Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label consumer. Show all posts

Monday, May 8, 2017

Household Spending Growth Expectations Crash To Cycle Lows

Despite record high stock prices, soaring consumer sentiment measures, and the constant Fed-spun narrative that incomes will rise amid "full-employment", the latest survey of Americans by The New York Fed signals hope is collapsing for a spending renaissance...


Median household spending growth expectations tumbled from 3.29% in March to 2.58% in April, lowest level in data going back to June 2013..




Still, as long as NFLX, AAPL, AMZN, and GOOG are rallying, this is nothing to worry about, right?

Thursday, April 13, 2017

BofA Finds Surging Consumer Confidence Does Not Result In Higher Spending

While markets are closed tomorrow for Good Friday, the Census Bureau will release both CPI and Retail Sales data at their regularly scheduled times. And since it will be impossible to trade these numbers as they are released, here is a courtesy advance look from Bank of America which as usual has released its internal debt and credit card data in advance of the government report. What it found is that while there has been a slight improvement to the surprisingly poor data from recent months, it is nowhere near what one would expect based on near record consumer confidence surveys.


As BofA"s Michelle Meyer writes, according to the BAC internal card data, consumer spending improved in March relative to the weak pace in February. The bank"s estimate of retail sales ex-autos, derived from the aggregated credit and debit card data, increased at a 0.4% mom seasonally adjusted pace in March - the highest print in nearly a year - even as gasoline prices declined on a seasonally adjusted basis in March. While Meyer notes that this points to "healthy growth in core control retail sales released by the Census Bureau on Friday", she cautions that "the gain may not be quite as strong given that the BAC data had been trending below the Census and was therefore due for a bounce higher."


Furthermore, the monthly pattern has been particularly noisy of late – sales fell sharply in December (-0.9%), rebounded in January (1.6%) but slipped lower in February (-0.1%). There gave been a number of “special factors” which influenced retail sales, including the timing of the Christmas and New Year’s holidays and the delay in tax refunds which likely delayed spending from February to March. Therefore
it is prudent to smooth through the wiggles – on a three-month moving basis, retail sales ex-autos are up 0.6% mom, while retail sales ex-autos are up 4.5%


And while retail sales point to a modest improvement, Meyer writes that the potential rebound is nowhere near close to matching "the dramatic improvement in consumer confidence", which is also Bank of America"s Chart of the month.



To put it into perspective, the Conference Board measure of confidence has reached the highest level since December 2000 while earlier today the University of Michigan hit highest since November of the same year. Putting 2000 in comparison, back then retail sales ex autos were running above 7% yoy and in 2007, about 4% yoy.  BofA"s take:





While we think there are fundamental reasons for higher confidence – low unemployment rate, increasing wage growth, low borrowing costs and solid stock market performance – we believe that part of the increase in confidence reflects expectations for fiscal stimulus. In our view, there is a rocky road ahead for tax reform which we believe could trigger a partial reversal in confidence. Meanwhile, we expect actual spending to continue to grow at only a moderate pace.



It also means that, as cautioned here repeatedly, the soft data has now plateaued, and is rushing to converge with the "hard" data to the downside.


Some other observations:


don"t expect a sharp rebound in northeast spending.


  • The Northeast was hit by a blizzard during the week of March 12th, dropping several feet of snow in parts of the region.

  • We can see the impact of the storm in our card data. We find that card spending in the Northeast exceeded the rest of the country in the days heading into the storm as households presumably stocked up with necessities in preparation.

  • This was offset by a meaningful drop in card activity during the storm. On balance, we estimate that the blizzard served as a very slight drag on overall spending in the month


Restaurant spending remains recessionary


  • Spending growth at restaurants has generally been on a downward trajectory, increasing only 3.2% yoy in March.

  • Part of this weakness reflects difficult year-over-year comparatives. As you can see from the month-over-month changes, spending at restaurants is still increasing on a sequential basis, but at a slower pace than last year.

  • There was also an unusual swing at the turn of the year where spending was down sharply in December but climbed higher in January. We suspect this may reflect the timing of Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve which both fell on Saturdays, therefore distorting the typical weekly spending patterns.


Finally, 4 more charts showing that whether it tracks confidence or not, the US consumer has seen far better days.


Sunday, April 2, 2017

GOP Bill Could Let Employers Access Your Genetic and Health Info

A GOP bill in Congress could give employers access to employees’ personal medical and genetic information and increase financial penalties for people who reject workplace wellness programs. [1]


House Republicans have proposed this legislation that would make it easier for companies to gather DNA and health information from employees and their families – children included – when it’s collected as part of a ‘voluntary’ workplace wellness program. Debate still remains, however, on the effectiveness of such wellness programs in general. [2]


H.R. 1313, the Preserving Employee Wellness Programs Act, was proposed by Rep. Virginia Foxx, a Republican from North Carolina and chair of the House Committee on Education and the Workforce. The bill is under review by other House committees and is awaiting review by the Senate. It has drawn the ire of numerous consumer, health, and privacy advocacy groups, as well as House Democrats.




A spokesperson for the House committee argued that “the legislation will reaffirm existing law and provide regulatory clarity so that employers can have the certainty they need to help lower health care costs for their employees.” Opponents, however, say that the bill could undermine existing laws designed to protect an individual’s personal medical information from use by employers and others. [2]


In a statement, Nancy J. Cox, Ph.D., president of The American Society of Human Genetics, said:


“We urge the Committee not to move forward with consideration of this bill. As longtime advocates of genetic privacy, we instead encourage the Committee to pursue ways to foster workplace wellness and employee health without infringing upon the civil rights afforded by ADA (Americans with Disabilities Act) and GINA (Genetic Information Nondiscrimination Act).” [2]


GINA was intended to prohibit genetic discrimination, and passed Congress with bipartisan support in 2008. Under the bill, companies can neither hire nor fire workers on genetic grounds, and GINA banned employers from asking for DNA test results. Workplace wellness programs were the exception to the rule, but the information had to be given voluntarily and only the program director, not employers, would have access. [3]



When President Obama signed the Affordable Care Act into law in 2010, employers were given the power to levy financial incentives and penalties to urge employees to participate in the supposedly voluntary programs.


As of 1 January 2017, according to Equal Employment Opportunity Commission regulations, employees who opt out of a wellness program can face penalties of up to 30% more, or even 50% more under certain conditions, for work health insurance than those who participate in the program.


Under the Republican bill, employers can demand DNA test results for employees in wellness programs, which directly conflicts with the GINA ban on forcing workers to share their results. If the bill is passed, it would mean that the GINA provisions don’t apply to wellness programs.


Cox said that, if enacted, the bill would “fundamentally undermine” GINA and ADA. [2]


In a letter to Foxx, a group of advocates, including AARP, the American Diabetes Association, the American Academy of Pediatrics, the Epilepsy Foundation, the March of Dimes, and others wrote:


“We strongly oppose any legislation that would allow employers to inquire about employees’ private genetic information or medical information unrelated to their ability to do their jobs, and to impose draconian penalties on employees who choose to keep that information private.” [1]





Sources:


[1] The New York Times


[2] Fox News


[3] Buzzfeed



Storable Food


About Julie Fidler:


Author Image
Julie Fidler is a freelance writer, legal blogger, and the author of Adventures in Holy Matrimony: For Better or the Absolute Worst. She lives in Pennsylvania with her husband and two ridiculously spoiled cats. She occasionally pontificates on her blog.

Saturday, April 1, 2017

The Divergence Between 'Hard' & 'Soft' Data Explained (And Republican Bulls Won't Like It)

Another dataset, another head-scratching disparity between ostensibly fulsome confidence and evidently sluggish activity.  While markets get whipsawed reacting to divergent hard and soft data points, the question that traders need to ask is whether this gap makes any sense.



Bloomberg"s Macro Strategist Cameron Crise may have the answer... If you"re willing to believe that survey respondents allow their political beliefs to color their answers, then it very well might.





I modeled U.S. economic growth since 1975 using the softest of the soft data releases: consumer confidence and the small business optimism survey. I omitted the ISM because it includes factual questions, i.e. are orders increasing?  The fit is actually pretty good for such a simple model, with an r-squared of 0.51.  As you can see, the model is now pretty upbeat.





I then disaggregated the data and compared the model forecast to actual economic growth for each president since Gerald Ford. The results were fascinating.


  • Under Republican presidencies, average annual growth has been 2.7%...but the model has forecast it at 3%.

  • Under Democrats, growth has been a little higher, at 2.8%...but the model has forecast growth of just 2.3%.



In fact, the model slightly underestimated growth during the Ford and Reagan years. Since George HW Bush, however, the trend is pretty pronounced: survey respondents have been optimistic relative to underlying growth for GOP presidents and pessimistic relative to growth for their Democratic counterparts.



It seems likely that at least some of the recent boost to confidence is evidence of the same phenomenon manifesting itself.  That being said, the model currently projects growth of nearly 3.5%, so even if we were to knock off the usual half a percent for a post-Reagan GOP presidency that would still imply a marked uptick over the post-crisis run rate.



Of course, achieving that growth will probably be contingent on the government enacting some of its more business-friendly campaign promises such as tax reform or deregulation. If they don"t, then the "optimism gap" may close, and not in a way that the White House might like.



Either way, traders will need to keep an eye on government policy and its implications. The efficacy of the Trump administration may not matter on a day-to-day basis for bond markets, but in the long run it probably will.



A glance at the last 20 years or so of "soft" and "hard" data also helps confirm this over-confidence... it"s the hope that pumps... then dumps... and never the reality that jumps...


Tuesday, March 21, 2017

Survey Says... Ignore The Hard Data At Your Peril

Authored by Michael Pento via PentoPort.com,


Surveys of both consumers and businesses show there is an extreme level of confidence regarding future GDP growth. Consumer confidence is now at its highest level since 2001. Small and medium-sized business owners, the driving force of growth in the economy, appear downright giddy; as the NFIB Small Business Optimism Index recently soared to its highest level since 2004.


The Philly Fed Index, a survey that gauges how well manufacturers are feeling, hit its highest level since 1984. Business leaders are betting on tax cuts, infrastructure spending and a scale-back of onerous regulations that will, hopefully, make America great again!


But just as we were beginning to get tired of all this “winning”, investors are also receiving a strong reality check from the actual hard data regarding the current state of economic activity.


The economy slowed more than expected in the fourth quarter of 2016. Gross domestic product increased at a lackluster 1.9 percent annual rate at the end of last year. For all of 2016, the economy grew only 1.6 percent, which was the weakest pace since 2011.


And despite all the good feelings about the current state of affairs, the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow model, is forecasting real GDP growth (at a seasonally adjusted annual rate) in the first quarter of 2017 to come in at a pitiful 0.9 percent.



The hype regarding the potential implementation of Trumponomics appears to be creating a trenchant gap between today’s economic reality and hope about the future.



More evidence of this gap can be found in the January Durable Goods Report, which met expectations at 1.8 percent. However, excluding aircraft, transportation equipment fell 0.2 percent, well below the estimate of a 0.2 percent gain. Core capital goods showed a 0.4 percent decline in orders. This ends 3 months of strength for this reading and dispels the hope for a first quarter business investment boom suggested by the business confidence readings.  Unfilled orders were down 0.4 percent and have now fallen in 7 of the last 8 months--the deepest contraction since the Great Recession.


And we may need to start working on that wall right away if investors are to believe that confidence surveys will catch up with reality. Construction spending fell a sharp 1.0 percent in January. The consensus was for construction spending to increase 0.6 percent.


Personal spending increased only 0.2 percent in January, one-tenth below the consensus. This brings into question whether upbeat consumers are putting their money where their mouths are. Inflation-adjusted spending fell 0.3 percent, the largest drop since September 2009.


Also, Industrial Production for the month of February registered a big fat zero percent growth rate.


And how do you explain the recent drop in the CRB Index?  An economy that is rapidly expanding should see a rise in commodity prices. However, in the week of March 6th; oil price dropped 8%, copper dropped 3.3%, and iron ore dropped 5%. This key growth index is down about 7% since the start of the year and has lost over a third of its value since 2014.


In addition, the latest data on department store and retail sales is alarming. Retail sales increased by just 0.1% in February, which was the smallest gain in the past 6 months. And Zerohedge reported that Bank of America data shows February department store sales fell about 15% yoy—the largest drop on record.


Yet despite any real evidence of actual economic growth, we have a stock market trading at all-time highs and a Fed that is determined to slam the brakes on “runaway” 0.9% growth.  The Republicans in congress are in a battle with Democrats and Libertarians over raising the debt ceiling; and they can’t seem to get out of their own way on health care and tax reform.


Hopefully, these employment and survey anecdotes are leading economic indicators that will turn out to have foreshadowed a leg up in GDP growth. Or, they could end up being the fleeting hiccups of hope in the new President that will end up sinking in the mire of D.C. politics. If the latter case proves to be correct, survey anecdotes will soon reconcile with the persistent anemic path of a sub-par and grossly-injured economy that has been beset by asset bubbles and debt.


The stock market has priced in perfection coming from the new Administration. Unless the Donald can put some tax and regulatory meat on the bones very soon, the stock market should suffer a huge fall.

Monday, March 20, 2017

El-Erian Warns Of America's CONfidence Economy

Authored by Mohamed El-Erian via Project Syndicate,


Financial markets seem convinced that the recent surge in business and consumer confidence in the US economy will soon be reflected in “hard” data, such as GDP growth, business investment, consumption, and wages. But economists and policymakers are not so sure. Whether their doubts are vindicated will matter for both the United States and the world economy.



Donald Trump’s election as US president has triggered a surge in positive economic sentiment, because he pledged that his administration would aggressively pursue the policy trifecta of deregulation, tax cuts and reform, and infrastructure construction. Republican majorities in both houses of Congress reinforced the positive sentiment, as they signaled that Trump would not face the kind of paralyzing gridlock that Barack Obama confronted for most of his presidency.


The surge in business and consumer sentiment reflects an assumption that is deeply rooted in the American psyche: that deregulation and tax cuts always unleash transformative pro-growth entrepreneurship. (To some outside the US, it is an assumption that sometimes looks a lot like blind faith.)


Of course, sentiment can go in both directions. Just as a “pro-business” stance like Trump’s can boost confidence, perhaps even excessively, the perception that a leader is “anti-business” can cause confidence to fall. Because sentiment can influence actual behavior, these shifts can have far-reaching impacts.


In his groundbreaking General Theory of Employment, Interest, and Money, John Maynard Keynes referred to “animal spirits” as “the characteristic of human nature that a large proportion of our positive activities depend on spontaneous optimism, rather than mathematical expectations, whether moral or hedonistic or economic.” Jack Welch, who led General Electric for 20 years, is a case in point: he once stated that many of his own major business decisions had come “straight from the gut,” rather than from analytical models or detailed business forecasts.


But sentiment is not always an accurate gauge of actual economic developments and prospects. As the Nobel laureate Robert J. Shiller has shown, optimism can evolve into “irrational exuberance,” whereby investors take asset valuations to levels that are divorced from economic fundamentals. They may be able to keep those valuations inflated for quite a while, but there is only so far that sentiment can take companies and economies.


So far, the exuberant reaction of markets to Trump’s victory – all US stock indices have reached multiple record highs – has not been reflected in “hard data.” Moreover, economic forecasters have made only modest upward revisions to their growth projections.



It is not surprising that equity investors have responded to the surge in animal spirits by attempting to run ahead of a possible uptick in economic performance. After all, they are in the business of anticipating developments in the real economy and the corporate sector. In any case, they believe that they can quickly reverse their portfolio positions should their expectations change.


That is not the case for companies investing in new plants and equipment, which are less likely to change their behavior until announcements begin to be translated into real policies. But the longer they wait, the weaker the stimulus to economic activity and income, and the more consumers must rely on dissaving to translate their positive sentiment into actual purchases of goods and services.


It is in this context that the economy awaits a solid timeline for policy announcements to evolve into detailed design and durable implementation. While there is often some delay when political negotiations and trade-offs are involved, in this case, the sense of uncertainty may be heightened by policy-sequencing decisions. By deciding to begin with health-care reform – an inherently complicated and highly divisive issue in US politics – the Trump administration risks losing some of the political goodwill that could be needed to carry out the kinds of fiscal reform that markets are expecting.


Even if a bump in the economic data does arrive, it may not last, unless the Trump administration advances policies that enhance longer-term productivity, through, for example, education reform, apprenticeship programs, skills training, and labor retooling. The Trump administration would also have to refrain from pursuing protectionist trade measures that would disrupt the “spaghetti bowl” of cross-border value chains for both producers and consumers.


If improved confidence in the US economy does not translate into stronger hard data, unmet expectations for economic growth and corporate earnings could cause financial-market sentiment to slump, fueling market volatility and driving down asset prices. In such a scenario, the US engine could sputter, causing the entire global economy to suffer, especially if these economic challenges prompt the Trump administration to implement protectionist measures.


The US is on relatively strong footing to achieve higher economic growth. Indeed, by animating the economy’s animal spirits, the Trump administration has laid the groundwork for the private sector to do a lot of the heavy lifting. But there is more to do. Unless the Trump administration can work well with a cooperative Congress to translate market-motivating intentions into well-calibrated actions soon, the lagging hard data risks dragging down confidence, creating headwinds that extend well beyond financial volatility.

Tuesday, March 7, 2017

US Consumer Spending Highest Since 2008 As Economic Confidence Hits Record High: Gallup

Perhaps it is the last hurrah of the Trump post-election euphoria  but according to Gallup there were two notable development in February.


First, Americans" daily self-reports of spending climbed to an average of $101 in February. This, Gallup reports, was the highest average for the month of February since 2008, when spending averaged $106. The latest monthly average is up $13 from January"s figure, but still lower than December"s holiday-influenced $105.



Gallup notes that this is the seventh daily spending average of $100 or more that Gallup has recorded for any month over nine years of tracking Americans" spending reports, and the only one in February since 2008. During that year - but before the global financial crisis in the fall - Americans" monthly average spending exceeded $100 four times.


What makes the Gallup report even more surprising were previous reports that due to a delay in the payment of Tax refunds by the US Treasury, spending would be muted in the past month. The latest data not only refutes this assumption but suggests that the outcome was just the opposite of what many had expected.


Additionally, Gallup observes that since 2008, Americans" spending in the month of February has generally been similar to their January spending, though it is common to see a slight increase in February after January"s seasonal, post-holiday drop. But the January-to-February increase in 2017 is larger than usual, with this year"s $13 bump outpacing the previous record $9 increases in 2008 and 2014.



That said, the spending spree was not uniform and was mostly thanks to wealthier consumers.  The increase in spending was slight -- to $73 from $70 in January -- among Americans living in households that earn less than $90,000 annually. The increase among higher earners was much larger. Consumers in households earning $90,000 or more annually spent significantly more in February than in January -- $168 versus $142. This $26 month-to-month increase is one of the largest Gallup has found for this group in its nine years of tracking.


U.S. Consumer Spending, by Annual Household Income


Gallup"s bottom line: Americans" views of the U.S. economy have improved markedly since Donald Trump"s election in November; and with stock market averages reaching new highs this year, they may be in a position to feel more comfortable than they have been in loosening their purse strings.


Yet while there is a distinct risk that disappointment with Trump policies could result in a sharp slowdown, while a market slump would lead to far lower spending, for now there is no wuch concern as confirm by the second notable Gallup observation, namely that economic confidence in the latest week hit an all time high: "Many Americans either gained or regained economic optimism last week, as Gallup"s U.S. Economic Confidence Index soared seven points to hit +16. This marks the highest weekly average in Gallup"s nine-year trend. The index has recovered the ground it lost over the week of Jan. 30-Feb. 5, when it fell from the previous record high of +14 to +8 and languished at that lower level for the next three weeks."



One possible catalyst for the latest surge in confidence is Trump"s February 28 address to Congress.





Last week was an eventful one for the U.S. economy. President Donald Trump gave his maiden address to Congress on Feb. 28, emphasizing his key economic policy goals such as lowering the corporate tax rate. Those who watched the speech were generally pleased with it, and traders on Wall Street were decidedly upbeat: Stock markets rallied on Wednesday, and the Dow Jones industrial average closed above 21,000 for the first time in its history. Federal Reserve Board Chair Janet Yellen also spoke favorably of current economic conditions in a speech on Friday.



Gallup admits that it is is impossible to know which of these events played the most important role in boosting Americans" confidence last week, "though it seems unlikely that Yellen"s remarks influenced the public much given her low name recognition." Trump, meanwhile, commanded a large national audience, and his speech likely helped spark the stock market"s record-setting performance the next day.


And here, another interesting twist: while one would expect Republican confidence to soar, it was Democrats who showed the largest
improvement in economic confidence from Wednesday to Sunday of last
week,
the period after Trump"s speech and the stock market rally. Over
the seven days leading up these two events (Feb. 22-28), Democrats
registered an index score of -7; for the five-day period of March 1-5,
their score rose to 0. Republicans, on the other hand, showed modest
gains; their index score rose from +45 to +48 in the same time frame.


As Democrats, by and large, disapprove
of Trump"s job performance as president, this would seem to suggest
that other factors, such as the stock market rally, may have helped
shape economic attitudes last week.


Breaking out confidence between current condition and the future outlook shows another interesting divergence: in February, one-third of U.S. adults (33%) described economic conditions as "excellent" or "good," while 20% rated them as "poor." This resulted in a current conditions score of +13 for the month -- a three-point increase from January"s score and a nine-year high for this component.


Meanwhile, opinions about the future trajectory of the economy soured last month. Less than half of U.S. adults (48%) said economic conditions were "getting better," while nearly as many (45%) said they were getting worse -- yielding a score of +3 for the economic outlook component. In January, the economic outlook component averaged +11.


Gallup U.S. Economic Confidence Index Components


Gallup"s conclusion:





Though confidence in the economy appeared to stall in the month of February after rising steadily throughout the past three months, it may have gained a second wind last week after Trump"s speech to Congress and the stock market"s strong performance.



Our take: markets continue to soar on consumer confidence, while consumer confidence - reportedly - is rising on all time highs in the stock market. This circular feedback loop, which is self-referential and illogical, works for time until eventually there is a snap (just like with the stock with the same ticker) and with the S&P now at the upper range of all Wall Street estimates, and even established organizations like the OECD warning that the market is "disconnected" from reality, the surge in confidence, and spending, may be about to come to an abrupt end, at the worst possible time for the Trump administration.

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

WTF Chart Of The Day: American Consumer Confidence Soars To 16 Year Highs As Real Wages Plunge

Continuing the trend of "soft" survey data strong performance and expectation beats, The Conference Board"s Consumer Confidence surged above the highest analyst"s expectation to 114.8 - the best print since July 2001.




Consumers’ assessment of current conditions held relatively steady in February. Those saying business conditions are “good” declined slightly from 29.0 percent to 28.7 percent, while those saying business conditions are “bad” also decreased, from 15.9 percent to 13.2 percent.


Consumers’ assessment of the labor market was also mixed. Those stating jobs are “plentiful” declined from 27.1 percent to 26.2 percent, while those claiming jobs are “hard to get” also decreased, from 21.1 percent to 20.3 percent.


Consumers were more optimistic about the short-term outlook in February. The percentage of consumers expecting business conditions to improve over the next six months increased from 22.9 percent to 24.0 percent, however those expecting business conditions to worsen also rose slightly from 10.8 percent to 11.1 percent.


Consumers’ outlook for the labor market was also moderately more upbeat. The proportion expecting more jobs in the months ahead increased from 19.7 percent to 20.4 percent, while those anticipating fewer jobs declined from 14.4 percent to 13.6 percent. The percentage of consumers expecting their incomes to increase rose marginally from 18.1 percent to 18.3 percent, while the proportion expecting a decrease declined from 9.4 percent to 8.2 percent.


We have one question for these euphoric American consumers - do you not care about wages?




As The Conference Board details...





“Consumer confidence increased in February and remains at a 15-year high (July 2001, 116.3),” said Lynn Franco, Director of Economic Indicators at The Conference Board.



“Consumers rated current business and labor market conditions more favorably this month than in January. Expectations improved regarding the short-term outlook for business, and to a lesser degree jobs and income prospects. Overall, consumers expect the economy to continue expanding in the months ahead.” 



Monday, February 20, 2017

The Week's Key Economic And Financial Events

In this holiday-shortened week, attention will be on the US FOMC minutes, housing data and consumer confidence. There will be GDP, PMI and inflation releases across the Euro Area as well as the latest Greek Eurogroup meeting. Look for GDP and public finances data in the UK. In emerging markets, there are monetary policy meetings in Brazil, Colombia, Korea and Kazakhstan.


Watch Fed minutes for more clarity on March FOMC


The minutes of the February 1st FOMC meeting are likely to reveal that Fed officials have become increasingly constructive on the outlook for the economy. There will likely be a mention of the meaningful improvement in business and consumer sentiment surveys. The FOMC is also expected to note that the labor market is likely close to full employment and that signs of underutilization have diminished. Finally, there could be some mentions of concern over "external" developments. Any discussion about the Fed"s balance sheet should also garner interest: recent comments from Fed officials suggest there being an increasing debate about the future of the Fed"s balance sheet.


Eurogroup meets on Greek economic adjustment program


Grexit is back, though as a tail risk. If all three sides insist on their red lines, the logical outcome would be Grexit. While this would likely not be in the political interest of either Greece or the creditors, markets could become nervous as we approach the July maturities (€6bn excluding bills). There is also a high risk of a snap election which initially could be market negative, but ultimately lead to a more stable government.


The week ahead in Emerging Markets


There will be monetary policy meetings in Brazil, Colombia, Korea and Kazakhstan. Brazil’s BCB is expected to cut the Selic rate by 75bp.


In other data


  • In the US, focus is largely on the Feb FOMC Minutes. Also due are home sales data along with a wide range of Fed speakers currently on schedule.

  • In the Eurozone, meaningful releases include consumer confidence and PMIs.

  • In the UK, data about public sector finances and GDP is on deck.

  • In Japan, the main data releases include trade balance and PMIs

  • In Australia, we get RBA minutes for February along with wage price index and construction data. Nothing major due from New Zealand.

A daily breakdown of key events from Deutsche Bank:


To this week’s calendar now. With the US on holiday for President’s Day (and markets subsequently closed) the data this morning is reserved for Europe where we’ll get PPI in Germany and CBI selling prices data in the UK. Euro area consumer confidence data will also be released.


Kicking things off on Tuesday will be Japan where we get the flash February manufacturing PMI. It’ll be all about the PMI’s in the European session too with flash manufacturing, services and composite readings all due. We’ll also get CPI in France and public sector net borrowing data in the UK. In the US we’ll also get the three flash PMI readings.


In the Asia session on Wednesday the lone data release is property prices data in China. Over in Germany we’ve got the IFO survey results for February as well as preliminary Q4 GDP for the UK, along with the various growth components. The final January CPI figures for the Euro area will also be watched. In the US on Wednesday the lone data is January existing home sales, while we’ll also get the FOMC minutes from the January meeting.


Thursday kicks off with more GDP data, this time the final January report in Germany while we’ll also get confidence indicators out of France. In the US data due includes initial jobless claims, FHFA house price index and Kansas City Fed’s manufacturing survey.


There’s nothing of note in Europe on Friday while in the US we’ll get new home sales and the University of Michigan consumer sentiment reading.


Away from the data the Fedspeak this week consists of Kashkari, Harker and Williams on Tuesday, Powell on Wednesday and Lockhart on Thursday. Another focus for markets will be today’s Eurogroup meeting where finance ministers are due to discuss Greece’s bailout situation. Also of note today is the House of Lords commencing a two-day debate on the draft law passed in the House of Commons with a vote due on Tuesday. BoE Governor Carney is also due to testify before UK Parliament on Tuesday.


A tabular summary of key events courtesy of SocGen



Finally, here is commentary from Goldman of all key US events, together with consensus estimates:


Monday, February 20


  • President"s Day. US markets are closed.

Tuesday, February 21


  • 08:50 AM Minneapolis Fed President Kashkari (FOMC voter) speaks:Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari will give a speech on the US economy and the role of the Federal Reserve to the Financial Planning Association of Minnesota in Golden Valley, Minnesota. Audience Q&A is expected.

  • 09:45 AM Markit Flash US Manufacturing PMI, February preliminary (consensus 55.2, last 55.0)

  • 09:45 AM Markit Flash US Services PMI, February preliminary (consensus 55.8, last 55.6)

  • 12:00 PM Philadelphia Fed President Harker (FOMC voter) speaks: Philadelphia Fed President Patrick Harker will give a speech on the economic outlook at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania. Audience and media Q&A is expected.

  • 03:30 PM San Francisco Fed President Williams (FOMC non-voter) speaks: San Francisco Fed President John Williams will give a presentation on economics to students at Boise State University.

Wednesday, February 22


  • 10:00 AM Existing home sales, January (GS +2.0%, consensus +0.9%, last -2.8%): We look for a 2.0% rebound in January existing homes sales, following last month’s 2.8% decline. Regional housing data released so far suggest sequential improvement in closed homes sales, consistent with the 1.6% rise in December pending homes sales (which represent contract signings). Existing homes sales annual revisions are also scheduled to be released. Existing home sales are an input into the brokers" commissions component of residential investment in the GDP report.

  • 01:00 PM Fed Governor Powell (FOMC voter) speaks: Federal Reserve Governor Jerome Powell will give a speech on the economic outlook and monetary policy at the Forecaster’s Club of New York’s luncheon at the Cornell Club in New York. Audience Q&A is expected.

  • 02:00 PM FOMC Minutes from the January 31-February 1 meeting: The FOMC kept policy rates unchanged at its January meeting and made few revisions to its statement, which described the economy as expanding “at a moderate pace” and characterized job growth as “solid.” In the minutes, we will look for any hints about the timing of the next hike as well as any comments about the FOMC’s evolving expectations for fiscal policy under the new administration.

Thursday, February 23


  • 08:30 AM Initial jobless claims, week ended February 18 (GS 240k, consensus 241k, last 239k); Continuing jobless claims, week ended February 11 (consensus 2,065k, last 2,076k): We expect initial jobless claims to edge up by 1k to 240k. The ongoing improvement in jobless claims provides additional evidence of underlying improvement in the pace of layoffs, and we also note the year-to-date improvement in several energy-producing states. Accordingly, we expect the pace of layoffs to remain low.

  • 09:00 AM FHFA house price index, December (last +0.5%): The FHFA house price index has a wider geographic coverage than the S&P/Case-Shiller home price index, but is based only on properties financed with conforming mortgages. On a year-over-year basis, FHFA home prices rose at a 6.1% pace in November.

  • 11:00 AM Kansas City Fed manufacturing index, February (last +9)

Friday, February 24


  • 08:35 AM Atlanta Fed President Lockhart (FOMC non-voter) speaks: Atlanta Federal President Dennis Lockhart will speak on his tenure at the Fed during the bank’s 2017 Banking Outlook Conference. President Lockhart will be officially leaving his post on February 28.

  • 10:00 AM New home sales, January (GS +9.5%, consensus +6.5%, last -10.4%): We expect new home sales to rebound 9.5% in January, mostly reversing a 10.4% drop last month that we believe was partially driven by unseasonably high snowfall in the Midwest. We expect a favorable fundamental backdrop and the elevated level of single-family building permits to mitigate the negative impact of higher mortgage rates on new homes sales activity.

  • 10:00 AM University of Michigan consumer sentiment, February final (GS 96.2, consensus 96.0, last 95.7): We expect the University of Michigan consumer sentiment index to rebound 0.5pt to 96.2 in the February final estimate, reflecting improvement among more timely measures of consumer confidence as well as the favorable stock market performance over the last two weeks. The University of Michigan’s survey of 5- to 10-year ahead inflation expectations fell 0.1pp to 2.5% in the preliminary February reading but remains above the record low of 2.3% in December. We expect this measure to remain stable or edge up in the final reading.

Source: BofA, DB, SocGen, GS

Monday, February 13, 2017

Fed Study: Fake News drives Fake Markets

Thanks Bloomberg, for another useless piece of regurgitated info we"ve known for years; fake news drives the fake markets which are artificially inflated.  Actually thanks to the Fed for doing the academic research on this topic to confirm what we"ve known for years - the markets are rigged and one way they are manipulated is by the mainstream news.  As we explain in our book Splitting Pennies - the markets are artifically inflated and manipulated by remote control (yes - that remote control.  It"s a metaphor!)  TV watchers have a "remote control" and so does the CIA.  They press "play" and markets move as they want.  Just as TV viewers change the channel the CIA changes the "mood" of the country with a few clicks of the remote.  They even have a pause button! From Bloomberg:





Buy the news and sell the soft data.  That’s the conclusion drawn from a paper by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, which suggests that financial news holds predictive power when it comes to a slew of economic data. Stories about the U.S. economy can even outperform more traditional measures such as surveys of consumer sentiment when it comes to gauging ‘‘animal spirits’’ and forecasting future activity, it found.  While trust in news sources among the general American population has fallen to historic lows amid accusations of fake news lobbed during the U.S. presidential elections, the Fed research throws cold water on the notion that the mainstream media is far removed from Main Street, if headline economic indicators are anything to go by.


“Specifically, we have shown that sentiment extracted from newspaper articles correlates with both contemporaneous and future key business cycle indicators,” economists Adam Hale Shapiro and Daniel Wilson of the San Francisco Fed concluded in a report co-written last month with Moritz Sudhof, of data analytics firm Kanjoya. “In a head-to-head comparison, these news sentiment measures perform better than both the University of Michigan and Conference board measures of consumer sentiment.”



You can read the Study here "Measuring News Sentiment" at Global Intel Hub"s library.


The paper is very well documented, an A+.  Great job.  We by no means mean to detract from the great work accomplished here by paraphrasing the paper as "fake news drives fake markets" - it simply serves as a great example of yet another proof how markets are manipulated, even if as the paper suggests - indirectly.  



To add some real Alpha to your portfolio, checkout www.alphazadvisors.com For a pocket guide designed to make you a market Genius - Checkout Splitting Pennies Understanding Forex @ www.splittingpennies.com and get a free robot - too!

Friday, February 10, 2017

Consumer Confidence Tumbles As Democrats' "Hope" Plunges Near Record Lows

After a couple of months of animal-spirit-inducing exuberance in soft-survey-hope-data, UMich consumer sentiment printed a disappointing 95.7 in Feb (versus 98.0 exp and down from 98.5 in Jan). The biggest driver was a notable drop in "hope" as Democrats Expectations plunged near record lows.



The Democrat’s Expectations Index is close to its historic low (indicating recession) and the Republican’s Expectations Index is near its historic high (indicating expansion). While currently distorted by partisanship, the best bet is that the gap will narrow to match a more moderate pace of growth. Nonetheless, it has been long known that negative rather than positive expectations are more influential in determining spending, so forecasts of consumer expenditures must take into account a higher likelihood of asymmetric downside risks.


Inflation expectations were mixed - rising in the short-term and dropping in the longer-term - which matches the markets inflation breakeven collapse...




Finally we note University of Michigan"s comments that when asked to describe any recent news that they had heard about the economy, 30% spontaneously mentioned some favorable aspect of Trump’s policies, and 29% unfavorably referred to Trump’s economic policies.


Thus a total of nearly six-in-ten consumers made a positive or negative mention of government policies. In the long history of the surveys, this total had never reached even half that amount, except for five surveys in 2013 and 2014 that were solely dominated by negative references to the debt and fiscal cliff crises.


Moreover, never before have these spontaneous references to economic policies had such a large impact on the Sentiment Index: a difference of 37 Index points between those that reported news of favorable and unfavorable policies. When the Sentiment Index was calculated by party affiliation, a nearly identical difference of 40 Index points was found between Democrats and Republicans. These differences are troublesome.


It seems the "soft" data surge is starting to fade...


Thursday, February 9, 2017

Americans Haven't Been This Positive About The US Economy Since July 2007, But...

Bloomberg"s Consumer Comfort index surged once again this week to its highest since April 2015, but it was the "state of the economy" survey that really soared - breaking to new cycle highs at 42.8 - the highest since July 2007...


The last time we saw a surge like this was the post-QE3 "well they would not have stopped QE if they didn"t know that everything was awesome" narrative...




How did that work out for them?

Tuesday, January 31, 2017

Consumer Confidence Disappoints, Drops From Trump-Fueled 16-Year Highs As Hope Fades

Having surged to its highest since August 2001 in the afterglow on Trump"s election victory, Conference Board Consumer Confidence slipped for the first time since October.




Interestingly, while "present situation" rose, hope plunged with "expectations" slumping most since Feb 2016.


Notably, fewer survey respondents believed it was a good time to buy a home, car, or major appliance.

Friday, January 27, 2017

Consumer Confidence Is The Highest In 13 Years

The final UMichigan consumer confidence print is in, and it was even higher, printing at 98.5, up from 98.2 in December, and above the 98.1 consensus estimate. This was the highest print since January 2014, or as the survey emphatically notes, "consumers expressed a higher level of confidence January than any other time in the last dozen years."



The reason for this ongoing surge in US consumer confidence, once again, continues to be Trump:





The post-election surge in confidence was driven by a more optimistic outlook for the economy and job growth during the year ahead as well as more favorable economic prospects over the next five years. Consumers also reported much more positive assessments of their current financial situation due to gains in both incomes and household wealth, and anticipated the most positive outlook for their personal finances in more than a decade.



Consumers also naively believe that the Fed"s rising rates will translate into higher savings rate; it also states that expectations of higher rates are promptly more Americans to borrow:





Consumers have become more convinced that the stronger economy would finally prompt the Fed to increase interest rates at a quicker pace, which caused one-in-five consumers to favor borrowing-in-advance of anticipated increases in mortgage rates, the highest level in more than twenty years.



This can be seen in inflation expectations, which recently hit record low, but have since rebounded from 2.2% in December to 2.6% in the final January print, and from 2.3% to 2.6% for 5 year inflation expectations.



Finally, the survey cautions that "the post-election surge in consumer confidence was based on political promises, and not, as yet, on economic outcomes. Moreover, over the past half century the surveys have never recorded as dominant an impact of partisanship on economic expectations. When the same consumers were re-interviewed from six months ago, the survey recorded extreme swings based on political party affiliation, with Democrats becoming much more pessimistic and Republicans much more optimistic. Such divergences will ultimately converge since consumers hold economic expectations."


Expect a prompt reversal once reality clashes with Trump"s yuuge promises.

Thursday, January 12, 2017

BofA Finds Consumer Spending Tumbled In December, Warns Of Disappointing Retail Sales

With this week"s most important economic data point - this Friday"s retail sales - fast approaching, economists are keen for clues if this key datapoint giving insight into the health of the US consumer will maintain the recent outsized spike in favorable and better than expected economic data, or if adversely, it may be a downward inflection point which could have significant implications on the dollar trade as RBC explained earlier. And according to BofA"s internal debit and credit card data, always released just ahead of the retail sales report, it looks like it will be the latter.


As Bank of America"s chief US economist Michelle Meyer reports, the aggregated BAC credit and debit card data showed that retail sales ex-autos declined 1.0% mom seasonally adjusted in December. "This contrasts with other indicators of consumer strength including reports of a robust holiday shopping season, a rebound in consumer confidence and strong autos sales" according to Meyer.


Actually, based on earnings reports of those companies who have recently closed their quarter, a weak December is precisely what one should expect, further corroborated by JPM"s satellite imagery at early December showing empty parking lots (recall: "Satellite Imagery Reveals Sharp Retail Spending Slowdown After The Election") and a plunge in brick and mortar sales, which has been greater than the offsetting pick up in online sales.


This is how the bank"s adjusted retail spending data looks when charted.



As BofA notes, "the BAC aggregated card data showed that retail sales exautos declined 1.0% mom SA in December. This reversed the strong gains over the prior few months, leaving the 3- month average growth rate to slow."


Amusingly, while in the past everyone ignored seasonal adjustments when it comes to retail sales (a reconciliation which as we have shown on various occasions, would always undermine the adjusted data), this time it is BofA which tries to justify the weakness with seasonal adjustments. This is how it "justifies" the sharp drop in data:





We think the explanation is that our BAC aggregated card data is biased lower due to our seasonal adjustment process. Note that the Census Bureau uses a similar approach, and therefore, we expect their data to be subject to a similar downward bias.





The two major holidays in December — Christmas and the New Year — are fixed in terms of the date but not in terms of the day of the week. This year, Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve both fell on Saturdays. Spending on those dates was much weaker than on a typical Saturday, presumably since people were enjoying the holidays. However, the seasonal adjustment process treated these days like any other Saturday. This suggests that the adjustment process “over-fits” the data and biases the seasonally adjusted figures lower.



We think the bias in December should correct in January, translating to strong growth in January. A strong gain in January would support our view that the weakness we are seeing in the data is simply “noise”. However, that means waiting until February 15th for the January data to provide confirmation.



Unless, of course, January data does not rebound, in which case that bank"s economists can simply blame the "abnormally cold weather" for the lack of spending, as they have every time over the past three years.  Even so, with that caveat in mind, BofA warns, "since the Census Bureau uses a comparable approach, we think it is prudent to prepare for a similarly negative number in Friday"s report."


And while the December, or even January, data may surprise to the up, or downside, due to quirks in seasonal adjustments, reporting, one thing is undisputable: long-term spending trends, especially when it comes to goods and products, continue to deteriorate. Here"s BofA:


  • The sector data suggests that consumers continue to spend on experiences, with airlines and lodging spending up impressively over the prior three months. Presumably, consumers are taking trips around the holidays.

  • On the flipside, consumers appear to be spending less on goods, with particular weakness in electronics spending, home goods, and clothing. As we also show in Chart 6, spending at restaurants continues to weaken.


Also, as a result of surging gasoline prices, spending at gasoline stations is rebounding but only due to nominal spending increases. Which means less disposable income available to be spent on other potential purchases. 


And here is the evidence:


Restaurant spending is tumbling



Furniture and home improvement spending has flatlined



Spending on young adult clothing has tumbled.



Spending at food and beverage stores is growing at the lowest rate in 5 years.




And finally, luxury spending - that traditionally reserves to the upper middle and higher classes- continues to crash.



So aside from all that, the consumer is doing great.

Thursday, December 29, 2016

Will Investors Get 'Hustled' By The Pros In 2017?

Submitted by Danielle DiMartino Booth via Money Strong,


It never pays to be an “afterthought.”


That was the word Jackie Gleason used to characterize the proposed reprisal of ‘Minnesota Fats’ in The Color of Money, 1986’s sequel to The Hustler. Chances are Paul Newman himself, who had at least 36 script conferences with the screenwriter, didn’t take offense to Gleason’s rebuff. “We desperately wanted the character to return,” Newman told the New York Times of Gleason’s ‘Fats,’ “but every time we put him in, it seemed like we were trying to glue an arm on a man and make it stick.”


Under the brilliant direction of Martin Scorsese, Newman would go on to win an Oscar for his role in Color. Still, as a whole, the sequel simply couldn’t stand up to the 1961 original. Hence the irony of Newman’s Oscar, which critics suggested was in belated recognition of his original performance as an ace pool player in The Hustler. In his young, glory days, Newman so deeply penetrated his characters’ roles that he literally vanished into them. His brilliance as an actor shined brightest in one scene when Eddie lost to Fats; rather than hostility or animus, his fascinated adoration for his idol was unabashedly on display, reflected in his bright eyes and amused expression. Now that’s Hollywood.


As for Wall Street, it’s recent performance has also laid the drama on thick and in perfect form as stocks pierce record highs. The investor community, the Street’s audience, couldn’t agree more. According to the latest survey from the Conference Board, retail investors’ enthusiasm for the stock market’s prospects is at the highest level since February 2007. A stroll down memory lane reveals that similar readings on the giddiness gauge were contrarian in nature, aka sell signals. That is, unless you’re referring to 1996 as a step-off point. In that case, today’s positive parallels suggest stocks’ 2017 sequel could best the original rally that culminated in the S&P 500 peaking in 2001.


What’s driving the train to stock market stardom? The singular theme since Trump was elected has been happiness bordering on euphoria. The overall December Conference Board survey hit a 15-year high. This echoed the most recent University of Michigan December survey, which hit a 12-year high. But it’s not just your average Joe on the street, as in Main Street. Small business confidence also witnessed its biggest one-month surge since 2009, while regional manufacturing surveys have uniformly topped forecasts. Based on an average of five regional Fed surveys, Morgan Stanley raised to a two-year high its expectations for the upcoming release of the national manufacturing survey.


The question is, can the economic fundamentals Trump the (over?)-heated hope? For that to happen, every bit of optimism has to be substantiated. And that supremely sublime stage has yet to be set.


The entirety of the Conference Board spike was due to expectations; current conditions, which remain high, actually fell on the month. Similarly, small business owners’ expectations for future sales rose smartly, which runs counter to actual sales, hiring and capital expenditures declining last month. And finally, one red flag that’s popped up in multiple places centers on the jobs market. While consumers’ expectations for income growth rose to the highest level in a decade, their perceptions of jobs being ‘plentiful,’ fell while those lamenting jobs were “hard to get” rose, affirming the recent drift upwards in jobless claims.


Some of the regional Fed surveys also showed employment had unexpectedly hit reverse gear, contrary to respondents’ effusive outlook for the future. Most surprising, perhaps, were the losses reported in Texas’ manufacturing sector in November; they defy the recent uptick in rig counts. Renmac’s chief economist Neil Dutta figures the number of operating rigs has surged 120 percent over the third quarter average. That puts the current number of drilling wells at the highest since January; oil maintaining its price gains implies more to come, reflected in Texas manufacturers’ outlook, which hit its highest level in 12 years. Presumably job growth will follow, according to the script, that is, and not just in the Lone Star State. Presumably.


Continuing along the contented motif, homebuilders are downright ecstatic – their optimism is ringing in the new year at the highest level since 2005. As per the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB):





“Builders are hopeful that President-elect Trump will follow through on his pledge to cut burdensome regulations that are harming small businesses and housing affordability. This is particularly important given that a recent NAHB study shows that regulatory costs for home building have increased 29 percent in the past five years.”



Potential homebuyers are also buying in to the potential for falling prices; the NAHB sub-index that measures Prospective Buyers Traffic registered its first print in expansionary territory since August 2005. There’s a good chance the cheery potential homebuyers overlap with the record number of consumers (18 percent) who the University of Michigan reported “spontaneously mentioned the expected favorable impact of Trump’s policies on the economy.” This figure is twice as high as its prior peak, recorded in 1981 as Reagan was taking office.


The teensiest of caveats before continuing – all of this rhapsody is not free; it’s been more than reflected in higher interest rates which have notably manifested themselves in the highest mortgage rates since the bond market threw a taper tantrum in the summer of 2013. Not even Yale economist Robert Shiller can predict which way the winds will blow, good or bad, as he told Bloomberg News:





“I don’t know how people react to rising mortgage rates. One thought is they want to lock in right now. And that’s why we’ve had good home sales recently. And it might continue as mortgage rates rise. This thing could feed a boom. I’m not saying it will.”



Talk about measured!


Paradoxically, households’ inflation expectations looking out five years over the horizon sank to their lowest level on record in data going back to 1979, even as businesses whine about the highest input costs in years.


If you think you’re hearing a wee bit of a mixed message emanating from households and businesses, you’re not losing your marbles. Policymakers and politicians have a heck of a lot to make good on when Congress takes to the Hill and the new administration sets foot in the White House next month.


We can all hope that breaking the gridlock and freeing businesses to conduct business the old-fashioned American way will unleash animal spirits among employers. Job creation, of a meaningful, high-income-generating sort, would thus beget consumption. This in turn would spur the best sort of economic growth we can hope for, and at the same time reflect businesses carrying through on their stated confidence with actions, by expanding their payrolls, inducing a lovely, virtuous cycle that feeds on itself. How economically endearing indeed.


Would you be surprised to discover there are a few skeptics who doubt Goldilocks is primed to whip out those golden locks, validating, well, just about everyone’s cockiness?


Though other perpendiculars have already been posited, it’s fair to interject a friendly reminder that we are not in 1982, the last time stocks were trading at a single-digit price-to-earnings multiple and Baby Boomers were less than half their age. Is it relevant that productivity growth was running at eight times its current pace with the saving rate double where it is today and household debt to income half of where it is? Wait…won’t rising rig counts cap oil prices? And does it matter that Uncle Sam’s debt load has grown to 105 percent of GDP compared to 30 percent back then? Does this country and its inhabitants technically have to have a pot that’s growing in size to piss in?


Not according to the measured volatility on the stock market, which is near the lowest in recorded history. We have nothing to worry about and that’s that. Hence the perplexing pessimism among institutional investors. The State Street Investor Confidence Index (ICI) peaked in March of this year, and after a wimpy stab at a comeback, has retreated anew.


The developers of the ICI observed that 2016 ended on a downbeat note as institutional investors continued to shun the stock market, preferring instead to wait for follow-through from the incoming administration and greater clarity on just how serious the Federal Reserve is about hiking rates in 2017.





“While markets increasingly look to be ‘priced for perfection’ over the US economic outlook for 2017, it is interesting that institutional investors are more circumspect,” said Lee Ferridge, State Street’s head of North American strategy. “Most noteworthy for me is the decline in the North American index even as US equities and the US dollar continue to rise.”



If the stars don’t align perfectly, if the sequel doesn’t best the original, smaller investors might want to wise up to the fact that they’re being hustled by the equivalent of professional gamblers. Know that they’ve been at this game for long enough to cash out their winnings while they can still be put to good use. What’s the alternative? That would be investors finding themselves in naïve form, as Fast Eddie did, just before he lost to Minnesota Fats, asking, “How can I lose?