Stocks are at record highs while volatility is at a record low. Which is another way of saying that investors aren’t as worried as they probably should be about the coming year.
That’s okay. Price corrections (with their attendant volatility spikes) are normal and natural ways for markets to teach overconfident investors a little humility. Think of them as the financial word’s forest fires, clearing out the underbrush of misconception, malinvestment, and hubris.
But there’s another area of Peak Complacency that is neither natural nor benign. And that’s cyberspace.
Americans – and Europeans and Japanese – have moved most of their financial lives online just as hackers and other cyber-enemies get the upper hand.
Recently:
Credit rating agency Equifax – apparently through its own incompetence – allowed hackers to access and presumably copy and sell “sensitive personal information” of 146 million Americans.
Online portal Yahoo upped the number of accounts that were hacked in 2013 to – get this — 3 billion.
The National Security Agency admitted that its state-of-the-art hacking tools were stolen by hackers and are now available for sale on the dark web.
The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) suffered more than 50 data breaches between January 2015 and December 2016, exposing “personally identifiable information (PII) of U.S. citizens.”
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission EDGAR database of corporate documents was hacked, leading to illegal insider trading that the SEC is still trying to unravel.
And then there’s bitcoin, where online exchanges are being hacked with apparent impunity and zero recourse for victims:
(Independent) – There have been at least three dozen heists of cryptocurrency exchanges since 2011 and more than 980,000 bitcoins stolen, worth about $4 billion.
Dan Wasyluk discovered the hard way that trading cryptocurrencies such as bitcoin happens in an online Wild West where sheriffs are largely absent.
Mr Wasyluk and his colleagues raised bitcoins for a new tech venture and lodged them in escrow at a company running a cryptocurrency exchange called Moolah. Just months later the exchange collapsed; the man behind it is now awaiting trial in Britain on fraud and money-laundering charges. He has pleaded not guilty.
Mr Wasyluk’s project lost 750 bitcoins, currently worth about $3m, and he believes he stands little chance of recovering any money.
“It really was kind of a kneecapping of the project,” said Mr Wasyluk of the collapse three years ago. “If you are starting an exchange and you lose clients’ money, you or your company should be 100 per cent accountable for that loss. And right now there is nothing like that in place.”
Cryptocurrencies were supposed to offer a secure, digital way to conduct financial transactions but they have been dogged by doubts. Concerns have largely focused on their astronomical gains in value and the likelihood of painful price crashes. Equally perilous, though, are the exchanges where virtual currencies are bought, sold and stored. These exchanges, which match buyers and sellers and sometimes hold traders’ funds, have become magnets for fraud and mires of technological dysfunction, posing an underappreciated risk to anyone who trades digital coins.
The obvious conclusion is that our bank, brokerage and bitcoin accounts aren’t safe from hackers and/or cyber-attacks that shut down settlement systems and power grids.
In the aftermath of Hurricane Maria, for example, much of Puerto Rico is still without power, which means ATM machines aren’t working. See Puerto Rico is now a cash-only economy.
So physical cash – always a good thing to have on hand – is a crucial part of disaster planning. And precious metals in the form of small denomination gold and silver coins are if anything even more important, since who knows what a large-scale cyber event and the subsequent central bank money printing will do to fiat currency values.
Nomi Prins joined Sprott Money News for its Ask the Expert segment that covered the Federal Reserve system, Glass-Steagall reform and even the recent activity from the U.S Treasury.
Nomi Prins is a former Wall Street insider where she worked as a Managing Director at Goldman Sachs among other major financial outlets. She is also a best-selling author who wrote All the Presidents’ Bankers, a book that examines the hidden alliances between Wall Street and Washington.
Beginning the conversation she highlighted U.S debt and the position of U.S treasury bonds. Prins remarks, “One of the reasons in general that government debt is considered an asset is that it can be traded and holds enough liquidity to either raise money or post as collateral for other forms of capital. They have an intrinsic benefit in the financial system between central banks, large multinational institutions and banks, etc.”
“U.S Treasury bonds also have the idea behind them that they have this implicit guarantee by their respective government that they will not default. Even though, right now, these bonds barely have any interest from a return perspective and are not particularly lucrative, it does have the idea behind them that it is not going to lose its value.”
Switching gears, she was pressed on whether the U.S treasury bonds could face a replacement Nomi Prins noted, “In the current international monetary system we have where the U.S dollar is the major reserve currency there is a necessity for central banks and private banks to use and have the U.S treasury bonds. The bonds are used to balance payments and used for potential liquidity emergency mechanisms and any other financial circumstances.”
She went on to elaborate on the U.S treasury bonds and their use in the global financial system that, “In general, global governments around the world happen to use the treasury bond system to finance the discrepancy between their own domestic balance of payments. That is the revenues that come in from taxes, versus the payments that the U.S government might need to run the country.”
“From a two prong perspective, first look at the debt, because we don’t have a balance of payments that is positive, it needs to be issued to make up that gap in the U.S.
Second, the dollar is the prevalent currency and U.S treasury bonds are the most liquid form of moving central bank policy around that currency relationship they do not seem to be going away anytime soon. In the last ten years we’ve had an extraordinary increase in U.S treasury debt to the extent that we are well over 100% relative to GDP.”
The interview then transitioned to talk about Federal Reserve reform and whether it can be reformed? Prin’s notes,
“As we learned from the global financial crisis, the Federal Reserve has done a lousy job at regulating the risks that were coming into the financial system from the major private banks.”
“Not only did it do a bad job at detecting risks, it did the opposite and deflected concerns from those highlighting the risks. From the standpoint of monetary policy, looking ten years out, its pursuit of policy with absolutely no limitation from the outside (printing money, buying securities) was a failure.”
“If the Federal Reserve policies were able to make a real impact, we wouldn’t have needed them to go on for ten years following the financial crisis. What we are seeing right now is that there is no particular end in sight. The fact that there is no jurisdiction that can instruct the Fed what to do, where it is currently working under unconventional policy for artificial markets, has created more risk instead of less.”
“If we were to create an external benchmark that at the very least pulls them into some coordinated approach, that would be a better way of maintaining stability. Whether that is a standard currency approach or whatever that might be.”
When speaking on how long the central banks might be able to stall and what tools in the face of another crisis Nomi Prins elaborates on her most recent research.
“There has been collusion and collaboration amongst the G7 central banks. They have been ensuring that central banks like the Federal Reserve and others coordinate in their policy consortium moves. In effect we have seen a consistent global zero percent interest rate policy and ongoing quantitative easing policy be unveiled, even if some banks reduce their engagement. That’s why we have been able to perpetuate this system for so long.”
“This is not one individual central bank but a coordinated, collusive approach. Can that continue? The guidance, as well as the actions of the central banks has indicated there could be multiple years of this to come. Because there is no external limitation on their policy and there’s no voting them out I’d say this could go on for at least a few more years. For the most part the people in power are going to stay in power. Even in the case of the U.S, if we were to see Janet Yellen leave and Gary Cohn step in at the Fed, I’d expect we would see much of the same.”
When examining what chances for financial reform, whether in the form of Glass-Steagall or beyond, were for the Trump administration Prins’ directed,
“Glass-Steagall is interesting because it is a check to a large extent on the reserve system. As a law, Glass-Steagall would be a counter to whatever crisis might happen. It would separate banks from being able to utilize deposits as loans, while still trading other types of less transparent and risk prone securities.”
Glass-Steagall is something that has more consideration right now in the U.S Congress under the Trump administration than it had under the last. I say that because I have spent a lot of time talking with members of Congress on the issue of Glass-Steagall. I have directly seen the expressed interest in members on both sides that have been looking at the avoidance of the government and central bank intervention in the event of another financial crisis. The biggest banks are still too big to fail.”
There is still risk in the financial system. What will help in the event of a real crisis, from ensuring that we don’t have to have another bailout, is to not have a connection between commercial banking and investment banking. That would mean banks would have to look at the risks that they are creating within their books. It would mean these risk taking banks would have to independently have to take on their own ventures.”
“There is a bill right now called HR-790 with around 50 signed co-sponsors that is a bipartisan suggested proposal that would reinstate Glass-Steagall. I think that is going to grow substantially in upcoming sessions of Congress. It will be very difficult to pass because none of the banks want this. The potential is better now than it has been and could, unfortunately, be better if there is another crisis.”
Turning to a global focus on central banking, she was asked in particular for her read on the Japanese experience. The best-selling author and economist notes, “Japan over the last 30 years has experienced a major banking crisis in the 90’s. That took a while to work its way through the system. Ultimately, they put in place more regulations for banks within Japan that had government support. They also jumped ahead of the Fed and launched one of the first quantitative easing (QE) programs amongst central banks in the mid-2000’s. They had the Bank of Japan, their central bank, inject money to help resurrect banks and maintain support for the banking system.”
“Ultimately, they found out that stimulus itself didn’t stimulate the economy and could only go so far to assist with banks that were in trouble. They complimented the QE program with more financial regulation on the types of risks in the financial system. Now their QE model is very active and in fact since Kuroda became the head of the BoJ, the percentage of assets that the central bank holds on its books relative to GDP is close to 80%. That’s something to watch and could end badly for Japan.”
Apparently the Banks have been lobbying heavily, and expending significant amounts of money again, leaning on their Congressmen and pressuring regulators, saying that their capital standards need to be relaxed so that they can make more loans to stimulate economic growth.
But that, according to the FDIC Vice-Chairman, is utter nonsense.
Hoenig, who was a high-ranking Federal Reserve official during the crisis, cautioned Senate Banking Committee Chairman Mike Crapo and the committee"s senior Democrat, Sherrod Brown, "against relaxing current capital requirements and allowing the largest banks to increase their already highly leveraged positions."
Using public data to analyze the 10 largest bank holding companies, Hoenig found they will distribute more than 100 percent of the current year"s earnings to investors, which could have supported to $537 billion in new loans.
On an annualized basis they will distribute 99 percent of net income, he added.
He added that if banks kept their share buybacks, totaling $83 billion, then under current capital rules they could boost commercial and consumer loans by $741.5 billion.
"While distributing all of today’s income to shareholders may be received well in the short run, it can undermine their future returns and weaken the growth outlook for the larger economy," he wrote."
The Banks are spending a substantial amount of their current income on dividends to shareholders and large stock buyback programs designed to increase their share prices.
The chart above shows in the first column the almost shocking Payout Ratios being maintained by some of the Banks.
In the second column there is an estimate of how many more loans the Banks could have made at current capital requirements if they had not spent their cash buying back their own shares.
Since Bank managers are personally heavily rewarded on the share price of the Banks through bonuses and share options, the cause of this is clear.
There has been insufficient reform in the Banks. Lending and basic banking would better function like a utility, with much more efficient and effective levels of risk management.
Basic banking including loans and deposits ought not to be an adjunct or cover for the kinds of speculation and gambling with other people"s money that led to the last financial crisis that brought the global economy to its knees.
This problem was addressed by Glass-Steagall and functioned very well, keeping the banking system essentially sound for almost seventy years, until it was repealed under the Clinton Administration in conjunction with a Congress all too willing to sacrifice the interests of their voters to Big Money.
* * *
"If at times his [Andrew Jackson"s] passionate devotion to this cause of the average citizen lent an amazing zeal to his thoughts, to his speech and to his actions, the people loved him for it the more. They realized the intensity of the attacks made by his enemies, by those who, thrust from power and position, pursued him with relentless hatred. The beneficiaries of the abuses to which he put an end pursued him with all the violence that political passions can generate. But the people of his day were not deceived. They loved him for the enemies he had made.
Backed not only by his party but by thousands who had belonged to other parties or belonged to no party at all, Andrew Jackson was compelled to fight every inch of the way for the ideals and the policies of the Democratic Republic which was his ideal.
An overwhelming proportion of the material power of the Nation was arrayed against him. The great media for the dissemination of information and the molding of public opinion fought him. Haughty and sterile intellectualism opposed him. Musty reaction disapproved him. Hollow and outworn traditionalism shook a trembling finger at him. It seemed sometimes that all were against him—all but the people of the United States.
Because history so often repeats itself, let me analyze further. Andrew Jackson stands out in the century and a half of our independent history not merely because he was two-fisted, not merely because he fought for the people"s rights, but because, through his career, he did as much as any man in our history to increase, on the part of the voters, knowledge of public problems and an interest in their solution. Following the fundamentals of Jefferson, he adhered to the broad philosophy that decisions made by the average of the voters would be more greatly enduring for, and helpful to, the Nation than decisions made by small segments of the electorate representing small or special classes endowed with great advantages of social or economic power.
He, like Jefferson, faced with the grave difficulty of disseminating facts to the electorate, to the voters as a whole, was compelled to combat epithets, generalities, misrepresentation and the suppression of facts by the process of asking his supporters, and indeed all citizens, to constitute themselves informal committees for the purpose of obtaining the facts and of spreading them abroad among their friends, their associates and their fellow workers."
As an aside, I find it telling that the current crop of Democratic Party plutocrats want nothing to do with the policies of Jackson or Roosevelt.
I think the reasons are obvious. I would like to think that they are merely mistaken. But it is clear that they are serving the masters that they love the most. As for the Republicans, they have long ago betrayed their roots and become the servants of Big Business, and seem to be beyond all hope of reform.
Nomi Prins joined The Foreign Correspondents’ Club of Japan in Tokyo to discuss the banking landscape and state of financial regulations in the Trump era. The central bank historian and financial expert also took a deep dive into the shifting relations between the United States and Japan and what easy money policy has meant for financial markets.
The author began the discussion noting that, “A lot of things have happened in the past months in particular within finance and trade alliances amongst countries in the Trump era.”
Speaking on the recent gathering of world leaders Prins’ notes,
“One of the things that came out of the G20 is whether it is America last in terms of the alliances occurring today. The American first policy is pushing new diplomacy and agreements with countries that have not spoken with one another in the past. This is happening for two reasons. One, from a standpoint of protecting the commonality of the world. It is filling the gap between receding powers versus rising power. Two, it is an anti-protectionist move.”
Prins’ then builds on easy money policy stating,
“We still have a problem of banks that are too big to fail. We still have a problem where the initial financial crisis that happened ten years ago in the United States, that was the result of the banks being too large and too speculative… in using the guarantees that the U.S government has provided to bank depositors and the provisions provided in the Glass-Steagall. Those deposits have become a guarantee for banks to become bigger and a guarantee for financial crises to become something that the government subsidizes. Our Federal Reserve, our central bank, also subsidizes this.”
Nomi Prins is a former Wall Street insider where she worked as a Managing Director at Goldman Sachs among other major financial outlets. She is also a best-selling author who wrote All the Presidents’ Bankers, a book that took on the hidden alliances between Wall Street and Washington.
Easy Money and Too Big to Fail
While answering to what the global central bank policy has been over the past decade the financial expert levels, “Quantitative easing, which was the idea of the Federal Reserve, is the idea that putting money into the markets and banking systems in order to keep the banking system alive. For ten years the central banks of the world, in particular the G7.”
“Those banks, at the behest of the Fed, were pushed to support too big to fail institutions and continued to support zero percent interest rate policy. Yes, the Fed has raised them a little bit. The economy in the U.S has been good enough and growing fast enough for them to start to raise rates a bit.”
“Since December 2015 until this June they have raised rates a full one percent. In contrast, the Bank of Japan and European Central Bank has gone negative on rates. We still have a world where money has helped the banking system and gone into stock markets. Debt continues to be issued cheaply and it has all been treated very easily.”
Switching focus the author turned to the current White House asking, “How does all of this related to Trump and everyday populations? None of this money is going into the real economy. In particular, for the G7, wages have been stagnant. Actual real growth has been stagnant. Inequality has been the same, if not higher. However, the markets have been up as we can see in bonds, stocks and particularly bank stocks within the Trump administration.”
“All of that connects back to the fact that in the beginning of the financial crisis was a removal of Glass-Steagall. Prior to 1999, this Act segmented off for safety sake, people’s deposits, the bets that banks were allowed to take.”
“By 2007-2008 the economy would’ve crashed and burned without this G7-type alliance between the central banks that provided cheap capital to the markets. It did not have a government push into real infrastructure building, development or economic growth beyond what was found in markets and banks.”
Central Banks Since the Global Financial Crisis
She argues critically that easy money did cause a considerable pushback from Non-Western states. “Something else has happened since the crisis. In the ten years since, a growing number of central banks, outside of the G7, began to push back. The People’s Bank of China, the Chinese central bank, let out a growing criticism of what the U.S and its central bank had done financially in the wake of the crisis. In March of 2009 the PBoC Governor Zhou said at the time, very publicly, that this cannot continue.”
“Having the U.S dollar as the main international reserve is inherently unstable for the world. Other countries began to echo the same sentiment. Not that the U.S dollar hasn’t stayed strong since, along with a major U.S military force, but a “testing of the waters” has begun. This has brought about new alliances in the deals in markets, trading, diplomacy and defense. Since the arrival of Trump, this trend has accelerated.”
Speaking on the state of the global economy she warned, “There is nearly 17% of global GDP that equals the equivalent of the top three central banks. There is a substantial amount of money that has gone into these banks that have basically reconstructed their balance sheets as “taking money out of the market.” That is money not being used for anything constructive such as infrastructure, training programs, etc.”
“The instability that people feel and the level of constraint in their lives can be translated to money being put in the market and not to the public. There is a possibility that as these new trade alliances happen that more infrastructure development and jobs could be utilized and tap into this money for real growth. Otherwise, we are just going to continue to see the same instability.”
“Ultimately, being stagnant will just leave the door open for another financial crisis. If debt repayment has to occur, whether from governments or corporations, things will start to default. All of the shifting alliances that continue to grow out of political and financial instability will continue to happen.”
Taking aim at reckless central bank policy Nomi Prins pressed, “Unless we see this central bank money deployed in a way that is positive and contributes to real economic growth, then we do have the possibility of getting to another crisis. Meanwhile the lack of actual economic conversations and policy action from places like the G20 will continue.”
In a final warning about the negligence seen from financial leadership the economist left with a stark warning. “The U.S banks may have done well during the last set of stress tests done by the Federal Reserve. However, the Fed took the answers from the people responding to their own questions – which were the banks.”
“More recently we’ve seen Fed Chair Janet Yellen note in June that she does not expect another crisis in our lifetime. The reality is that completely ignores how fundamentally distorted money and markets actually are.”
For 66 years the Glass-Steagall act reduced the risks in the banking system. Eight years after the act was repealed, the banking system blew up threatening the international economy. US taxpayers were forced to come up with $750 billion dollars, a sum much larger than the Pentagon’s budget, in order to bail out the banks. This huge sum was insufficient to do the job. The Federal Reserve had to step in and expand its balance sheet by $4 trillion in order to protect the solvency of banks declared “too big to fail.”
The enormous increase in the supply of dollars known as Quantitative Easing inflated financial asset prices instead of the consumer price index. This rise in bond and stock prices is a major cause of the worsening income and wealth distribution in the United States. The economic polarization has undercut the image and reality of the US as a land of opportunity and has introduced political and economic instability into the life of the country.
These are huge costs and for the benefit only of the rich who were already rich.
So, what we can say about the repeal of Glass-Steagall is that it turned a somewhat egalitarian democracy with a large middle class into the One Percent vs. the 99 percent. The repeal resulted in the destruction of the image of the United States as an open prosperous society. The electorate is very much aware of the decline in their economic situation, and this awareness expressed itself in the last presidential election.
Americans know that the nonsense from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics about a 4.3% unemploment rate and an abundance of new jobs is fake news. The BLS gets the low rate of unemployment by not counting the millions of discouraged workers who cannot find employment. If you haven’t looked for a job in the last 4 weeks, you are not considered unemployed. The birth/death model, a purely theoretical construct, accounts for a large percentage of the non-existent new jobs. The jobs are there by assumption. The jobs are not really there. Moreover, the replacement of full time jobs with part time jobs proceeds. Pension and health care benefits that once were a substantial part of the pay package are being terminated.
It makes perfect sense to separate commercial from investment banking. The taxpayer insured deposits of commercial banking should not serve as backing for investment banking’s creation of risky financial instruments, such as subprime and other derivatives. The US government understood that in 1933, but no longer did in 1999. This deterioration in government competence has cost America dearly.
By merging commercial banking with investment banking, the repeal of Glass-Steagall greatly increased the capability of the banking system to create risky financial instruments for which taxpayer backing was available. So, we have the extraordinary situation that the repeal of Glass-Steagall forced the 99 percent to bail out the One Percent.
The repeal of Glass-Steagall has turned the United States into an unstable economic, political, and social system. We have a situation in which millions of Americans who have lost full time employment with benefits to jobs offshoring, whose lower income employment in part time and contract employment leaves them no discretionary income after payment of interest and fees to the financial system (insurance on home and car, health insurance, credit card interest, car payment interest, student loan interest, home mortgage interest, bank charges for insufficient minimum balance, etc.), are on the hook for bailing out financial institutions that make foolish and risky investments.
This is not politically viable unless Congress and the President are going to resign and turn over the governance of America to Wall Street and the Big Banks. A growing cresendo of voices are saying that this has already happened.
So, where is there any democracy when the One Percent can cover their losses at the expense of the 99 Percent, which is what the repeal of Glass-Steagall guarantees?
Not only must Glass-Steagall be restored, but also the large banks must be reduced in size. That any corporation is too big to fail is a contradiction of the justification of capitalism. Capitalism’s justification is that those corporations that misuse resources and make losses go out of business, thus releasing the misused resources to those who can use them profitably. Capitalism is supposed to benefit society, not be dependent on society to bail it out.
I was present when George Champion, former CEO and Chairman of Chase Manhattan Bank testified before the Senate Banking Committee against national branch banking. Champion said that it would result in the banks becoming too large and that the branches would suck savings out of local communities for investment in traded financial assets. Consequently, local communities would be faced with a dearth of loanable funds, and local businesses would die or not be born from lack of loanable funds.
I covered the story for Business Week. But despite the facts as laid out by the pre-eminent banker of our time, the palms had been greased, and the folly proceeded.
As Assistant Secretary of the US Treasury in the Reagan Administration, I opposed all financial deregulation. Financial deregulation does nothing but open the gates to fraud and sharp dealing. It allows one institution, even one individual, to make a fortune by wrecking the lives of millions.
The American public is not sufficiently sophisticated to understand these matters, but they know when they are hurting. Few in the House and Senate are sufficiently sophisticated to understand these matters, but they do know that to understand them is not conducive to having their palms greased. So how do the elected representatives manage to represent those who vote them into office?
The answer is that they seldom do.
The question before Congress today is whether they will take the country down for the sake of campaign contributions and cushy jobs if they lose their seat, or will they take personal risks in order to save the country.
America cannot survive if excessive risks and financial fraud can be bailed out by taxpayers.
US Representatives Walter Jones and Marcy Kaptur and members of the House and staff on both sides of the aisle, along with former Goldman Sachs executive Nomi Prins and leaders of citizens’ groups, have arranged a briefing in the House of Representatives on June 14 about the importance of Glass-Steagall to the economic, political, and social stability of the United States. Let your representative know that you do not want the financial responsibility for the reckless financial practices of the big banks. Let your representative know also that you do not want big banks that dominate the financial arena. Let them know that you want the return of Glass-Steagall.
The effort to reduce the financial risks arising from the commingling of commercial and investment banking by requiring stronger capital positions of financial corporations is futile. The 2007-08 financial crisis required the taxpayers and the printing press and an amount of money that exceeded any realistic capital and liquidity requirements for financial institutions.
If we don’t re-enact Glass-Steagall, the risks taken by financial greed will complete the economic destruction of America.
After the subprime mortgage bubble burst back in 2009, new regulations prevented banks from rushing right back into mortgages to re-inflate a market that nearly took down the global financial system. Of course, Uncle Sam didn"t restrict wall street from blowing massive bubbles in all asset classes, in fact the Fed seemingly condones it, just the mortgage market.
And so, all that loan volume shifted to autos...
...and student loans.
Alas, it seems as though commercials banks are finally starting to wonder whether they"ve inflated at least the auto loan bubble to the brink of bursting. As the Financial Times points out today, the FDIC"s commercial lending report for 1Q 2017 showed that commercial banks slashed their auto loan exposure sequentially for the first time in the past six years.
But data released last week by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation showed the first sequential drop in car loans outstanding at commercial banks in at least six years. The total slipped $1.6bn to $440bn from the fourth quarter of last year to the first of this, suggesting that banks — wary of repeating the mistakes of the subprime mortgage crisis — have been spooked by rising delinquencies and the threat of litigation.
Wells Fargo and JPMorgan Chase, the two biggest banks in the sector, saw first-quarter originations drop by double digits from the same period a year earlier. Even relatively aggressive specialists such as Capital One — which added a net $2bn to its $50bn car loan book over the first quarter — are toning down their outlook.
“We’re certainly one more notch cautious,” said Richard Scott Blackley, chief financial officer, noting bigger-than-expected falls in used car prices in the first quarter. “We think that by pulling back a little bit, we’re going to . . . maximise price over volume,” he said.
But for all you banking investors out there who are worried about replacing that juicy auto lending revenue stream, fear not because Citizens Financial"s CEO would like for you to know that while they "ran up auto for a while" they now see "better risk-adjusted returns" in things like student loans....
One of the banks pulling back is Citizens Financial Group, the US’s ninth largest by assets. Bruce van Saun, chief executive, told the Financial Times he would rather steer resources into areas such as student loans. “We ran up auto for a while when there was not much else going on. Now we have growth in other areas which offer better risk-adjusted returns.”
Of course, this shouldn"t be new news to our readers as we recently pointed out that after 21 consecutive quarters of loosening lending standards from 2Q 2011 through 2Q 2016, commercial banks finally started to pull back on auto loans in 3Q 2016...
Lending Standards Have Eased...: While overall household debt remains below pre-crisis peaks, auto debt has ballooned to all-time highs. While this debt grew, the median FICO score of borrowers receiving auto loans fell roughly 30 points from peak to trough. According to the Senior Loan Officer Opinion Survey (SLOOS), auto lenders eased lending standards for 21 consecutive quarters from 2Q 2011 through 2Q 2016.
...but Lenders Now Appear to Be Reversing Course and Tightening Standards: While FICO scores did drop precipitously, they have recovered in recent months, and the SLOOS reports 3 quarters of tightening standards after the 21 of easing. A look at the weighted average FICO scores of loans going into subprime ABS deals reveals similar trends, with a number of lenders reporting increases in these scores over recent years. However, the overall trend has moved lower since 2013.
...which probably had something to do the soaring delinquency rates that have resulted from years of declining underwriting standards.
But sure, 18mm new cars per year is probably a "normalized" level of demand for the U.S. market...just like 1.3mm in new home sales was "normal" in 2005.
—William Blackstone, Commentaries on the Laws of England
“When the president does it, that means that it is not illegal.”
—Ex-President Richard Nixon, interview with David Frost
The question at bar is why the U.S. Department of Justice has failed to prosecute any too-big-to-fail banks or - more importantly - their bankers, even for admitted crimes.
It’s a crucial question, because after eight straight years of unremitting prosecutorial failure, it looks very much as if a select group of top banks can, in fact, do no wrong. If that’s the case, then our constitutional republic isn’t merely in trouble. It"s dead.
A person or group of people who satisfy Blackstone’s criterion for ultimate sovereign power—the power to commit crimes with impunity—can’t exist in a nation where the law reigns supreme. And yet here we are a decade after the financial crisis began in earnest, and not one TBTF bank executive has gone to jail.
Legally, the TBTF banks are indistinguishable from the King, since the power to commit crimes with impunity swallows all other sovereign powers; such a power isn’t even supposed to exist in the U.S., and yet it does.
Moreover, since there can’t be two kings in a kingdom, the entire U.S. government, from the president on down, is just one of the King’s men under this formulation of power. The real job of the U.S. government, then, isn’t to represent the will of the people at all, it’s to do the King’s bidding. A nation that isn’t governed by law is governed by instead by a king—it’s one or the other—and the president’s inferiority to such an above-the-law sovereign was confirmed over 40 years ago with Nixon’s ouster. The president, unlike the King, answers to the law (despite Nixon"s opinion).
Now, you may say that while the TBTF banks might arguably have the de facto power of the King, that’s a far cry from wielding such power formally (i.e., having de jure criminal immunity).
The reply to that objection is set forth in this film, “All the Plenary’s Men,” which is a sequel to “The Veneer of Justice in a Kingdom of Crime.”
Another objection, raised by the DOJ itself, is that it HAS prosecuted TBTF bankers, citing cases like that of Raj Rajaratnam. These cases, however, in fact reveal the DOJ acting on behalf of the criminal global banking cartel.
On that score, the DOJ’s abysmal track record is by now so extensive and so thorough that it’s possible to spot legal patterns in the DOJ’s protracted miscarriage of justice, and, as you’re about to see, those patterns are very deeply disturbing indeed. What’s been going on cuts right past a garden variety constitutional crisis like Watergate straight to a crisis of sovereignty.
The backdrop for all of this is HSBC’s exoneration in December of 2012 for laundering money for drug dealers and terrorists, about which the House Financial Services Committee issued a report in July of 2016. Whether it was due to the political circus in town at the time, or to the Republican authorship of that report (albeit without dissent), it didn’t get nearly the scrutiny it deserved.
You see, prosecutors working on the HSBC case were actually going to indict the bank, but they got overruled, and HSBC and its team of criminals skated. The story of how exactly that reversal came about reveals, if not the King himself, then certainly many of the King’s top men.
Make the coffee extra strong before viewing. Lots of ground gets covered, quickly.
And don’t mothball those pitchforks and torches just yet.
Last week the Internet was ablaze with disgust after a man was physically dragged off a United Airlines flight.
What’s amazing, though, is that there are countless cases of another industry abusing its customers in far, far worse ways than the airlines.
I’m talking, of course, about the banking industry.
1. Banks treat you like criminal suspects too.
Sure, United had a man dragged away like he was a rape suspect being hauled off to jail.
But banks treat their customers like criminal suspects on a daily basis.
If you think I’m exaggerating, try walking into your bank and asking to withdraw $20,000 in cash.
See how quickly they start acting like police investigators, demanding to know what you intend to do with your own savings.
Thanks to a law called the Bank Secrecy Act, banks are legally required to fill out “Suspicious Activity Reports” on their customers and send them to the government.
Banks filed nearly 1 million suspicious activity reports in 2016 alone.
Think about that; United treated one passenger like a criminal suspect. Banks treated 1 million customers like criminal suspects last year.
2. Banks nickel and dime you even more.
The airline industry is constantly being ridiculed for its incessant and ridiculous fees. Selecting a seat, checking a bag, booking over the phone, even ‘payment fees’.
My favorite is the ‘fuel surcharge,’ which most airlines imposed back in 2007-2008 to compensate for the high price of fuel after oil prices surged past $120.
Of course, when oil fell to below $30, they didn’t get rid of the fuel surcharge.
Airlines rake in tens of billions of dollars each year on these fees that absolutely infuriate their passengers.
But once again, banks are no different, endlessly nickeling and diming their customers with unnecessary fees… especially if you’re a small business owner.
Some of the most infuriating are fees for sending and receiving money.
To send a domestic wire transfer, for example, banks charge a fee of $25 to $35.
Yet the actual -cost- of banks sending each other money through the Federal Reserve system is just pennies– as low as 3 cents per transaction.
So banks are literally charging more than ONE THOUSAND TIMES as much for a wire transfer as it costs them.
3. Overbooking? Try fractional reserve banking
Last week’s United incident highlighted the common practice of overbooking, in which airlines deliberately sell more seats for a flight than actually exist.
If there are 150 seats on a plane, an airline might sell 160-165 seats on the assumption that 5% of ticketed passengers won’t show up.
In other words, they make money by selling something that doesn’t actually exist… which isn’t a problem until all the passengers show up.
Well, this happens in the banking industry as well; banks routinely make loans and charge interest on money that doesn’t actually exist.
It’s called “Fractional Reserve Banking”, a type of financial system that only requires banks to hold a tiny portion (or none) of their customers’ deposits in reserve.
If you deposit $100,000 at a bank, for example, the bank might hold 5% of that money in reserve, and loan out the remaining $95,000.
That $95,000 will eventually be deposited in the bank, upon which the bank will hold 5% of that amount ($4,750) and loan out the remaining $90,250.
This continues again and again until the bank has made $2 million in loans on a single $100,000 deposit.
The other $1.9 million doesn’t actually exist. But the bank is raking in the interest.
Just like airline overbooking, fractional reserve banking is a risky practice. And we saw in 2008 how quickly the entire system unraveled.
But that’s OK because. . .
4. Banks are in bed with the government too.
After the 9/11 attacks, the already-troubled airline industry was quickly sliding into bankruptcy, so the US government provided a $15 billion bailout through the Air Transportation Safety and Stabilization Act.
Airlines, as it turned out, were too big to fail.
Seven years later, the banks received a bailout worth more than $1.7 TRILLION, over 100x what the airlines received.
So no matter how stupid or risky their practices are, banks expect the taxpayer to bail them out.
5. Yet they brazenly screw their own customers
One of the things that was most disturbing about the United episode was how quickly the situation escalated to violence.
After overbooking the flight, United offered $800 in vouchers to passengers who voluntarily got off the plane.
$800, apparently, was the magic number. After breaching that limit they resorted to violence.
It shows a pitiful lack of respect for human dignity and a terrible violation of the public trust.
At least airlines pretend to compete with one another and engage in the occasional ‘fare war’.
Banks actually conspire to screw their customers.
And even when they get caught there are hardly any consequences.
One guy got dragged off a plane and the Internet lost its mind. But banks abuse their customers on a daily basis. Where’s the outrage?
If people are angry about United, they should give serious thought to their financial system.
Sadly there are no real alternatives to the airline industry.
If you need to get from Vancouver to London, you pretty much have to fly.
But with banking, there’s a whole world of solutions.
Everything from deposits to lending to exchange services can already be done better, faster, and cheaper outside of the banking system.
With options like Peer-to-Peer platforms, Blockchain services, or even physical cash and precious metals, there’s no reason to keep 100% of your savings in a system that is rigged against you.
I don"t talk to my classmates from business school anymore, many of whom went to work in the financial industry.
Why?
Because, through the lens we use here at PeakProsperity.com to look at the world, I"ve increasingly come to see the financial industry -- with the big banks at its core -- as the root cause of injustice in today"s society. I can no longer separate any personal affections I might have for my fellow alumni from the evil that their companies perpetrate.
And I"m choosing that word deliberately: Evil.
In my opinion, it"s long past time we be brutally honest about the banks. Their influence and reach has metastasized to the point where we now live under a captive system. From our retirement accounts, to our homes, to the laws we live under -- the banks control it all. And they run the system for their benefit, not ours.
While the banks spent much of the past century consolidating their power, the repeal of the Glass-Steagall Act in 1999 emboldened them to accelerate their efforts. Since then, the key trends in the financial industry have been to dismantle regulation and defang those responsible for enforcing it, to manipulate market prices (an ambition tremendously helped by the rise of high-frequency trading algorithms), and to push downside risk onto "muppets" and taxpayers.
Oh, and of course, this hasn"t hurt either: having the ability to print up trillions in thin-air money and then get first-at-the-trough access to it. Don"t forget, the Federal Reserve is made up of and run by -- drum roll, please -- the banks.
How much "thin air" money are we talking about? The Fed and the rest of the world"s central banking cartel has printed over $12 Trillion since the Great Recession. Between the ECB and the DOJ, nearly $200 Billion of additional liquidity has been -- and continues to be -- injected into world markets each month(!) since the beginning of 2016:
With their first-in-line access to this money tsunami, as well as their stranglehold on the financial system that it all runs through, the banks are like a parasite feasting from a gusher on the mother-lode artery.
It should come as little surprise that, with all this advantage they"ve amassed, the banks have enriched themselves and their cronies spectacularly. They have made themselves too big to fail, and too big to jail. Remember that their reckless greed caused the 2008 financial crisis, and yet, in 2009, not only did bankers avoid criminal prosecutions, not only did the banks receive hundreds of billions in government bailouts, but they paid themselves record bonuses?
And the bonanza continues unabated today. By being able to borrow capital for essentially free today from the Fed, the banks simply lever that money up and buy Treasurys. Voila! Risk-free profits. That giveaway has been going on for years.
Couple that with the banks" ability to push market prices around using their wide arsenal of unfair tactics -- frontrunning, HFT spoofing and quote stuffing, stop-running, insider knowledge, collusion, etc -- the list is long. James Howard Kunstler is dead on: we don"t have a free market anymore. Instead, we have rackets, run by racketeers. The rest of us are simply suckers to be fleeced.
Nobel Prize-winning economist Angus Deaton recently agreed:
Income inequality is not killing capitalism in the United States, but rent-seekers like the banking and the health-care sectors just might, said Nobel-winning economist Angus Deaton on Monday.
If an entrepreneur invents something on the order of another Facebook, Deaton said he has no problem with that person becoming wealthy.
“What is not OK is for rent-seekers to get rich,” Deaton said in a luncheon speech to the National Association for Business Economics.
Rent seekers lobby and persuade governments to give them special favors.
Bankers during the financial crisis, and much of the health-care system, are two prime examples, Deaton said.
Rent-seeking not only does not generate new product, it actually slows down economic growth, Deaton said.
“All that talent is devoted to stealing things, instead of making things,” he said.
As further proof, let"s look at this data recently obtained by Zero Hedge. In the past 4 years, JP Morgan"s in-house trading group has had exactly 2 days of losses:
That"s not trading. Trading involves uncertainty and risk. This situation has none. It"s an extraction process -- siphoning value from the market day after day with ironclad dependability.
And it"s not just a few dollars here and there. In 2016, JP Morgan"s daily average trading revenues were $80 million. Per day! That"s nearly $20 billion for the year.
So if not "trading", what should we call it when a bank can extract tens of billions of dollars a year from the markets, with no downside risk? "Sanctioned theft" sounds about right.
Because for every trade there is a buyer and a seller. If JP Morgan is the winner every day, who is losing? Turns out, it"s the big pools of "dumb money" that don"t have the cheat codes for the system the way the banks do. These are the pension funds, the index funds, the retirement accounts -- the aggregated money of all the "little people" out there. Little people who don"t have visibility into how they"re being constantly fleeced; nor do they have agency to do anything about it even if they did.
So yeah, "theft" feels like a pretty accurate term.
And it"s reached the point where the banks don"t even care about hiding it anymore. If you had a nice inside racket going on, wouldn"t you at least pretend to hide your advantage, to avoid drawing attention? Not the banks. They"re either too proud or too obtuse to conceal it. Look at our string of perfect trading days! Look at our record bonuses!
These boasts fall on the ears of everyday American"s as the modern version of Let them eat cake!
And just like the out-of-touch French monarchs, the banks have positioned themselves as the enemy of the public. For as I claimed at the beginning of this article, a tremendous amount of the injustice in this country can be laid at the feet of the banks directly, or indirectly via the Federal Reserve.
Are you a senior who can"t afford to retire because you can"t live off your fixed-income savings? Thank the Fed"s 0% interest rates for that.
Are you a millennial who can"t afford to buy a home? Again, thank the Fed"s policy of suppressing interest rates and thereby blowing another housing bubble.
Are you struggling to get out of poverty? Are you finding it hard to remain in the middle class? Whatever your income, are you having to work harder and harder to just stay in the same place? See here how the Fed"s money printing, and the banks" first-position access to it, has created the most concentrated imbalance of wealth in our country"s history:
Are you frustrated with how our lawmakers seem to serve corporations instead of the people? Listen to this mind-blowing podcast of how gobs of lobbyist money, much of it provided by Wall Street, dictates how our politicians legislate:
Whether it"s social equity, the security of your job or retirement, your day-to-day existence, or the fairness of the laws we live under -- our fate is currently in the hands of the banks. And, of course, should their behavior trigger another meltdown of the global economy -- something we warn about often here at PeakProsperity.com -- we"ll have them to thank for that, too.
Yes, the banks are going to keep writing the rules in their favor; and yes, there"s little agency any of us has individually to do much about it. But as a society, we need to start addressing the dire situation we"re in honestly and openly. By whatever path, we have granted the banks far too much control over our lives, and they are taking gross advantage of that. Exactly like a parasite, the banking system is siphoning off our wealth and limiting our freedoms and future prospects -- all for the benefit of an elite few.
That"s wrong. It"s immoral. And it"s Evil.
It"s far beyond time to call a spade and spade. The path to change always begins with an accurate assessment of the problem. We need to start using accurate language -- like "evil" -- when discussing the harm we"re being subjected to. We need to make it clear to our elected officials and to our communities that we understand what the banks are doing and that we find it unacceptable.
We need to make the criticism specific and personal. To JP Morgan CEO Jamie Dimon. To Fed Chair Janet Yellen. We need to turn up the heat on the perpetrating decision-makers, so that the borg-like structure of the banking system no longer serves as a deflective shield to scrutiny and criticism. These people need to feel the disapproving stares when speaking to the public. They need to hear the disdainful boos, and see their faces on the protest signs and nightly media reports.
And if you yourself work in the financial system, I"ll be blunt. You"re part of the problem. Just like my former classmates, I"m sure you"re a very nice person in many ways -- but you"re complicit in the banks" rapaciousness.
I know it"s not pleasant to hear, or admit. I worked for an investment bank for a few years early on my career. I was part of the problem, too.
But we have a choice, both as individuals and as a society, to align our actions with our values. It"s not always easy. And likely not as profitable if you indeed end up leaving the financial industry (as I can tell you from personal experience). But it"s the only way we"ll ultimately gain back control of our destiny.
Look, the banks" dominion is going to end one day. Either due to collapsing under the weight of the stupendous amount of debt they"ve helped laden our economy with, or due to an uprising from the bottom 99% once it has become fully destitute. Neither path is appealing.
So our best choice here as individuals is to position ourselves where we can be least subjected to the game the banks want to force us to play.
Finally, as a society, we need to wake up and make some hard, courageous choices. Obviously, the banks will not relinquish their control willingly. But if we start speaking truthfully and openly about the evil we"re dealing with, we"ll start fearing it less. It"s time for us all to speak up.
According to the Journal Star, Federal officials have executed search warrants at three Caterpillar, Inc. facilities in the Tri-County Area — including the corporate headquarters — Thursday morning. Company officials confirmed the presence in a statement without specifying which agency was performing the search or what the search was in regard to. A spokeswoman declined by email to provide further details.
Dow Jones adds that agents from the IRS, FDIC and Commerce Department are involved in the searches. They are probably not looking for CAT profits.
"Caterpillar is cooperating," the brief statement said.
The spokeswoman for the U.S. Attorney for the Central District of Illinois confirmed that facilities in three communities were the subject of the activity — Peoria, East Peoria and Morton. At the Downtown Caterpillar global headquarters building, at least some company employees were directed to the building"s cafeteria and were told to remain there and not leave, according to one employee at the facility.
At least some of the agents entering the headquarters building wore jackets bearing an Internal Revenue Service logo, others appeared to be from the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. Others simply denoted that they were federal agents. A placard in the window of one of the federal vehicles noted it was used by police from the U.S. Department of Commerce Bureau of Industry and Security Office of Export Enforcement.
CAT stock, which traditionally soars on bad news and reports of losses, is inexplicably sliding on the news.
Maybe investigators are trying to figure this out?
As a reminder, this is not the first time CAT has gotten in trouble with regulators: back in 2014 CAT and PWC got in trouble before Congress for evading taxes using offshore locations when this infamous line came up: "What the heck, we’ll all be retired when this audit comes up on audit." In retrospect, perhaps not all will be retired.
On January 23, Reuters reported that dialing back the Volcker Rule which limits banks" ability to engage in speculative investments using their own balance sheet, has emerged a top priority for President Donald Trump"s nominee for U.S. Treasury secretary, Steve Mnuchin. In written responses to questions posed by members of the U.S. Senate Finance Committee, Mnuchin said he would use his role as head of the interagency Financial Stability Oversight Council to give the Volcker Rule a stricter definition of proprietary trading.
At issue is the Volcker Rule, a contentious provision in the 2010 Dodd-Frank Act that sought to prevent lenders from putting federally-insured deposits at risk through wagers on stocks, bonds and other assets.
"As Chair of FSOC I would plan to address the issue of the definition of the Volcker Rule to make sure that banks can provide the necessary liquidity for customer markets and address the issues in the Fed report," Mnuchin wrote in the document, which also included senators" questions and was verified by a Senate aide.
According to Reuters, Mnuchin also said that "regulators have applied proprietary trading prohibitions to too many activities" adding that "In the responses Mnuchin also made it clear he believes the rule should only apply to "a bank that benefits from federal deposit insurance." The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation guarantees retail deposits at about 6,000 banks, including the consumer banking arms of the country"s largest investment banks."
Just a few days later, in a follow up to Mnuchin"s written responses, this time from Bloomberg, the interpretation of his statement was 180 degrees opposite, and as Bloomberg reported, "Steven Mnuchin made clear he doesn’t want Wall Street banks getting back into the business of making risky market bets with their own capital, after Senate Democrats pushed him to clarify his responses to questions they asked during his confirmation process to be Treasury secretary."
Why the difference? Because in the span of just two days, Mnuchin appears to have flip-flopped on Volcker:
Mnuchin’s updated comments, which Bloomberg News obtained, were made after several Democrats on the Senate Finance Committee felt his earlier responses weren’t adequate, according to a Jan. 25 letter that Senator Ron Wyden of Oregon wrote to Utah’s Orrin Hatch, the panel’s Republican chairman.
It appears that the biggest variance between the two sets of responses had to do with the new Treasury Secretary"s outlook on prop trading. Mnuchin"s Bloomberg added that in his written remarks to lawmakers, "Mnuchin said that even banking units that lack a government backstop should be restricted from making speculative trades."
“A legal distinction between the insured and non-insured entity is an important factor in eliminating risky activities within the institution that has” insured deposits, Mnuchin said in an amended response to a senator’s question about Volcker. “I do not believe that the uninsured entity should be able to perform proprietary trading."
If Bloomberg"s interpretation of Mnuchin"s statement is accurate, it could cause substantial headaches for bank investors, many of which have priced in substantial deregulation, among which the return of the Volcker rule, as banks were once again expected to have free reign in a Dodd-Frank free environment.
* * *
In addition to Volcker, Mnuchin also weighed in on the issue of how to reform America’s GSE in particular, and mortgage-finance system in general, a topic that has huge consequences for the multitrillion mortgage industry and the fate of shareholders who’ve invested billions of dollars in Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. In his response, Mnuchin wrote that “any solution will be dependent upon the GSEs being capitalized properly and other such controls that eliminate risk to taxpayers.”
The answer could cheer some advocates of preserving Fannie and Freddie, including investors, small lenders, and some affordable housing groups. Over the past few years, those groups tried to convince the Obama administration to allow the companies to rebuild capital to no avail. In the days after President Donald Trump’s surprise election win in November, his advisers pledged to dismantle Dodd-Frank and cut regulations broadly.
Mnuchin took a softer tone at his hearing before the Finance Committee. He said he mostly favors making changes to rules put in place in the wake of the 2008 financial crisis, not repealing the law entirely. In his amended responses to the Finance panel, Mnuchin said he’d like to use “empirical assessments” to monitor the effects Dodd-Frank has had on the finance industry. He also said that he’ll advocate that any rules needed to protect “public safety” shouldn’t be included in the regulatory freeze Trump has ordered across all federal agencies.
* * *
Assuming that Mnuchin"s harsher, second set of responses is accurate, it may also be one of the reasons for today"s bank stock selloff, as yet another significiant decoupling between the post-Obama reality and the Trump hope was gently squeezed, prompting traders just how much will really change under Trump who is increasingly getting bogged down in day to day scandals and minutiae - involving both republicans and democrats - that have little to do with his economic promises, something which infurated none other than Matt Drudge earlier today.