Showing posts with label Market Breadth. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Market Breadth. Show all posts

Sunday, September 10, 2017

7 Reasons Why Goldman's Clients Are Very Worried About An Imminent Crash

Over the years, the clients of Goldman Sachs have periodically found themselves on the verge of panic.


In March of 2015, we said that Goldman"s clients were most worried about the then-relentless crash in the EUR and how the resulting strong USD would hit US earnings (which, in retrospect, is ironic now that the tables have fully turned). Then In November 2015 we reported that "Goldman"s Clients Are Suddenly Very Worried About Collapsing Market Breadth" (and with good reason, the market was about to crash precisely for that reason). Several months later, Goldman"s clients were again confused - and worried - this time demanding that all their questions be answered before BTFD.


Then, in July 2016, Goldman"s clients again had a burning question: they were struggling to reconcile how extreme valuations of both equities and bonds can co-exist. As David Kostin explained one year ago, "client discussions reveal low portfolio risk coupled with concern that the rally lasts. Most investors have  been skeptical of the valuation expansion and have not participated in the 8% rebound from the post-Brexit low on June 27. Upside call buying has been a popular strategy to insure against upside risk." Additionally, Goldman clients were very worried that this remains a market without any earnings growth, and that much of the S&P upside has been due multiple expansion: "the S&P 500 forward P/E has already expanded by 70% during the past five years, exceeding all other expansion cycles except 1984-1987 (up 111%) and 1994-1999 (up 115%). Both prior extreme P/E multiple expansion cycles ended poorly for equity investors."


While it is unclear if said clients got over their concerns and got on with the BTFD program, what we do know is that since last July, already extreme valuations have only gotten more extreme, and as a result, Goldman clients are once again very worried, this time about an "imminent equity downturn" (banker euphemism for crash).


As Goldman"s chief equity strategist, David Kostin writes in his latest Weekly Kickstart, "the question every client asks: “Is an equity correction imminent?”


He then concedes that "Of course, at some point the S&P 500 will retreat"... but then gives two (painfully laughable) explanations why not just yet. First, however, he lays out the 7 reasons why Goldman"s clients are so fearful:


  • 1. History. Many investors argue the bull market is “long in the tooth” and will soon come to an end. It has been 14 months since the S&P 500 index experienced a 5% sell-off and 19 months since the market had a correction of 10%. The last bear market defined as a fall in the index greater than 20% ended in 2009. The current bull market has lasted for 8.5 years and the S&P 500 has climbed by 260% compared with a 124% rise in earnings and a 64% P/E multiple expansion to 18x forward EPS.
     

  • 2. Volatility (or lack thereof). Realized 3-month vol is nearly the lowest in 50 years. Implied vol as measured by the VIX stands at 12, a 6th percentile event since 1990. In his recent book, Tectonic Shifts in Financial Markets, the legendary Salomon Brothers economist Henry Kaufman (with the superb sobriquet “Dr. Doom”) references the lesson of Sherlock Holmes in “The curious incident of the dog in the night-time” that what doesn’t happen matters as much as what does. Low volatility across asset classes may be masking risks that are not evident today but will be obvious in retrospect.

  • 3. Valuation. Equity valuations are stretched on almost every metric. The typical stock trades at the 98th percentile and the overall index at the 87th percentile relative to the past 40 years. Only on a Free Cash Flow (FCF) yield basis is the market valued at an average level (4.4%). But as we detailed in a recent report, the collapse in capex spending explains the FCF yield. On a cash flow from operations basis the market trades at the 87th percentile. Other asset classes are also highly valued vs. history: nominal Treasury yields (92nd), real yields (75th), and HY (75th) and IG (69th) spreads.

  • 4. Economics. The current US economic expansion just celebrated its 8th birthday making it one of the longest stretches without a recession. Only the 10-year expansion during 1991-2000 and the 9-year expansion from 1961 to 1969 had longer durations. The median length of the 16 expansions since 1921 has been 42 months. Along with the question about an equity correction, another frequent inquiry is “when will the next recession occur?” Our economists assign an 18% probability of a recession within 12 months.

  • 5. Fed policy. The FOMC has lifted the funds rate by 100 bp since it started tightening in December 2015. During prior hiking cycles, equity P/E multiples typically fell but multiples have actually expanded during the past two years. Futures imply one hike by year-end 2018 vs. our economists’ estimate of five. The uncertain pace of further tightening is a cause of much investor anxiety.
     

  • 6. Interest rates. Two months ago, Treasury yields equaled 2.4%, ten-year implied inflation was 1.7%, and the S&P 500 stood at 2410. Our year-end forecasts of a 2.75% bond yield and a 2400 level in the S&P 500 looked rational. However, weaker-than-expected inflation data sparked a 35 bp drop in bond yields to 2.05% and a 2% stock market rally to 2465 (+10% YTD). Looking ahead, we maintain our year-end 2017 target (-3%).

  • 7. Politics. President Trump’s fluid positions on domestic policy disputes in Washington, D.C. and geopolitical gamesmanship with Pyongyang and Beijing make political forecasting a precarious activity. One fund manager cited the “Law of Conservation of Volatility” under which there is a finite amount of uncertainty in the world. All the risk is now concentrated inside the Beltway and volatility outside of politics is close to zero. Of course, this could change at a moment’s notice.

As Kostin further adds, "investors cite the points above to justify their forecast of a looming correction. According to their narrative, high valuation leaves little room for error. A Fed tightening despite low inflation will spark concerns about the sustainability of economic expansion and lead to a jump in vol that may be compounded by a political event that in turn will spark a wave of selling. As factors reverse performance, quant funds will liquidate positions putting additional downward pressure on share prices and driving indices lower."


So what is Goldman"s response to these 7 very valid concerns? In a nutshell, "don"t worry and just BTD" or as Kostin puts it, "because investor euphoria is non-existent, an imminent start of a long decline seems
unlikely."


Skepticism abounds with normal 3% mutual fund cash positions. However, a sturdy consumer accounts for 69% of US GDP and buybacks remain persistent. Firms with high growth investment ratios have durable prospects even in the event of a market hurricane.


Sturdy consumer? Strong Buybacks? Has Kostin seen either of these two charts proving that neither of these statement is true, first the worst retail sales in nearly 4 years...




... or at least SocGen"s chart showing the biggest drop in buybacks since the financial crisis?


. 



Maybe Goldman clients should add an 8th concern: a grossly incompetent advisor. 


In any event, for those who enjoy having their hand held and buying stocks which trade at the 98th percentile in valuations, hoping for even higher prices, this is who Kostin "rationalizes" his grossly wrong assessment:





Although the preceding sequence of events could happen, we view it as a low probability event in the near-term for two key reasons:



First, investors are not complacent. In Sir John Templeton’s timeless observation, “Bull markets are born on pessimism, grow on skepticism, mature on optimism, and die on euphoria.” Investors today are situated between skepticism and optimism. Few are euphoric as 27% of core managers are beating their benchmark. “Tormented bulls” best describes investor mentality. Alpha-seekers have normal cash positions (3.2% of mutual fund assets), active manager redemptions are offset by beta inflows (ETFs), and corporates continue to repurchase shares.



Second, US economic growth persists led by consumers that account for 69% of GDP. Monthly job growth has averaged 175K YTD, wages are rising (our leading indicator is a 2.7% rate), confidence is at the highest level since 2001, and household balance sheets are the strongest since 1980. For corporates, S&P 500 sales and EPS will rise by 5% and 7% in 2018. “Firms of tomorrow” with Growth Investment Ratios averaging 91% of CFO in past 3 years (vs. S&P 500 median of 17%) will grow 2018 sales and EPS by 7% and 12% and will outperform should a market hurricane occur (GSTHHGIR).



In short: yes, the market should crash, but because investors are not complacent (just don"t look at the VIX), and because the economy is so strong (just don"t look at the 10Y), everything will be fine.  Surely this optimistic bias would lead Goldman to at least expect some upside from here in the S&P? Well, no:


  • "We expect the S&P 500 will end 2017 at 2400 (-2.6)%."

And scene.


Dear David: a) you are not even trying any more, and b) in your next weekly letter, can you please just let us know how much more Goldman"s prop desk has left to sell before it pulls the rug out of the market. Thanks.

Sunday, August 6, 2017

Labor Market 'Breadth' Nears Record Low

Tom Keene was out with a chart today referencing Zerohedge’s point that a large percentage of the non-farm payroll growth has been a result of lower paying industries, such as food and drinking places – or as they would put it, more bartenders.




While a job is a job, the composition and strength of gains is quite important, as it gives us an understanding of aggregate health.


If total growth is strong, but is the result of only a few sectors, the breadth of the overall market is weak. This typically provides us with a signal on where the overall market is heading – and this goes both ways.


This brings me to an indicator that I built out over the past year – labor market breadth – which seeks to measure the aggregate health of the labor market by looking at its sub-components. While I don’t break out how it’s calculated, I will say it is comparable to the breadth of the stock market.


Following Friday’s employment report of 209k new jobs, beating estimates of 183k, labor market breadth fell to an un-smoothed cycle low, as shown below. So while the headline number was strong, it’s aggregate sub-components continue to slow, which is not indicative of strength.



We can see this by sharp decreases in total job growth of retail trade, which many will attribute to the rise of Amazon.



And information, which is not affected by the retail giant.



As well as arts, entertainment, and recreation.



And health care, which has slowed materially over the past four months.



There is some strength however in wholesale trade.



And durable goods



But this today was offset by weakness in a previously strong industry – real estate.



And a slowing financial sector.



In total, the current breadth of the labor market is indicating that wages and salaries will move lower over the next 6 months, as shown below.



We’ll see if this manifests or not.

Saturday, May 20, 2017

The Simplest Reason Behind Collapsing Volatility: Hedge Funds Are Barely Trading

"Gamma", "vega", CTAs, risk-parity, vol-neutral, central bank vol-suppression, the soaring popularity of (inverse) VIX ETFs , and so on: over the past year there have been countless attempts to explain why despite the surging political uncertainty in recent years, and especially since the US election...



... global equity volatility, both implied and realized, has tumbled to record lows, sliding even below levels not even seen before the 2008 financial crisis.


There may be a much simpler reason.


In its latest hedge fund tracker report, which every quarter analyzes the 13F filings by US hedge funds, Goldman found something quite striking. When looking at the gross portfolio turnover of hedge funds in Q1, the bank found that it had retreated to a record low at 28% of positions in 1Q 2017.



At the same time, turnover of the largest quartile of hedge fund positions, which account for two-thirds of hedge fund long holdings, fell to 15%, close to its lowest level since 2002. As a result the typical hedge fund has 67% of its long equity assets invested in its 10 largest positions, a decline from last quarter but still near historical highs.



This suggests that in the first quarter, hedge funds found themselves even further "paralyzed", and for whatever reason have reduced overall trading levels to all time lows. This further suggests that with virtually no trading by the "smart money", those traditionally most likely to put on "volatile" positions, contrary to consensus, the bulk of executed trading took place among passive funds and other trend followers, which would facilitate and accelerate the ongoing decline in volatility.


Stated simply: volatility has collapsed for the simple reason that increasingly fewer directional, non-momentum chasing market participants are actually trading.


But if hedge fund turnover has collapsed, how do these "active managers" hope to generate alpha? One explanation is that in lieu of stock picking, hedge funds have simply lifted leverage to post-crisis highs as their most popular long positions outperformed in a rising equity market. The Goldman Sachs Prime Services Weekly shows that, after bottoming in mid-2016, hedge fund net and gross exposures have continued to rise. Net exposure (73%) is now roughly in line with its cycle highs reached in 2013, while gross leverage (234%) has soared to new post-crisis highs.



This dynamic has contributed to a virtuous cycle as our Hedge Fund VIP basket of the most popular hedge fund long positions rallied, outperforming the S&P 500 by 360 bp YTD (10.1% vs. 6.5%).


And while such dramatic concentration among the top positions has been observed before, most recently yesterday when we showed the fresh collapse in market breadth vs the once again resilient "broader" market...



... this bring up another key concern: with the bulk of hedge funds holding just a handful of names - mostly tech stocks comprising the so-called FAANG, which as a group have returned nearly 30% and are responsible for half of the S&P YTD gains - proppeled to record highs by a fresh burst of momentum chasing, what happens when for whatever reason, this trade is unwound.



This is Goldman"s take:





The rise in leverage alongside growing popularity of outperforming growth stocks has raised some concerns among clients, even while boosting their portfolios. Investors recall the sharp momentum reversal of early 2016, which came on the heels of a similar period of rising popularity and performance for “FANG” (FB, AMZN, NFLX, GOOGL) and similar stocks in late 2015.



Indeed, investors have reason to be concerned: for a vivid example of what happens when such "hedge fund" hotel trades go into reverse, look no further than Valeant...

Tuesday, January 31, 2017

Why February May Be An Ugly Month For Markets: Here Are BofA's "Danger Signals"

With the S&P500 ending January on the back foot, more pain may be in store for markets in February.


This is the observation of BofA"s chief technician Stephen Suttmeyer, who provides several danger signals why bulls may want to be particularly cautious ahead of the coming months.


As he notes, the post-Presidential Election S&P 500 rally has done better than the post-Brexit rally, but there are warning signs moving into February just as there were coming off the mid-August post-Brexit S&P 500 peak.



These include complacent VXV/VIX and put/call ratios, a bearish divergence for the US most active advance-decline line, and a Net Tab sell signal. In addition, there is the risk of a weaker
February based on seasonals and the US Presidential Cycle Year 1 pattern going back to 1928. A close below 1.17 on the VXV/VIX as well as a cross for VIM Distribution above VIM Accumulation would increase the risk for following weaker February seasonals.


Of the items listed, we find the seasonal argument most persuasive. While February tends to be a weaker month for the S&P 500 in general and is up only 52.8% of the time with an average return of -0.05% going back to 1928, February is particularly weak in the first year of a presidential cycle: in that case February is up only 41% of the time with an average S&P 500 decline of 2.10%. Even more troubling, when the President is in his first term, February of Year 1 is up only 23% of the time with an average decline of 3.84%.



And then there are the purely "overbought" technicals, chief among which is the VXV/VIX ratio. As Suttmeyer notes, the VXV/VIX is overbought & complacent. The VXV/VIX spiked at oversold levels below 1.0 low on Brexit in late June and ahead of the US Election in early November. Overbought readings can persist and the VXV/VIX has been overbought for the most part since mid November. However, it could go even higher, and would take a decisive move below 1.17, similar to the bearish late August/early September signals, to suggest the risk of a deeper decline in the S&P 500.



Then, there is the 25-day CBOE total put/call ratio which generated a buy signal off the contrarian bullish or fearful levels associated with the US Presidential Election. However, since then this measure of tactical market sentiment moved to overbought in mid December and is on a sell signal off these overbought or complacent levels, which is a risk for February.



Finally, one last tactical concern moving into the weaker seasonal month of February is a bearish divergence on the US Top 15 Most Active A-D line. A bearish divergence occurs when an indicator peaks before the market does. A 12/27 peak for the most active A-D line vs a 1/25 peak for the S&P 500 is a bearish divergence (yellow light) for this important market breadth (and volume) indicator. The most active A-D line measures the breadth of the top 15 US stocks (market cap > 500m) by share volume. When this A-D line falls ahead of the market indices, it suggests that smart money may be selling into strength.



So while a further pullback may be imminent, BofA leaves on a hopeful note: "Many indicators support buying into dips", such as NYSE A/D line, a bullish MACD, Dow Theory still is confirming a buy signal, as well as global breadth which still remains bullish.