Showing posts with label National Association of Realtors. Show all posts
Showing posts with label National Association of Realtors. Show all posts

Saturday, November 11, 2017

Hedge Fund Homebuyers In The Hamptons Already Have A Plan To Game Trump"s Mortgage Cap

One of the key changes in the House GOP tax bill was to implement a cap on home interest deductions to the first $500,000 worth of mortgage debt and eliminate  interest deductions from second homes.  Of course, given active opposition from some very powerful realtor and homebuilder lobbying groups, it"s unclear whether the changes will find their way into the final tax bill.  But, at least according to Bloomberg, New York"s "millionaire, billionaire, private jet owning" hedge fund managers aren"t waiting around to find out and are already taking steps to game any potential tax changes.








Out in the Hamptons, Wall Street’s favored beach resort on Long Island, brokers and buyers already have a workaround for a tax-plan provision under consideration in Congress that would take away the mortgage-interest deduction for second homes.


 


A client of Brown Harris Stevens broker Jessica von Hagn who works at a hedge fund decided to turn the vacation home he’s buying into an investment property by setting up a limited liability company. That will allow him to deduct the interest and earn rental income at the height of the season from the modern home on Bridgehampton’s Lumber Lane, with four bedrooms, three baths and a swimming pool on an acre of land.


 


For the buyer: problem solved. For the Hamptons market: more high-end vacation properties getting listed as rentals, more competition and, most likely, falling rents.


 


“If you aren’t able to take advantage of the mortgage deduction for your second home, you’ll see more people putting their homes on the market and the inventory will grow,” von Hagn said. “There’s only a certain number of renters every season and we just keep adding more and more inventory.”


 


Whatever happens with the tax plan, the Bridgehampton buyer isn’t worried. He’s paying more than $2 million for his 3,400-square-foot vacation home, and though he’ll end up spending less time there than he had originally hoped, he figures the rent he’ll earn will more than cover his property taxes and help pay the mortgage.



Hamptons


Of course, it"s not just the Hamptons that would be impacted by the GOP tax bill as brokers in second-home markets across the U.S., from Cape Cod in Massachusetts to Lake Tahoe, California, are bracing for a hit.


A House version of the tax plan, passed by the Ways and Means Committee on Thursday, cuts the mortgage-interest deduction on second homes, and on home-equity loans, which buyers sometimes take out on their primary residence to pay for a vacation property. The Senate’s plan, details of which were released late Thursday, also does away with the home-equity deduction, but preserves the break for second-home mortgages.


That said, realtors, like Tim Bailey in Cape Cod, will undoubtedly call on his powerful lobbying groups to preserve his livelihood which "relies on selling second homes."








Even before any change is passed by Congress, the possibility that the second-home mortgage deduction will be gone is already changing the calculus for some buyers, said Timothy Bailey, a broker with John C. Ricotta & Associates Inc. in the affluent Cape Cod town of Chatham.


 


Bailey said an agent told him that one of her deals, for a $1.5 million vacation property, fell apart over the tax plan.


 


“My whole living relies on selling second homes,” Bailey said. “Because it’s a discretionary purchase, if they lose that deduction, it might be more attractive to rent.”



Of course, as we pointed out recently, this is just more unwelcome news for realtors in a market where buyers favoring lower-priced homes, you know those shacks costing less than $2 million, continued to rise in the third quarter, according to the latest Douglas Elliman Real-Estate Report. This left the high end of the market in a double-bind as supplies of new homes hit the market while sales tapered off...








Purchasers agreed to pay more than the asking price in 10 percent of deals for properties under $3.3 million -- this quarter’s definition of “non-luxury” homes, making up the bottom 90 percent of the market, according to a report Thursday by appraiser Miller Samuel Inc. and brokerage Douglas Elliman Real Estate. It was the biggest share of transactions with bidding wars since the firms began tracking the data in the second quarter of 2016.


 


In their zeal for lower-end deals, buyers snapped up condos as well. Those units -- with a median sale price of $567,500 -- were available for just 97 days on average before going under contract, the fastest clip in six years of record-keeping. On the high-end, buyers showed less interest in acquiring luxury homes than sellers did in listing them. Inventory in that top 10 percent of the market jumped 22 percent, the biggest pile-up in two years.


 


“The market is looking towards those smaller, more manageable homes,” said Carl Benincasa, a regional vice president at Douglas Elliman who oversees sales in the Hamptons. “That’s certainly been a trend we’ve been observing.”



Meanwhile, the real question, at this point, is will this extreme show to aggression towards America"s billionaire class be allowed to stand by the Senate?  What say you?









Thursday, November 9, 2017

The Republican Tax Plan Will Crush These Housing Markets

For the past few weeks, Chuck Schumer and Nancy Pelosi have screamed to anyone who would listen that the GOP tax plan is nothing more than a tax break for millionaires and an attack on middle class working families.  But, as the Wall Street Journal points out this morning, America"s millionaire, billionaire, private jet owners living in expensive urban areas are set to lose "bigly" if Trump"s $500,000 cap on the mortgage interest deduction survives.








But in the priciest markets, concentrated in some of the nation’s largest coastal cities, the impact could be significant. In the San Jose, Calif., metropolitan area, 75% of new mortgage loans thus far in 2017 were for more than $500,000, according to an analysis by CoreLogic Inc., a housing data provider. The median home price there is more than $1 million, and even small starter homes can climb well above the proposed cap.


 


In the San Francisco metro area, 60% of new loans were for more than $500,000, while in Los Angeles and San Diego, the figures were 44% and 37%, respectively.


 


The impact wouldn’t be limited to California. In Honolulu, 48% of loans were greater than $500,000, while the figures for the New York area and Seattle were 22% and 25%, respectively.


 


An analysis by ATTOM Data Solutions yielded similar results. In the Washington, D.C., area, 35% of purchase and refinance loans in 2017 thus far were for more than $500,000. In Hawaii, 15% of loans fell into that category, while in California 12% did.




In addition to capping the mortgage interest deduction, the current GOP bill also limits the amount of property taxes that households can deduct to $10,000 annually.


Not surprisingly, the assault on McMansions has angered the realtor lobby which we"re certain will fight tooth and nail to preserve the status quo.








Jeff Barnett, a California realtor and vice chairman of the National Association of Realtors’ large-firm real-estate services committee, said his area will be hit “very, very hard” if the tax bill passes. Even if corporate tax cuts help boost the economy, he doesn’t think that will be enough to compensate.


 


“You’ve taken away so many incentives for housing, they can’t spend” the money from any extra economic growth, he said.



Of course, as we pointed out earlier this week (see: Trump Is About To Crush Home Prices In Counties That Voted For Hillary: Here"s Why), Clinton won the vote in the top 45 counties in the country with the highest median home prices which has resulted in rampant speculation that the mortgage cap is nothing more than a clever punishment levied on Democratic voters.



As Dennis Lee calculated, "assuming that all of these homeowners are taxed at a marginal rate of 39.6%, we find that the increase in tax burden during the first 12 months of homeownership driven solely by the mortgage interest and property tax deduction caps varies from $0 for the county with the 20th highest median home price (San Miguel County, Colorado) to approximately $7,200 for the highest-priced county (San Francisco County, California)." Barclays" conclusion: these counties - all of which are largely pro-Clinton - would need a 0-11% decline in their median home prices to keep the after-tax monthly mortgage and property tax payments the same for would-be buyers.



Of course, only time will tell whether the swamp (a.k.a. "The National Association of Realtors" in this case) will allow this particular component of the GOP tax bill to survive...









Monday, October 30, 2017

The House Will Reveal Its Tax Bill On Wednesday: Here"s What"s At Stake

Having recently passed a budget as a result of communal efforts between the House and Senate which were notably absent during healthcare reform efforts earlier this year, the stage is set for Congress to enter a very intense multi-week period leading up to Thanksgiving, filled with headlines on tax reform. From a market standpoint, the outcome of this process will determine whether US interest rates continue to go up or retrace the recent increase. Meanwhile, from a purely political perspective, from here the two main questions surrounding tax reform are: what is the process to get from these budget resolutions to actual tax reform and what are the potential pitfalls that Congress needs to avoid in order to successfully pass the bill.


In terms of next steps, the progression from budget resolutions to tax reform is as follows:


  • Having recently passed a 2018 budget, an important step which unlocks "budget reconciliation", or the process by which tax reform can be passed with a simple majority vote, the next step is to write the actual bill; this will be done by the Ways and Means Committee in the House and the Senate Finance Committee in the Senate, likely in unison (much like with the budget resolutions) in an effort to speed up the process. 

  • After it passes the committee vote, it will be brought to the floor for a full vote in the House, which will then be sent to the Senate upon approval.  At this point, the Senate can vote for the bill as is and send to the president’s desk, vote to kill the bill, or they can add amendments to the bill and vote on their new version.  In the latter case where the Senate adds amendments, the new bill will be sent to a “conference committee” of both Senators and House Representatives, in which they would reconcile the bill and send it back to House/Senate for passage and then sent to the President’s desk. 

As noted earlier, the House is now expected to release a draft tax reform bill this Wednesday, November 1.  The content and structure of the bill are of supreme importance and there will be negotiations and amendments following the release of the initial draft.  That said, the initial draft should be very telling, giving insight into the aggressiveness of the cuts, funding measures and where the GOP sees room to compromise.  With a variety of ideas suggested throughout this process, understanding which make it into the actual bill is important; according to Citi, key things to look for include:


  • Are middle-class cuts from the budget framework (like doubling the standard deduction and expanded child tax credits) included?

  • Is the SALT deduction included (or capped in some way)?

  • What level is the corporate tax rate (over/under Trump’s 20% target)

  • Is there a fourth tax bracket (rumblings suggest incomes above 1mm USD would be affected)

  • Is the tax cut retroactive to Jan. 1, 2017?

  • Is there a repatriation deal for money kept overseas?

  • Does it add to the deficit?  If so, how much?

  • Will extraneous issues be slipped into the draft to entice specific voters?
    • Minimum wage hike

    • Border wall funding

    • Debt ceiling compromise

    • Planned parenthood funding


There are a lot of unknowns in this process and any number of discussed (or new) provisions may be added; over the weekend Bloomberg reported that bowing to concerns from Republican House members in high-tax states, the chamber’s chief tax writer said he’ll preserve a federal income-tax break for property taxes.


“At the urging of lawmakers, we are restoring an itemized property tax deduction to help taxpayers with local tax burdens,” House Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady said in a statement Saturday afternoon.


In a sign of the complex balancing act that Brady must perform to produce a tax-overhaul bill this week, the property-tax announcement came on the same day that the National Association of Home Builders pulled its support for the legislation. The group’s chief cited concerns that the bill might undermine existing tax breaks that support the housing market. Likewise, a coalition that includes the National Association of Realtors said in an emailed statement that it “will vigorously oppose this plan.”


The removal of the so-called SALT provision means that Congressional leaders will need to find an alternative way of finding as much as $1.3 trillion over 10 years - revenue that would help offset the deep tax-rate cuts they want for businesses and individuals. Restoring the property-tax deduction would trim that revenue projection by about a third - or $430 billion - said a conservative tax lobbyist who asked not to be named because discussions about the bill were private.


And yet, adding to the confusion, it would appear that deductions for state and local income taxes and sales taxes would still be repealed under the planned House bill.


As Bloomberg reported moments ago, the confusion is so great that corporate tax cuts may have to be staggered reaching the 20% threshold over a matter of years:


  • PLAN WOULD CUT CORPORATE RATE GRADUALLY, REACHING 20% IN 2022

Regardless of the details of the final bill, the important question for the market is whether or not meaningful corporate and individual tax cuts will be enacted; Citi believes that the answer "is a resounding yes – and it will happen sooner rather than later."








Given the speed and determination with which the GOP passed the budget resolutions and the general agreement regarding the details and necessity of passing tax reform (both economically and politically), I have little doubt that Republicans will find a way to compromise.  I can comfortably predict tax reform becomes law before the end of 2017, with an eye towards the first week in December. 



Finally, there is the question whether today"s Manafort charges could derail tax reform.  Addressing that issue, Paul Ryan said in a radio interview that “nothing’s going to derail what we’re working on in Congress" adding that he feels good about Senate votes for tax bill as the outline of the plan has already been discussed with senators.









Tuesday, August 29, 2017

Housing Bubble 2.0: Home Equity Loans Soar To Highest Level Since 2008

It seems as though the practice of using one"s home as a personal ATM machine is making a "yuge" comeback of late thanks, at least in part, to the same aggressive lending terms and attractive teaser rates that nearly sank the world economy just under a decade ago.  According the Wall Street Journal and Equifax, home equity originations soared to $46 billion in 2Q 2017, the highest level since the market collapsed in 2008.





“If customers feel like their home values are stable or increasing, and if they feel like their job prospects are good—that they will have the ability to pay back a loan they take—then they will start to take out more home-equity lines,” said Mike Kinane, head of U.S. consumer-lending products at TD Bank. “That is what we are starting to see.”



Home-equity line originations rose 8% to nearly $46 billion in the second quarter, their highest level since 2008, according to credit-reporting firm Equifax . Borrowing via cash-out mortgage refinances hit $15 billion, up 6% from a year earlier, according to recent data from Freddie Mac.



The main engine driving demand: rising home prices. The median sale price of an existing home rose to $263,800 in June, the highest on record, up 40% from $187,900 at the start of 2014, according to the National Association of Realtors.



HOme Equity



But, don"t worry because the banks and loan officers re-inflating the housing bubble are here to assure you that it"s all different this time around...





Banks insist the increased borrowing doesn’t herald a return to housing-bubble days when consumers came to view their homes as cash registers. Banks say they are being more cautious in how they make such loans and some add they are encouraging borrowers to tackle renovations or consolidate debt—uses that are considered investments rather than luxuries.



“We continue to watch what’s going on and the way it’s being done, but it’s much different from before the crisis,” said Tom Wind, head of U.S. Bancorp ’s home-mortgage division. Mr. Wind added that the bank expects this type of borrowing to keep rebounding because the equity in people’s homes is “meaningful and people want things like renovations.”



...because home prices appreciating at over 5x inflation is just "normal."




But perhaps the best example of why "this time is different" is illustrated by the case study of Marc Yu of Atlanta who took out a home equity loan on his family"s home just so he could afford the down payment on an "investment property".  See, completely different this time.





Marc Yu took out a home-equity line to buy an investment property, a house he now rents out at a profit. He has thought about paying off the line early, but instead decided to keep it open as long as interest rates stay relatively low.



“I wanted to use the equity” in the first house, rather than “it just sitting there,” said Mr. Yu, who works in digital forensics in the Atlanta area.



Seems like we"ve seen this movie before...

Thursday, July 20, 2017

Purchases Of US Real Estate By Foreigners Hit All-Time High In 2016

In a testament to Chinese oligarchs, criminals, money launderers and pretty much anyone who is desperate to park their cash as far away from the mainland as possible, purchases of US real estate by foreign buyers surged to an all-time high in 2016, according to data from the National Association of Realtors via CNBC.


Foreign purchases of US residential real estate surged to the highest level ever in terms of number of homes sold and dollar volume last year, with Chinese buyers leading the pack, followed by buyers from Canada, the United Kingdom, Mexico and India. Meanwhile, Russian buyers made up barely 1 percent of the purchases.


Foreign buyers closed on $153 billion worth of US residential properties between April 2016 and March 2017, a 49 percent jump from the period a year earlier, according to the NAR. That surpasses the previous high, set in 2015. Foreign sales accounted for 10 percent of all existing home sales by dollar volume and 5 percent by number of properties. In total, foreign buyers purchased 284,455 homes, up 32 percent from the previous year.



According to CNBC, the increase in home sales comes as a surprise, given the dollar’s relatively expensive valuation versus both developed and emerging-market currencies. Half of all foreign sales were in just three states: Florida, California and Texas.


Aging Canadians buying property in Florida and other warmer climates were responsible for the largest increase of buying activity from any one country.





“But the biggest overall surge in sales in the last year came from Canadian buyers, who scooped up $19 billion worth of properties, mostly in Florida. They are also spending more, with the average price of a Canadian-bought home nearly doubling to $561,000.



‘There are more [baby] boomers now than ever before. It"s the demographic,’ said Elli Davis, a real estate agent in Toronto who said she is seeing more older buyers downsize their primary home and purchase a second or third home in Florida. ‘The real estate here is worth so much more money. They all have more money. They"re selling the big city houses that are now $2 million-plus, where they went up so much in the last 10 to 15 years, so they"re cashing in.’”



Mexican buyers nearly doubled their purchases by dollar volume from a year earlier, coming in third behind China and Canada. Though Adam DeSanctis, economic issues media manager at the National Association of Realtors, said "you could easily make the point that perhaps their uptick was wanting to buy now before new immigration policy was in place.”



In general, though, Mexicans have been buying less expensive homes.





“The average purchase price of buyers from Mexico came in at about $327,000, compared with the $782,000 average among Chinese buyers and $522,000 for Indian buyers. Mexicans overwhelmingly favored homes in Texas, while Chinese buyers opted more for California and, increasingly, Texas.



‘The environment is much more Asian-friendly than it used to be with churches, grocery stores and schools that cater to their tastes,’ said Laura Barnett, a Dallas-Fort Worth area Re/Max agent. ‘I have been told they target good schools and newer homes. Yards are not a high priority, but rather community parks.’”



In a sign that home valuations in America’s most populous state might be nearing a peak, some Chinese are being priced out of California, forcing them to buy property in...Texas.





“It"s also possible that Chinese buyers are being priced out of California. The average price of a home purchased by a buyer from China fell from about $937,000 to $782,000, even as the number of properties purchased jumped to nearly 41,000 from 29,000. The drop in purchasing power likely stems from tightened regulations in China with regards to capital outflow.”



As we’ve reported, Chinese authorities trying to stem the capital flooding out of their country adopted new currency controls specifically aimed at stopping Chinese nationals from illegally repurposing money to buy real estate. Those took effect early this year. Because of the new restrictions, CNBC says Chinese demand is beginning to wane – which could be catastrophic for home prices. Luxury markets in cities like New York City are already struggling with high vacancy rates. The recovery in home prices since the crisis has been uneven, but expensive coastal markets like New York and San Francisco experienced massive home-price inflation as younger Americans flocked to urban areas. However, if foreign demand weakens, these markets could be poised for a crash as fewer residents can afford to own their homes.


And of course, there’s the Trump factor…





"Stricter foreign government regulations and the current uncertainty on policy surrounding U.S. immigration and international trade policy could very well lead to a slowdown in foreign investment," said Lawrence Yun, chief economist for the NAR.



But if Chinese oligarchs are now out of the US real-estate game, who’s going to pay $150 million for this 14-acre parcel of beachfront property in the Hamptons?