risk Demand Index (GRDI*) has fallen to -3.6, an ‘oversold’ level seen only a handful of times over the last eight years. The volatility term structure has inverted, which has also tended to be a reasonable indicator of elevated fear. And we think there is capacity to add exposure eventually, especially in the US, where Prime Brokerage tells me net leverage is in the 20th percentile. Given the steepness in skew, calls may offer some of the most attractive ways to be brave in the US, while put spreads may offer the best value for those looking to hedge what is still a relatively mild pullback. Overall, our positioning would remain constructive.



Is there an exception? We would not ‘buy the dip’ in US credit, where my colleague Adam Richmond sees more risks, given weaker fundamentals, expensive pricing and limited upside in exchange for swimming against the recent tide.


Saturday, August 5, 2017

Anticipating "VIX Shock", Interactive Brokers Raises Volatility Margins

Even as the VIX has continued to plumb new all time lows, unable to rebound from the realm of single-digits where it has spent a record amount of time in 2017, warnings about a potential surge in the volatility index have been growing in recent weeks.


Last week, in a note looking at what may happen "if the VIX goes bananas", Morgan Stanley"s Chris Metli cautioned that it’s easy to become numb to the low volatility environment and the risks it presents.  While trying to pick a trough in vol has been a fool’s errand, Metli said that focusing on the risks resulting from vol being so low is not, and warned that low vol has produced a regime where the risks are asymmetric and negatively convex, so being prepared for an unwind is critical.  "This is not a call that vol is about to spike, but you need a plan if it does", he echoed many other similar warning issued in recent months.


Of course, while nobody can know when a VIX explosion could occur, Morgan Stanley explained what could catalyze such a violent rise in volatility, showing that "just" a 3% to 4% one-day S&P 500 selloff could result in a 12 point VIX surge, a relationship MS showed through the gamma in vol related products, where demand for VIX futures from three main sources could result in 100,000 contracts ($100mm vega) to buy in a down 3.5% SPX move.  For context VIX futures ADV over the last year is 230,000 (although has risen to as high as 700,000 in big selloffs).


For those who missed it, below we recap some of the salient points of what would happens if the S&P 500 were to fall 3.5% today, based on Morgan Stanley calculations:


  • First, the VIX could rise as much as 12 points.  When volatility is low it tends to move a lot for a given change in the S&P 500.  That effect is likely to be exacerbated now because a) skew is steep (and VIX rolls up the skew in a selloff) and b) many players in the VIX market are short.  Taking these dynamics into account QDS estimates VIX could rise ~12 points for a 3.5% 1-day decline in SPX. Of course, a far smaller move in the VIX would be sufficient to result in massive losses among the vol-selling community according to previous calculations by JPM"s Marko Kolanovic.

  • Just as concerning, if VIX futures approach +100% in a single day, there is a risk that the providers of inverse VIX ETPs cover the VIX futures that they sold to hedge the products.  This is because there is a mismatch in the hedge if VIX futures rise more than 100% – the inverse ETPs can’t go below zero (-100%) but the loss on a short VIX futures position can be more than -100%.

  • For XIV (holding ~73,000 contracts short) the prospectus indicates that it will unwind if the NAV falls more than 80% intraday, with investors receiving the end of day value.  Given this is a known threshold, anything close to a +80% move in VIX futures would likely trigger buying (by the ETN provider and/or market participants) in anticipation of the unwind.  Note that because XIV is an ETN, investors receive the theoretical value of the index based on its rules, not what the provider actually trades.

  • SVXY (holding ~37,000 contracts short) does not have a set threshold to unwind according to its prospectus.  That said VIX futures currently have a margin requirement of ~45% of notional for the average of the front two contracts, and any decline in value of the inverse ETPs to those levels could trigger a rapid forced unwind.   Note that SVXY is an ETF, so the NAV is based on the actual holdings of the fund at the end of the day.


  • Adding to the pain – on days after the initial shock – would be the flow from annuity and risk parity deleveraging.  Both of those investors are slow by comparison to the VIX market – annuities will sell over several days, starting the day after a selloff.  Risk parity funds are more discretionary, and the supply could come over a matter of weeks.  But given high leverage resulting from the low vol environment, their potential supply is large and could prolong any downturn. Between all three vol players, a 3% drop in the S&P would result in forced selling of roughly $60 billion in one day, growing to $140 billion should the plunge accelerate to -5% intraday.


* * *


In a separate report also discussed here previously, Fasanara Capital"s Francesco Filia revealed what the "wipeout scenario" - one in which the VIX were to double from its current level in the 9/10 range to 18/20 - would look like for vol sellers. In a word, it would be an unmitigated disaster.





Our analysis shows that if VIX goes from 9.60 to 18/20 in absolute values (it was approx. 40 as recently as Aug2015), and stays there for 8 / 10 days in backwardation, VIX-based ETFs may stand to lose up to 55%. Short positions on long-vol ETFs can then lose up to 250% of capital with VIX at 20. Losses are higher in case of wider backwardation of the term structure of the VIX (i.e. front contracts trading higher than back contracts), or the longer VIX stays elevated while in backwardation, or clearly the higher it goes. For example, if VIX quadruples from here to 40, losses on a UVXY position would amount to a staggering 656%!




* * *


We bring up all of the above, because as Morgan Stanley said, "This is not a call that vol is about to spike, but you need a plan if it does" and at least one exchange is doing just that.


In a notice to clients sent out late on Friday, Interactive Brokers admits it is starting to get a worried about the recent VIX record lows and as a result after expiration processing on August 19, "Interactive Brokers will put into place greater margin requirements for Volatility Products."


While the IB notice had it usual dose of fluff and generic admonitions...





VIX has established new all-time lows over the course of the past month. The price dynamics of that product are such that it can have very large relative price increases over a very short period of time base on news and other market factors. In recognition of the special risk of sudden, large increases in market volatility, that is inherent in Volatility Products such as VIX, Interactive Brokers will put into place greater margin requirements for Volatility Products after expiration processing on Saturday, 19 August. 



... It was surprisingly clear in what the specific parameters of the anticipated move are, to wit:





IB"s margin policy will be to consider market outcome scenarios under which VIX might rise to a price of 18 (even when it is currently priced much lower) and under which the other Volatility Products could rise to proportionately similar degrees.



In other words, IB is starting to prepare for the day that the VIX doubles from current levels, which as Fasanara showed above, is sufficient to wipe out most vol sellers, and in the case of those with levered, naked volatility shorts, results in losses greater than 600%.


Who will be impacted:





If you have positions in Volatility Products that have risk in large upward moves of market volatility, then your margin may increase significantly.



Of course, since volatility is the "fulcrum security" of today"s reflexive market nature - does a surge in the VIX send stocks lower, or does a market crash lead to a VIX surge? - the very fact that vol-linked leverage is about to be aggressively cut first by one, then by many more if not all exchanges, as we head into the critical for volatility fall period, these warnings could create a self-fulfilling prophecy whereby the margin increases are the very catalyst that leads to a surge in volatility.


Whether that is what happens over the next two weeks remains to be seen. In the interim, IB said that "it will with immediate effect increase its Initial Margin requirements on Volatility Products to a degree consistent with the upcoming 19 August increases in Maintenance Margin."


What this means is that vol sellers will now have to pay up substantial additional margin (i.e. cash) for new short-vol positions, and that in two weeks, maintenance margins for legacy positions will be likewise affected. It also means that unless the short-vol traders have a generous amount of cash lying around, they will have no choice but to close out of existing positions, in the process sending vol, and VIX, higher if purely mechanistically.


IB also specifically cautions inverse vol sellers:





Some Volatility Products have "ultra" and "inverse" characteristics. Ultra products are expected to have greater daily returns than normal products while inverse products are expected to have returns that are of the opposite sign to normal products. It is therefore expected that an increase in market volatility will result in a decrease in the price of an inverse volatility product. As a consequence, for example, under the new policy the margin on a naked short call will increase for a normal product while the margin for a naked short put will increase for an inverse product.



This unexpected margin hike across the vol universe by Interactive Brokers (to be followed by its competition) is especially notable because one month ago Bank of America warned that the most dangerous moment for markets "will come in 3-4 months", or 2-3 months as of today, when the confluence of the adverse debt-ceiling negotiation, disappointing Q3 earnings, and the Fed"s balance sheet unwind all converge into one broad risk-off shock.


It is precisely this "event" that Interactive Brokers is the first to admit may have drastic consequences on the market.


IB"s full notice is below.


Friday, August 4, 2017

The Market is Lurching Closer and Closer to a Single Day Flash Crash

Whoever is rigging the market is getting increasingly desperate.


The daily VIX slams are getting more and more ridiculous. It’s getting to the point that the VIX is getting slammed 5%-6% every single day at 9:50AM  just to pin the S&P 500 (they’re not even trying to get a gain anymore).


Here’s the VIX.



Here’s the S&P 500’s last nine closes. The index is LITERALLY not being allowed to move. It’s now gyrating a point or two per day.



This level of extreme fixing indicates we’re much closer to the end of this rig than the beginning. The reality is that Central Banks can manipulate some asset classes all the time, but they CANNOT manipulate every asset class at the same time.


Eventually something is going to “break.” Whether it"s Oil, the German DAX, or some other item, we"re going to see the markets call the fixer"s bluff. When this happens, whoever is fixing the S&P 500 will have to let it go.


When they do we"re looking at a single day collapse similar to what happened in May 2010.


You"ve been warned.


For more insights that can help you see serious returns from your investments, join our FREE daily e-letter, Gains Pains & Capital.


Every weekday you"ll receive our research reports before the market"s open.


In the last 6 months we"ve called the massive sell-off in the $USD, the out-performance by Emerging Markets, and more.


And best of all, it"s 100% totally FREE.


To join us, swing by: http://gainspainscapital.com/


Best Regards


Graham Summers


Chief Market Strategist


Phoenix Capital Research

Wednesday, July 26, 2017

"If The VIX Goes Bananas", Morgan Stanley Shows What It Would Look Like

From Chris Metli of Morgan Stanley


It’s easy to become numb to the low volatility environment and the risks it presents.  While trying to pick a trough in vol has been a fool’s errand, focusing on the risks resulting from vol being so low is not.  Low volatility has produced a regime where the risks are asymmetric and negatively convex, so being prepared for an unwind is critical.  This is not a call that vol is about to spike, but you need a plan if it does.


This note details how a short vol unwind might develop. A violent rise in volatility could be driven by just a 3% to 4% one-day S&P 500 selloff.  Right now the risk is greatest in the VIX complex, and demand for VIX futures from three main sources could result in 100,000 contracts ($100mm vega) to buy in a down 3.5% SPX move.  For context VIX futures ADV over the last year is 230,000 (although has risen to as high as 700,000 in big selloffs).



It’s important to note that this only happens if there is a large 1-day move lower in equities starting when VIX is very low – a slower drawdown, or a selloff from higher starting levels of vol, would not create as much demand.  The biggest S&P 500 selloff when VIX was less than 12 was 3.5% (Feb 2007), so this type of move would be on par with the worst-case historical move for a low vol environment.


Why highlight this now?  Simply because as volatility goes lower, these risks rise.   In April and May QDS acknowledged that the short vol base was large, but viewed the risk as manageable (‘Keep Calm and Carry On’).  In June the team’s stance on volatility turned neutral.  And since then volatility levels have only gone lower.


What happens if the S&P 500 were to fall 3.5% today?


1) First, the VIX could rise as much as 12 points.  When volatility is low it tends to move a lot for a given change in the S&P 500.  That effect is likely to be exacerbated now because a) skew is steep (and VIX rolls up the skew in a selloff) and b) many players in the VIX market are short.  Taking these dynamics into account QDS estimates VIX could rise ~12 points for a 3.5% 1-day decline in SPX.


If VIX rises 12 points, 1-month VIX futures are likely up 5.5 points, a ~50% increase.  The 1-day percentage change is a big deal in the VIX complex because the levered and inverse VIX ETFs and ETNs rebalance daily based on the percentage change, and some of the thresholds for forced unwinds are based on the percentage change.  This is why lower vol creates higher risk.



2) In a 50% increase in VIX futures, the levered and inverse VIX ETFs and ETNs need to buy ~70,000 VIX futures to rebalance their portfolios and maintain target exposures (this estimate is net of redemptions – long vol ETPs are generally sold by their holders as vol rises, offsetting the levered rebalance).  While these flows likely occur near the close, the dynamic is well known, and many traders will bring forward those flows to the middle of the day.




3) A VIX futures level in the high teens (up from 11 – 12 now) means dealers get short VIX call gamma.  There has been considerable buying of VIX calls and call spreads, with much of the hedging flow in the last month focused on VIX (instead of SPX).  As VIX futures rise, dealers will get more and more short delta, which needs to be hedged by buying VIX futures.  In a 3.5% SPX selloff QDS estimates there could be 25,000 VIX futures to buy from dealers hedging.



4) If VIX futures approach +100% in a single day, there is a risk that the providers of inverse VIX ETPs cover the VIX futures that they sold to hedge the products.  This is because there is a mismatch in the hedge if VIX futures rise more than 100% – the inverse ETPs can’t go below zero (-100%) but the loss on a short VIX futures position can be more than -100%.



There are two inverse ETPs that sell the front of the VIX futures curve – XIV (an ETN) and SVXY (an ETF).  For XIV (holding ~73,000 contracts short) the prospectus indicates that it will unwind if the NAV falls more than 80% intraday, with investors receiving the end of day value.  Given this is a known threshold, anything close to a +80% move in VIX futures would likely trigger buying (by the ETN provider and/or market participants) in anticipation of the unwind.  Note that because XIV is an ETN, investors receive the theoretical value of the index based on its rules, not what the provider actually trades.


SVXY (holding ~37,000 contracts short) does not have a set threshold to unwind according to its prospectus.  That said VIX futures currently have a margin requirement of ~45% of notional for the average of the front two contracts, and any decline in value of the inverse ETPs to those levels could trigger a rapid forced unwind.   Note that SVXY is an ETF, so the NAV is based on the actual holdings of the fund at the end of the day.




5)  The 2nd derivative impacts are likely large.  An overnight gap higher that doesn’t give investors the opportunity to hedge is the worst case.  Consider if there is an overnight gap in VIX futures of +150% (VIX futures to ~29, VIX to 35+):


  • The holders of the inverse ETPs lose the $1.4bn as the AUM of inverse ETPs goes to zero.

  • The providers (hedge counterparties / clearers) of the ETPs lose $600mm due to the mismatched hedge if VIX futures more than double.

  • Investors that sold long vol ETPs against short vol ETPs (a somewhat common carry trade) have the same unhedged gap risk in a +100% VIX futures move as the ETP providers.  Assuming they are 20% of the shorts in the inverse ETPs (a guess) – they lose $250mm.

  • Dealers who can’t hedge their delta on the way up could lose $500mm on our estimates.

  • Hedge funds who are short VIX futures ($250mm vega on just the short leg per CFTC) playing the rolldown trade lose over $4bn.

  • Investors who are wrong way in VXX, SVXY, and UVXY options could lose hundreds of millions – estimating loss here is hard, but assuming 20% of the open interest is wrong way, the loss would be ~$1bn.

  • Investors who have sold vol in other forms (options, variance, etc.) would take losses and likely look to cover as well.

With a buyer for every seller someone is making this money too, and some of the above could be hedged as well.  But the point is that when there are losses, ‘sell what you can’ will take over and drive further supply.  While the point of max pain in volatility would likely be the first day of the spike, the knock on effects could mean equity markets take longer to recover.



6)   Adding to the pain – on days after the initial shock – would be the flow from annuity and risk parity deleveraging.  Both of those investors are slow by comparison to the VIX market – annuities will sell over several days, starting the day after a selloff.  Risk parity funds are more discretionary, and the supply could come over a matter of weeks.  But given high leverage resulting from the low vol environment, their potential supply is large and could prolong any downturn.




Investors have been crying wolf about the VIX complex for years, and have been wrong so far.  And it’s important to note that the odds are still heavily stacked against the above scenario playing out and the most likely scenario is still a graceful unwind of the short vol trade:


  • If volatility is just a little bit higher, the unwind potential is much less – there needs to be a shock when volatility starts at these very low levels

  • The unwind in VIX only happens in a 1-day gap lower in stocks – a slow bleed would not create as much supply

  • History suggests a gap from low vol levels is unlikely:  the biggest selloff in S&P 500 when VIX was less than 12 was -3.5%, and -2.2% when VIX was less than 11, not enough to trigger this type of unwind.  That -2.2% selloff occurred on Feb 4th 1994 when the Fed raised interest rates – bond volatility remains the major risk factor.

  • Investors are still not all-in on stocks, with exposures moderate and many hiding out in defensives and Tech – raising the bar for a big selloff in stocks

  • Active manager performance this year has been strong, meaning funds are less likely to become forced sellers of positions, which helps keeps volatility tame and can limit the speed of a selloff

  • Correlation remains low due to both fundamentals and positioning, and for the index to sell off sharply it would need to rise

The point is simply that if there is an external market shock that nobody is prepared for (and this likely coincides with a selloff across asset classes), the risks of a quick unwind are higher than in the past.  QDS favors staying long equities, but does not view the risk / reward on simply selling volatility as attractive anymore.  Instead consider:


  • Replacing long stock with S&P 500 upside calls that look very cheap given low volatility – buy the SPX Dec 2550 call (30^) for ~1% (sub-9% implied vol)

  • Buying VIX puts instead of selling VIX futures to collect rolldown – buy the VIX Sept 10.5 put for $0.25, which offers attractive leverage if futures roll down to current spot levels of VIX with a 9 handle.

  • Hedging this potential tail event with OTM VIX calls – buy the Sept 20 calls (17^) for $0.45.  VIX calls are not cheap by any measure, but they are reasonably priced given these potential risks, and for those that see a shock occurring in the next few months VIX calls are the best hedge.

Tuesday, July 11, 2017

Retail Investors Are Piling Into "The Most Dangerous Trade In The World"

It shouldn"t be too surprising that the XIV exchange-traded note - which is designed to deliver the inverse performance of the well-known CBOE Volatility Index (or the VIX) on a daily basis - is attracting fresh attention after surging as much as 87 percent this year.



But, as CNBC notes, some caution that investing in the exchange-traded product now could be deeply risky.





This could be "the most dangerous trade in the world," according to macro strategist Boris Schlossberg of BK Asset Management.



"It"s already had a massive runup because we"ve had very low volatility," but at this point, "it"s very likely that volatility is going to increase," Schlossberg said Thursday on CNBC"s "Trading Nation."



The rise in this product hasn"t escaped traders" attention. In terms of the dollar value of shares traded, the short-VIX-futures XIV has actually surpassed the long-VIX-futures VXX.


"We think it"s especially interesting that there is now more XIV trading than VXX, perhaps pointing to the growing interest in shorting volatility among retail [investors] and others who are not specialists in volatility trading," Pravit Chintawongvanich, head of derivatives strategy at Macro Risk Advisors, wrote in a Wednesday note to clients.




As for Schlossberg, his warning about the product is based on his view that volatility is set to rise from its current, ultralow levels.





"It"s simply a dangerous trade from a macro point of view," he said Thursday. "As central banks begin to increase rates, we"re going to see more volatility, and this [product] is going to show some very negative days."



In fact, "negative" may be putting it mildly. On a day when the VIX and the VIX futures double in value (perhaps due to bad news out of Freedonia), the VXX could easily double as well, while the XIV could perform the inverse move.





"One big thing that we"ve been highlighting is that this product can actually go to zero," Chintawongvanich said Thursday on "Trading Nation."



"Right now the VIX is around 12 -- just think of a scenario that takes the VIX from 12 to 20-plus in a single day. It"s not impossible. In that case the XIV could easily go to zero," which is something "many investors in this product may not be aware of."



Those who buy the XIV with money they cannot afford to lose, then, could be putting their portfolio in great danger indeed.


And while shares outstanding in the "bearish" VXX has exploded (as shares outstanding in "bullish" XIV), adjusted for the endless decay in price, the trend is clear - forget hedging, forget fear, sell VIX!!



What could possibly go wrong?

Monday, June 5, 2017

VIX 'Risk' Hits Record High As Traders Bet On Chaos To Come

While VIX closed at its lowest level since 1993 on Friday, VVIX (which tracks the anticipated volatitilty of VIX) completed a fourth week of gains in five, reaching a record high relative to the measure of equity turbulence.




As Bloomberg notes, with the VIX down more than 30% this year through the end of last week, investors have been using options to bet on volatility.



As the chart above shows, the volume of contracts wagering on a resurgence of market turmoil has reached its highest level since last February relative to those calling for a drop in price movements.

Wednesday, May 10, 2017

Fear Index (VIX); Testing 2007 level support level!


Below looks at the VIX index over the past decade. Over the past three weeks, the VIX has been falling sharply, over 40%. This decline has our attention from a Power of the Pattern perspective, see why below.


VIX index since 2010 kimble charting solutions


CLICK ON CHART TO ENLARGE


Over the past 7-years, the VIX has remained inside of falling channel (1). Line (2), is a parallel line of falling channel (1). The VIX index is now testing the lows of 2007 and line (2) at (3). When the VIX hit this level in 2007, it skyrocketed.


This price level could become a very important level for the VIX index and potentially could send an important message to the bullish trend in stocks.


The collapse in Fear has been great for ETF XIV, as it has rallied over 25% in the past three weeks. Premium and Sectormembers have been long the XIV trade and now they are harvesting gains and pulling up stops. See good news of fear collapse post (HERE).



Website: KIMBLECHARTINGSOLUTIONS.COM


Blog:  KIMBLECHARTINGSOLUTIONS.COM/BLOG



Questions: Email services@kimblechartingsolutions.com or call us toll free 877-721-7217 international 714-941-9381

Tuesday, March 7, 2017

VIX-Crusher Algo Sparks Buying Scramble - Dow Green

Pension funds, yup.  They need an implosion of biblical proportions as a pretense to turn 401(k)s into national annuities, er, ahem, "guranteed retirement accounts".  Thus the "fiduciary rule" . . .market implosion and sad-sack narratives that follow, looky at poor Ms. Betty Jones, lost half her retirement in the market crash . . . but her 401(K) advisor made money!  (Cue Elizabeth "Vyshinsky" Warren)  We need a retirement system that works for everyone!  We"ll put your 401(K) someplace where it will be safe . . .don"t worry, you will retire "comfortably". . .

Monday, January 23, 2017

Europe's "VIX" Spikes Most In 4 Months

While still at relatively low levels, the VStoxx index (Europe"s VIX) spiked over 17 this morning, its highest in 3 weeks and the biggest jump since September...


The post-election low vol regime is under pressure...



Is that regime about to change?




Time for Draghi to get even more dovish?