Showing posts with label Conference Board. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Conference Board. Show all posts

Tuesday, November 28, 2017

In The Past 50 Years, Americans Have Seldom Been "More Confident" Than Today

The Conference Board"s survey of Americans" Consumer Confidence surged to its highest since November 2000 in November, with both current and furture expectations spiking.


In th epast 50 years, Americans have - apparently - seldom been more confident than they are now...



Does that sound right?


Additionally, confidence in a soaring stock market is back near record highs...










Friday, July 7, 2017

June Payrolls Preview: With The Fed On Autopilot, You Can Skip This One

After a poor March jobs report, followed by an April scorcher, then another debacle in May, the June payrolls report due at 8:30am will be... very much irrelevant, because as Citi pointed out earlier, the Fed is now data-independent and will keep hiking until financial conditions finally tighten (read: stocks drop). In other words, with the Fed on autopilot, feel free to skip this one - it hardly matters. For what it"s worth, here are the consensus expectations for tomorrow"s report:


  • June Nonfarm Payrolls Exp. 179K vs May 138K

  • Unemployment Rate Exp. 4.3% vs May 4.3%

  • Average Hourly Earnings M/M Exp. 0.3%, vs May 0.2%; Y/Y Exp. 2.60%, vs May 2.50%

Courtesy of RanSquawk, here is a detailed breakdown of expectations:


HEADLINE NFP: Analysts expect 179k nonfarm payrolls will be added to the US economy in June, against 138k added in May. Headline payroll growth has eased: The three-month rolling-average of the headline is running at a 121k clip, the slowest since July 2012, suggesting the pace of slack erosion is easing.


  • Analysts at Barclays, who are more-or-less in line with the consensus view, write “factors influencing our forecast include initial claims, which continue to point to low rates of job separation, and the timing of the survey week in May.” The bank says claims have been pointing toward stronger payroll growth for some time too, but add that “in the other direction are calendar-day effects that we believe held back reported employment last month.”

JOBLESS RATE: The unemployment rate is seen steady at 4.3%; the FOMC has forecast that the jobless rate will end-2017 at that level, while it recently cut its projection of NAIRU (non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment) to between 4.5-4.8%; in June 2016, that estimate stood at between 4.7-5.0%. Given that the jobless rate is beneath the NAIRU estimate, many are once again focusing on the U6 measure of unemployment, which was running at 8.4% in May.


WAGE GROWTH: Given that the labor market supposedly is tight, and the path of monetary policy is contingent on the progress of inflation, attention will be on the gauges of wage growth. The consensus view looks for average hourly earnings Y/Y to decrease to 2.6% from 2.5%, but the M/M measure is seen rising by 0.1ppts to 0.3% due to calendar effects.


  • Analysts at CitiFX suggest that the USD is most sensitive to surprises on wages. But the bank notes that “a strong wage print would still not allay concerns on inflation where shelter, healthcare and apparel have represented a bigger drag than expected,” but add “a stronger wage print would strengthen conviction however that slack has been exhausted and potential growth is falling.”

  • The market pricing of interest rate hikes is more pessimistic than the FOMC’s projections, with the former pricing in three hikes through 2019 versus the Fed’s forecast looking for seven. One theory explaining this discrepancy is that the Fed’s longer-term projection of the Federal Fund rate around 3% is too optimistic, and a lack of growth in the medium term may mean that the peak in the cycle is lower than its projection. Another part of this is that with weak inflationary pressures, there isn’t much reason for rates to jump higher. Accordingly, inflation data, as gauged by PCE, core PCE, CPI and wage growth, will be key in shaping expectations of inflation, and thus the trajectory of Fed policy.

* * *


Goldman"s summary:





We estimate nonfarm payrolls rose 180k in June, following a 138k increase in May and compared to three- and six-month moving averages of 121k and 161k, respectively. Labor market fundamentals were mixed in June. While business employment surveys remained at strong levels and the Conference Board’s labor market differential rose to a new cycle high, initial jobless claims drifted higher and continuing claims increased for five consecutive weeks. In terms of one-off effects, we expect payroll growth to benefit from the arrival of students and recent graduates into the labor force, following a pronounced drop in youth participation rates in May likely caused by the timing of the survey week. While this would suggest scope for reacceleration in payroll growth, it would also suggest upward pressure on the unemployment rate, as students begin their summer job searches. While we expect the unemployment rate to remain stable at 4.3%, we note potential upside risks accordingly.



On wages, Goldman is optimistic this time, mostly due to a favorable calendar effects;





We estimate average hourly earnings increased 0.3% month over month and 2.6% year over year in June, reflecting the interaction of firming wage growth with somewhat favorable calendar effects. We view the risks to the year-over-year number as skewed to the upside. The June payroll period ended on the 17th, which in our model is associated with somewhat above-average wage growth, and we are constructive on wage growth more generally, exemplified by the acceleration in the employment cost index to a cycle-high pace in Q1.



Factors arguing for a stronger report:


  • Youth Employment Rebound. We believe some of the May weakness in both payrolls and labor force participation reflected the timing of student summer hiring. Details of the household survey show that job growth and participation were particularly weak among young people: despite representing less than 15% of the workforce, 16-24-year-olds drove three fifths of the overall drop in household employment (-158k of -252k, mom sa) and three quarters of the drop in the labor force (-306k of -419k). As a result, the unemployment rate among this segment declined sharply to its lowest level in nearly 50 years (-0.6pp to 8.8%). In contrast, unemployment rates were stable among respondents 25 years and older. We suspect the relatively early May survey week may have contributed here. As shown in Exhibit 1, the size of the youth labor force is relatively volatile and mean-reverting, and sharp moves in May tend to reverse in June (correlation of -0.60 in May/June since 1990). The same relationship holds for youth monthly employment growth in those months (correlation of -0.49). The unwinding of these effects suggests scope for accelerating job growth (in both the household and establishment survey) and potentially upward pressure on the unemployment rate (reflecting a possible rebound in labor force participation).

Exhibit 1: Youth Labor Force Entry Should Put Upward Pressure on Payrolls


  • Manufacturing sector surveys. Employment components of manufacturing sector surveys were generally encouraging on net in June. The ISM manufacturing employment component improved for a second month (+3.7pt to 57.2), and both the Dallas Fed and Kansas City Fed employment subindices also moved higher. However, the Philly Fed, NY Fed, Richmond Fed, Chicago Fed and Markit PMI employment components all fell in June. Our overall manufacturing employment tracker edged higher by 0.3pt to 56.0. Manufacturing payroll employment edged down 1k in May, its first outright decline in seven months, and has increased 12k on average over the last six months.

  • Service sector surveys. Service-sector employment surveys have been mixed in June but remained at generally high levels, with the ISM non-manufacturing survey falling to 55.8 in June (from a one year high of 57.8 in May). Our overall non-manufacturing employment tracker increased 0.7pt to 54.8 in June, with gains in the Philly Fed and Dallas Fed employment subindices but deterioration in the New York Fed and Richmond Fed measures. Encouragingly, the key labor market subcomponent of the Consumer Confidence report strengthened 3.1pt to 14.8, a 16-year high. Service sector payroll employment grew 131k in May and has increased 122k on average over the last six months.

Factors arguing for a weaker report:


  • Jobless claims. Initial claims for unemployment insurance benefits rebounded somewhat, averaging 243k during the five weeks between the May and June payroll survey periods, up from a cycle low of 241k on average during the prior-month period. Additionally, continuing claims rose by 21k from survey week to survey week and have now risen for five consecutive weeks.

  • Continued retail weakness. Retail employment growth has fallen from its historical trend of 15-20k per month to -20k on average over the past four months. We believe the structural shift of retail sales from brick and mortar stores toward less labor-intensive e-commerce firms will continue to weigh on payrolls growth in that industry, with the impact on the order of 10k per month relative to its previous trend. This drag on retail employment has appeared particularly pronounced recently, and we note the possibility that weak brick and mortar sales trends this year may be accelerating the pace of this structural shift.

Neutral Factors:


  • ADP. The payroll processing firm ADP reported a 158k increase in private payroll employment in June – below consensus expectations and its slowest pace of the year. However, we believe that some of the sequential softness in the report likely reflected weakness in the financial and economic indicators also used in the ADP model, making it difficult to tease out the underlying signal regarding the pace of job growth. Exhibit 2 shows the relationship between ADP surprises (vs. consensus based on first-reported ADP) and non-farm payrolls surprises, which appears rather limited outside of large surprises.

Exhibit 2: Limited Relationship between ADP and Payrolls, but Don’t Completely Ignore Large ADP Surprises


  • Labor supply constraints. We view the labor market as close to full employment, and as slack diminishes further, this should exert both upward pressure on wages and downward pressure on job growth. However, labor supply constraints historically appear less binding in June, perhaps reflecting the entry of students and recent graduates into the labor force. As shown in Exhibit 3, in years with relatively tight labor markets, payroll growth tends to slow during the spring but then reaccelerate in June/July. One potential driver of this June reacceleration is that firms may hire more graduates and students on summer vacation if they had difficulty filling positions earlier in the year.

Exhibit 3: Labor Supply Constraints Are Historically Less Binding in June


  • Job availability. The Conference Board’s Help Wanted Online (HWOL) report showed a 1.0% pullback in June online job postings following May’s 4.2% increase. However, we continue to place limited weight on this indicator at the moment, in light of research by Fed economists that suggests the HWOL ad count has been depressed by higher prices for online job ads.

  • Job cuts. Announced layoffs reported by Challenger, Gray & Christmas after our seasonal adjustment declined modestly (-5k to 35k), near the middle of its recent range. On a year-over-year basis, announced job cuts declined by 8k.

  • Seasonals. Since 2010, June payroll growth has surprised positively relative to consensus in four of the seven instances with an average surprise of +14k. We don’t view this as compelling evidence of a systematic bias in June.

* * *


Other Labor Market Considerations:


CLAIMS: On a four-week moving average basis, initial jobless claims are at 243k going into June’s employment situation report; though that is technically a touch higher than the 239.75k four-week moving average heading into May’s employment report, it is essentially flat, and stable. Continuing claims have, however, edged up on the four-week moving average basis to 1.944mln from 1.918mln before the previous NFP report.


ADP: The ADP reported 158k payrolls were added to the US economy in June; analysts had expected a print of 185k versus the prior (downwardly revised) 230k. However, the report is “very likely to understate the official payroll number,” write analysts at Pantheon Macroeconomics. Pantheon explains that “ADP"s number is generated from a model which includes lagged official payroll numbers, so the soft May number, 147K for private payrolls, has pulled down today"s ADP”. It adds that May"s official number was hit be a seasonal adjustment issues, which likely won"t reverse in full in June, but definitely will not be repeated. “Payrolls should therefore revert to the trend implied by a host of survey data, at least.”


JOB CUTS: US employers announced intentions to trim payrolls by 31,105 jobs in June, Challenger reported, which is the lowest monthly total in 2017, 6% lower than May’s number, and 19% lower than June 2016. The consultancy also reported that job cuts had declined 28% in the first half of the year. “The pace of job cutting is significantly slower compared to the first half of last year,” Challenger said, adding “in a tight labour market, it’s no surprise companies are holding on to their existing workforces. Companies are also waiting to see how proposed regulations from the Trump administration may impact business going forward.”


BUSINESS SURVEYS: The non-manufacturing ISM report indicated a slight easing in labour market conditions, with the employment sub-index falling by 2 points to 55.8, though the measure has been in expansion (above 50) for 40 consecutive months. Markit, another survey compiler, noted that in its own services PMI, employment growth remained strong in June, with the pace of job creation at the fastest since February. The manufacturing ISM, meanwhile, reported an acceleration in labour market conditions, with the employment sub-index rising by 3.7 points to 57.2 to print the ninth straight month in expansion.

Friday, June 2, 2017

May Payrolls Preview: The Tiebreaker

After a poor March jobs report, followed by an April scorcher, the May payrolls report due at 8:30am on Friday will be the tiebreaker, not only for the current state of the economy where both soft and hard data have been deteriorating in recent weeks, but perhaps also for the June rate hike decision, which as the Fed noted in its May FOMC minutes, may not take place without "evidence" that the recent "transitory weakness" in the economy is over. Here are the consensus expectations for tomorrow"s report:


  • May Nonfarm Payrolls Exp. 185K (Range 140K to 235K) vs April 211K

  • Unemployment Rate Exp. 4.4% (Range 4.30%-4.60%) vs April 4.4%

  • Average Hourly Earnings M/M Exp. 0.20%, vs April 0.30%; Y/Y Exp. 2.60%, vs April 2.50%

Payrolls Expectation


In terms of overall expectations, the consensus is looking for 185k nonfarm payrolls to be added to the US economy in May - the same as the April consensus - compared to 211k actual jobs added in April. That according to RanSquawk would be in line with the 185k/month pace seen in 2017 thus far. On one hand, there is potential for upside surprise, as per today"s stellar ADP report which came in at 253K, far above the 185K expected. On the other, Goldman believes a favorable swing in the weather between the March and April survey periods boosted last month"s hiring pace, and suggests the 211k pace of April job growth "likely overstates the near-term underlying trend", as such there will be payback in the May report. Also, Goldman cautions that the ADP measure has been running above official private payroll growth so far this year, by 60k per month on average, so take it with a grain of salt.


Unemployment rate


The unemployment rate is forecast to hold steady at 4.40%, matching the lowest reading recorded since 2001, and beneath the FOMC’s NAIRU projection between 4.70% and 5.00% (made in its March forecasts). A 4.4% print would be stronger than the Fed’s own year end forecast of 4.50%. If May unemployment stays at or near that level, it would be further evidence the economy has reached full employment and is at full capacity, meaning virtually everyone seeking work has found a job, even if that doesn"t explain why wage growth remains anemics. If the rate dips lower, that could put upward pressure on wages and inflation, or alternatively it will prompt questions about the quality of jobs added.


Earnings


As a result, most of the attention is likely to fall on the earnings data for signs of inflationary pressures. Average hourly earnings (AHE) are seen rising by 0.20% M/M, easing a touch from the +0.30% pace seen in April. On an annualised basis, the pace of AHE growth is seen rising by 0.10 ppts to 2.60%. In its latest Beige Book, the Fed stated that “most firms across the districts noted little change to the recent trend of modest to moderate wage growth,” though many firms reported offering higher wages to attract workers “where shortages were most severe.”  According to RanSquawk, HSBC notes that though wage growth has picked up, as of late, it remains sluggish when compared to previous cycles. Looking at the May wage number in particular, Goldman warns there may be a negative surprise pointing out that the May payroll period ended on the 13th, which is associated with meaningfully below-average wage growth.


Goldman"s summary:





We estimate nonfarm payrolls increased 170k in May, a moderate slowdown from April’s +211k pace and modestly below the three-month moving average of +174k. While labor market fundamentals remained broadly stable – featuring a further decline in continuing jobless claims – recent deterioration in service sector employment surveys suggests hiring may be slowing at the margin. We also believe a favorable swing in the weather between the March and April survey periods suggests the 211k pace of April job growth likely overstates the near-term underlying trend, which we believe is closer to 175k (and should slow further as the economy moves beyond full employment). Relatedly, May is also an important hiring month, and labor supply constraints in some geographies and industries suggest some additional downside risk. On the positive side, both jobless claims and the ADP report suggest more favorable labor market fundamentals, and the end of the federal hiring freeze suggests scope for above-trend growth in federal employment.



On wages, Goldman warns there may be disappointment:





We estimate average hourly earnings increased 0.2% month over month and 2.5% year over year in May, reflecting the interaction of firming wage growth with negative calendar effects. The May payroll period ended on the 13th, which in our model is associated with meaningfully below-average wage growth. However, we are more constructive on wage growth generally, exemplified by the acceleration in the  employment cost index to a cycle-high pace in Q1.



Factors arguing for a stronger report:


  • Jobless claims. Initial claims for unemployment insurance benefits declined, averaging 241k during the four weeks between the April and May payroll survey  periods, a new cycle low. Additionally, continuing claims dropped by an encouraging 63k from survey week to survey week, roughly the same pace as in the prior month.

  • ADP. The payroll processing firm ADP reported a 253k increase in private payroll employment in April – above consensus expectations – suggesting a solid underlying pace of job growth. The ADP measure has been running above official private payroll growth so far this year (by 60k per month on average), and we believe the May ADP reading received a boost from the net strength in the financial and economic indicators also used in their model. These considerations make the task of teasing out the underlying signal from the report more difficult.

  • End of federal hiring freeze. The administration’s hiring freeze n for federal workers (excluding defense and public safety) went into effect on January 23 and concluded on April 11 – the Tuesday of the April survey week. Its impact on overall payrolls appears fairly limited, with average monthly payroll growth in these categories slowing from +3k in 2016 to -4k during the three months of the freeze. The impact also seems minor when compared to federal job growth during the 1981 federal hiring freeze at the start of the Reagan administration (see Exhibit 2). Assuming the 2016 trend in labor demand growth continued this year, the cumulative impact of the 2017 freeze was approximately -20k (on the level of federal payrolls). Accordingly, we see some scope for an above-trend reading in tomorrow’s report,  reflecting pent-up labor demand (we assume +10k for total government payrolls).

Arguing for a weaker report:


  • Service sector surveys. Service-sector employment surveys n have deteriorated somewhat in recent months, with the ISM non-manufacturing survey falling to 51.4 in April (from its recent high of 55.2 in February) and available May surveys weakening on net. Our overall non-manufacturing employment tracker fell to 53.4 in May from 54.4 in April, with declines in the Philly Fed and Richmond Fed employment subindices but improvement in the New York Fed and Dallas Fed measures. More encouragingly, the key labor market subcomponent of the Consumer Confidence report remained strong, rebounding 0.8pt to 11.7, not far from its cycle-high reading. Service sector payroll employment grew 173k in April and has increased 129k on average over the last six months.

  • Labor supply constraints. We view the labor market as close to full employment, with the unemployment rate roughly 0.3pp below its structural rate and yesterday’s Beige Book referencing increased reports of labor supply constraints. As slack diminishes further, this should exert both upward pressure on wages and downward pressure on job growth. From a hiring perspective, May is a particularly important month, with non-seasonally adjusted payroll growth averaging 838k over the last five May reports. As shown in Exhibit 3, we find that payroll growth tends to slow during late spring in years with relatively tight labor markets, as defined by an above-median Q1 employment gap (i.e. 2017).1. Labor constraints appear particularly binding in May (and August) in these years. One potential explanation is that the May payroll  period occurs after much of the start-of-year seasonal slack has been wound down (earlier in the Spring hiring season) but before the entry of students and recent graduates into the labor force (in late May and June).


  • Continued retail weakness. Retail employment growth has fallen n from its historical trend of 15-20k per month to -2k on average over the past six months. We believe the structural shift of retail sales from brick and mortar stores toward less labor-intensive e-commerce firms will continue to weigh on payrolls growth in that industry, with the impact on the order of 10k per month relative to its previous trend. This drag on retail employment has appeared particularly pronounced recently – with a 50k cumulative drop in retail payrolls over the last three months – and we note the possibility that weak brick and mortar sales trends in Q1 may be accelerating the pace of this structural shift. Similarly, we note the possibility that the weakness in April home sales and housing construction may have weighed on hiring in that industry.

  • Seasonals. Since 2010, May payroll growth has surprised negatively relative to consensus in four of the seven instances. While this is only slightly more than half the time, the average surprise has been fairly sizeable at -50k over this period. This may suggest downside risk to the extent the BLS seasonal factors have not fully evolved to reflect this tendency.

  • Job cuts. Announced layoffs reported by Challenger, Gray & Christmas after our seasonal adjustment rose sharply (+28k to 59k, a one-year high). Over half of the increase reflects a 20k layoff announcement at Ford Motor that was announced after the May payroll survey period. After taking into this account, the increase in May job cuts was more modest

Neutral Factors:


  • Return to Normal Weather. We believe the early-March winter storms likely exerted a meaningful drag on March payroll growth and provided a boost to April. Winter Storm Stella hit the Midwest and East Coast at the beginning of the March survey week, with the level of population-weighted snowfall during a March survey week at its highest since at least 2005. This suggests the April employment report may have benefitted from workers in the establishment survey returning to their jobs in some industries. Our preferred aggregate of weather-sensitive industries (construction, retail, and leisure and hospitality) also rebounded, to +66k from -17k in March. Accordingly, we believe headline job growth in April likely overstates the near-term trend, suggesting scope for moderation in May.

  • Manufacturing sector surveys. Employment components of manufacturing n sector surveys were mixed in May, with improvement in the ISM manufacturing employment component (+1.5 to 53.5), but deterioration in several regional surveys, including the Philly Fed, New York Fed, and Dallas Fed employment components as well as the Markit PMI subindex. Our overall manufacturing employment tracker pulled back to 0.6pt to 55.7, still a healthy level. Manufacturing payroll employment rose 6k in April, its fifth consecutive increase, and has increased 12k on average over the last six months.

  • Job availability. The Conference Board’s Help Wanted Online (HWOL) report showed a rebound in May online job postings (+4%) following April’s 1% pullback. However, we continue to place limited weight on this indicator at the moment, in light of research by Fed economists that suggests the HWOL ad count has been depressed by higher prices for online job ads.

* * *


Other observations:


Impact on Fed policy:


  • With the implied probability of a June hike at around 96%, it would likely take a horrific report to stop the Fed from lifting rates by 25bps. With the rate of joblessness below the Fed’s estimate of NAIRU, as well as its end-2017 target, it would likely look through a big headline miss, so long as wages don’t collapse.

  • Many Fed speakers have been paying particularly close attention to wages, observing that they have been a notable weakness.

  • Fed’s Kashkari (voter, dove) last month said there may be more slack in the labour market, arguing that stronger wage growth may pull more people back into the labour market, helping participation to rise.

  • Fed’s Evans (voter, dove) points out that across the board wage growth has not proceeded as quickly as the Fed would have thought. A sentiment that has also been touched on by the Fed’s Kaplan (voter, slightly hawkish) too.

  • Fed’s Williams (non-voter, centrist) went further, and described wages as “stubbornly soft.”

  • In terms of Fed hikes, even if wages missed, it may still not be enough to derail the Fed’s hike plans. Pantheon Macroeconomics has argued that in the previous cycle, the Fed lifted rates when AHE were running at 2.60% Y/Y, and it then accelerated sharply to 4.00% within five quarters.

  • Given rate changes operate with a four/five quarter lag, Pantheon says the Fed will be aware of the dangers of leaving it too late to raise rates.

Possible market reaction


  • The market is pricing in just one full hike in 2017, with the implied probability of two hikes slightly better than a coin flip.

  • An upside surprise in the Employment Situation Report may contribute to a repricing where the market converges towards the Fed’s forecasts, though with clear doubts about whether inflation can sustainably pick-up towards the Fed’s inflation goal (PCE has been easing as of late), it is unlikely the market and Fed’s view will converge.

  • Given past market reactions, a likely expression to an upside surprise may be a flattening of 2s10s, a sell-off in the long-end, which could help to lift the dollar.

  • Stocks are almost guaranteed to go up no matter the actual data.

Thursday, June 1, 2017

Canada Unveils $650 Million Lumber Industry 'Bailout' "To Stand Up To US"

Canada"s Natural Resources Minister Jim Carr just announced C$867 million (around $650 million) in financial supports for softwood lumber producers and the communities where they are based...“Canada is standing up to the U.S., Canada is standing up for Canadians.”



On Wednesday, the Conference Board of Canada released a report saying Canadian softwood producers would pay $1.7 billion in duties a year and cut 2,200 jobs and $700 million in U.S. exports over the next two years before the dispute is settled.


And perhaps on the basis of that report, as Canadian Press reports, the package includes loans and loan guarantees to help cushion the blow for forestry companies and to help them exploring new markets and innovations.





Package includes up to C$605 million in loans and loan guarantees for companies, C$45 million to reach new markets, C$118 million in innovation funding for firms, C$9.5 million funding for those who lose jobs, C$80 million in training, C$10 million for indigenous resource development.



The help includes C$260 million to help diversify the market base for Canadian lumber products, improve the efficiency of indigenous forestry initiatives and extend work-sharing agreement limits to minimize layoffs.



The money also includes measures to support workers who want to upgrade their skills and transition to a different industry.



Cabinet discussed the options for a package last month, but the federal government wanted more input from the provinces via the special working group Carr established in February.



Notably, the government has been careful to characterize the money as a support package, not a bailout, in order to avoid running further afoul of protectionist forces in the United States.


Remember how everyone screamed at Trump that this would send Lumber prices soaring, crush homebuilder margins, send housing costs through the roof? Well...


Friday, May 5, 2017

April Payrolls Preview: "It Better Be Good"

After the abysmal March labor report, all we - and the Fed - can say is that April better be good, or else Yellen"s claim of "transitory weakness" will simply be the latest nail in the coffin of Fed credibility. Here is the consensus for the key numbers the BLS will report at 8:30am ET on Friday morning.


  • March Nonfarm Payrolls Exp. 185K, (Prey. 98K, Feb. 235K) US Unemployment Rate (Mar) M/M Exp. 4.6% (Prey. 4.5%, Feb. 4.7%)

  • Average Hourly Earnings Exp. 0.30% (Prey. 0.20%, Feb. 0.20%)

Payrolls Expectation by Bank:


  • Barclays: +225K,

  • Bank of America: +170K,

  • Goldman Sachs: +200K,

  • SocGen: 165K,

  • UBS: +210K,

  • Wells Fargo:+178K,

Big Picture: Friday’s non-farm payrolls release follows Wednesday’s FOMC meeting where the Fed, as expected, kept rates on hold with all eyes now on June’s decision. One key takeaway from this week’s decision was the Fed noting the labour market conditions continuing to strengthen as growth slowed, as it deemed that job gains had been solid despite March’s softer than expected labor market report and quasi-recessionary Q1 GDP. The Fed’s statement was devoid of any real negatives and has led to Fed Fund futures pricing in a near 80% chance of a 25bps hike at its June meeting.


As RanSquawk notes, the expectation for a headline print of 185K points to a solid bounce-back from last month’s 98K, with the possibility of an upward revision to last month’s release as many analysts have attributed the weakness to negative payback following a late Easter holiday and an unusually warm winter in the US. However, the unemployment rate is expected to tick up to 4.6% from 4.5%, with many suggesting that last month’s fall was a result of sampling noise.


Goldman is even more optimistic than the consensus, and estimates payrolls increased by 200k in April, a sharp acceleration from March’s +98k pace and above the three-month moving average of +178k. It sees labor market fundamentals remaining encouraging on the whole, as April exhibited a further decline in initial jobless claims, improvement in regional service sector employment surveys, and an elevated labor market differential reported by the Conference Board. Continuing claims also fell sharply from survey week to survey week, dropping at their fastest pace in two years (-64k). Additionally, Goldman believes a favorable swing in the weather –reflecting mainly the timing of Winter Storm Stella during the March survey week – is likely to boost April job growth by roughly 25-40k relative to trend.


On the negative side, the bank believes the trend in retail employment growth is now slowing, reflecting the weaker brick-and-mortar sales trends and a continued shift towards less labor-intensive e-commerce firms. We also expect minor drags on job growth from the tail end of the federal hiring freeze and from a telecom strike that continued into the survey week (a -2k impact).


Goldman"s summary:





We estimate the unemployment rate remained stable at 4.5% in April following the one tenth drop in March (to 4.496% unrounded). The pace of employment growth picked up sharply in the household survey to start the year, with 1.4 million cumulative jobs added over the past three months (adjusted for the impact of the January population controls). Offsetting this improvement, the participation rate also moved higher, rising three tenths over the same period to 63.0%. While the risks to our unemployment rate forecast are likely skewed to the upside (given the possibility of mean-reversion), our base case expectation is that the rate continues to round to 4.5%.



Finally, we expect average hourly earnings to increase 0.3% month over month and 2.7% year over year, reflecting the interaction of firming wage growth with positive calendar effects. The April payroll period ended on the 15th, which in our model, is associated with above-average wage growth. Additionally, we believe the acceleration in the employment cost index to a cycle-high pace in Q1 provides additional evidence of firming underlying wage growth.



Recent Data: Wednesday’s ADP employment report showed another sign of steady growth, coming in at 177K vs. the expected
175K. Despite last month’s lack of correlation, the private employment figures tend to give an indication of the
headline figure when viewed over a longer horizon. April’s soft data (The Markit and ISM PMIs) point to a slowing in
hiring, although all the surveys’ employment sub-indices remained in expansionary territory, with all the headline
releases strong.


Factors arguing for a stronger report (per Goldman):


Weather rebound. We believe the winter storms in early March likely exerted a meaningful drag on payroll growth in the last report, as Winter Storm Stella hit the Midwest and East Coast at the beginning of the March survey week. The level of population-weighted snowfall during a March survey week was at its highest since at least 2005, and similarly, the month-to-month drop in April survey week snowfall is also the largest over that period. Accordingly, we expect April payrolls growth to benefit, as swings of this magnitude have historically been associated with meaningful acceleration in weather-sensitive payroll categories, such as construction, retail, and leisure and hospitality (Exhibit 1).


Exhibit 1: Weather Likely Shifting from a Drag on March Payroll Growth to a Boost in April

Source: National Centers for Environmental Information, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Bureau of Labor Statistics, Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research


Regional granularity also suggests a meaningful drag from weather in the March employment report. Overall payroll growth in New England, Mid-Atlantic, and East North Central regions swung from +102k in February to -52k in March (compared to a 2016 average pace of +47k), likely reflecting unusually snowy March weather and some payback from the relatively warm February. Weather-sensitive industries in the regions contributed the majority of the March deceleration. One additional consideration is that the effects of Winter Storm Stella appear to have lingered throughout the March survey week in many populated areas. As a point of comparison, the snow produced by the January storms in the South – which did not appear to materially affect payrolls – had largely melted away by the Tuesday of that survey week. This suggests scope for the April employment report to benefit from workers in the establishment survey returning to their jobs. Taken together, our base case expectations assume that weather will boost April payrolls growth relative to the underlying trend by between 25k and 40k.


Jobless claims. Initial claims for unemployment insurance benefits declined, averaging 243k during the four weeks between the March and April payroll survey periods, a new cycle low. Additionally, continuing claims dropped by 65k from survey week to survey week, their largest decline over such a period since April 2015.


Service sector surveys. Despite declines in some of the service-sector employment surveys, our overall non-manufacturing employment tracker improved in April (to 54.5 from 53.7), and all of its components remained in expansionary territory. The ISM non-manufacturing (-0.2pt to 51.4), New York Fed (-5.2pt to +8.5, SA by GS), Dallas Fed (-3.6pt to +4.5), and Markit PMI Services employment components softened. However, this was more than offset by a sharp rise in the Philly Fed subindex (+9.2pt to +26.4) and further improvement in the Richmond Fed employment component (+4pt to +21). The key labor market subcomponent of the Consumer Confidence report also remained strong, edging down by 1.1 from the cycle-high reading in March to 11.7. Service sector payroll employment grew 61k in March and has increased 121k on average over the last six months.


Job cuts. Announced layoffs reported by Challenger, Gray & Christmas after our seasonal adjustment fell by 15k to 31k in April, a six-month low.


Arguing for a weaker report:


Continued retail weakness. Retail employment growth has fallen from its historical trend of 15-20k per month to -5k on average over the past six months. While some of the March weakness was likely weather-related, we expect the structural shift of retail sales from brick and mortar stores toward less labor-intensive e-commerce firms will continue to weigh on payroll growth in that industry, with the impact on the order of 10k per month relative to its previous trend. This drag on retail employment has appeared particularly pronounced recently – with a 61k cumulative drop in retail payrolls over the last two months – and we note the possibility that weak brick and mortar sales trends in Q1 may be accelerating the pace of this structural shift.


Exhibit 2: Shift Towards Online Retail Could Reduce Overall Job Growth by Roughly 10k per Month

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research


Federal hiring freeze. The administration’s hiring freeze for federal workers (excluding defense and public safety) went into effect on January 23 and concluded on April 11 – the Tuesday of the April survey week. So far, its impact appears quite limited, with federal payrolls down negligibly in February and March (mom sa). As shown in Exhibit 3, the impact also seems minor in the context of federal job growth during the 1981 federal hiring freeze at the start of the Reagan administration (Exhibit 3). Thus far, government departments may have been able to offset the hiring freeze through reduced attrition or increased contracted hiring. Accordingly, we expect a minimal drag from the final month of the freeze and are assuming a flat reading for total government payrolls in tomorrow’s report.


Exhibit 3: Federal Hiring Freeze Exerting Minimal Impact on Payrolls So Far

Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research


Telecom strike. The April employment report coincided with a strike of 2k workers in the wired telecom subindustry, which is set to reduce payroll growth in the information sector by 2k this month.


Neutral Factors:


Manufacturing sector surveys. Employment components of manufacturing sector surveys were mixed in April but all remained in expansion territory. The ISM manufacturing employment component fell 6.9 points to 52.0 after reaching its highest level since mid-2011 in the March report. The Richmond Fed (-15pt to +5) and Kansas City Fed (-4pt to +9) employment subindices also declined. In contrast, the Empire State (+5.1 to +13.9), Philly Fed (+2.4pt to +19.9), Dallas Fed (+0.1pt to +8.5) and Chicago PMI employment components all improved. Manufacturing payroll employment rose 11k in April, its fourth consecutive increase, and has increased 10k on average over the last six months.


ADP. The payroll processing firm ADP reported a 177k increase in private payroll employment in April – about as expected – suggesting a stable underlying pace of job growth. The ADP measure overshot considerably to the upside relative to BLS private payroll growth in March (+255k vs. +89k), making the task of teasing out the underlying signal from the report more difficult. We believe the 177k pace of private job gains was encouraging on the whole, and we also expect the rebound from Winter Storm Stella to show up more visibly in Friday’s employment report.


Job availability. The Conference Board’s Help Wanted Online (HWOL) report showed a modest decrease in April online job postings (-1%) following February’s uptick (+2%). However, we continue to place limited weight on this indicator at the moment, in light of research by Fed economists that suggests the HWOL ad count has been depressed by higher prices for online job ads.


Some other observations:


Fed Impact: The impact on the Fed’s thinking could be slightly more in focus following last month’s headline 98K. Despite the employment growth average still sitting well above the Fed’s threshold for moving towards full employment, another big miss could begin to throw up some questions for the central bank. At present the rate path and the Fed’s message remain clear, and as a result it would seemingly take a string of poor labour market reports to derail the Fed’s plans to deliver two more 25bps hikes this year.


There are also wider factors in play within the Fed’s thought process, such as an inflated stock market, its large balance sheet and the Trump administration’s proposed fiscal stimulus.


Market Reaction: As ever, fast money moves will surround the initial headline. A stronger than expected number historically sends the USD higher and Treasuries lower with the opposite tending to be the case for a weaker number, before markets digest some of the other details of the report.


H/t: @RanSquawk

Thursday, April 13, 2017

BofA Finds Surging Consumer Confidence Does Not Result In Higher Spending

While markets are closed tomorrow for Good Friday, the Census Bureau will release both CPI and Retail Sales data at their regularly scheduled times. And since it will be impossible to trade these numbers as they are released, here is a courtesy advance look from Bank of America which as usual has released its internal debt and credit card data in advance of the government report. What it found is that while there has been a slight improvement to the surprisingly poor data from recent months, it is nowhere near what one would expect based on near record consumer confidence surveys.


As BofA"s Michelle Meyer writes, according to the BAC internal card data, consumer spending improved in March relative to the weak pace in February. The bank"s estimate of retail sales ex-autos, derived from the aggregated credit and debit card data, increased at a 0.4% mom seasonally adjusted pace in March - the highest print in nearly a year - even as gasoline prices declined on a seasonally adjusted basis in March. While Meyer notes that this points to "healthy growth in core control retail sales released by the Census Bureau on Friday", she cautions that "the gain may not be quite as strong given that the BAC data had been trending below the Census and was therefore due for a bounce higher."


Furthermore, the monthly pattern has been particularly noisy of late – sales fell sharply in December (-0.9%), rebounded in January (1.6%) but slipped lower in February (-0.1%). There gave been a number of “special factors” which influenced retail sales, including the timing of the Christmas and New Year’s holidays and the delay in tax refunds which likely delayed spending from February to March. Therefore
it is prudent to smooth through the wiggles – on a three-month moving basis, retail sales ex-autos are up 0.6% mom, while retail sales ex-autos are up 4.5%


And while retail sales point to a modest improvement, Meyer writes that the potential rebound is nowhere near close to matching "the dramatic improvement in consumer confidence", which is also Bank of America"s Chart of the month.



To put it into perspective, the Conference Board measure of confidence has reached the highest level since December 2000 while earlier today the University of Michigan hit highest since November of the same year. Putting 2000 in comparison, back then retail sales ex autos were running above 7% yoy and in 2007, about 4% yoy.  BofA"s take:





While we think there are fundamental reasons for higher confidence – low unemployment rate, increasing wage growth, low borrowing costs and solid stock market performance – we believe that part of the increase in confidence reflects expectations for fiscal stimulus. In our view, there is a rocky road ahead for tax reform which we believe could trigger a partial reversal in confidence. Meanwhile, we expect actual spending to continue to grow at only a moderate pace.



It also means that, as cautioned here repeatedly, the soft data has now plateaued, and is rushing to converge with the "hard" data to the downside.


Some other observations:


don"t expect a sharp rebound in northeast spending.


  • The Northeast was hit by a blizzard during the week of March 12th, dropping several feet of snow in parts of the region.

  • We can see the impact of the storm in our card data. We find that card spending in the Northeast exceeded the rest of the country in the days heading into the storm as households presumably stocked up with necessities in preparation.

  • This was offset by a meaningful drop in card activity during the storm. On balance, we estimate that the blizzard served as a very slight drag on overall spending in the month


Restaurant spending remains recessionary


  • Spending growth at restaurants has generally been on a downward trajectory, increasing only 3.2% yoy in March.

  • Part of this weakness reflects difficult year-over-year comparatives. As you can see from the month-over-month changes, spending at restaurants is still increasing on a sequential basis, but at a slower pace than last year.

  • There was also an unusual swing at the turn of the year where spending was down sharply in December but climbed higher in January. We suspect this may reflect the timing of Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve which both fell on Saturdays, therefore distorting the typical weekly spending patterns.


Finally, 4 more charts showing that whether it tracks confidence or not, the US consumer has seen far better days.


Tuesday, February 28, 2017

WTF Chart Of The Day: American Consumer Confidence Soars To 16 Year Highs As Real Wages Plunge

Continuing the trend of "soft" survey data strong performance and expectation beats, The Conference Board"s Consumer Confidence surged above the highest analyst"s expectation to 114.8 - the best print since July 2001.




Consumers’ assessment of current conditions held relatively steady in February. Those saying business conditions are “good” declined slightly from 29.0 percent to 28.7 percent, while those saying business conditions are “bad” also decreased, from 15.9 percent to 13.2 percent.


Consumers’ assessment of the labor market was also mixed. Those stating jobs are “plentiful” declined from 27.1 percent to 26.2 percent, while those claiming jobs are “hard to get” also decreased, from 21.1 percent to 20.3 percent.


Consumers were more optimistic about the short-term outlook in February. The percentage of consumers expecting business conditions to improve over the next six months increased from 22.9 percent to 24.0 percent, however those expecting business conditions to worsen also rose slightly from 10.8 percent to 11.1 percent.


Consumers’ outlook for the labor market was also moderately more upbeat. The proportion expecting more jobs in the months ahead increased from 19.7 percent to 20.4 percent, while those anticipating fewer jobs declined from 14.4 percent to 13.6 percent. The percentage of consumers expecting their incomes to increase rose marginally from 18.1 percent to 18.3 percent, while the proportion expecting a decrease declined from 9.4 percent to 8.2 percent.


We have one question for these euphoric American consumers - do you not care about wages?




As The Conference Board details...





“Consumer confidence increased in February and remains at a 15-year high (July 2001, 116.3),” said Lynn Franco, Director of Economic Indicators at The Conference Board.



“Consumers rated current business and labor market conditions more favorably this month than in January. Expectations improved regarding the short-term outlook for business, and to a lesser degree jobs and income prospects. Overall, consumers expect the economy to continue expanding in the months ahead.” 



Monday, February 13, 2017

Fed Study: Fake News drives Fake Markets

Thanks Bloomberg, for another useless piece of regurgitated info we"ve known for years; fake news drives the fake markets which are artificially inflated.  Actually thanks to the Fed for doing the academic research on this topic to confirm what we"ve known for years - the markets are rigged and one way they are manipulated is by the mainstream news.  As we explain in our book Splitting Pennies - the markets are artifically inflated and manipulated by remote control (yes - that remote control.  It"s a metaphor!)  TV watchers have a "remote control" and so does the CIA.  They press "play" and markets move as they want.  Just as TV viewers change the channel the CIA changes the "mood" of the country with a few clicks of the remote.  They even have a pause button! From Bloomberg:





Buy the news and sell the soft data.  That’s the conclusion drawn from a paper by the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, which suggests that financial news holds predictive power when it comes to a slew of economic data. Stories about the U.S. economy can even outperform more traditional measures such as surveys of consumer sentiment when it comes to gauging ‘‘animal spirits’’ and forecasting future activity, it found.  While trust in news sources among the general American population has fallen to historic lows amid accusations of fake news lobbed during the U.S. presidential elections, the Fed research throws cold water on the notion that the mainstream media is far removed from Main Street, if headline economic indicators are anything to go by.


“Specifically, we have shown that sentiment extracted from newspaper articles correlates with both contemporaneous and future key business cycle indicators,” economists Adam Hale Shapiro and Daniel Wilson of the San Francisco Fed concluded in a report co-written last month with Moritz Sudhof, of data analytics firm Kanjoya. “In a head-to-head comparison, these news sentiment measures perform better than both the University of Michigan and Conference board measures of consumer sentiment.”



You can read the Study here "Measuring News Sentiment" at Global Intel Hub"s library.


The paper is very well documented, an A+.  Great job.  We by no means mean to detract from the great work accomplished here by paraphrasing the paper as "fake news drives fake markets" - it simply serves as a great example of yet another proof how markets are manipulated, even if as the paper suggests - indirectly.  



To add some real Alpha to your portfolio, checkout www.alphazadvisors.com For a pocket guide designed to make you a market Genius - Checkout Splitting Pennies Understanding Forex @ www.splittingpennies.com and get a free robot - too!

Friday, February 3, 2017

Payrolls Preview: Expect An Upside Surprise (Thanks To The Weather)

Despite ADP"s blowout print this week, consensus January payrolls is 175k (somewhat below the 6- and 12-month averages), but Goldman Sachs expects a higher 200k print thanks to a combination of lower-than-usual year-end layoffs, favorable weather effects, and further improvement in labor market indicators.


Notably, Bloomberg Intelligence explains that over the past decade, consensus has tended to overestimate the January payrolls gain, but it appears to have corrected this bias over the past five years -- a period in which the average miss has been less than 5k. As such, the current consensus forecast implies a significantly weaker outcome than was suggested by the latest ADP employment survey, which showed a 246k increase in private payrolls.


The seasonal adjustment of the payroll data turns sharply negative in January, as recurring winter layoffs commence in a range of sectors. In recent years, the seasonal adjustment factor for January has averaged near -3036k. (In other words, employers typically layoff 3 million workers in January.)


Furthermore, as Goldman notes, the report will also be accompanied by the annual benchmark revision to the establishment survey as well as the annual introduction of new population controls in the household survey.


Overall Goldman forecasts that nonfarm payroll employment increased 200k in January, after an increase of 156k in December and 204k in November. Labor market indicators generally strengthened last month, with a drop in jobless claims between the survey periods to four-decade-lows and further improvement in the employment components of many service-sector and manufacturing surveys. The key labor market subcomponent of the consumer confidence report also rose to levels close to cycle highs. We also expect two temporary factors to boost January employment growth relative to surrounding months, specifically a weather-related rebound (on the order of 20-40k) and lower-than-usual year-end layoffs in the retail sector. On the negative side, we expect some pullback in transportation and warehousing payrolls following elevated growth in December, itself likely related to the secular shift toward online holiday sales.


Factors arguing for a stronger report:


  • Weather rebound from December. Our analysis of NOAA (National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration) weather station data suggests that unusually high snowfall during the December payroll survey period may have reduced job growth by roughly 20-40k. As shown in the left panel of Exhibit 1, snowfall in early January was much more in line with seasonal norms, suggesting scope for a weather-related rebound. Updating this analysis to incorporate regional granularity from the December state and local employment survey bolsters the case for January improvement, in our view. In addition to a 3k drop in the weather-sensitive construction category, the softness in overall December payrolls was particularly pronounced in the East North Central and Pacific regions, two parts of the country where snowfall was above seasonal norms during the week of December 17th. More specifically, in the right panel of Exhibit 1 we show that below-trend December payroll growth occurred in several states that also exhibited unusually high snowfall (in the weeks relevant for December payroll growth). Michigan, Illinois, Wisconsin, and Indiana stand out as four relatively large states where payrolls may have been depressed by weather in December.

Exhibit 1: Weather Likely to Boost January Payrolls Relative to December



Source: Source: National Centers for Environmental Information, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Department of Labor, Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research


  • Jobless claims and retail layoffs. Initial claims for unemployment insurance benefits moved lower, averaging a four-decade-low 248k during the four weeks between the December and January payroll survey periods. While seasonally adjustment difficulties likely account for much of the drop, we believe some of the decline reflects underlying labor market improvement and relatively fewer January retail layoffs – both of which would suggest scope for a rebound in January payrolls growth.

  • ADP. The payroll processing firm ADP reported a 246k rise in private payroll employment in January, up from +151k in December and well above expectations of +168k. In past research, we have found that large surprises in the ADP report tend to be predictive of the subsequent nonfarm payroll surprise. Additionally, we believe the above-trend growth in ADP construction employment (+25k) provides evidence for a rebound in weather-sensitive payrolls categories.


  • Manufacturing sector surveys. The employment components of manufacturing surveys generally improved in December, with most now in expansionary territory. The ISM manufacturing employment component rose to a 30-month high (+3.3pt to 56.1), and the Philly Fed (+9.2pt to +12.8), Dallas Fed (+9.5pt to +6.1), Richmond Fed (+9pt to +8), and Empire State (+10.5pt to -1.7) employment indices also improved. On the negative side, the Kansas City Fed (-2pt to +6) employment component softened, and the Chicago PMI employment index declined into contractionary territory. Manufacturing payroll employment rose 17k in December, its first increase in five months.

  • Service sector surveys. Most of the employment components of service sector surveys improved or remained at encouraging levels in January. The Philly Fed non-manufacturing employment index rose to a 1-year high (+2.8pt to +19.5) and the New York Fed index increased to an 18-month high (+4.5pt to +16.9, SA by GS). Meanwhile, the Richmond Fed (-4pt to +8.0) and Dallas Fed (-2.1pt to +4.8) measures pulled back modestly to levels still consistent with expansion. The ISM non-manufacturing survey will be released tomorrow, though the December employment index of 52.7 was consistent with moderate growth in service-sector jobs. Service sector payroll employment increased 132k in December and has increased 167k on average over the last six months.

  • Job availability. The Conference Board’s Help Wanted Online (HWOL) report showed an increase in online job postings for a second consecutive month in January, though their total job ad count remains 9.5% lower on a year-over-year basis (vs. -8.8% in December and -14.9% in November). We place a limited weight on this indicator at the moment in light of research by Fed economists, which suggests the HWOL ad count has been depressed by higher prices for online job ads.

Arguing for a weaker report:


  • Transportation jobs. Transportation and warehousing payrolls have seen elevated growth in December in recent years followed by softer growth or outright declines the next month, a phenomenon that may be driven by a secular shift toward online holiday sales. This winter seems to be exhibiting the same pattern, as transportation payrolls increased at an above-trend pace of +15k in December. With the holidays now behind us, we expect tomorrow’s report to show restrained growth or a modest decline in this category.

  • Early-month storms in the South. Despite fairly unremarkable snowfall on a national basis during early January, one counterargument against the case for a weather-related rebound is the early-month snowstorms in the South, a region less accustomed to severe winter weather. While admittedly a risk, we would note that these storms generally occurred the Friday and Saturday before the survey week, and our analysis of snow cover – the depth of snow recorded by weather stations on a given day – indicates that most of the snow accumulation had melted by the Monday or Tuesday of the survey week (see Exhibit 2). Accordingly, we believe the negative payrolls impact of these storms is likely to be fairly modest, though storm-related absences could exert some downward pressure on hours worked (for employees with multi-week pay periods).

Exhibit 2: Most of the Snow Accumulated in the Southern Winter Storms Had Melted by the Monday and Tuesday of the Payroll Survey Week



Source: Source: National Centers for Environmental Information, National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research


  • Seasonals. Since 2010, January payroll growth has surprised negatively relative to consensus in five of the seven instances, with an average miss of -18k. While this may suggest some downside risk at the margin, we would note that severe winter weather was likely a factor in some of these observations (2010 and 2011, for example).

Neutral factors:


  • Federal Hiring Freeze. The new administration’s announced hiring freeze for Federal works took place on January 23rd, over a week after the January payrolls survey period had ended. As a result, we do not expect any negative impact on the January employment report. In fact, we see some possibility of a positive impact if, for example, some federal departments anticipated the hiring freeze and front-loaded employment growth accordingly. That being said, we doubt we will observe evidence of a material impact in the aggregate data.

  • Job cuts. Announced layoffs reported by Challenger, Gray & Christmas after our seasonal adjustment declined by 5k to 36k in January, though the level of announced layoffs remains moderately above the October lows.

*  *  *


We believe that the unemployment rate is likely to fall one-tenth to 4.6% (from 4.716% unrounded) – which would mark a return to the cycle low – driven by reduced year-end retail layoffs and our expectation of broader labor market improvement in January. We forecast average hourly earnings to rise 0.3% month over month and 2.8% year over year, reflecting firming labor markets and state-level minimum wage hikes. Our estimate incorporates a boost of 10 basis points from minimum wage hikes, which affected 19 states and increased the effective national minimum wage by about $0.25 (to $8.50 per hour).


Tomorrow’s employment report will be accompanied by the annual benchmark revision to the establishment survey as well as the annual introduction of new population controls in the household survey. In September, the BLS released a preliminary estimate of the establishment survey revision, which suggested a downward adjustment of 150k to the level of March 2016 employment (or -12.5k per month from April 2015 to March 2016). This preliminary estimate appears broadly consistent with the trends in the Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages, from which the benchmark revision is primarily derived. We would note that the composition of September’s preliminary estimates was somewhat unfavorable, with a larger downward revision expected in private payrolls (-224k) – concentrated in professional services (-133k) and retail trade (-120k) – offset by an expected upward revision to the level of government employment (+74k).


As a reminder the entire world is long stocks, short vol, and short bonds, so any surprise tomorrow that would upset The Fed"s carefully choreographed 3-rate-hikes plan could spook a very one-sided ship.


But if that fails Buy The Fucking Payrolls Dip no matter what...


Tuesday, January 31, 2017

Consumer Confidence Disappoints, Drops From Trump-Fueled 16-Year Highs As Hope Fades

Having surged to its highest since August 2001 in the afterglow on Trump"s election victory, Conference Board Consumer Confidence slipped for the first time since October.




Interestingly, while "present situation" rose, hope plunged with "expectations" slumping most since Feb 2016.


Notably, fewer survey respondents believed it was a good time to buy a home, car, or major appliance.

Friday, January 6, 2017

Payrolls Preview: Blame Weakness On Weather, Strength On Trump

With all eyes likely on wage growth indications in the subtext of tomorrow"s payrolls report (following The Fed Minutes" comments on full employment), Goldman Sachs is forecasting a better-than-expected 0.3% rebound in average hourly earnings (helped by more favorable calendar effects) and a better-than-expected 180k payrolls print (albeit with a small rise in the unemployment rate). However, they are careful to note that any downside can be blamed on "a considerable drop in temperatures."


As Goldman Sachs details:


We forecast that nonfarm payroll employment increased 180k in December, after an increase of 178k in November and 142k in October. On balance, labor market indicators were moderately strong in December, with improvement in the employment components of many service-sector and manufacturing surveys and a rise in consumer confidence to a 15-year high. The key labor market subcomponent of consumer confidence also hovered near its post-crisis high, despite a modest pullback from November. We also expect above-trend payroll growth in the transportation and warehousing industry, driven by elevated hiring related to strong online holiday shopping. On the negative side, initial jobless claims drifted higher and continuing claims posted the largest survey-week-to-survey-week increase in nearly a year. December’s relatively cold payroll survey week could also constrain payroll growth in weather-sensitive industries such as construction, particularly after the warmer-than-usual November.


We do not expect the end of the election to be a major factor this month. If election-related uncertainty reduced or delayed hiring plans earlier in 2016, the end of the election could potentially catalyze a reacceleration in hiring, as we’ve documented in research studying past elections. However, the reacceleration historically tends to occur over several quarters, and perhaps more importantly, we would not characterize the post-election landscape as one of reduced uncertainty. We will study the industry composition of tomorrow’s reports for signs of an impact from the election, such as above-trend growth in energy or financial services, or below-trend growth in healthcare or import-reliant subindustries.



Arguing for a stronger report:


  • Service sector surveys. Most of the employment components of service sector surveys improved or remained at encouraging levels in December. The Philly Fed non-manufacturing employment index rose most dramatically to an 18-month high (+5.4pt to +19.7), and the New York Fed index increased to a 9-month high (+1pt to +12.0, SA by GS). The ISM non-manufacturing employment component was disappointing, falling to 53.8 from 58.2, but remains at a level consistent with moderate growth in service-sector employment. Meanwhile, the Richmond Fed (-1pt to +12.0) and Dallas Fed (-1.4pt to +7.8) measures pulled back modestly to levels also consistent with expansion. Service sector payroll employment increased 139k in November and has increased 177k on average over the last six months.

  • Manufacturing sector surveys. The employment components of manufacturing surveys were somewhat stronger in December. The ISM manufacturing employment component rose to an 18-month high (+0.8pt to 53.1), and the Philly Fed (+9.0pt to +6.4) and Kansas City Fed (+9pt to +10) employment components both improved sharply. On the negative side, the Dallas Fed (-7.4pt to -2.9), Richmond Fed (-6pt to -1), and Empire State (-1.3pt to -12.2) employment components all declined into contractionary territory, and the Chicago PMI employment component remained flat. Manufacturing payroll employment declined by 4k in the November report, and has declined by 3.5k on average over the last six months.

  • Job availability. The Conference Board labor differential—the difference between the percent of respondents saying jobs are plentiful and those saying jobs are hard to get—declined modestly to +4.4 from a cycle high +6.6 November. Despite the pullback, this measure has risen 5pt year-over-year and remains 8pt above its 2015 average, suggestive of a strong report. The Conference Board labor differential is historically correlated with economy-wide hiring rates (JOLTS), which slowed during 2016 and have yet to rebound as of October (see Exhibit 2).

  • Transportation Jobs. Transportation and warehousing payrolls have seen elevated readings in recent Decembers (Exhibit 1), as the seasonal adjustment factors have appeared to lag the secular shift toward online holiday sales. We also note the possibility that the seasonal factors have been anchored to some extent by a particularly weak reading in December 2009 (-52k, compared to an average of -10k in the preceding three months and +12k in the subsequent three months). Given the generally positive anecdotes around online holiday shopping, we expect another year of above-trend growth in this industry, which should provide a boost to headline payrolls of roughly 10k relative to its recent trend.

Exhibit 1: Online Holiday Shipments May Boost December Transportation Payrolls (Again)



Source: Department of Labor, Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research


  • Hurricane Matthew. We also see a small amount of upside risk from continued bounce-back from Hurricane Matthew, which hit the East Coast in October. Employment across East Coast states in the three sectors that we find are most sensitive to weather– retail, construction, and leisure and hospitality – declined by a total of 17k in October, compared to an average monthly increase of 15k over the prior six months. The November rebound in these state-level industries was fairly lackluster, with +10k total gains across that state-industry grouping. Accordingly, we see a possibility of above-trend December growth (or an upward revision to November) to restore employment levels toward their pre-hurricane trend.

Arguing for a weaker report:


  • Jobless claims. Initial claims for unemployment insurance benefits moved higher, averaging 261k during the 5 weeks between the November and December payroll survey periods, compared to 253k for the November report. Continuing claims also showed its largest survey-week-to-survey-week increase (+53k) in nearly a year (January 2016). Jobless claims can be difficult to seasonally adjust around this time of the year, and we partially discount the data accordingly. Some of the rise in initial claims may also reflect a return toward mid-year levels after especially low results in late-Q3/early-Q4.

  • ADP. The payroll processing firm ADP reported a 153k gain in private payroll employment in December, down from +215k in November and somewhat below expectations of +175k. In the past we have found minimal incremental predictive power for nonfarm payrolls in the ADP report, with the notable exception of large surprises/deviations. The new methodology ADP introduced in October creates some additional uncertainty around the translation of the somewhat softer ADP data into the outlook for tomorrow’s nonfarm payroll report. Notably, ADP’s measure of healthcare employment has slowed in recent months – even more so than official BLS estimates – and in December rose just 26k, matching the two-year low growth rate achieved last month.

  • Temperatures. The December payroll period featured few notable storms, but saw a considerable drop in temperatures following much warmer-than-usual weather in early and mid-November. Accordingly, December’s relatively cold payroll survey week could constrain job growth in weather-sensitive industries. For example, we anticipate some payback in the construction industry, which has averaged +20k payroll growth in the last three months, compared to trend monthly growth in the 10-15k range.

Neutral Factors:


  • End of the election. We do not expect the end of the election to be a major factor this month. If election-related uncertainty reduced or delayed hiring plans earlier in 2016, the end of the election could potentially catalyze a reacceleration in hiring, as we’ve documented in research studying past elections. However, the reacceleration historically tends to occur over several quarters, and perhaps more importantly, we would not characterize the post-election landscape as one of reduced uncertainty. Payroll growth did slow during the course of 2016, consistent with the possibility that election-related uncertainty reduced or delayed hiring plans, though dwindling labor market slack represents a second viable explanation. More granular data from JOLTS show a decline in the pace of hiring since the beginning of the year, with a further meaningful drop in hiring in September and October ahead of the election (Exhibit 2). We would note that considerable policy uncertainty remains. For example, the anticipation of policy changes related to health insurance and destination-based taxation could slow hiring in the healthcare sector and in import-reliant industries such as retail, wholesale, and parts of manufacturing. Much like the policy outlook itself, the evolution of business-sector expectations and their implications for aggregate-level job growth remain open questions. In terms of short-term hiring in election-related job categories, note that the BLS makes a special adjustment to estimate and remove these effects in election years, and November payrolls showed no pronounced spike in marketing research categories or government.

Exhibit 2: Were 2016’s Slower Hiring Rates Election-Related?



Source: Department of Labor, Goldman Sachs Global Investment Research


  • Online job ads. The Conference Board’s Help Wanted Online (HWOL) report reversed most of last month’s decline, and stands 9% lower than levels last year (vs. -15% yoy in November). However, we put limited weight on this indicator at the moment in light of research by Fed economists that argued that the HWOL ad count has been depressed by higher prices for online job ads.

  • Job cuts. Announced layoffs reported by Challenger, Gray & Christmas after our seasonal adjustment increased by 7k to 34k in December, but the level of announced layoffs remains range-bound and not far from cycle-lows.

  • Seasonals. Since 2010, December payroll growth has surprised positively relative to consensus two thirds of the time (4/6), however the average surprise is slightly negative at -3k.

We believe the unemployment rate most likely rebounded one-tenth to 4.7% after a 0.3pp drop last month. The unemployment rate fell 0.3pp to an unrounded 4.64% last month, but the decline was mainly driven by the participation rate, as opposed to an acceleration in household employment (which nonetheless rose a respectable 160k in the month). Sharp changes in the participation rate often reverse, and the fact that the second decimal nearly rounded up, we believe a modest rebound to 4.7% is more likely than another 4.6% reading.


Average hourly earnings likely rose 0.3% after a 0.1% decline in November, as the December survey period ended on the 17th, a relatively late calendar that is historically associated with average or favorable earnings growth. The year-over-year rate is likely to accelerate from 2.5% to 2.8%, which would match the cycle high. Our wage tracker, which captures the broader trend in wage growth across four major indicators, stands at 2.8% year-over-year as of Q3.


Tomorrow’s employment report will be accompanied by the annual revision to the household survey, with potential revisions to the last 5 years of seasonally adjusted household data. Annual revisions to the establishment survey – as well as the incorporation of updated population estimates from the Census into the household survey – are scheduled for February 3rd. The revisions to the household survey accompanying the December report are usually minor, and last year’s revisions did not result in a change to any of the monthly unemployment rates for 2015.


*  *  *


And Ransquawk details the potential market reaction:





As ever with the NFP release, the headline is likely to garner much of the initial focus with algorithms and fast money moves jumping on any large discrepancies, participants must be aware that moves could be exacerbated and choppy trade likely due to the beginning of January"s historic thin trading conditions.



If there is an overwhelmingly strong report, the USD will strengthen across the board however, as the dollar index continues to ramp many analysts consider the dollar upside to be limited and the possible move to lookout for is a poor report, negatively affecting the USD.



As focus detatches from the Fed and interest rates, equity markets are likely to be a much cleaner trade than recent months. Furthermore, with whispers of a reversal in equity markets and many participants still long the market an overwhelming poor report may prove to be a slight catalyst in a bearish push. In terms of technical levels in the S&P 500, November"s high at 2214.10 can prove to be some support on the downside and there is an internal downtrend line which originates on 23/08/16 to the next lower high on the 07/09/16 and support likely at 2158.20.



Gold and treasury markets are likely to act in tandem with classic price action in regards to the NFP likely to be evident in flight to safety asset classes, with a strong report likely to cause some risk on sentiment resulting in weakness in both gold and treasury markets and vice versa for a weak report. Participants are likely to keep an eye on fixed income markets, with tight trading ranges evident across the curve throughout December and any discrepancy in either direction could result in some traction.



And if that fails Buy The Fucking Payrolls Dip no matter what...


Thursday, December 29, 2016

Will Investors Get 'Hustled' By The Pros In 2017?

Submitted by Danielle DiMartino Booth via Money Strong,


It never pays to be an “afterthought.”


That was the word Jackie Gleason used to characterize the proposed reprisal of ‘Minnesota Fats’ in The Color of Money, 1986’s sequel to The Hustler. Chances are Paul Newman himself, who had at least 36 script conferences with the screenwriter, didn’t take offense to Gleason’s rebuff. “We desperately wanted the character to return,” Newman told the New York Times of Gleason’s ‘Fats,’ “but every time we put him in, it seemed like we were trying to glue an arm on a man and make it stick.”


Under the brilliant direction of Martin Scorsese, Newman would go on to win an Oscar for his role in Color. Still, as a whole, the sequel simply couldn’t stand up to the 1961 original. Hence the irony of Newman’s Oscar, which critics suggested was in belated recognition of his original performance as an ace pool player in The Hustler. In his young, glory days, Newman so deeply penetrated his characters’ roles that he literally vanished into them. His brilliance as an actor shined brightest in one scene when Eddie lost to Fats; rather than hostility or animus, his fascinated adoration for his idol was unabashedly on display, reflected in his bright eyes and amused expression. Now that’s Hollywood.


As for Wall Street, it’s recent performance has also laid the drama on thick and in perfect form as stocks pierce record highs. The investor community, the Street’s audience, couldn’t agree more. According to the latest survey from the Conference Board, retail investors’ enthusiasm for the stock market’s prospects is at the highest level since February 2007. A stroll down memory lane reveals that similar readings on the giddiness gauge were contrarian in nature, aka sell signals. That is, unless you’re referring to 1996 as a step-off point. In that case, today’s positive parallels suggest stocks’ 2017 sequel could best the original rally that culminated in the S&P 500 peaking in 2001.


What’s driving the train to stock market stardom? The singular theme since Trump was elected has been happiness bordering on euphoria. The overall December Conference Board survey hit a 15-year high. This echoed the most recent University of Michigan December survey, which hit a 12-year high. But it’s not just your average Joe on the street, as in Main Street. Small business confidence also witnessed its biggest one-month surge since 2009, while regional manufacturing surveys have uniformly topped forecasts. Based on an average of five regional Fed surveys, Morgan Stanley raised to a two-year high its expectations for the upcoming release of the national manufacturing survey.


The question is, can the economic fundamentals Trump the (over?)-heated hope? For that to happen, every bit of optimism has to be substantiated. And that supremely sublime stage has yet to be set.


The entirety of the Conference Board spike was due to expectations; current conditions, which remain high, actually fell on the month. Similarly, small business owners’ expectations for future sales rose smartly, which runs counter to actual sales, hiring and capital expenditures declining last month. And finally, one red flag that’s popped up in multiple places centers on the jobs market. While consumers’ expectations for income growth rose to the highest level in a decade, their perceptions of jobs being ‘plentiful,’ fell while those lamenting jobs were “hard to get” rose, affirming the recent drift upwards in jobless claims.


Some of the regional Fed surveys also showed employment had unexpectedly hit reverse gear, contrary to respondents’ effusive outlook for the future. Most surprising, perhaps, were the losses reported in Texas’ manufacturing sector in November; they defy the recent uptick in rig counts. Renmac’s chief economist Neil Dutta figures the number of operating rigs has surged 120 percent over the third quarter average. That puts the current number of drilling wells at the highest since January; oil maintaining its price gains implies more to come, reflected in Texas manufacturers’ outlook, which hit its highest level in 12 years. Presumably job growth will follow, according to the script, that is, and not just in the Lone Star State. Presumably.


Continuing along the contented motif, homebuilders are downright ecstatic – their optimism is ringing in the new year at the highest level since 2005. As per the National Association of Home Builders (NAHB):





“Builders are hopeful that President-elect Trump will follow through on his pledge to cut burdensome regulations that are harming small businesses and housing affordability. This is particularly important given that a recent NAHB study shows that regulatory costs for home building have increased 29 percent in the past five years.”



Potential homebuyers are also buying in to the potential for falling prices; the NAHB sub-index that measures Prospective Buyers Traffic registered its first print in expansionary territory since August 2005. There’s a good chance the cheery potential homebuyers overlap with the record number of consumers (18 percent) who the University of Michigan reported “spontaneously mentioned the expected favorable impact of Trump’s policies on the economy.” This figure is twice as high as its prior peak, recorded in 1981 as Reagan was taking office.


The teensiest of caveats before continuing – all of this rhapsody is not free; it’s been more than reflected in higher interest rates which have notably manifested themselves in the highest mortgage rates since the bond market threw a taper tantrum in the summer of 2013. Not even Yale economist Robert Shiller can predict which way the winds will blow, good or bad, as he told Bloomberg News:





“I don’t know how people react to rising mortgage rates. One thought is they want to lock in right now. And that’s why we’ve had good home sales recently. And it might continue as mortgage rates rise. This thing could feed a boom. I’m not saying it will.”



Talk about measured!


Paradoxically, households’ inflation expectations looking out five years over the horizon sank to their lowest level on record in data going back to 1979, even as businesses whine about the highest input costs in years.


If you think you’re hearing a wee bit of a mixed message emanating from households and businesses, you’re not losing your marbles. Policymakers and politicians have a heck of a lot to make good on when Congress takes to the Hill and the new administration sets foot in the White House next month.


We can all hope that breaking the gridlock and freeing businesses to conduct business the old-fashioned American way will unleash animal spirits among employers. Job creation, of a meaningful, high-income-generating sort, would thus beget consumption. This in turn would spur the best sort of economic growth we can hope for, and at the same time reflect businesses carrying through on their stated confidence with actions, by expanding their payrolls, inducing a lovely, virtuous cycle that feeds on itself. How economically endearing indeed.


Would you be surprised to discover there are a few skeptics who doubt Goldilocks is primed to whip out those golden locks, validating, well, just about everyone’s cockiness?


Though other perpendiculars have already been posited, it’s fair to interject a friendly reminder that we are not in 1982, the last time stocks were trading at a single-digit price-to-earnings multiple and Baby Boomers were less than half their age. Is it relevant that productivity growth was running at eight times its current pace with the saving rate double where it is today and household debt to income half of where it is? Wait…won’t rising rig counts cap oil prices? And does it matter that Uncle Sam’s debt load has grown to 105 percent of GDP compared to 30 percent back then? Does this country and its inhabitants technically have to have a pot that’s growing in size to piss in?


Not according to the measured volatility on the stock market, which is near the lowest in recorded history. We have nothing to worry about and that’s that. Hence the perplexing pessimism among institutional investors. The State Street Investor Confidence Index (ICI) peaked in March of this year, and after a wimpy stab at a comeback, has retreated anew.


The developers of the ICI observed that 2016 ended on a downbeat note as institutional investors continued to shun the stock market, preferring instead to wait for follow-through from the incoming administration and greater clarity on just how serious the Federal Reserve is about hiking rates in 2017.





“While markets increasingly look to be ‘priced for perfection’ over the US economic outlook for 2017, it is interesting that institutional investors are more circumspect,” said Lee Ferridge, State Street’s head of North American strategy. “Most noteworthy for me is the decline in the North American index even as US equities and the US dollar continue to rise.”



If the stars don’t align perfectly, if the sequel doesn’t best the original, smaller investors might want to wise up to the fact that they’re being hustled by the equivalent of professional gamblers. Know that they’ve been at this game for long enough to cash out their winnings while they can still be put to good use. What’s the alternative? That would be investors finding themselves in naïve form, as Fast Eddie did, just before he lost to Minnesota Fats, asking, “How can I lose?