Showing posts with label Airline. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Airline. Show all posts

Friday, September 8, 2017

Private-Plane Taxes: Another Way The Poor Subsidize The Rich

Wealthy CEOs and athletes have found a loophole that allows them to minimize their tax bills while traveling in style – all at the expense of the everyday traveler who flies commercial and must bear an outsize percentage of aviation taxes in the US.


According to a Bloomberg analysis of government data, operators of private jets pay far less in taxes than airline passengers and other commercial flyers. On a per flight basis, a private jet could generate as little as two percent of the taxes and fees paid by airline passengers on an identical route. Private planes make up about 10 percent of US flights under air-traffic control, yet pay less than 1 percent into a trust fund that finances air-traffic control and other Federal Aviation Administration operations.



Sports teams like the New England Patriots are increasingly investing in private jets to take advantage of these cost-savings, Bloomberg reported.


Of course, after years of declining prices, buyers of private jets can easily get a good deal if they’re willing to buy used. Sales prices for used jets have fallen as much as 35% over the past three years, with the average price falling from $13.7 million in April 2014 to $8.9 million today.


Bloomberg’s analysis prompted some aviation experts to complain that private-jet owners aren’t paying their fair share of taxes.





"By and large, a private aircraft costs the same for the FAA to process as a large aircraft," said Michael Ball, senior associate dean at the University of Maryland’s Robert H. Smith School of business and co-director of an aviation research consortium. "If you look at it from that standpoint, they clearly aren’t paying their due.”



Private-jet owners, unsurprisingly, must have an army of powerful lobbyists in their employ, because, as Bloomberg explains, the US system where private owners are exempt from the bulk of taxes that commercial airlines pay is different from the system used by most of the rest of the world.






“Unlike most of the rest of the world, which charges fees based on aircraft weight and distance flown, the taxes private jets in the U.S. pay are different from the ones imposed on airlines.



Private aircraft operators pay 21.8 cents per gallon of jet fuel. By contrast, airlines and charter operators have three separate taxes: an excise tax of 7.5 percent on tickets or charter charges, a fee of $4.10 per passenger and 4.3 cents per gallon of jet fuel.”



This means that airline passengers are effectively subsidizing some of the world’s largest corporations and wealthiest people under the current system, said Matthew Gardner, a senior fellow at the nonprofit Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy.





"Pretty clearly, we all feel the pain every time we buy an airline ticket and see how big a share of the costs those fees are," Gardner said.



Indeed, the disparity in taxes for comparable private and commercial flights can be staggering:





“A transcontinental flight from New York to Los Angeles on a Virgin America Inc. Airbus SE A320, would be charged about $3,900 in taxes, assuming the plane was 85 percent full and passengers paid the average fare calculated by the Transportation Department’s Bureau of Transportation Statistics.



The tax bill for a flight between the same cities on a privately owned Bombardier Inc. Global 6000, one of the world’s longest range corporate jets, would be about $525. That’s about 87 percent less than the airline flight.”



And the differences can be even larger if the private plane is a smaller model that burns less fuel.





“A trip from Nashville, Tennessee, to Philadelphia by Southwest Airlines Co., which typically uses a Boeing Co. 737-700 on that route, would typically be charged more than $2,000 in taxes. An Embraer SA Phenom 100E, a smaller and more fuel efficient corporate jet, on the same leg would be assessed about $50, or roughly 2 percent of the Southwest plane.”



Putting their total tax contribution in context, private business plane owners contributed just $104 million to the FAA’s trust fund in 2016 – that amounts to just 0.7 percent of the overall aviation taxes paid that year.






“The FAA estimated that these business planes contributed $104 million to the trust fund in 2016. That amounts to just 0.7 percent of the overall aviation taxes. That compares to 92 percent of the tax payments, or more than $13 billion, that came from U.S. carriers, foreign airlines and charter carriers -- most of which were paid directly by passengers.”



And thanks to their army of lobbyists, private jet owners have virtually guaranteed that the tax disparity will persist.





“Any potential changes in the taxes on private aviation were effectively taken off the table this year by the powerful chairman of the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee, Pennsylvania Republican Bill Shuster.



In order to mute opposition to his plan to create a nonprofit company to operate the air-traffic system, Shuster’s bill would keep the current tax levels for private planes. Shuster’s attempt to mollify private plane owners has had little effect as they continue to oppose his proposal. The bill has passed the committee and is awaiting a vote before the full House.”



As one expert pointed out, if the purpose of the FAA’s tax system was to evenly distribute costs for maintaining the US’s aviation infrastructure among its users, than the current system is an abject failure.





“If the purpose of aviation taxes is to create an equitable way to pay for the air-traffic centers, computers and radars, the existing system is a failure, said Robert Frank, a professor at Cornell University’s Johnson Graduate School of Management.



“It doesn’t sound like this fee structure comes even close to imposing fees on the costs respective users impose on the system,” Frank said."



But hey…like they say, life isn’t fair.

Friday, July 14, 2017

United Creates Volunteer "Rewards Program" For Overbooked Flights

The controversy surrounding the forcible removable of Dr. David Dao left an indelible blemish on United Airlines’ brand. It also started a conversation about how airlines should handle overbooked flights. Well it seems United has found a solution – though it may not be the solution customers had hoped for.


This week, United Airlines Inc. is quietly unveiling a new technology platform that it will use to manage the problem of oversold flights - and, in the same breath, turn them into a profit opportunity, according to Bloomberg.





With the help of its new Flex-Schedule Program, the airline is piloting a way to buck the trend of involuntary bumping - the term for kicking passengers off oversold flights - without necessarily offering four-figure payouts to passengers at the gate, or curbing their practice of overselling inventory.



Instead, it’ll simply offer buyouts earlier - up to five days in advance. The upside for United? The chance to resell your ticket at a wider profit margin.



In partnership with Volantio, a third-party aviation technology startup based in Atlanta, United will soon begin sending e-mail newsletters with subject lines such as “Are You Flexible with Your Travels to Los Angeles?” Inside, travelers will have the option to sign up for potential rewards - so long as they’re willing to budge a little on their flight itineraries.



But as Forbes points out, the policy change might be a smart move by the airline, but it’s not the best deal for consumers. Under the new policy, passengers on a flight with heavy demand who sign up for marketing emails will sometimes be asked—up to five days before their scheduled departure—to accept a $250 travel voucher in return for flying on a different flight to the same destination on the original departure date. United then would be able to resell the seat at a higher price to business travelers.


While $250 might seem like a lot to some, it’s typically less than what the airline would offer passengers at the gate when they asked for volunteers.





“For many travelers, though, $250 is a lot less than they were given in the past when gate agents at airports asked for volunteers before takeoff to surrender their seats. Many gate agents have traditionally started by offering at least a $250 travel voucher and a seat on a subsequent flight, and, when they haven’t gotten any, or enough takers, quickly made the offer more lucrative.”



Only those who book on United.com and opt in to receive marketing messages will be eligible for the sign-up offer - and signing up doesn’t guarantee that you’ll be asked to change your flight, according to Bloomberg.


After months of negative press, United has become desperate for some kind of gimmick to help restore its battered brand. And it seems like whoever sold this idea to United couched it as an opportunity to do just that.  





“According to Azim Barodawala, the chief executive of Volantio who created the technology and brought it to United, the Flex-Schedule Program could be an opportunity to change the narrative with the help of innovative technology, rather than cumbersome regulations.



“If you can offer a buyout to a customer in advance, everyone will be happier,” he said. ‘For airlines, it represents a release valve—a way to shuffle people around when you’re capacity-constrained. This benefits the customer as well you’re creating choice for them, and that’s what gets me really excited. [Passengers] get the short stick a lot.’”



But will fliers in advance give up a seat for a $250 credit? To some, it seems unlikely. A Forbes reporter claimed he saw no takers for that amount at the gate before an American flight he took in late May.
An admitted frequent flier who also spoke with Forbes said he doubts it’ll be enough.





“The policy is great for United but not for passengers,” he says. “Giving a $250 credit is a steal for United, but will a person give up a seat for $250? I don’t think so. Where can you go for a $250 credit? I would only start considering giving up my seat at $500.”
 


Tuesday, April 18, 2017

The Banking Industry Treats Its Customers Worse Than United Airlines

Authored by Simon Black via SovereignMan.com,


Last week the Internet was ablaze with disgust after a man was physically dragged off a United Airlines flight.



What’s amazing, though, is that there are countless cases of another industry abusing its customers in far, far worse ways than the airlines.


I’m talking, of course, about the banking industry.


1. Banks treat you like criminal suspects too.


Sure, United had a man dragged away like he was a rape suspect being hauled off to jail.


But banks treat their customers like criminal suspects on a daily basis.


If you think I’m exaggerating, try walking into your bank and asking to withdraw $20,000 in cash.


See how quickly they start acting like police investigators, demanding to know what you intend to do with your own savings.


Thanks to a law called the Bank Secrecy Act, banks are legally required to fill out “Suspicious Activity Reports” on their customers and send them to the government.


Banks filed nearly 1 million suspicious activity reports in 2016 alone.


Think about that; United treated one passenger like a criminal suspect. Banks treated 1 million customers like criminal suspects last year.


2. Banks nickel and dime you even more.


The airline industry is constantly being ridiculed for its incessant and ridiculous fees. Selecting a seat, checking a bag, booking over the phone, even ‘payment fees’.


My favorite is the ‘fuel surcharge,’ which most airlines imposed back in 2007-2008 to compensate for the high price of fuel after oil prices surged past $120.


Of course, when oil fell to below $30, they didn’t get rid of the fuel surcharge.


Airlines rake in tens of billions of dollars each year on these fees that absolutely infuriate their passengers.


But once again, banks are no different, endlessly nickeling and diming their customers with unnecessary fees… especially if you’re a small business owner.


Some of the most infuriating are fees for sending and receiving money.


To send a domestic wire transfer, for example, banks charge a fee of $25 to $35.


Yet the actual -cost- of banks sending each other money through the Federal Reserve system is just pennies– as low as 3 cents per transaction.


So banks are literally charging more than ONE THOUSAND TIMES as much for a wire transfer as it costs them.


3. Overbooking? Try fractional reserve banking


Last week’s United incident highlighted the common practice of overbooking, in which airlines deliberately sell more seats for a flight than actually exist.


If there are 150 seats on a plane, an airline might sell 160-165 seats on the assumption that 5% of ticketed passengers won’t show up.


In other words, they make money by selling something that doesn’t actually exist… which isn’t a problem until all the passengers show up.


Well, this happens in the banking industry as well; banks routinely make loans and charge interest on money that doesn’t actually exist.


It’s called “Fractional Reserve Banking”, a type of financial system that only requires banks to hold a tiny portion (or none) of their customers’ deposits in reserve.


If you deposit $100,000 at a bank, for example, the bank might hold 5% of that money in reserve, and loan out the remaining $95,000.


That $95,000 will eventually be deposited in the bank, upon which the bank will hold 5% of that amount ($4,750) and loan out the remaining $90,250.


This continues again and again until the bank has made $2 million in loans on a single $100,000 deposit.


The other $1.9 million doesn’t actually exist. But the bank is raking in the interest.


Just like airline overbooking, fractional reserve banking is a risky practice. And we saw in 2008 how quickly the entire system unraveled.


But that’s OK because. . .


4. Banks are in bed with the government too.


After the 9/11 attacks, the already-troubled airline industry was quickly sliding into bankruptcy, so the US government provided a $15 billion bailout through the Air Transportation Safety and Stabilization Act.


Airlines, as it turned out, were too big to fail.


Seven years later, the banks received a bailout worth more than $1.7 TRILLION, over 100x what the airlines received.


So no matter how stupid or risky their practices are, banks expect the taxpayer to bail them out.


5. Yet they brazenly screw their own customers


One of the things that was most disturbing about the United episode was how quickly the situation escalated to violence.


After overbooking the flight, United offered $800 in vouchers to passengers who voluntarily got off the plane.


$800, apparently, was the magic number. After breaching that limit they resorted to violence.


It shows a pitiful lack of respect for human dignity and a terrible violation of the public trust.


It’s the same in banking.


Hardly a month goes by without some major banking scandal– colluding on interest rates and exchange rates, manipulating asset prices, manufacturing fake accounts…


It never stops.


At least airlines pretend to compete with one another and engage in the occasional ‘fare war’.


Banks actually conspire to screw their customers.


And even when they get caught there are hardly any consequences.


One guy got dragged off a plane and the Internet lost its mind. But banks abuse their customers on a daily basis. Where’s the outrage?


If people are angry about United, they should give serious thought to their financial system.


Sadly there are no real alternatives to the airline industry.


If you need to get from Vancouver to London, you pretty much have to fly.


But with banking, there’s a whole world of solutions.


Everything from deposits to lending to exchange services can already be done better, faster, and cheaper outside of the banking system.


With options like Peer-to-Peer platforms, Blockchain services, or even physical cash and precious metals, there’s no reason to keep 100% of your savings in a system that is rigged against you.


Do you have a Plan B?

Wednesday, April 12, 2017

End Airline Protectionism: Allow Foreign Carriers On Domestic Routes

In the wake of the United Airlines debacle - in which the airline had airport police assault one of its own customers - customers have begun to ask why there doesn"t seem to be more competition for United to contend with. They ask: would United treat its customers so poorly if they had more competition? 


Maybe not. 


Is the Airline Industry Competitive? 


Compared to governments  — which enjoy near-absolute monopolies — airlines are quite competitive. But compared to many private-sector industries, they are not especially competitive. 


It is true that a small number of firms dominate the airline business in North America. Investopedia claims the three top carriers enjoy 70 percent of the business, and Salon and the NYT say the top four enjoy 80 percent. 


By the numbers provided here, we find that the top four combing for around 80 percent according to 2015 enplaned passengers: 



airlines.png


Nevertheless, the fact that there are only a handful of firms dominating the industry does not prove that the airline business is an oligopoly or a cartel or is "non-competitive." True oligopolies and monopolies can only exist when governments fully prevent firms from entering the marketplace. The relatively few number of airlines in the US may be due to the capital-intensive nature of airlines as much as it is due to government intervention. 


How Governments Limit Airline Competition


But, government regulations do limit competition and market entry to an extent. They do this in several ways, including: 


Moreover, the generally-high level of bureaucratization in the airline business means that airlines spend a sizable amount of effort satisfying government bureaucracies rather than concentrating on their own customers. As Per Bylund has explained, regulated markets destroy consumer sovereignty. 


So, yes, there are multiple government-imposed constraints that indirectly limit competition in the airline industry — to the benefit of incumbent firms like United. 


The Ban on Domestic Routes for Foreign Carriers


But there is also one big government regulation that directly protects all domestic airlines from competition: the US ban on foreign carriers.


USAToday reports: 





International airlines do operate in this country, of course, but they"re forbidden from flying point-to-point destinations domestically. These laws, which are meant to protect American consumers and jobs, are having the exact opposite effect. Eliminating — or at least partially lifting — outdated restrictions could significantly increase competition and improve customer service.



The author of the above is wrong about at least one thing. The protectionist laws eliminating foreign competition are not "outdated." They were never a good idea to begin with. Protectionist laws such as the ban on foreign carriers have always favored the owners of domestic firms at the expense of their customers. 


United Airlines is more easily able to weather PR disasters because US law prohibits foreign carriers from coming in and offering services that don"t involve being smacked around by police when the airline can"t count how many seats it has on the plane. 


Were free trade allowed in the airline business, customers could potentially elect to fly the Irish carrier Aer Lingus — for example — between Boston and New York rather than United. This would, of course, drive down prices and give more choices to consumers. 


The Usual Protectionist Rhetoric 


Now, we can already predict what the protectionists will say. "Why, don"t you know that foreign airlines are subsidized by foreign governments? Those airlines will provide services at below-market prices!" This presumably will mean American firms will be unable to compete. 


This is the classic "argument" against so-called dumping and the proper response to this is always the same: "so what?" 


It would not be a problem for Americans if the UK taxpayer were subsidizing British Airways flights between New York and Miami. That"s too bad for the British taxpayer, of course, but as Murray Rothbard notes,  American customers would simply be enjoying lower airfares thanks to free trade. The argument against dumping has long relied on the largely imaginary concept of "predatory pricing." Rothbard continues: 





For decades, indeed, opponents of the free market have claimed that many businesses gained their powerful status on the market by what is called "predatory price cutting," that is, by driving their smaller competitors into bankruptcy by selling their goods below cost, and then reaping the reward of their unfair methods by raising their prices and thereby charging "monopoly prices" to the consumers. The claim is that while consumers may gain in the short run by price wars, "dumping," and selling below costs, they lose in the long run from the alleged monopoly. But, as we have seen, economic theory shows that this would be a mug"s game, losing money for the "dumping" firms, and never really achieving a monopoly price. And sure enough, historical investigation has not turned up a single case where predatory pricing, when tried, was successful, and there are actually very few cases where it has even been tried.



As with every restriction on foreign competition, the ban on foreign carriers benefits the existing dominant firms at the expense of their customers. Naturally, we shouldn"t be surprised their airlines have fought repeatedly against any effort to expand foreign competition. 


Even With More Competition, Many Will Still Choose United


But even when a moderate amount of competition is available — as is the case with US airlines — it"s extremely likely that many of United"s customers will stay with the airline even in the wake of Sunday"s beat-down. 


After all, taking another airline might mean a slightly higher price, or it might mean fewer non-stop flights. Or it might mean taking flights at slightly less convenient times. Regardless of the industry, two firms virtually never offer exactly the same product. Thus, even with multiple firms to choose from, many customers will still prefer the mix of flight times and locations offered only by United. Many potential passengers will decide to "chance it" and recognize the odds of being bloodied in a confrontation with the airline are small. 


But don"t expect airlines to count on this sort of company loyalty when faced with the prospect of foreign competition. No firm wants to have to deal with more competitors, and fortunately for America"s big airlines, the federal government is very willing to help.

Monday, January 30, 2017

Delta Lifts Stop Grounding All Domestic Flights For Over Two Hours Due To Computer Glitch

Update: as of 9:30pm ET, Delta said in an advisory that the ground stop has been lifted.


* * *


One week after United Continental was forced to ground its flights for nearly three hours due to a computer failure, on Sunday around 7pm Eastern, Delta Air Lines - the second-largest US airline  - halted all U.S. flights because of another technology glitch.






"Our systems are down," Delta tweeted, adding "the IT department is working to rectify the situation as soon as possible," said Atlanta-based Delta.




The company"s international flights are exempt from the grounding, which was caused by “automation issues,” the Federal Aviation Administration said in a statement.



The second consecutive froced grounding at Delta struck as airlines struggled to comply with new travel restrictions following President Trump’s executive order blocking travelers from seven predominantly Muslim nations. As Bloomberg adds, last year, a rash of computer failures disrupted flight operations at U.S. airlines. Thousands of passengers were stranded as carriers struggled to keep older information systems working. 





Delta took a $100 million hit to sales after a power-control module at the company’s Atlanta command center caught fire in August, cutting power to computers. Southwest Airlines Co. had to halt flights the month before that because of issues with “multiple technology systems.”



Ground stops, as the FAA calls them, are relatively common reactions to thunderstorms and other disruptions in the U.S. aviation system. They are typically short-lived and narrowly drawn, such as halting departures to a congested airport for an hour or two.



Nearly two hours after the FAA first notified about the ground halt, Delta still has to resolve the system outage.