Showing posts with label Pension fund. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Pension fund. Show all posts

Tuesday, December 19, 2017

CalPERS Goes All-In On Pension Accounting Scam; Boosts Stock Allocation To 50%

Starting July 1, 2018 stock markets around the world are going to get yet another artificial boost courtesy of a decision by the $350 billion California Public Employees" Retirement System (CalPERS) to allocate another $15 billion in capital to already bubbly equities.  Of course, if this decision doesn"t make sense to you that"s because it"s not really meant to make sense. 


As Pensions & Investments notes, CalPERS" decision to hike their equity allocation had absolutely nothing to do with their opinion of relative value between assets classes and nothing to do with traditional valuation metrics that a rational investor might like to see before buying a stake in a business but rather had everything to do with gaming pension accounting rules to make their insolvent fund look a bit better.  You see, making the rational decision to lower their exposure to the massive equity bubble could have resulted in CalPERS having to also lower their discount rate for future liabilities...a move which would require more contributions from cities, towns, school districts, etc. and could bring the whole ponzi crashing down. 








The new allocation, which goes into effect July 1, 2018, supports CalPERS" 7% annualized assumed rate of return. The investment committee was considering four options, including one that lowered the rate of return to 6.5% by slashing equity exposure and another that increased it to 7.25% by increasing the exposure to almost 60% of the portfolio.


 


The lower the rate of rate means more contributions from cities, towns and school districts to CalPERS. Those governmental units are already facing large contribution increases — and have complained loudly at CalPERS meetings — because a decision by the $345.1 billion pension fund"s board in December 2016 to lower the rate of return over three years to 7% from 7.5% by July, 1, 2019.



Meanwhile, there was only one dissenting vote on the decision to hike the fund"s equity exposure.  Ironically, the dissent did not come from a rational investor looking to preserve the fund"s assets, but rather from a board member named J.J. Jelincic who wanted to go all-in on the pension accounting scam and hike the fund"s equity allocations to 60% so that discount rates could be raised even higher than the current 7%.


CalPERS


Of course, this is hardly a new topic for us. As we pointed out a year ago in a post entitled "CalPERS Board Votes To Maintain Ponzi Scheme With Only 50bps Reduction Of Discount Rate," each year CalPERS has to weigh mathematical realities against the risk of disrupting the ponzi scheme and forcing several California cities to the brink of bankruptcy with lower discount rates..."mathematical realities" rarely win that fight.








But a CalPERS return reduction would just move the burden to other government units. Groups representing municipal governments in California warn that some cities could be forced to make layoffs and major cuts in city services as well as face the risk of bankruptcy if they have to absorb the decline through higher contributions to CalPERS.


 


“This is big for us,” Dane Hutchings, a lobbyist with the League of California Cities, said in an interview. “We"ve got cities out there with half their general fund obligated to pension liabilities. How do you run a city with half a budget?”


 


CalPERS documents show that some governmental units could see their contributions more than double if the rate of return was lowered to 6%. Mr. Hutchings said bankruptcies might occur if cities had a major hike without it being phased in over a period of years. CalPERS" annual report in September on funding levels and risks also warned of potential bankruptcies by governmental units if the rate of return was decreased.



Under the plan adopted Monday, in addition to their 50% equity allocation, CalPERS will have a 28% weighting to fixed income, up from 20%.  Real assets, which includes real estate, will keep its 13% allocation, while private equity will remain at 8% and CalPERS" liquid portfolio, made up of cash and other short-term instruments, will fall to 1% from 4%.









Tuesday, October 31, 2017

What Kentucky’s Retirement Rush Says About The Future of State Pensions

Via The Daily Bell


Just because a Ponzi scheme is run by a government doesn’t mean it won’t collapse.


The situation in Kentucky serves as a dire warning about larger pension systems including Social Security.


What Kentucky is currently facing in like a bank run. When people hear that a bank is failing, they all scramble to get their money out before it goes bust. This snowballs and the bank runs out of cash that much quicker.


Kentuckians are retiring in droves, hoping to get a piece of the pension funds they were promised. Worried that the money might not be there in a few years, they are opting to start collecting now, lest they get nothing. But this is causing a run-on-the-bank effect. The pension system is collapsing that much quicker.


Politicians have long kicked the can down the road. The idea is that there will always be a future generation, unborn children to pay for the promises they make today. There will always be new suckers to pay for their unfunded liabilities.


But the bubble bursts. Unless a population grows exponentially, this cannot work. That is why it is a Ponzi scheme. There’s always a bottom layer that holds up the rest of the pyramid.


Of course, the government of Kentucky has assured potential retirees that they don’t need to panic. The state claims that even if the legislation passes to fix the problem, government employees will have time to retire on the old plans if they choose.


But that hasn’t seemed to ease the high retirement numbers. In past months, between 24-64% more people have retired (depending on the sector) compared to 2016. And with officials floating the idea of raising the retirement age, many have a better safe than sorry attitude.


This also shows that people don’t trust the government assurances. And of course, they shouldn’t. After all, the government also told them not to worry, the pensions they promised were funded. After a history of governments at all levels reneging on their promises, it is better to take the money and run.


And it’s the same old story for how they got into the mess. Spend now, worry about funding it later. There’s never enough money for the government, have you ever noticed that? Companies balance their sheets or go bust. Governments keep chugging along despite breaking promises, overspending, and failing to plan.


PFM mostly blames the approach used to fund the systems, one used by most public pension plans across the country, which based the government’s contributions to the plans on a percentage of a growing payroll. It says that’s like a homeowner basing mortgage payments on a percentage of future income he expects, or hopes, will grow.



Translation: it was a Ponzi scheme. And that same scheme is used by most government retirement plans. The money in these accounts is reinvested. But you don’t control where they are putting the money. Turns out Kentucky made some bad decisions on placing retirement money in certain hedge funds that didn’t do so hot after the 2008 recession.


Also, in the 1990s when the pension plans were fully funded, the General Assembly approved benefit increases without funding them — including an expensive cost of living benefit increase for Kentucky Retirement System members in place between 1996 and 2012.



The bottom line is that you never want to be dependent on the government, or even a private company for your pension. The only way to truly safeguard your retirement is to take it into your own hands.


Maybe some of your retirement goes into a hedge fund, but certainly not all of it. But a better plan is to do the research for what kinds of stocks and investments make sense. Spread the risk across different sectors, and maybe even different country’s stock markets. If you can’t do the research for proper investments, at least do the research to find out who the best person or organization is to inform you.


Your plan may be in part a company pension or retirement plan. But it should not stop there. It is always better to diversify savings (foreign accounts, cash, precious metals) and diversify investments (property, foreign and domestic stocks). Then you can also spend what you can afford to lose on riskier, but potentially high yielding, speculations (cryptocurrency, startups).


But you know the old saying about doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results. With their track record, it’s time to stop putting trust in government to take care of your finances.

Saturday, September 2, 2017

Pension Ponzi Exposed: Minnesota Underfunding Triples After Tweaking This One Small Assumption...

Defined Benefit Pension Plans are, in many cases, a ponzi scheme.  Current assets are used to pay current claims in full despite insufficient funding to pay future liabilities... classic Ponzi.  But unlike wall street and corporate ponzi schemes no one goes to jail here because the establishment is complicit.  Everyone from government officials to union bosses are incentivized to maintain the status quo...public employees get to sleep better at night thinking they have a "retirement plan," public legislators get to be re-elected by union membership while pretending their states are solvent and union bosses get to keep their jobs while hiding the truth from employees.  


So what allows this ponzi to persist?  It all comes down to one simple assumption: Discount Rates.  You see, if you simply discount future liabilities at a high enough discount rate then you can make any massively underfunded pension ponzi look like a stable, healthy retirement gold mine. 


In fact, just over a year ago we took a look at what would happen if we calculated the true underfunded level of America"s public pensions at more reasonable discount rates.  The result showed that the media"s highly referenced underfunding of $2 trillion soared to something closer to $5-$8 trillion when more reasonable discount rates were employed.





We decided to take a look at what would happen if all federal, state and local pension plans decided to heed the advice of Mr. Gross. As one might suspect, the results are not pleasant.  We conservatively assume that public pensions are currently $2.0 trillion underfunded ($4.5 trillion of assets for $6.5 trillion of liabilities) even though we"ve seen estimates that suggest $3.5 trillion or more might be more appropriate.  We then adjusted the return on asset assumption down from the 7.5% used by most pensions to the 4.0% suggested by Mr. Gross and found that true public pension underfunding could be closer to $5.5 trillion, or over 2.5x more than current estimates.  Others have suggested that returns should be closer to risk-free rates which would imply an even more draconian $8.4 trillion underfunding.  


 


Pension Underfudning




Now, the state of Minnesota has gracefully stepped forward to beautifully illustrate our point.  Upon making a few minor "tweaks" to their various funds" discount rates, the state found that their aggregate pension underfunding more than tripled from roughly $16 billion to over $50 billion.  Here"s more from Bloomberg:





Minnesota’s debt to its workers’ retirement system has soared by $33.4 billion, or $6,000 for every resident, courtesy of accounting rules.



The jump caused the finances of Minnesota’s pensions to erode more than any other state’s last year as accounting standards seek to prevent governments from using overly optimistic assumptions to minimize what they owe public employees decades from now. Because of changes in actuarial math, Minnesota in 2016 reported having just 53 percent of what it needed to cover promised benefits, down from 80 percent a year earlier, transforming it from one of the best funded state systems to the seventh worst, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.



The Minnesota’s teachers’ pension fund, which had $19.4 billion in assets as of June 30, 2016, is expected to go broke in 2052. As a result of the latest rules the pension has started using a rate of 4.7 percent to discount its liabilities, down from the 8 percent used previously. As a result, its liabilities increased by $16.7 billion.



But other factors also helped boost Minnesota’s liabilities: Eight of Minnesota’s nine pensions reduced their assumed rate of return on their investments to 7.5 percent from 7.9 percent, while three began factoring in longer life expectancy.



All of which resulted in this:


Minnesota



Of course, Minnesota"s underfunding didn"t just magically "soar by $33.4 billion" as Bloomberg puts it...in reality, the state"s pensions were always underfunded by ~$50 billion...the only difference is that that some pension administrators finally decided to stop lying to their retirees and report reality.


All of which rendered this Bloomberg map from just two months ago showing an 80% funding ratio for Minnesota completely obsolete...




...Sorry, Minnesota teachers but you"re almost as screwed as your counterparts in Illinois...you just didn"t know it until your bosses finally decided to stop lying to you.


Pension map

Tuesday, March 14, 2017

This Is What Happens When Private Equity Firms Run Out Of Things To Buy

What do you do when you"re part of an industry that has levered up $100"s of billions of dollars in investor capital and paid a handsome premium for pretty much every asset available all while "excess cash sits on the sidelines" because there are just no deals left to do at remotely attractive valuations?  Well, if you"re Investindustrial, a European private equity fund founded by Italian dealmaker Andrea Bonomi, then you simply raise a new fund to buy all the investments of your old fund.


And while that may sound like a joke, unfortunately it"s very true.  As the Wall Street Journal points out today, Bonomi has recently raised $800mm to buy assets that he initially acquired via a $1.1 billion fund originally raised in 2008. 


All of which raises a number of important questions like how exactly are valuations set for such a deal in the absence of a distinct buyer and seller negotiating a fair, market clearing price?  Presumably Bonomi tested the market for his assets but simply didn"t like the valuations he was offered?  If so, how could new Limited Partners ever possibly get comfortable with the valuations paid for assets being purchased from the old fund?  After all, the ole "mark to model" methodology didn"t work out so well for the Dallas Police and Fire Pension, among others.  


And then there is the question of fees.  Surely, LPs wouldn"t be willing to pay "2 & 20" for the runoff of an existing portfolio?  If so, sign us up.


PE



Of course, according to the WSJ, Bonomi"s effort to buy his own prior investments has nothing to do with gaming fees but is rather just a creative way to be more competitive with sovereign wealth funds that don"t have term limitations on their funds...and if you believe that then Bonomi, a man who typically only sells assets to himself, would very much like to offer you the once in a lifetime opportunity to buy some ocean front property in Oklahoma. 





Buyout firms face increasing competition from patient investors like sovereign-wealth funds. One has found a way to play them at their own game: Investindustrial, a European buyout firm, is creating a new fund to buy €750 million ($800 million) of assets it already owns.



Investindustrial, founded by Italian dealmaker Andrea Bonomi, has decided on this novel course of action as it responds to greater competition for assets from institutions such as sovereign-wealth funds, which don’t have restrictions on how long they can own companies. The competition is pressuring buyout firms to devise new ways to own companies.



Moreover, the decision is in no way related to poor returns.  In fact, the primary motivator for recycling their old portfolio, at least according to the head of investor relations at Investindustrial, is that returns have been so amazing that it just makes sense to hold on to take advantage of further price appreciation. 





Historically, buyout specialists took pride in their ability to turn around the fortunes of ailing companies and sell them for a big profit within five years.



“There used to be no alternative to selling,” Carl Nauckhoff, head of investor relations at Investindustrial, said in an interview.



Investindustrial’s move to hold onto Port Aventura for longer comes as fierce competition is pushing up prices for companies, meaning it increasingly makes more sense to hold on to assets than to sell. Some sovereign-wealth funds and pension funds—traditional investors in buyout funds—are increasingly competing directly for assets. And they can hold them for as long as they want. In response, buyout firms like New York-based Blackstone Group LP are raising longer term funds so they can own companies for more than the traditional 10-year maximum.



Meanwhile, as Lazard notes, it"s only a matter of time before other funds attempt to copy Bonomi"s "innovative" approach to private equity investing. 





The deal could mark the start of a new trend because the increasing size of the buyout industry means many more funds are coming to the end of their lives than in the past, said Pablo de la Infiesta, a banker at Lazard Ltd. who advised on the transaction.



“Investindustrial has set a new direction,” Mr. de la Infiesta said in an interview. “I think everybody who has assets sitting in a fund that is coming to the end of its life will be thinking about it.”



Truly genius plan if we understand it correctly.

Saturday, January 7, 2017

City Of Dallas Looks To "Clawback" Ill-Gotten Pension Gains From Police

Almost exactly one month after taking the unprecedented step of suspending withdrawals from the Dallas Police and Fire Pension (DPFP), the Dallas city council is looking to "clawback" what it views as ill-gotten interest payments made to pensioners to the tune of roughly $1 billion.


Of course, we have followed the epic meltdown of the DPFP closely over the past several months after a series of shady real estate deals brought the fund to, in the words of Dallas Mayor Mike Rawlings, "the verge of collapse" and resulted in an FBI raid of one of the funds largest real estate investors (see "Dallas Cops" Pension Fund Nears Insolvency In Wake Of Shady Real Estate Deals, FBI Raid").  The discovery of the failed real estate deals led to a "run on the bank" as scared pensioners looked to withdraw as much as possible before the whole ponzi scheme collapsed (see "After A "Run On The Pension Fund" Dallas Mayor Demands Halt Of Withdrawals").  All of which culminated with the unprecedented decision last month to suspend withdrawals (see "In Unprecedented Move, Dallas Pension System Suspends Withdrawals") after nearly $500mm was removed from police accounts.


Now, according to a local ABC affiliate, the Dallas city council is frantically working with the DPFP board to close a $4 billion funding gap.  While the city has agreed to throw an incremental $1 billion of taxpayer money at the problem over the next 30 years, that additional funding comes with some strings attached, which includes a $1 billion "clawback" of what the city views as ill-gotten gains from Police DROP accounts.  The proposed "clawbacks" would come in the form of reduced future distributions for pensioners.


For those who haven"t followed this story as closely, DROP, which was created in the early 90"s, allowed police and firefighters in Dallas to retire while still on the job. Their monthly pension checks were then diverted into DROP accounts, which were guaranteed an 8-10% return regardless of how the overall fund performed.  Unfortunately for DPFP pensioners, the Dallas City Council now views those guaranteed returns as an effort to defraud Dallas taxpayers of billions...we would tend to agree.





The city has agreed to put in an additional billion dollars over 30 years, but they"re proposing a series of bitter pills to make up the rest of the nearly $4 billion shortfall.



The bitterest pill: A proposal to take back all of the interest police and firefighters earned on Deferred Option Retirement accounts, or DROP. That would amount to an additional billion dollars saved.



The city is calling it an "equity adjustment." Retirees call it an illegal "claw back."



Whatever you want to call it, it"s outlined in a draft legislation being hammered out by the city and pension fund leaders. Pension fund representatives and the city have been meeting almost daily to try to come to an agreement on proposed legislation that they can take to the state capital to fix the failing fund.



Of course, anyone with half a brain probably should have realized that this ponzi on steroids was doomed to fail from the start.  But, better late than never we suppose. 


To add insult to injury, for Dallas taxpayers at least, the City Council also notes that the DPFP"s artificially high annual cost of living adjustments have resulted in pension checks that are 20% higher than they would have been had they been tied to actual inflation levels instead. 





News 8 obtained a copy of the legislation which says accounts would be "adjusted to zero percent of interest."



"It"s very tough but the city wants to protect the monthly benefit," Kleinman said. "It"s a restatement of their accounts."



The city is also seeking to "equity adjustment" on cost of living increases. The city says that pension checks are about 20 percent higher than they would have been if increases had been tied to inflation.



The city"s proposing to freeze cost of living increases until it catches up to the inflation index.



DROP and the cost of living increases account for about half of the fund"s liability, the city says.



For those retirees who have already taken the money out of DROP accounts, they"d garnish their future pension checks to recoup excess interest. Worried retirees have withdrawn in excess of $500 million from DROP accounts in recent months.



Meanwhile, all of these discussions have Dallas" police predictably upset.





"We used the rules they gave us now all of the sudden they"re going to go back on the rules and say hey you don"t get any of that," said Charles Hale, a retired police officer. "That"s not fair."



Retirees promised they"d be suing if anybody tried to take back money they feel they"ve earned.



"It"s acting like it was an underhanded Ponzi scheme that we pulled," said Joe Dunn, a retired police officer. "It"s not fair."



Frankly, we too are shocked at the audacity of the Dallas City Council to suggest that public employees be forced to be compensated in a way somewhat more akin to private employees.  It"s just outrageous.