Showing posts with label Charles Ponzi. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Charles Ponzi. Show all posts

Saturday, November 11, 2017

The Ponzi Scheme That"s Over 100x The Size Of Madoff

Authored by Simon Black via SovereignMan.com,


By January 1920, much of Europe was in total chaos following the end of the first World War.


Unemployment soared and steep inflation was setting in across Spain, Italy, Germany, etc.


But an Italian-American businessman who was living in Boston noticed a unique opportunity amid all of that devastation.


He realized that he could buy pre-paid international postage coupons in Europe at dirt-cheap prices, and then resell them in the United States at a hefty profit.


After pitching the idea to a few investors, he raised a total of $1,800 and formed a new company that month– the Securities Exchange Company.


Early investors were rewarded handsomely; within a month they had already received a large return on investment.


Word began to spread, and soon money came pouring in from dozens, then hundreds of other investors.


By the summer of 1920, the company’s founder was receiving more than $1 million per day from investors.


His name was Charles Ponzi. And as you could guess, it was a total scam.


Ponzi wasn’t really generating any investment returns. He was simply taking the new investors’ money to pay the old investors.


The business collapsed later that year, giving rise to the term “Ponzi Scheme”.


The most famous Ponzi Scheme in recent history was the case of Bernie Madoff, whose scam robbed investors of $65 billion.


But today there’s another major Ponzi Scheme that’s literally 100x the size of Bernie Madoff’s.



I’m talking about pension funds.


Pensions are the giant funds responsible for paying out retirement benefits to workers.


And if you think calling them a “Ponzi Scheme” is sensational, it’s not.


Pension funds (including Social Security) literally make payments to their beneficiaries with money contributed by people in the work force.


In other words, the money that people pay in to the pension fund is paid out to the people receiving benefits.


In theory this could go on indefinitely as long as


a) there’s a sufficient ratio of workers paying into the system vs. retirees receiving benefits; and


 


b) the pension funds are receiving an adequate return on investment



When one (or both) of these conditions is not being met, the pension is considered to be “underfunded,” and it starts burning through its cash balance.


Eventually it will burn through all of the fund’s assets until there’s nothing left. Poof.


Credit-rating agency Moody’s estimates state, federal and local government pensions are $7 trillion short in funding.


And corporate pension funds are underfunded by $375 billion.


One of the big drivers behind this is that investment returns are way too low.


Pension funds need to invest in safe, stable assets (like government bonds), but have to achieve yields of around 7% per year in order to stay solvent.


But today with government bonds yielding 3% or less (and in some cases bond yields are NEGATIVE), they aren’t achieving their targets.


One or two years with sub-optimal investment returns is not catastrophic.


But it’s been like this now for a decade.


And that’s just problem #1.


Problem #2 is that the ratio between workers and retirees is moving in the wrong direction.


As an example, despite all the hoop-lah about the unemployment rate falling in the Land of the Free, the number of retirees receiving Social Security is rising MUCH more rapidly.


Ten years ago in November 2007, the Bureau of Labor Statistics calculated that 146 million Americans were working.


Today that figure is 153 million, a 4.8% increase over the past decade.


Social Security, on the other hand, was paying benefits to 34.4 million Americans in November 2007, versus 44.2 million today– a 28.5% increase.


These are government statistics– and the numbers clearly show a terrible trend: there aren’t enough workers to pay for retirees.


The problems persists across state and local pensions as well.


The State of Kentucky’s Teachers’ Retirement System, for example, saw a 64% increase in retirees just in the last twelve months.


Unsurprisingly Kentucky’s retirement system is massively underfunded.


It’s so bad that Governor Matt Bevin is publicly attacking teachers who retire early (early retirement means that someone is taking benefits sooner and paying less into the pension fund).


Bottom line– this trend is real:


– Pension funds are earning a lower investment return than they require


 


– The ratio of people paying in to the fund vs. people receiving benefits is moving in the WRONG direction.



This is how Ponzi schemes invariably unravel.


Again, I’m not trying to be sensational. These are facts.


And given that just about everyone at some point probably plans on retiring, it’s important to be able to have an objective, data-driven conversation about the topic.


I know it’s uncomfortable. We want to believe so badly that the system is going to work.


I also want to be the starting Quarterback of the Dallas Cowboys. But that’s probably not going to happen either.


Retirement is a BIG component of a Plan B– which is fundamentally about taking sound, sensible steps to be in control of your own fate.


And there ARE plenty of options.


For example, you can look into a self-directed SEP IRA or Solo(k), which both allow you to contribute 10x more each year for retirement than a conventional structure.


Plus these structures allow you greater flexibility in where you can invest your retirement savings– real estate, lucrative private businesses, even cryptocurrency.


Just ONE great investment through a more flexible structure can make an enormous difference to your retirement.


And even if the Ponzi pension crisis somehow miraculously rights itself, you certainly won’t be worse off having your own independent nest egg.


It just makes sense… no matter what happens (or doesn’t happen) next.


Do you have a Plan B?









Tuesday, October 31, 2017

What Kentucky’s Retirement Rush Says About The Future of State Pensions

Via The Daily Bell


Just because a Ponzi scheme is run by a government doesn’t mean it won’t collapse.


The situation in Kentucky serves as a dire warning about larger pension systems including Social Security.


What Kentucky is currently facing in like a bank run. When people hear that a bank is failing, they all scramble to get their money out before it goes bust. This snowballs and the bank runs out of cash that much quicker.


Kentuckians are retiring in droves, hoping to get a piece of the pension funds they were promised. Worried that the money might not be there in a few years, they are opting to start collecting now, lest they get nothing. But this is causing a run-on-the-bank effect. The pension system is collapsing that much quicker.


Politicians have long kicked the can down the road. The idea is that there will always be a future generation, unborn children to pay for the promises they make today. There will always be new suckers to pay for their unfunded liabilities.


But the bubble bursts. Unless a population grows exponentially, this cannot work. That is why it is a Ponzi scheme. There’s always a bottom layer that holds up the rest of the pyramid.


Of course, the government of Kentucky has assured potential retirees that they don’t need to panic. The state claims that even if the legislation passes to fix the problem, government employees will have time to retire on the old plans if they choose.


But that hasn’t seemed to ease the high retirement numbers. In past months, between 24-64% more people have retired (depending on the sector) compared to 2016. And with officials floating the idea of raising the retirement age, many have a better safe than sorry attitude.


This also shows that people don’t trust the government assurances. And of course, they shouldn’t. After all, the government also told them not to worry, the pensions they promised were funded. After a history of governments at all levels reneging on their promises, it is better to take the money and run.


And it’s the same old story for how they got into the mess. Spend now, worry about funding it later. There’s never enough money for the government, have you ever noticed that? Companies balance their sheets or go bust. Governments keep chugging along despite breaking promises, overspending, and failing to plan.


PFM mostly blames the approach used to fund the systems, one used by most public pension plans across the country, which based the government’s contributions to the plans on a percentage of a growing payroll. It says that’s like a homeowner basing mortgage payments on a percentage of future income he expects, or hopes, will grow.



Translation: it was a Ponzi scheme. And that same scheme is used by most government retirement plans. The money in these accounts is reinvested. But you don’t control where they are putting the money. Turns out Kentucky made some bad decisions on placing retirement money in certain hedge funds that didn’t do so hot after the 2008 recession.


Also, in the 1990s when the pension plans were fully funded, the General Assembly approved benefit increases without funding them — including an expensive cost of living benefit increase for Kentucky Retirement System members in place between 1996 and 2012.



The bottom line is that you never want to be dependent on the government, or even a private company for your pension. The only way to truly safeguard your retirement is to take it into your own hands.


Maybe some of your retirement goes into a hedge fund, but certainly not all of it. But a better plan is to do the research for what kinds of stocks and investments make sense. Spread the risk across different sectors, and maybe even different country’s stock markets. If you can’t do the research for proper investments, at least do the research to find out who the best person or organization is to inform you.


Your plan may be in part a company pension or retirement plan. But it should not stop there. It is always better to diversify savings (foreign accounts, cash, precious metals) and diversify investments (property, foreign and domestic stocks). Then you can also spend what you can afford to lose on riskier, but potentially high yielding, speculations (cryptocurrency, startups).


But you know the old saying about doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. With their track record, it’s time to stop putting trust in government to take care of your finances.

Saturday, October 7, 2017

One Chart Explains What Bernie Madoff And Kentucky Public Pensions Have In Common

If Bernie Madoff taught us anything it"s that every successful ponzi scheme requires precisely one critical component to keep it afloat: a steady stream of fresh capital to fund redemptions.  Absent that key component, even the most carefully crafted ponzi, with the best, most creative accounting fabrications in the world, will inevitably fail from a lack of real, cold, hard cash to keep the illusion going.


Unfortunately, it seems that Kentucky"s public pensions are now running into the very same problem that ultimately brought down Madoff"s multi-billion dollar "empire".  As the Lexington Herald Leader points out today, it"s no coincidence that the Kentucky public pension system is suddenly collapsing just as the number of retirees (redemptions) has surged beyond the number of active employees (fresh capital) required to keep the ponzi going.





It’s impossible to know exactly who, where or when, but one day in 2016, a Kentucky state employee packed up her desk, said goodbye to her colleagues and retired.



Once she hit the exit, the number of retirees drawing a pension from the Kentucky Employees Retirement System (Non-Hazardous), the struggling $2.6 billion fund that serves most of state government, officially topped the number of active workers paying into it.



The 60-year-old fund has been mathematically upside down from that day forward.



Social Security, by comparison, has a roughly 3-to-1 ratio of workers supporting retirees, but KERS’ ratio is less than 1 to 1. Its numbers are expected to worsen as state government continues to cut its work force and aging baby boomers keep heading into retirement. The average age of a worker in KERS is 45, up from 43 just a few years ago. And they retire at age 57 on average to draw a lifetime pension.



“You just can’t depend on this model anymore,” said state Sen. Joe Bowen, R-Owensboro.




As Senator Joe Bowen notes, "it creates a cash flow problem"...





Bowen is working with Gov. Matt Bevin and other GOP lawmakers on proposed changes to Kentucky’s public pension systems, which face tens of billions of dollars in unfunded liabilities due to inadequate contributions and unrealistic financial assumptions by state government over much of the past two decades.



Bowen said Wednesday that an outline of their pension proposals could be unveiled within the next week, with a special legislative session to enact those changes possible later this year.



“The model of a defined-benefits plan doesn’t work for us anymore because we can’t raise enough money from this work force to pay for everyone who is going into retirement,” Bowen said. “This is why moving to 401(k) accounts, moving to defined-contribution plans, and then committing to paying down the existing liabilities … that’s really the only option we have.”



“It creates a cash-flow problem,” said David Eager, interim executive director of Kentucky Retirement Systems, which manages KERS (non-hazardous) and other state and local government pension funds. “The benefit payments are going to continue to go up. The contributions are going to continue to go down. That’s just the math of it.”



Of course, the demographics of the Kentucky pension system are hardly unique.  A surge in Baby Boomer retirements over the next couple of decades, combined with technological advancements that ensure that only a fraction of those retirees will have to be replaced with actual human workers, will inevitably result in a wave public pension ponzi failures as they meet with the same "cash flow problem" as Bernie Madoff.




That said, unlike the Madoff ponzi, no one will go to jail when the public pension ponzi schemes of the U.S. are exposed because, for some reason, defrauding taxpayers, as opposed to investors, is perfectly legal.

Sunday, July 2, 2017

America's Pension Bomb: Illinois Is Just the Start

We"ve written quite a bit over the past couple of months about the pending financial crisis in Illinois which will inevitability result in the state"s debt being downgraded to "junk" at some point in the near future (here is our latest from just this morning: "From Horrific To Catastrophic": Court Ruling Sends Illinois Into Financial Abyss).


Unfortunately, the state of Illinois doesn"t have a monopoly on ignorant politicians...they"re everywhere.  And, since the end of World War II, those ignorant politicians have been promising American Baby Boomers more and more entitlements while never collecting nearly enough money to cover them all...it"s all been a massive state-sponsored scam.


As we"ve noted frequently before, some of the largest of the many entitlement "scams" in this country are America"s public pension funds.  Up until now, these public pension have been covered by stealing money set aside for future generations to cover current claims...it"s a ponzi scheme of epic proportions...$5-$8 trillion to be exact.


Of course, the problem with ponzi schemes is that eventually you get to the point where the ponzi is so large that you can"t possibly steal enough money from new entrants to cover redemptions from those trying to exit...and, with a tidal wave of baby boomers about to pass into their retirement years, we suspect that America"s epic ponzi is on the verge of being exposed for the world to see.


And when the ponzi dominoes start to fall, Bloomberg has provided this helpful map to illustrate who will succumb first...




Of course, if you live in a state like South Dakota, you may take some solace from the fact that your public pension is fully funded...don"t. 


Once the dominoes start to fall, and they will, those "ignorant politicians" we mentioned above will think they"re doing the right thing when they attempt to "socialize the issue" with federal bailouts and tax hikes.  Unfortunately, this is one crisis that will be too large for even American taxpayers to bailout.

Saturday, July 1, 2017

"Fyre Festival" Founder Arrested For Fraud, "Promising A Life-Changing Event But Delivering A Disaster"

It"s been just over two months since thousands of attendees at an ill fated music festival in the Bahamas were left to fend for themselves in a Millennial"s worst nightmare of dying cell phones, cardboard sandwiches, burning tents, roving bands of thieves, feral dogs, and worst of all - anarchy at the bar.  Advertised as having "first-class culinary experiences and a luxury atmosphere," things like the "Private Luxury Villas" turned out to be nothing more than USAID disaster relief tents.



As reported in late April, the festival was quickly canceled after the story broke, with event organizers Ja Rule (Jeffrey Atkins) and Billy McFarland "sort of" apologizing:



Fast forward to Friday night, when two months after Geragos and Geragos slapped Ja Rule and McFarland with a $100 million class action lawsuit, the Manhattan US Attorney"s office announced that Fyre Festival founder Billy McFarland, the organizer of the disastrous music festival, was arrested on federal charges that he defrauded investors who bought a stake in the media company.



In the complaint, the 25-year-old MacFarland reportedly cheated at least two investors out of about $1.2 million by lying about the revenue and income of Fyre Media  which he founded last year. He gave them phony documents claiming the company generated millions of dollars in revenue from thousands of artist bookings in a single year, when it really earned just $60,000 from about 60 performances.



Billy McFarland at a benefit event in Water Mill, NY.


Acting Manhattan U.S. Attorney Joon Kim said: “As alleged, William McFarland promised a "life changing" music festival but in actuality delivered a disaster. McFarland allegedly presented fake documents to induce investors to put over a million dollars into his company and the fiasco called the Fyre Festival. Thanks to the investigative efforts of the FBI, McFarland will now have to answer for his crimes.”


He continued: "McFarland truly put on a show, misrepresenting the financial status of his businesses in order to rake in lucrative investment deals. In the end, the very public failure of the Fyre Festival signaled that something just wasn’t right.”


The fraudulent investment scheme unraveled in April when as we reported at the time, the Fyre Festival - which was advertised as a luxury getaway for moneyed millennials, who paid up to five figures for VIP packages - collapsed. Touted as an exotic festival with the promise of supermodels, haute cuisine, and wall-to-wall excess, guests instead arrived to a lack of facilities, sparse lighting, inadequate housing, and lots of cheese sandwiches. Many attendees were stranded in an airport through the night as they tried to get off the Bahamian island of Great Exuma.


That said, the festival fiasco certainly provided a novel spin on ponzi schemes.


According to Bloomberg, McFarland was arrested in New York and charged with wire fraud, which carries a maximum 20-year prison sentence. He is scheduled to appear Saturday in Manhattan federal court. His lawyer couldn’t be immediately contacted.


Some more details from the Justice Department"s complaint, courtesy of Bloomberg:





Fyre Media sought to build a mobile phone app that could be used to hire entertainers for clubs, concerts and parties. Later in the year, McFarland launched a subsidiary that began promoting his festival, claiming it would bring a global audience together to share a life-changing event, prosecutors said.



Meanwhile, the government said, McFarland was misleading his investors. Besides providing phony documents about the company’s performance, he is alleged to have altered a stock ownership statement to make it appear that he could personally guarantee an investment. He made it indicate that he owned shares valued at more than $2.5 million when he really owned stock worth less than $1,500, prosecutors said.



As we reported at the time, after the concert’s collapse, McFarland and his company were quickly hit with at least a half-dozen lawsuits from furious customers and unpaid vendors, up to and including the $100MM class action lawsuit noted above. Those complaints were followed by demands from backers looking to recoup their investment: funding that in one case was directly connected to how much attendees spent on such extras as tours, booze, and “upgrades.”


Ironically, the amateur fraud wasn"t even enough as organizers ended up borrowing as much as $7 million in a last-minute bid to fund the doomed Bahamas music showcase, according to Bloomberg. One of those loans, for $3 million, is currently the subject of a civil case after the lender, EHL Funding LLC, claimed Fyre defaulted on payments.


Even more amusing, Bloomberg reports that in a March term sheet, Fyre Media claimed to be worth $90 million. The venture capital division of Comcast chose not to invest as much as $25 million in Fyre Media after issues in due diligence, according to a person familiar with the negotiations. Which deserves at least some modest congratulations for Comcast: it appears the company was the only one who actually did some diligence on the ponzi scammer; thousands of clueless, nouveau riche millennials did not .


It remains unclear where the stolen funds have been parked. To all those civil and criminal plaintiffs seeking to recover something - or anything, good luck.

Tuesday, April 25, 2017

Rich People Are Living Longer And It's Going To Cost Taxpayers 'Bigly'

Social Security, like America"s trillions of dollars of underfunded public and private pensions, is nothing more than a ponzi scheme that will eventually fail.  Any system that relies on capital drawdowns to fund benefit obligations while the number of beneficiaries continues to soar is, by definition, a rather obvious ponzi.  That said, it"s always easier to "kick the can down the road" and hope for the best than to preemptively address the real problems that face retirees...after all, old people love to vote and taking away their retirement money is not a good way to earn their support.


Ironically, it"s not just the lower tiers of the socio-economic spectrum that will bankrupt social security.  As a new study entitled "How the Growing Gap in Life Expectancy May Affect Retirement Benefits and Reforms" points out, rich people are living a lot longer than they used to and it"s going to take a massive toll on government entitlement programs over the next couple of decades.


Per the chart below from Bloomberg, a "rich" 50-year-old in 2010 can expect to live 12.7 years longer than someone in the lowest income bracket.




Converting those longer life expectancies into dollars implies that people in the highest income brackets will draw $66,000 more from Social Security than the previous generation of retirees.  Moreover, using current distribution rates and adjusted for longevity, a top-earner could expect to extract nearly $300,000 from Social Security over a lifetime compared to $122,000 for the bottom income bracket.




Combined with other entitlements like medicare, the longevity penalty on young taxpayers is even more pronounced. 




Of course, these entitlement programs should completely collapse at some point over the next couple of decades leaving young folks high and dry.  But, luckily the average millennial has stashed away like $1,000...which, when compounded at 7% for 40 years, should be enough to cover 2-3 months of rent, at least.

Monday, April 24, 2017

Wayfair Tumbles After Amazon Launches Furniture Seller Program

It looks like another "retailer" is about to be "Amazon"-ed. Wayfair - the retail household goods seller - is tumbling this morning after Amazon reportedly pitches a new furniture seller program. Additionally, not helping the stocks, Citron"s Andrew Left goes negative on the stock, comparing the company"s controls to Madoff.


As FurnitureToday reports,





Speaking to about 40 retailer members of the Furniture Marketing Group buying group here, Amazon representatives in the furniture category said the e-commerce giant hopes to launch the new “Unified Delivery with Services” change to its platform late in the third quarter.



Under the plan, furniture sellers, such as stores, won’t be required to sell nationwide. The retailers will set their own pricing that can change with the services an Amazon customer chooses. White glove delivery (to a dry room) is the bare minimum service requirement — no drop-off at the door — but retailers can offer additional services, including delivery to the customers’ “room of choice,” set-up and haul away.



And the cost: Amazon is asking for a $39.99 monthly fee for an unlimited number of listings as well as 15% on the product sale and 20% on the services, according to Brett Hobson, Amazon business development representative in the furniture category. He added that retailers can choose to roll their services into the product price and offer just one price to customers for that 15% fee. However, in that case, Amazon shoppers wouldn’t see a menu of service options.



Read more here...



The result is not good...



And was not helped by Citron"s Andrew Left comparing the company to a ponzi scheme...





Wayfair may have buyers excited about rock-bottom prices for home goods, but its business model is unsustainable, Citron Research analyst Andrew Left says.



"The accounts payable, the cash flow, the business model – it"s stupid," Left said in a phone interview with Real Money. "They"ll never make money."



Left, a notable short seller, says shareholders should be alarmed that a company of Wayfair"s size, with more than 10,000 suppliers, uses manual internal controls, or does accounting by hand instead of automation. He compared the process to that used by convicted Ponzi? schemer Bernie Madoff, who personally supervised his company"s manual process.



In other areas of concern to Citron, Boston-based Wayfair’s accounts payable comprises 50 percent of its total assets and are 10 percent more than its revenue. Its accounts payable is also more than its $100 million cash on hand, Left says in an unpublished report obtained by Real Money.



Read more here...


Tuesday, April 18, 2017

Taxation Is Theft

It’s a double-whammy for the U.S. taxpayer. Bloomberg notes that not only are many Americans writing yet another check to Uncle Sam this tax season, they’re also paying more to have someone handle their returns. The Labor Department’s consumer-price index for tax return preparation rose 2.4 percent, the third-biggest monthly gain ever, to a record in March.


Such trends show why firms like Intuit Inc., the maker of TurboTax, and H&R Block Inc., have spent millions of dollars lobbying Congress to limit efforts to simplify the tax-filing process.



But it gets worse, as Andrew Napolitano writes via The Mises Institute; with a tax code that exceeds 72,000 pages in length and consumes more than six billion person hours per year to determine taxpayers’ taxable income, with an IRS that has become a feared law unto itself, and with a government that continues to extract more wealth from every taxpaying American every year, is it any wonder that April 15th is a day of dread in America?


Social Security taxes and income taxes have dogged us all since their institution during the last century, and few politicians have been willing to address these ploys for what they are: theft.


During the 2012 election, then-Texas Gov. Rick Perry caused a firestorm among big-government types during the Republican presidential primaries last year when he called Social Security a Ponzi scheme. He was right. It’s been a scam from its inception, and it’s still a scam today.


When Social Security was established in 1935, it was intended to provide minimal financial assistance to those too old to work. It was also intended to cause voters to become dependent on Franklin Delano Roosevelt’s Democrats. FDR copied the idea from a system established in Italy by Mussolini. The plan was to have certain workers and their employers make small contributions to a fund that would be held in trust for the workers by the government. At the time, the average life expectancy of Americans was 61 years of age, but Social Security didn’t kick in until age 65. Thus, the system was geared to take money from the average American worker that he would never see returned.


Over time, life expectancy grew and surpassed 65, the so-called trust fund was raided and spent, and the system was paying out more money than it was taking in – just like a Ponzi scheme. FDR called Social Security an insurance policy. In reality, it has become forced savings. However, the custodian of the funds – Congress – has stolen the savings and spent it. And the value of the savings has been diminished by inflation.


Today, the best one can hope to receive from Social Security is dollars with the buying power of 75 cents for every dollar contributed. That makes Social Security worse than a Ponzi scheme. You can get out of a Ponzi investment. You can’t get out of Social Security. Who would stay with a bank that returned only 75 percent of one’s savings?


The Constitution doesn’t permit the feds to steal your money. But steal, the feds do.


Also in 2012, during a Republican presidential debate, a young man asked the moderator to pose the following question to the candidates: “If I earn a dollar, how much of it am I entitled to keep?” The question was passed to one of the candidates, who punted, and then the moderator changed the topic. Only Congressman Ron Paul gave a serious post-debate answer to the young man’s question: “All of it.”


Every official foundational government document – from the Declaration of Independence to the U.S. Constitution to the oaths that everyone who works for the government takes – indicates that the government exists to work for us. The Declaration even proclaims that the government receives all of its powers from the consent of the governed. If you believe all this, as I do, then just as we don’t have the power to take our neighbor’s property and distribute it against his will, we lack the ability to give that power to the government. Stated differently, just as you lack the moral and legal ability to take my property, you cannot authorize the government to do so.


Here’s an example you’ve heard before. You’re sitting at home at night, and there’s a knock at the door. You open the door, and a guy with a gun pointed at you says: “Give me your money. I want to give it away to the less fortunate.” You think he’s dangerous and crazy, so you call the police. Then you find out he is the police, there to collect your taxes.


The framers of the Constitution understood this. For 150 years, the federal government was run by user fees and sales of government land and assessments to the states for services rendered. It rejected the Hamiltonian view that the feds could take whatever they wanted, and it followed the Jeffersonian first principle that the only moral commercial exchanges are those that are fully voluntary.


This worked well until the progressives took over the government in the first decade of the 20th century. They persuaded enough Americans to cause their state legislatures to ratify the Sixteenth Amendment, which was designed to tax the rich and redistribute wealth. They promised the American public that the income tax would never exceed 3 percent of income and would only apply to the top 3 percent of earners. How wrong – or deceptive – they were.


Yet, the imposition of a federal income tax is more than just taking from those who work and earn and giving to those who don’t. And it is more than just a spigot to fill the federal trough. At its base, it is a terrifying presumption. It presumes that we don’t really own our property. It accepts the Marxist notion that the state owns all the property and the state permits us to keep and use whatever it needs us to have so we won’t riot in the streets. And then it steals and uses whatever it can politically get away with. Do you believe this?


There are only three ways to acquire wealth in a free society. The inheritance model occurs when someone gives you wealth. The economic model occurs when you trade a skill, a talent, an asset, knowledge, sweat, energy or creativity to a willing buyer. And the mafia model occurs when a guy with a gun says: “Give me your money or else.”


Which model does the government use? Why do we put up with this?

Sunday, April 2, 2017

WARNING: U.S. Ponzi Retirement Market In Big Trouble As Withdrawals Now Exceed Contributions

srsrocco


By the SRSrocco Report,


The U.S. Retirement Market is in BIG TROUBLE as annual benefits paid out are now larger than total contributions.  Actually, the amount of net withdrawals were the highest in history.  When payouts become larger than contributions... then we have the making of the typical PONZI SCHEME.


Americans who have invested their hard-earned money into a 401K, had no idea that it was the Greatest Ponzi Scheme in history.  Unfortunately, when the markets crack, so will the value of the U.S. Retirement market.  On the other hand, Americans who were wise enough to purchase physical precious metals will protect their wealth as the U.S. Paper Retirement Market collapses.


According to the most recent data by the ICI - Investment Company Institute, the U.S. Retirement Market ballooned to a new record high of $25.3 trillion at the end of 2016:


US Retirmen Market


As we can see, the U.S. Retirement Market has nearly doubled since the collapse of the Housing & Banking sectors in 2008.  Total value of the U.S. Retirement Market increased from a low of $13.9 trillion in 2008 to $25.3 trillion at the end of 2016.  It"s not quite double... but close enough.


Furthermore, the surge in U.S. Retirement assets from $19.7 trillion in 2012 to $22.6 trillion in 2013 was due to the Federal Reserve QE 3 policy (Quantitative Easing #3).  This was the year that the monetary stimulus was funneled into the Stock, Bond and Real Estate Market and away from the precious metals.  Thus, the precious metals suffered huge price declines in 2013.


As Americans continue to contribute into their "supposed" retirement plans, few realize that more funds are now heading out than going in.  This is not a good sign at all.  If we look at the most recent data from the Investment Company Institute, Americans contributed a total of $373.6 billion into their Private Sector DC Plans in 2014 versus total benefits paid out of $402.3 billion.  Which means, net contributions were a negative $28.7 billion... the highest on record:


U.S. Retirement Market Contributions vs Withdrawals


The grey bars represent total contributions while the red line shows total benefits paid.  The net result is shown in the GREEN & RED bars at the lower part of the chart.  Green bars are positive net contributions, while the red bars are net withdrawals.  Unfortunately, the Investment Company Institute does not provide data for 2015 or 2016 yet.  It will be interesting to see if these net withdrawals continue to increase.  My gut tells me that they most likely have.


NOTE: The majority of the Private-Sector DC Plans were 401k"s, which accounted for roughly 98% of total contributions and 91% of total benefits paid.


So, why is the U.S. Retirement Market is BIG TROUBLE?  Well, if we look at the next chart, we find our answer:


US Retirement Market vs Public Debt


The chart shows that the U.S. Retirement Market has increased right along with surge in total U.S. public debt.  Thus, the U.S. Retirement Market"s value is being propped up by debt.   As the U.S. debt exploded from $875 billion in 1980 to $20 trillion currently, the U.S. Retirement Market surged from $822 billion to $25.3 trillion during the same time period.  We must remember the following:


DEBT IS NOT AN ASSET.  Also, the true value is subtracting total debt from total assets


Thus, if we just applied simple math here, the U.S. Retirement market"s net value is approximately $5 trillion... 80% less than what it is currently.  And that $5 trillion figure is likely inflated.  I do realize I am making a very general calculation here, but DEBTS are not ASSETS.


I discussed this in my recent interview on the Hagmann Report, which I highly recommend watching if you haven"t already:


The reason the U.S. Retirement Market is a huge Ponzi Scheme is that it has stored "Digital IOU"s" rather than real physical wealth.  A typical stock price is based on "Net Present Value."  They take the future value of the company"s earnings and give it a price today.  Unfortunately, companies earnings are based on the burning energy in the future.   There lies the rub.


Back during the 1930"s, most stock prices were based on the BOOK VALUE.  Basically, what the value of the company was worth if all its assets were sold.  Today, a stock price is based on EARNINGS.  Earnings can and will implode when the markets crack due to massive debt and falling oil production.


However, the few Americans who were wise enough to purchase physical precious metals rather than put their money into the Greatest Ponzi Scheme in history, will be protect wealth while most paper assets disintegrate.


$100,000 Physical Gold Investment vs $100,000 Invested in 401K


If an American decided to purchase $100,000 in physical gold over the past 30 years, they would have a true physical asset that they can sell close to that $100,000 figure.  If an American had $100,000 in their 401K, they would have to pay a 10% penalty for early withdrawal.  While a 401K withdrawal is taxed as regular income compared to physical gold taxed at a maximum of 28% capital gains, at least you can hold onto nearly three-quarters of your wealth (likely much higher percentage).


That being said, once the market crash occurs, the value of most American"s retirement assets are going to implode.  I would not be surprised to see at least 50-75% collapse (or more) in the typical U.S. Retirement Account.  Thus, the $100,000 invested in a 401K could fall to a low of $25,000, while $100,000 invested in physical gold, could easily double to $200,000.


Actually, this is the likely outcome.  Mark my words.  A typical American who has invested $100,000 into a typical 401K will find that his or her retirement account will fall to one-tenth its value versus someone who purchased physical gold instead.  The coming collapse of the U.S. and Global Oil Industries, due to lower oil prices, will be the factor that destroys the U.S. Retirement Ponzi Scheme.  It is not a matter of IF, it is a matter of WHEN.


Please continue to check back at the SRSrocco Report as I will be providing updates on the continued disintegration of the U.S. and Global Oil Industry.  Paying attention to what is taking place in the Energy Industry will provide CLUES to the timing of the Market Collapse.


Lastly, if you haven"t checked out our new PRECIOUS METALS INVESTING section or our new LOWEST COST PRECIOUS METALS STORAGE page, I highly recommend you do.


Check back for new articles and updates at the SRSrocco Report.

Friday, March 17, 2017

Famous Twitter "Trader" Arrested For Stealing $1.5 Million, Running A Ponzi

With nearly 64 thousand followers, the name Randall Rye will likely be familiar to those who follow finance Twitter:



Having built up the substantial following since joining August 2011, the famous Randalph "Randy" Rye unexpectedly stopped tweeting just after the new year, with his last tweet hitting on January 5.



Why the sudden silence?


It appears that"s about the time the 26-year-old Randall found out the authorities had figured out that instead of running a legitimate trading operation as he had represented to people gullible enough to give him their money, something called Faster Than Light Trading LLC, he was - allegedly  - merely the latest fraud, stealing and using up to $1.5 million in cash for his own personal expenses and engaging in the latest criminal Ponzi scheme.


Instead of using the money to trade, Randy "misappropriated the investors’ funds for his own personal expenses, such as air and hotel travel costs, including vacations to St. Lucia and Bali, tickets to sporting events, including the World Series and the Masters golf tournament, and on other luxury items and large cash withdrawals."


And, according to a DOJ indictment released last night, Randy won"t be tweeting again under this account, because last month Randy was arrested and remains in federal custody. "At the time of the arrest, law enforcement searched his home and office, seizing his business records and several expensive watches."


In retrospect, Randy was a far more convincing twitterer than trader. The allegations behind his misconduct were disclosed in the full complaint filed by the US Attorney"s Office for the Northern District of Illinois.


* * *


Chicago Trader Indicted on Fraud Charges for Allegedly Misappropriating at Least $1.5 Million in Client Funds


CHICAGO — A Chicago trader defrauded more than a dozen clients out of at least $1.5 million by pocketing their money instead of investing it, according to an indictment returned in federal court in Chicago.


RANDALL RYE, the owner of Faster Than Light Trading LLC, told investors that they would earn substantial profits from his proprietary trading program. Rye claimed that he would invest their money in options and futures contracts using a computer algorithm. In reality, Rye misappropriated the investors’ funds for his own personal expenses, such as air and hotel travel costs, including vacations to St. Lucia and Bali, tickets to sporting events, including the World Series and the Masters golf tournament, and on other luxury items and large cash withdrawals, according to the indictment.


As a result of the scheme, Rye fraudulently misappropriated at least $1.5 million from at least 15 investors, the indictment states.


The indictment was returned Wednesday in federal court in Chicago. It charges Rye, 26, of Chicago, with six counts of wire fraud. Arraignment is scheduled for March 21, 2017, at 1:15 p.m., before U.S. Magistrate Judge Michael T. Mason in Chicago.


According to the indictment, Rye falsely represented to investors that their money was generating substantial returns from his purported algorithmic trading program. Rye sent his investors numerous false account statements that appeared to be from established financial services companies, stating that all of the investors’ principal and profits were invested and profitable, the indictment states. However, Rye knew when he prepared the bogus statements that the documents were false and that investors’ funds were not actually maintained at the financial services companies.


Rye also used newer investors’ funds to make Ponzi-type payments to earlier investors.


Rye was arrested last month and he remains in federal custody. At the time of the arrest, law enforcement searched his home and office, seizing his business records and several expensive watches.


The public is reminded that an indictment contains only charges and is not evidence of guilt. The defendant is presumed innocent and is entitled to a fair trial at which the government has the burden of proving guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.


Each count of wire fraud carries a maximum penalty of 20 years in prison. If convicted, the Court must impose a reasonable sentence under federal sentencing statutes and the advisory U.S. Sentencing Guidelines.

Thursday, February 2, 2017

Here Are The Countries Where Millennials Will Struggle The Most To Support Retirees

The United States is a demographic time bomb, plain and simple.  Over the next 30 years, the U.S. economy will face an unrelenting demographic transition as ~75 million baby boomers exit the highest wage earning years of their life and start to draw down what little retirement savings they"ve managed to tuck away while wreaking havoc on the public "safety net" ponzi schemes, like Social Security, that will almost certainly be insolvent in a decade.


Per the U.S. Census Bureau, over the next 30 years, the number of people in the U.S. over the age of 65 is expected to double while those 85 and up will triple.  Needless to say, the overall population growth of the United States is a fraction of that which means that millennials are about to get crushed by their parents....so it"s probably a good thing they already live in mom and dad"s basement.





US Population




But, since misery loves company, we figured we would take this opportunity to highlight Bloomberg"s "Sunset Index" which tracks the number of working age people per retiree, by country and confirms that the United States is far from alone in their pending demographic crisis. 


Baby Boomers



While France and Singapore are currently the worst off with only 2.2 workers per retiree, the map below highlights just how pervasive the aging population crisis is around the globe. 





The world’s working-age population is shrinking faster than expected, leaving fewer people to support a growing number of seniors, according to the Bloomberg Sunset Index.



As seniors increasingly outnumber people still in the workforce, pressures rise on investment pools, medical systems and funds to build economies for future generations.



“The demographics cannot be ignored, but there are solutions,” said Suzanne Kunkel, director of the Scripps Gerontology Center at Miami University in Oxford, Ohio. “Those solutions need to be cultural, political, economic. There is no magic answer. The reality is China will deal with it differently than Italy.”



Asia could be facing the toughest choices in allocating resources. The Asia Pacific Risk Center estimates the region’s elderly population will rise 71 percent by 2030, compared with 55 percent in North America and 31 percent in Europe.



Baby Boomers



Of course, the financial burdens placed on young people around the world as a result of aging populations is highly dependent upon the extent of social services that have been promised and just how poorly funded those ponzi schemes are..which doesn"t bode well for the United States.





“There are other-than-alarmist views about population aging,” said David Ekerdt, director of the Gerontology Center at the University of Kansas. “Advanced economies face rather different challenges depending on the social provisions they have promised and the declines in fertility that have occurred in these nations.”



The U.S., for example, has “very high health-care costs for all citizens,” he said. “I would also say, politically, that it’s a large leap to assume that social spending, if reduced for one group, would be applied to another group.”



Baby Boomers



But, not to worry, we"re sure that markets are adequately discounting these long-term demographic risks that are almost certain to lay waste to the global economy over the next two decades.


S&P

Tuesday, January 10, 2017

Uber Has Too Much Debt For IPO (Video)

By EconMatters




We discuss Uber`s massive debt which we estimate around 4 to 4.5 Billion in aggregate, with a total capital raise of 11 Billion. The total debt number is astounding to say the least, but it is the rate of change of the debt number that is mindboggling. I don`t believe Uber has the Financials to go public, and investors risk losing everything at this rate of cash burn over the next three years. Uber may be the biggest high profile startup to file for bankruptcy before they make it to the IPO exit for the payoff for investors.


Uber has a spending problem, reminds me of Napster, quite a disruptor but not a profitable business model, flawed wasted energy, that becomes totally irrelevant and obsolete in five years anyway. Uber is essentially a glorified Ponzi scheme if you really get right down to the crux of the finances of this company. There are going to be sizable losses for all the investors valuing this company at a 62.5 Billion Valuation. That number will mean diddly squat in bankruptcy court!  



© EconMatters All Rights Reserved | Facebook | Twitter | YouTube | Email Digest | Kindle   

Saturday, January 7, 2017

City Of Dallas Looks To "Clawback" Ill-Gotten Pension Gains From Police

Almost exactly one month after taking the unprecedented step of suspending withdrawals from the Dallas Police and Fire Pension (DPFP), the Dallas city council is looking to "clawback" what it views as ill-gotten interest payments made to pensioners to the tune of roughly $1 billion.


Of course, we have followed the epic meltdown of the DPFP closely over the past several months after a series of shady real estate deals brought the fund to, in the words of Dallas Mayor Mike Rawlings, "the verge of collapse" and resulted in an FBI raid of one of the funds largest real estate investors (see "Dallas Cops" Pension Fund Nears Insolvency In Wake Of Shady Real Estate Deals, FBI Raid").  The discovery of the failed real estate deals led to a "run on the bank" as scared pensioners looked to withdraw as much as possible before the whole ponzi scheme collapsed (see "After A "Run On The Pension Fund" Dallas Mayor Demands Halt Of Withdrawals").  All of which culminated with the unprecedented decision last month to suspend withdrawals (see "In Unprecedented Move, Dallas Pension System Suspends Withdrawals") after nearly $500mm was removed from police accounts.


Now, according to a local ABC affiliate, the Dallas city council is frantically working with the DPFP board to close a $4 billion funding gap.  While the city has agreed to throw an incremental $1 billion of taxpayer money at the problem over the next 30 years, that additional funding comes with some strings attached, which includes a $1 billion "clawback" of what the city views as ill-gotten gains from Police DROP accounts.  The proposed "clawbacks" would come in the form of reduced future distributions for pensioners.


For those who haven"t followed this story as closely, DROP, which was created in the early 90"s, allowed police and firefighters in Dallas to retire while still on the job. Their monthly pension checks were then diverted into DROP accounts, which were guaranteed an 8-10% return regardless of how the overall fund performed.  Unfortunately for DPFP pensioners, the Dallas City Council now views those guaranteed returns as an effort to defraud Dallas taxpayers of billions...we would tend to agree.





The city has agreed to put in an additional billion dollars over 30 years, but they"re proposing a series of bitter pills to make up the rest of the nearly $4 billion shortfall.



The bitterest pill: A proposal to take back all of the interest police and firefighters earned on Deferred Option Retirement accounts, or DROP. That would amount to an additional billion dollars saved.



The city is calling it an "equity adjustment." Retirees call it an illegal "claw back."



Whatever you want to call it, it"s outlined in a draft legislation being hammered out by the city and pension fund leaders. Pension fund representatives and the city have been meeting almost daily to try to come to an agreement on proposed legislation that they can take to the state capital to fix the failing fund.



Of course, anyone with half a brain probably should have realized that this ponzi on steroids was doomed to fail from the start.  But, better late than never we suppose. 


To add insult to injury, for Dallas taxpayers at least, the City Council also notes that the DPFP"s artificially high annual cost of living adjustments have resulted in pension checks that are 20% higher than they would have been had they been tied to actual inflation levels instead. 





News 8 obtained a copy of the legislation which says accounts would be "adjusted to zero percent of interest."



"It"s very tough but the city wants to protect the monthly benefit," Kleinman said. "It"s a restatement of their accounts."



The city is also seeking to "equity adjustment" on cost of living increases. The city says that pension checks are about 20 percent higher than they would have been if increases had been tied to inflation.



The city"s proposing to freeze cost of living increases until it catches up to the inflation index.



DROP and the cost of living increases account for about half of the fund"s liability, the city says.



For those retirees who have already taken the money out of DROP accounts, they"d garnish their future pension checks to recoup excess interest. Worried retirees have withdrawn in excess of $500 million from DROP accounts in recent months.



Meanwhile, all of these discussions have Dallas" police predictably upset.





"We used the rules they gave us now all of the sudden they"re going to go back on the rules and say hey you don"t get any of that," said Charles Hale, a retired police officer. "That"s not fair."



Retirees promised they"d be suing if anybody tried to take back money they feel they"ve earned.



"It"s acting like it was an underhanded Ponzi scheme that we pulled," said Joe Dunn, a retired police officer. "It"s not fair."



Frankly, we too are shocked at the audacity of the Dallas City Council to suggest that public employees be forced to be compensated in a way somewhat more akin to private employees.  It"s just outrageous.