Showing posts with label Canadian government. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Canadian government. Show all posts

Thursday, December 21, 2017

In Unexpected Move, Trump Enacts Obama-era Law Opening US Arms Sales To Ukraine

After years of covert American involvement in the Ukrainian proxy and civil war which has raged since 2014 - and which a leaked recording confirmed was precipitated by the US State Department - President Trump has decided to come off the fence regarding his prior reluctance to formally approve arms sales to the Kiev government. Late Wednesday the Washington Post first reported the bombshell news that after months of indecision over whether or not to move forward with Obama-era legislation which initially paved the way for legalizing US arms sales to Ukraine, Trump has approved the first ever US commercial sale of weapons to the war-torn country.


According to The Washington Post, "administration officials confirmed that the State Department this month approved a commercial license authorizing the export of Model M107A1 Sniper Systems, ammunition, and associated parts and accessories to Ukraine, a sale valued at $41.5 million. These weapons address a specific vulnerability of Ukrainian forces fighting a Russian-backed separatist movement in two eastern provinces. There has been no approval to export the heavier weapons the Ukrainian government is asking for, such as Javelin antitank missiles."



Image via News Front


Though WaPo"s Josh Rogin characterizes the decision as intended to appease hawks while seeking to avoid broader conflict escalation based on "limited arms sales" (and not approving some of the heavier weaponry sought by Kiev), the move is likely to further ratchet up tensions with Russia, which is ironic for the fact that the decision comes the same week that former Director of National Intelligence James Clapper said that Russian President Vladimir Putin appears to be handling Trump like "an asset". Or perhaps we will be assured this is just more 4-dimensional chess playing between Trump and Putin to prove that not Putin but the Military Industrial Complex is once again "unexpectedly" in charge? 


Going back to nearly the start of the conflict, the US and EU have leveled increasingly harsh sanctions on Russia - first on individuals, companies, and banks - and then on Russian defense and energy sectors operating in relation to the Crimea. The US has long accused Russia of destabilizing the former Soviet republic along its southwest border, while Moscow credits American and European with engineering the Euromaidan coup in order to weaken Russian influence and suppress Russian-speaking minorities in Ukraine"s east. 


Congressional anti-Russia hawks have long sought greater long-term military engagement along Russia"s European border, especially after the May 2014 referendum which saw the pro-Russian Ukrainian regions of Donetsk and Luhansk declare independence from Kiev. And though Congress originally authorized weapons sales via the Ukraine Freedom Support Act signed into law in December 2014, the Obama administration never made the decision to actually follow through on the legislation.


Senator Bob Corker is one such original co-sponsor of the legislation, who told the Washington Post concerning Trump"s decision to move forward, “I’m pleased the administration approved the sale of defensive lethal arms to Ukraine.” And he added, “This decision was supported by Congress in legislation that became law three years ago and reflects our country’s longstanding commitment to Ukraine in the face of ongoing Russian aggression.”


Concerning the impetus behind internal White House deliberations to move on the issue, the Washington Post reports:


Another senior Trump administration official said that Trump personally approved the decision to allow the issuing of the license after being presented a decision memo by Defense Secretary Jim Mattis and Secretary of State Rex Tillerson. While there was never a formal ban on such weapons transfers, the decision was discussed internally as a lifting of the de facto Obama administration restrictions, the official said.



And while somewhat soft-peddling the significance of the decision in terms of on the ground escalation in Ukraine, WaPo admits that this likely means the floodgates are now open on multi-national weapons exports to Ukraine, especially as it coincides with a similar measure approved by Canada earlier this week. The WaPo report continues:


“We have crossed the Rubicon, this is lethal weapons and I predict more will be coming,” said one senior congressional official. It’s likely no mere coincidence that Canada also approved lethal defense sales to Ukraine this week, which would happen only if the Canadian government knew the United States was on board, the official said.


 


The Trump administration notified leading congressional committees of the sale on Dec. 13 but didn’t make any public announcements, which some say reflects the sensitivity of the decision and concern about how it will be received by Trump supporters who long opposed the move, as well as by Putin.



Meanwhile, as the Washington Post also affirms, fighting in eastern Ukraine is heating up after a period of relative Western media silence on the war. And likely with this announcement it will return to the media spotlight. 


During the presidential campaign Trump appeared to take a more conciliatory tone on the Ukraine and Russia issue, repeatedly stating that he would work with Putin to resolve the crisis while at the same time he resisted Republican efforts to include more aggressive language endorsing lethal assistance to Ukraine as part of the GOP platform.









Saturday, December 16, 2017

Bank of Canada Governor Is Right To Be Worried About The Economy

 


Bank of Canada Governor Is Right To Be Worried About The Economy


Written by Peter Diekmeyer, Sprott Money News


 


 



Stephen Poloz Right To Be Worried - Peter Diekmeyer

 


Bank of Canada governor Stephen Poloz cited numerous worries plaguing the economy during his speech to Toronto’s financial elites yesterday at the prestigious Canadian Club.





However, the title of Poloz’s presentation, “Three things keeping me awake at night” seemed odd, given positive recent Canadian employment, GDP and other data.





Poloz highlighted high personal debts, housing prices, cryptocurrencies and other causes for concern, along with actions that the BoC is taking to alleviate them. His implicit message was (as always) “We have things under control.”





But if that’s all true, then Canada’s central bank governor should be sleeping like a baby. So, what is really keeping Mr. Poloz up at night? Three possibilities come to mind.





The Poloz Bubble




Firstly, far from just a housing bubble, Canada’s economy shows signs of being in the midst of an “everything bubble.” Bitcoin, for example, hovered near CDN $23,000 this week. Stock and bond valuations are not far behind in their relative loftiness.





Worse for Poloz, who took office four years ago, his fingerprints are all over those bubble-like levels.





Canadian stock, bond and house prices were already at dizzying heights when Stephen Harper hired Poloz with the implicit expectation that he would juice up the economy, in preparation for what Canada’s then-Prime Minister knew would be a tough upcoming election.





Poloz didn’t disappoint, promptly delivering a nice Benjamin Strong-styled “coup de whiskey” to asset prices in the form of two interest rate cuts, which brought the BoC’s policy rate down to just 0.50% during the ensuing months.





Although Harper lost the election, loose BoC policy continues to provide the Canadian government with free money to borrow and spend as it wishes.





More broadly, the Poloz BoC’s current policy, like that of the US Federal Reserve, is to boost asset prices even higher in the hope that the resulting wealth effect will trickle down to spur economic activity among ordinary Canadians.






 


At the household level, the BoC’s low interest rates enticed Canadian families to borrow themselves to the hilt. Businesses haven’t been that far behind.





The upshot is that total government, private sector and personal debts are now in nosebleed territory with Canada’s economy seemingly on a knife’s edge, in danger of crumbling at the first patch of rough road.





Chained to a Ponzi




Another worry is that the Poloz BoC, by broadly mirroring the Federal Reserve’s actions, has firmly lashed Canada to a US economy which could prove to be an even bigger Ponzi than its own.





America’s “everything bubble”, like Canada’s, has been stroked by a central bank that has been pushing credit growth at a rate faster than GDP growth, a textbook Ponzi scenario.




 




 


One result, as Grant Williams, co-founder of Real Vision Television, noted in a recent presentation, is that US stock prices are currently far higher than they were during the Internet and housing bubbles. “[Central bankers] keep hoping that this time is different,” Williams warned. “But ladies and gentlemen – it’s never different.”





Refusal to ring fence Canada




Another worry for Poloz to ponder, is that although the BoC has identified financial system interconnectedness as a key concern, the central bank has done little to ring fence Canada’s economy from huge global macro threats on the horizon.





That’s particularly true of the hundreds of trillions of dollars in global derivatives books, many of which are unquantifiable, as they are trading outside of traditional exchanges. This threat is particularly acute, as it was the failure of AIG, a derivatives player, to cover its bets (not the subprime mortgage and Lehman implosions as most assume) that sparked the 2008 financial crisis.





Poloz, had he been ready to condone a recession, could have encouraged broader interest rate hikes to incentivize Canadian governments, businesses and households to pay down debts, build up savings and increase overall system stability.





Similarly, instead of building up Canada’s gold reserves to cushion against potential external shocks, the supposedly-independent BoC (as noted above) gives the money it prints to the big banks and the Canadian government to help it finance raises for politicians and bureaucrats.





Government and academic elites would argue that Poloz’s actions are understandable as he has only limited powers. They cite key constraints on the central bank’s actions.





These range from the BoC’s agreement with the Department of Finance to target 2% inflation, the fact that the government has primary authority over foreign exchange purchases and by realpolitik which dictates that Canada has to follow US policies – or else.





Tied to discredited Keynesian econometrics




Others, such as James Rickards, author of The Road to Ruin, would argue that Poloz is plagued with the same “group think” problem that faces Fed Chairmen.





Almost all the top economists these days, despite obvious brilliance, remain trapped by Keynesian/econometrics educations they endured to get their graduate degrees, which left them with few ideas regarding how to generate growth other than to print more money.





Canada’s top central banker rarely deviates from his talking points. So, it’s almost impossible to know what he really thinks.





However, a base case scenario suggests that Poloz (who has considerable private sector experience from his days at BCA Research) knows full well the treacherous position in which the BoC has placed the Canadian economy.





If that’s true, it’s little wonder that he is having trouble sleeping.


 


 


 


Questions or comments about this article? Leave your thoughts HERE.


 


 


 


 


Bank of Canada Governor Is Right To Be Worried About The Economy




Written by Peter Diekmeyer, Sprott Money News


 


 


Check out these other articles by our contributors:




Bitcoin Proves You Cannot Have Your Digital Cake and Eat it Too - Nathan McDonald


Political Pizza - Jeff Thomas


For Clues On The Economy, Follow The Money - Dave Kranzler




Eric Sprott Talks Lows in Gold, Comex Shenanigans, and Answers Your Questions (Weekly Wrap-Up, December 15, 2017)


 

Wednesday, September 27, 2017

UK Slams Tariffs On Bombardier: "This Is Not What We Expect From A Long-Term Partner"

It appears the Commerce Department"s preliminary ruling, issued late last night, to slap a 220% tariff on Canadian aircraft manufacturer Bombardier could trigger an all-out trade war between the UK and Canada (on one side) and the US (on the other) as public officials in the UK and Canada blasted the ruling and threatened retaliation should the sanctions, which still need to be approved by the US International Trade Commission, become permanent.


Earlier today, the Commerce Department ruled that Bombardier"s jets should face the levy because the company received anticompetitive government subsidies. The ruling comes after Boeing said the Bombardier C-Series jet would not exist without hundreds of millions of dollars in launch funding from the governments of Canada and Britain, or a $2.5 billion equity infusion from the province of Quebec and its largest pension fund in 2015. Boeing brought the complaint after Delta Air Lines agreed in April 2016 to purchase 75 C-Series jets, an order worth some $5 billion.


The preliminary ruling - which comes as the US, Canada and Mexico are holding their fourth meeting to renegotiate Nafta - has met with praise from Boeing, and criticism from virtually everybody else involved.



The UK, which does a brisk business with Boeing, is threatening to cut ties with the company if the decision against Bombardier is finalized. The reason? Bombardier has a large plant in Belfast, employing some 4,200 people in Northern Ireland, a region that the UK"s ruling conservative party relies on heavily for support. If Bombardier, which is already struggling, takes another hit, those people could lose their jobs, potentially threatening the conservatives" tenuous grip on power after losing their majority in snap elections over the summer, according to Reuters. 


UK Defense Minister Michael Fallon said in a TV interview today that the ruling could jeapordize Boeing"s business relationship with the UK government.





“This is not the behavior we expect from Boeing and it could indeed jeopardize our future relationship with them,” British Defence Secretary Michael Fallon told reporters in Belfast at a briefing in the historic Harland & Wolff shipyard, a few hundred yards from the Bombardier plant.



“Boeing has significant defense contracts with us and still expects to win further contracts. Boeing wants and we want a long term partnership but that has to be two way.”



“Boeing is an important investor in the United Kingdom and an important employer in the United Kingdom but we would prefer this kind of issue to be settled on a negotiated basis,” Fallon said.


“This is not the kind of behavior that we expect from a long-term partner and I’ve made that very clear to Boeing,” Fallon told reporters.




Britain recently ordered the Boeing P-8 maritime surveillance plane and a new fleet of Apache attack helicopters. Its armed forces have deployed Chinook helicopters, the C-17 transport plane and the E-3 Sentry airborne early warning and command post.


Meanwhile, British Business Secretary Greg Clark said on Wednesday he was confident he would be able to have the U.S. anti-subsidy complaint against Bombardier dismissed.





“We’ve been working very closely with the Canadian government to make it clear that this is a complaint that is unjustified,” Clark told Sky TV.



“What needs to happen now by the trade commission is that they look to see whether there has been any detriment to Boeing,” he added.



“There hasn’t been because this aircraft does not compete with Boeing so we’re confident that we will be able to demonstrate that and have this case dismissed.”



Threatening language aside, the Gaurdian points out that Boeing has substantial leverage should the UK act to curtail its business relationship with the defense contractor. Boeing employs or supports more than 10,000 jobs in the UK; any tit-for-tat retaliation could affect them.




Even the labor party, which isn"t politically dependent on Northern Ireland and thus has less of an incentive to care about the potential closure of a Bombardier plant there, has joined in the Boeing bashing. Labour leader Jeremy Corbyn has just told his party conference in Brighton that the tariffs imposed on Bombardier planes threaten “thousands of jobs”. He called on Prime Minister Theresa May to leverage her "special relationship" with the US to try and protect workers in Northern Ireland.





"Thousands of jobs are now at stake...a Prime minister is betting our economic future on a deregulated trade deal with the US might want to take a moment to explain how 220% tarifsf are going to boost our exports from this country."



Of course, once the ITC issues its ruling, the Trump administration will have the final say on tariffs. Will May"s relationship with the president be enough to save Bombardier? Or will Trump side with Boeing and spin the tariffs as a bid to protect US workers - throwing red meat to his base in the process?


What do you think?

Saturday, September 16, 2017

Stossel slams BOC Alt-Media ban: "Be nice or we kick you out."

Contributed by Sprott Money


Original available here:



Stossel, Moen Weigh In on Bank of Canada Free Market Economist, Alt-media Ban - Peter Diekmeyer


September 15, 2017



Criticism continues to mount in the wake of the Bank of Canada’s exclusion of free market
economists and the two-tier media strategy it implemented for a key policy-making conference, held yesterday in Ottawa.


The conference’s goal was to air out preliminary issues related to the BOC’s inflation-control
agreement with the Canadian government, which is renewed every five years.


Canada’s monetary policy politburo, which, through its interest rate policies, sets or influences
prices throughout the economy, is currently reflecting on how much more it
will ask ordinary Canadians to pay for their food, clothing and shelter during
the coming years.


Stossel: the establishment protects itself


However, there were few ordinary Canadians to be seen at the BOC workshop, which was essentially paneled
by bureaucrats, university professors and other government-financed officials.


“The establishment protects itself,” said John Stossel, a Fox News contributor, who was in town to address the
Montreal Economics Institute about the perils of central planning.
“People have become comfortable with the idea of a few old men setting public
policy in a back room.”


The long-time investigative journalist, author and consumer activist, who has followed
government closely for decades, was more nuanced regarding the Bank of Canada’s
ban on alternative media.


“I can understand their reasoning,” said Stossel. “You can’t really have a rabble disturbing things.”


BOC to MSM: be nice or we will kick you out


Stossel was more concerned about the message the BOC ban sends to mainstream media, such as the
Wall Street Journal and Bloomberg News, who were given preferential
access to the policy event.


“That’s a club that all governments have,” said Stossel, who recently began contributing to
Reason TV, a US-based free markets
web-cast. “It’s “be nice or we will kick you out.” The White House does that
too.”


Tim Moen, leader of the Libertarian Party of Canada, also broke his silence on the issue by
issuing a strong condemnation.


“The Bank of Canada is suffering from a real lack of free market input,” Moen wrote on a party-affiliated social media page. “It"s probably naive to imagine an institution charged with centrally planned
money creation would want input from critics.”




A perfect time to look “outside the box”


Surprisingly, one of the most obvious free market voices that the Bank of Canada ignored during
its consultation process came to the central bank’s defence.


“The reality is that most top monetary policy experts already work at central banks or at
university research departments that accept their ideas,” said David Howden, academic vice-president at the Mises Institute of Canada, and author of numerous papers dealing with monetary policy from a free markets
perspective.


“The bad news is that central banks are forced to refer to the same specialists over and over
again,” said Howden, who is currently working on a paper dealing with central
bank balance sheet analysis. “The fact that the current process is a multi-year
reflection makes it especially important that they consult outside opinions and
not rely on the presumption that the current framework is OK.”


Howden cited George Bragues, a professor at the University of Guelph-Humber, as one
example of an “outside the box” thinker who the BOC might have consulted.


A return to a gold standard?


Ironically, Stossel, who admits to not being a monetary expert nor an expert on Canada, has
offered interesting advice on the subject in the past.


“(Americans) should learn from Canada,” he wrote back in 2013. “The Canadians had no central bank when the Great Depression began, just
private banks issuing currency backed by gold. During the 1930s, not even one
Canadian bank failed. Thousands failed in the U.S.”


Stossel, who during his many years at ABC was regarded as one of America’s top
reporters, may be right. But a cursory glance suggests that they don’t make Canadians like they used to.


They don’t make economists the way they used to either.

Wednesday, August 23, 2017

Justin Trudeau To Refugees: There's "No Advantage" To Entering Canada Illegally

Eight months.


That’s how long it took for Canadian Prime Minister and liberal hero Justin Trudeau to realize his promise to welcome all immigrants and refugees to Canada may have been a little short-sighted. After the prime minister proudly proclaimed on Twitter back in January that Canada would welcome all those fleeing “persecution and war,” the prime minister changed his tone this week when he warned refugees crossing into Canada from the US that sneaking into the country illegally wouldn"t fast-track the process of granting asylum.



In the months that have passed since Trudeau made his famous promise, the number of refugees streaming over the border into the Canadian province of Quebec surged dramatically, straining local resources available to process their claims of asylum and provide necessities like food and shelter. The asylum seekers are primarily Haitians who fear that the Trump administration might revoke a special protected status implemented after the 2010 earthquake.



Here’s Trudeau, who was speaking at - of all places - a news conference before Montreal’s Pride parade:  





"If I could directly speak to people seeking asylum, I"d like to remind them there"s no advantage," Trudeau said at a news conference Sunday in Montreal.



"Our rules, our principles and our laws apply to everyone."



Trudeau also stressed that anyone seeking refugee status will have to go through Canada"s "rigorous" screening process.



The surge of migrants has overwhelmed both the Canadian legal system and the capabilities of local agencies tasked with aiding refugees. We reported earlier this month that Canada sent soldiers to a popular crossing site in upstate New York to help build a small encampment for newly arriving refugees. But beads have quickly filled up. According to CBC News, more than 3,800 people walked over the border into the province during the first two weeks of August, compared to the 2,996 who crossed throughout all of July.


As CBC notes, Unlike in the United States, Haitians have no special status in Canada, and about half of Haitians seeking refugee status in Canada have already been denied during the past couple of years.


Trudeau critic Michelle Rempel said the Canadian government too willingly ignored the brewing refugee crisis on its doorstep, and continues to play down the need to deal with the problem.  





“Conservative immigration critic Michelle Rempel said Trudeau is downplaying the urgent need to deal with the surge in people crossing the border.



"They knew it was going to be a problem this summer. And their response has been building tent cities on the U.S./Canada border," she said in an interview with CBC News."



Too help alleviate the problem, Rempel says the federal government should increase funding for the IRB, the board that evaluates all asylum claims. Even before the surge at the border, the IRB was hopelessly backlogged, ensuring that claimants could remain in the country in a legal limbo while they waited for their hearing.


Allowing the department to process claims more quickly would remove this incentive for asylum seekers to cross illegally.


Still, given his professed love for immigration and multiculturalism, we wonder just how far Trudeau will go to stanch the tide of refugees. Will there be more soldiers and more camps? Or will Trudeau hire an army of claims processers to start kicking people out of the country – or at least ensure that those allowed to remain deserve to do so?


One thing"s for sure: He"s going to need to do something.
 

Friday, August 11, 2017

Canada Sends Soldiers To Popular Border Crossing

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau should probably stop telling refugees that “everybody is welcome in Canada,” after his vow to protect asylum seekers inspired thousands of migrants to journey north across the US-Canada border, fearing deportation should they remain in the states following the election of President Donald Trump.


The influx of migrants has overwhelmed the ability of local and federal agencies to process and provide for the newcomers, leaving many in an uncomfortable legal limbo as they wait for their hearing dates. In recent months, thousands of Haitian asylum seekers have crossed into Quebec following Trump’s threat to remove the temporary protected status granted to nearly 60,000 Haitians living in the US following Haiti’s 2010 earthquake. Of the 4,345 people who either sought asylum at the Canadian border or were intercepted by police in the first six months of 2017, 3,350 were recorded in Quebec.



With the pace of new arrivals increasing, the federal government is being forced to take action.


According to the Associated Press, the Canadian government has dispatched soldiers to a remote back road connecting Quebec with upstate New York. The site has become a popular route for migrants, with more than 400 crossing on Sunday alone.



The military will assist the Royal Canadian Mounted Police and the Canadian Border Service agency in constructing a registration center complete with tents that can house close to 500 people at the site.


The site will function as a point of entry where asylum seekers are processed and turned over to the government. Soldiers will not play a security role, according to the AP.


Once the settlement is finished, only a few will stay behind. The rest will go back to their home base.



The decision to construct the makeshift shelter comes as Quebec is running out of space to house the migrants.


Local officials recently opened a temporary shelter in Montreal’s Olympic Stadium as they scramble to meet the demand for beds, with some local aid workers telling the Montreal Gazette that government-funded aid programs are “close to their limits.”  


It appears that, with local agencies straining under the workload, Trudeau has come through with some federal aid. But when will the progressive iconic and frequent Trump antagonist realize that Canada has simply taken in too many migrants?
 

Sunday, July 16, 2017

Canada's Multi-Million-Dollar Pay-Out To A 'Foreign Terrorist Fighter'

Authored by Ruthie Blum via The Gatestone Institute,


  • "Has any soldier who fought FOR Canada ever received as generous a reward as this soldier who fought against us?" — Canadian Senator Linda Frum.

  • In 2003, Khadr confessed to throwing the grenade that killed U.S. Special Forces Sgt. 1st Class Christopher Speer and caused Sgt. 1st Class Layne Morris to lose an eye. Years later, he retracted his confession, claiming it had been extracted under duress. In fact, it was part of a plea deal that enabled him to be extradited to Canada to serve the rest of his sentence there.

  • "There was a Canadian flag flying along with the American flag at our base there, so it"s quite a thing that now Canada is giving millions to a guy who would attack a compound where Canadians were serving. I don"t see this as anything but treason. As far as I am concerned, Prime Minister Trudeau should be charged." — Sgt. 1st Class Layne Morris, who lost an eye from the grenade thrown by Omar Khadr.

The government of Canada recently issued an official apology -- and acknowledged awarding an "undisclosed" sum of money -- to Toronto-born Islamist terrorist Omar Khadr for his "ordeal" at the U.S. military base in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and "any resulting harm" he was caused by the "torture" (specifically, sleep deprivation, solitary confinement and threats) that led to his confession.


On July 7, Canadian Foreign Minister Chrystia Freeland and Minister of Public Safety and Emergency Preparedness Ralph Goodale released a statement announcing the "hope that this expression, and the negotiated settlement reached with the Government, will assist him in his efforts to begin a new and hopeful chapter in his life with his fellow Canadians."


The civil settlement was reached with Khadr, 30, who was 10 when his family returned to the Middle East, and 15 when he was arrested fighting in Afghanistan with al Qaeda and the Taliban, the terrorist organizations to which his father was affiliated -- on the basis of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.


In 2003, Khadr confessed to throwing the grenade that killed U.S. Special Forces Sgt. 1st Class Christopher Speer and caused Sgt. 1st Class Layne Morris to lose an eye. Years later, he retracted his confession, claiming it had been extracted under duress. In fact, it was part of a plea deal that enabled him to be extradited to Canada to serve the rest of his sentence there.


With news of the large settlement he received -- 10,500,000 Canadian dollars (approximately USD $8,000,000) -- he gave an extensive interview to CBC"s Power & Politics host Rosemary Barton, in which he said he thinks that the apology from the Canadian government "restores a little bit my reputation here in Canada, and I think that"s the biggest thing for me." He declined to comment on having just received multi-millions in tax-free dollars.


He also had the effrontery to say that he just wants "to be a normal person" and finish his nursing degree to help under-served communities. "I have a lot of experience with... and appreciation of pain," he explained, expressing only sorrow that the Speer and Morris families consider him responsible for their own pain.


Amid harsh criticism against the Liberal government by opposition Conservatives and members of the public outraged that their tax dollars are going to a convicted terrorist, Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau responded to reporters" questions on the matter during a press conference marking the July 8 close of G20 summit in Hamburg.


Trudeau said that the settlement had nothing to do with Khadr"s 2002 actions on the battlefield in Afghanistan, but rather with the fact that his rights had been violated. This is precisely what the Canadian Supreme Court ruled in 2008 and 2010, after Khadr"s lawyers sued for damages.


Trudeau added that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms protects all Canadians, "even when it is uncomfortable. When the government violates any Canadian"s Charter rights, we all end up paying for it."


Meanwhile, Goodale tried to evade responsibility, by casting aspersions on the previous government, headed by Conservative Prime Minister Stephen Harper, in power when Khadr was returned to Canada in 2012 to serve the remainder of his prison sentence for five counts of war crimes. Goodale accused Harper of having "refused to repatriate Mr. Khadr or otherwise resolve the matter."


In spite of the fact that Khadr was arrested and detained when Liberal governments were in power in Canada, Goodale was referring to appeals during Harper"s tenure -- which began in 2006 -- by Canadian Liberal and human rights lawyers to "bring Omar Khadr home."


In 2008, former Canadian Justice Minister Irwin Cotler wrote:





"I join other scholars and associations of jurists in calling for Omar Khadr to be transferred into the custody of Canadian law enforcement officials, to be afforded due process under Canadian law, with prospects for appropriate rehabilitation and integration."



Cotler also stated,





"Admittedly, the Khadr family has emerged, as some have put it, as synonymous with terrorism. But, the test of the rule of law is not its application in the easy cases, but its retention in the unpopular ones... Omar Khadr, a child victim, should now be afforded the justice denied him all these years, however unpopular and unpalatable his case may appear to be."



In response to Goodale"s implication that had it not been for the previous government, the current one would not have been forced to apologize to and pay Khadr, Harper immediately took to social media, writing:





The government today attempted to lay blame elsewhere for their decision to conclude a secret deal with Omar Khadr. The decision to enter into this deal is theirs, and theirs alone, and it is simply wrong. Canadians deserve better than this. Today my thoughts are with Tabitha Speer and the families of all Canadian and allied soldiers who paid the ultimate price fighting to protect us.



Canadian Senator Linda Frum railed against the settlement, tweeting: "Has any soldier who fought FOR Canada ever received as generous a reward as this soldier who fought against us?"


Given Khadr"s family history, Frum"s fury is justified.


As the New York Post reported, Khadr is the son of a Palestinian mother and an Egyptian father (Ahmed Khadr), who had strong ties to the Muslim Brotherhood, and became one of Osama bin Laden"s loyal lieutenants. After 9/11, Ahmed Khadr was placed on the FBI"s most-wanted list in relations to the attacks. He was arrested in Pakistan in 1995 on suspicion of financing the suicide bombing at the Egyptian Embassy in Islamabad, in which 16 people were killed. Protesting his innocence, he went on a hunger strike, and the Canadian government, then headed by Liberal Prime Minister Jean Chrétien, rallied behind him.


While on a trade mission to Pakistan, Chrétien appealed to Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto, and a few months later, Ahmed was released from prison and sent back with his family to Toronto. However, according to the New York Post, the Khadr clan soon returned to Pakistan, where Ahmed Khadr resumed his connections with al Qaeda and the Taliban. Young Omar Khadr not only met with the leaders of these terrorist groups, but lived with his parents and siblings in the bin Laden family compound, attending al Qaeda training camps, which his father -- who was killed in 2003 -- partly funded.


The report continued:





"A month before he joined an al Qaeda cell in 2002, Omar was sent by his father for private instruction in explosives and combat... [where he] learned to launch rocket-propelled grenades and became skilled at planting improvised explosive devices that were used to blow up US armored vehicles in Afghanistan."



In his interrogation about the incident that led to his arrest and subsequent incarceration at Guantanamo, Omar Khadr said he had been on a suicide mission "to kill as many Americans as possible."



In this still image taken from a video found in the rubble of the compound where Omar Khadr was captured on July 27, 2002, a 15-year-old Khadr constructs an improvised explosive device. (Courtesy U.S. Defense Operations/Wikimedia Commons)


This did not prevent the U.S. military from flying an ophthalmologist to the Bagram Air Base -- where was being treated for wounds he sustained while fighting American and Canadian soldiers -- to save his eyes and keep him from going blind.


Nor did it cause Omar to experience gratitude on the one hand, or remorse on the other. On the contrary, as military court documents revealed, when he was informed that Speer had died, he said he "felt happy" for having murdered an American. He also said that whenever he remembered killing Speer, it would make him "feel good."


According to a report in the Globe and Mail, the Toronto lawyer representing Morris and Tabitha Speer -- who won a default judgment in 2015 in the U.S. against Omar for $134 million – began proceedings to contest the Canadian government"s settlement and prevent it from going forward.


It is clearly too late for that; the money has already been transferred to Omar. Furthermore, the transaction was done swiftly and "quietly," to make legal action by taxpayers in Canada or the Morris and Speer families in America virtually impossible.


Morris is understandably angry and hurt. "The fact is Chris Speer and myself were fighting with Canadians in Afghanistan," he said.





"We were alongside the PPCLI (Princess Patricia"s Canadian Light Infantry). There was a Canadian flag flying along with the American flag at our base there, so it"s quite a thing that now Canada is giving millions to a guy who would attack a compound where Canadians were serving. I don"t see this as anything but treason... As far as I am concerned, Prime Minister Trudeau should be charged."



Thus far, the administration in Washington has remained silent on Khadr pay-out, which came to light during the weekend of the G20 summit in Germany, where U.S. President Donald Trump heaped praise on his Canadian counterpart.


Trump even opened his speech at a World Bank event to promote and finance women entrepreneurs in developing countries by declaring: "We have a great neighbor in Canada and Justin [Trudeau] is doing a spectacular job... Everybody loves him, and they love him for a reason..."


This assertion, given the information that has since emerged about Khadr case, was unfortunate. Far more ironic under the circumstances, however, was the "Statement on Countering Terrorism," signed by the leaders of the G20.


Its 21 clauses include a commitment to "address the evolving threat of returning foreign terrorist fighters ... from conflict zones such as Iraq and Syria and remain committed to preventing [them] from establishing a foothold in other countries and regions around the world," and to "facilitate swift and targeted exchanges of information between intelligence and law enforcement and judicial authorities... [to] ensure that terrorists are brought to justice."


Such words are empty without actions to back them up. Omar Khadr is a classic example of a "foreign terrorist fighter." Yet the Canadian legal system categorized him -- in Cotler"s words -- as a "child victim, [who] should... be afforded the justice denied him all these years."


It is bad enough to describe a teenager who set out to "kill as many Americans as possible" in this way. It is far worse that he is a free -- and still very young -- man, paid not only respect by the government whose values he was raised to abhor, but millions of dollars, to boot. If anything serves to encourage other terrorists to leave North America and Europe to fight in the Middle East, it is stories such as this one.


The Trump administration must call Trudeau to task for this perversion, and offer an immediate and very public apology to Khadr"s American victims, who did not receive a penny for their patriotic sacrifice.

Thursday, May 11, 2017

Moodys Slashes Ratings On 6 Canadian Banks, Fears Asset-Quality Deterioration, Soaring Household Debt

Amid Poloz-described "unsustainable prices" in various cities, and just days after the collapse of Canadian mortgage lender Home Capital Group and our discussion of the dire state of Canadian savers (and their record household debt), Moodys has cut the ratings on six of Canada"s largest banks because of "ongoing concerns that expanding levels of private-sector debt could weaken asset quality in the future."


As a reminder, even Bank of Canada Governor Stephen Poloz noted that Toronto is out control tonight while answering questions following a speech in Mexico City...





"pretty sure recent gains in Toronto home prices were not sustainable and that the city’s housing market had elements of speculation"



"Financial stability is part of the Bank of Canada’s monetary policy decision making, but the central bank’s primary mission is inflation targeting,... it would be odd to use interest rates to target home prices in just one city."



Perhaps Mr. Poloz,  but, as we showed previously, it doesn’t take a genius to figure out that this will end in tears.  Even the big Canadian banks are fretting. “Let’s drop the pretense. The Toronto housing market and the many cities surrounding it are in a housing bubble,” Bank of Montreal Chief Economist Doug Porter warned clients. But the bubble’s deflation would push the city into a fiscal and financial sinkhole.



So that"s the supposed "asset" side, and to show just how bad the debt situation in Canada truly is, here are some more charts which are largely self-explanatory.




And perhaps the most important - and troubling - chart of all:



And of course the bank run at Home Capital Group...




It should hardly be a surprise that Moodys today downgraded the Baseline Credit Assessments (BCAs), the long-term ratings and the Counterparty Risk Assessments (CRAs) of six Canadian banks and their affiliates, reflecting Moody"s expectation of a more challenging operating environment for banks in Canada for the remainder of 2017 and beyond, that could lead to a deterioration in the banks" asset quality, and increase their sensitivity to external shocks.


The banks affected are: Toronto-Dominion Bank, Bank of Montreal, Bank of Nova Scotia, Canadian Imperial Bank of Canada, National Bank of Canada, and Royal Bank of Canada.


The BCAs, long-term debt and deposit ratings and CRAs of the banks and their affiliates were downgraded by 1 notch, excepting only Toronto-Dominion Bank"s CRA, which was affirmed. The short term Prime-1 ratings of the Canadian banks were affirmed. All relevant ratings for these banks continue to have negative outlooks, reflecting the expected introduction of an operational resolution regime in Canada.


"Today"s downgrade of the Canadian banks reflects our ongoing concerns that expanding levels of private-sector debt could weaken asset quality in the future. Continued growth in Canadian consumer debt and elevated housing prices leaves consumers, and Canadian banks, more vulnerable to downside risks facing the Canadian economy than in the past." said David Beattie, a Moody"s Senior Vice President.


In the same action, Moody"s affirmed the BCAs, long-term ratings and CRAs of CIBC Mellon Trust (CIBC Mellon), the Fédération des caisses Desjardins du Québec (the Fédération) and Caisse centrale Desjardins.


In view of today"s actions, Moody"s does not expect any upward rating pressure on the affected banks in the near term. However, the Canadian banks" ratings could be revised upwards if macro-economic conditions in Canada improve and the Canadian banks maintain sound financial metrics.


The affected banks" ratings could be downgraded if their fundamentals weaken, as evidenced by an even more challenging operating environment and/or deterioration in their financial metrics.


*  *  *


Here is the full ratings rationale by bank...





Moody"s considers that weakening credit conditions in Canada -- including an increase in private-sector debt to GDP to 185.0% as of the end of 2016, up from 179.3% for 2015 -- present increasing risk to Canadian banks" asset quality and profitability.



This increase has been led by household debt, which is now at a record high of 167.3% of disposable income (as at Q4 2016) and accompanying house price appreciation.



Despite macro-prudential measures put into place by Canadian policymakers in recent years -- which have had some success in moderating the rate of housing price growth -- house prices and consumer debt levels remain historically high. Business credit, the other component of private-sector debt, has also grown rapidly, at a 6.2% CAGR over the past 3 years.



We do note that the Canadian banks maintain strong buffers in terms of capital and liquidity. However, the resilience of household balance sheets, and consequently bank portfolios, to a serious economic downturn has not been tested at these levels of private sector indebtedness.



Toronto-Dominion Bank (TD, Aa2/Aa2 negative, a1); TD"s strong ratings are attributable to its very strong domestic retail franchise -- which generates stable and recurring profitability and its business mix. This strength is due to leading market share positions in many personal & commercial financial services products, where TD typically has market shares in the high teens and holds first or second positions.


TD is the most retail oriented of its Canadian peers, with approximately 90% of earnings coming from retail (combined Canadian personal & commercial, wealth management and US personal & commercial, excluding corporate). While CM income has increased over recent quarters and capital allocated to the wholesale business is rising, we expect that reliance on this inherently volatile source of income will remain relatively modest.


Through acquisition and organic growth, TD has increased its exposure to unsecured Canadian consumer credit risk in recent years. In our view, however, the strength and stability of the earnings from TD"s Canadian personal and commercial banking franchise remain the primary credit strength supporting its ratings. The ratings of TD"s US affiliates benefit from support from the parent, and as such are also affected by this action.


Bank of Montreal (BMO A1/A1 negative, a3); BMO is one of the six major banks in Canada which benefit from the protection of significant barriers to entry and the stability of a prudent regulatory environment. Although its Canadian retail market shares are towards the lower end of the Canadian peer group, BMO has double digit market shares across all significant retail financial services and products, providing scale and recurring earnings power in its home market. In our view, however, the strength and stability of the earnings from BMO"s Canadian personal and commercial (P&C) banking franchise remain the primary credit strength supporting its ratings. BMO has a strong and improving US regional banking presence through BMO Harris, which adds important diversification away from reliance on Canadian P&C earnings. However, BMO does not enjoy the same franchise strength and pricing power in the more competitive US market that it does in Canada. The ratings of BMO Harris and affiliates benefit from support from the parent, and as such are also affected by this action.


Bank of Nova Scotia (BNS A1/A1 negative, a3); BNS is the most internationally active of the Canadian banks with approximately half of its earnings generated outside of Canada. BNS has taken significant measures to increase its profitability that signal a fundamental shift away from the bank"s traditionally low risk appetite. While the bank"s strategic actions are intended to enhance current profitability -- in 2016, BNS reported domestic net interest margin lower than the six largest Canadian banks" average- in our view, they increase the prospect of future incremental credit losses.


While BNS had strategically grown its credit card and auto finance portfolios - both of which are particularly prone to deterioration during an economic downturn and exhibit higher defaults and loss severities than mortgage portfolios -- in recent years, growth in 2016 was flat. In addition, the bank has made a series of acquisitions away from its strong domestic franchise towards higher-growth but less stable international markets. BNS has aspirations to continue to grow its international earnings, which in Moody"s view adds to bondholder risk.


Canadian Imperial Bank of Commerce (CIBC A1/A1 negative, a3); CIBC is the most reliant of the Canadian banks on domestic P&C earnings, which generate approximately 65% of total earnings, excluding Corporate. In our view, however, the strength and stability of the earnings from CIBC"s Canadian personal and commercial banking franchise remain the primary credit strength supporting its ratings. CIBC has the second lowest proportionate exposure to unsecured and non-real estate secured consumer debt as a percentage of domestic consumer assets (roughly 11.5%), reflective of its very large book of insured mortgages.


CIBC is one of the six major banks in Canada that benefit from the protection of significant barriers to entry and the stability of a prudent regulatory environment. Although its Canadian retail market shares are mid-range relative to its Canadian peers, CIBC has solid double digit market shares across all significant retail financial services and products, providing scale and recurring earnings.


National Bank of Canada (NBC A1/A1 negative, baa1); NBC"s dominant position in commercial banking and strong second place share of market in retail banking in Québec are the primary credit strengths supporting its high ratings. The stability of the recurring earnings power of NBC"s regional retail franchise is, in Moody"s view, highly unlikely to be challenged. That being said, NBC"s asset base (CAD234 billion as of Q1 2017) and national deposit share (roughly 4%) are small relative to the other large Canadian banks whose branch systems are more national in scale. In our view, however, the strength and stability of the earnings from NBC"s Canadian personal and commercial banking franchise remain the primary credit strength supporting its ratings.


While each of the major Canadian banks enjoys the benefits of superior pricing power due to sustainable large market shares in many significant retail and commercial products and services, this is true for NBC only in the context of its regional market, the province of Québec. As such, the challenges in geographic diversification and earnings stability and the Québec credit concentrations offset partially the strength in local market share and sustainability. NBC is the Canadian bank most reliant upon inherently less stable capital markets earnings, which generated 38% of total earnings, excluding Corporate for 2016 (38% for 2015.)


Royal Bank of Canada (RBC A1/A1 negative, a3 ); RBC"s ratings reflect its profile as a strong and diversified universal bank with sustainable leading market shares across many retail products and services in its home market. The stable earnings from RBC"s domestic Personal and Commercial franchise are a key credit strength. RBC has had very low earnings volatility, supported by the stabilizing effect of the recurring profitability of RBC"s solid domestic retail banking franchise.


However, over the past four years RBC has demonstrated rapid growth in its Capital Markets business, led by growth in its US corporate loan book and the repo and securities finance business. We believe that RBC"s US-focused Capital Markets growth strategy increases its exposure to risks that could more rapidly erode its creditworthiness in volatile or adverse market conditions, and is therefore negative for the credit. To date, this risk has been well managed and its performance has been very stable. Maintaining this performance through more volatile markets will be key to RBC"s longer term risk management track record. We do not expect that this business will continue on this growth trajectory, and, in fact, that capital committed to the Capital Markets business will be more constrained.


Management plans to substantially grow the earnings of its recently acquired, California-based private and commercial bank, City National Bank, (deposits Aa3 stable, a2) both organically and through targeted acquisitions. Growth in the City National business presents less credit risk than continued growth in the Capital Markets area, in our view.


The ratings of two affiliates, RBC Capital Markets LLC and RBC (Barbados) Trading Bank Corporation were also affected by this action. In each case, both long and short term ratings were downgraded.


Fédération des caisses Desjardins du Québec (Aa2/Aa2 negative, a1 ); The Fédération is a cooperative entity responsible for governance and oversight activities for Desjardins Group (the Group). It acts as a control and supervisory body over the individual member caisses. The Fédération"s pivotal importance to the Group"s operations and performance, the application of regulatory supervision to the Group as a whole, as well as the strong strategic and financial cohesion among member caisses with a well-developed mutualist support framework, lead us to factor the strength of the Group into the Fédération"s BCA.


The Group has a secure retail banking franchise in rural Québec as well as strong capitalization and limited reliance on wholesale funding. Its regional banking concentration in Québec is offset in part by the Group"s national insurance and wealth management business.


The Fédération"s ratings were affirmed despite the Macro Profile change because Moody"s believes its operations to be largely isolated to the province of Quebec (which has experienced lower house price appreciation than other provinces) and because a large proportion of Desjardins" net income is derived from non-banking sources, such as life and property and casualty insurance.


CIBC Mellon Trust (CIBC Mellon A1/A1 stable, a1); CIBC Mellon is a major player in the Canadian custody market, underpinning its franchise value. The operations and technology platform provided by BNY Mellon lends a further competitive advantage. BNY Mellon is the largest custodian, globally, and its operating platform allows CIBC Mellon to benefit from economies of scale and service not available to its primary domestic competitor.


CIBC Mellon"s risk management and control environment is strong, with an appropriate emphasis on operational risk issues and effective supervision by the joint venture"s owners. CMT does not make loans (other than short-term overdrafts to custody clients) but incurs credit risk through its securities portfolio. The investment portfolio is made up largely of short-duration Canadian government and provincial bonds as well as corporate debt.


CIBC Mellon"s ratings were affirmed despite the change in the Macro Profile because Moody"s believes its custody bank business model is directly unaffected by high consumer debt as it does not lend to consumers.
 

Friday, April 28, 2017

Trade War, Round 2: Boeing Accuses Bombardier Of Dumping Jets; Canada Retaliates

Just days after the US Commerce Department imposed duties averaging 20% on Canadian softwood lumber, accusing Chinese timber companies of getting an unfair government subsidy, on Thursday round two of the trade war between the US and Canada broke out when Boeing asked the U.S. Commerce Department to investigate dumping, subsidies and unfair pricing for Canadian planemaker Bombardier"s new CSeries airplane, a competitor to the Boeing 737, confirming that the trade tensions between the two neighboring countries are set to get far worse.


Specifically, the Chicago-based aerospace giant has asking the International Trade Commission to rule that it has suffered injury to its business at the hands of Bombardier and to recommend that the Commerce Department impose duties on the Canadian jet builder (amusingly, Boeing also complained about the very existence of Bombardier itself, a company which has been aggressively bailed out by the Canadian government as recently as October 2015, when in exchange for $2.5 billion in taxpayer funds, the company fired 7,000 Canadian workers).


In its petition, Boeing said that Bombardier, determined to win a key order from Delta Air Lines after losing a competition at United Airlines, had offered its planes to the airline at an "absurdly low" $19.6 million each, well below what it described as the aircraft’s production cost of $33.2 million. "Propelled by massive, supply creating and illegal government subsidies, Bombardier Inc has embarked on an aggressive campaign to dump its CSeries aircraft in the United States," Boeing said in its ITC complaint.


A comparable 737-700 model by Boeing has a list price of $83.4 million, with the new 737-MAX 7 priced at $92.2 million. While sales discounts from list prices are typically 40 percent to 50 percent in the industry, another question is just how much of that price is courtesy of the implicit taxpayer subsidy of the Ex-Im bank, but that is a topic for another post.


The spat between the two companies came to a climax in April 2016, whe Bombardier won the Delta order, its biggest yet, for 75 CS100 jets, worth an estimated $5.6 billion based on the list price of about $71.8 million.  And now that Trump has given the green light to challenge Canadian trade competitors, Boeing is certainly not wasting time.


In its complaint against Bombardier, Boeing argued that the CSeries program would not exist without hundreds of millions of dollars in launch aid from the governments of Canada, Quebec and Britain, nor the abovementioned $2.5 billion equity infusion from Quebec in 2015.


Boeing wasn"t finished: the company also took a shot at European rival Airbus, which it accuses of benefiting from similar "unfair" government subsidies in a long-running dispute before the World Trade Organization.


“Evidently taking a page out of the Airbus strategy book, Bombardier has blatantly and intentionally demonstrated its goal of muscling its way into the U.S. aviation market by offering its heavily subsidized planes at cut-rate pricing,” Boeing said.


A Commerce Department spokesman told Reuters that the petition would be given "a thorough review" and further comment was premature.


In recent week, Commerce Secretary Wilbur Ross has taken swift action to protect the U.S. steel and aluminum industries from foreign competition, launching national security investigations that could lead to import restrictions. An investigation could lead to duties on the aircraft to offset any below-cost pricing or any subsidies deemed unfair.


Shortly after the complaint was filed, the Canadian government issued a statement objecting to Boeing"s allegations and noted that the CSeries has many U.S. suppliers, including for engines, and supports thousands of U.S. jobs. "The Government of Canada will mount a vigorous defense against these allegations and stand up for aerospace jobs on both sides of the border," it said. Full statement below:





The Government of Canada today made the following statement regarding the filing of a petition by Boeing Aerospace Corporation with the United States Department of Commerce, alleging the dumping of Bombardier aircraft in the United States market:



"The Government of Canada objects to the allegations made by Boeing. We are confident that our programs are consistent with Canada"s international obligations.       



"The aerospace industries of Canada and the United States are highly integrated and companies on both sides of the border benefit from this close partnership. For example, many C Series suppliers are based in the United States and it is projected that more than 50 percent of the components for the C Series, including the engine, will be supplied by American firms directly contributing to high quality jobs in that country. The C Series is a great example of how the North American industrial base can develop and produce a globally competitive product with industry-leading clean technologies.



Bombardier also has a significant presence in the U.S. across its aerospace and transportation divisions, directly employing more than 7,000 workers. In addition, the company works with more than 2,000 suppliers headquartered in states across the country thereby generating thousands of well-paid, high-tech American jobs.



"The Government of Canada will mount a vigorous defence against these allegations and stand up for aerospace jobs on both sides of the border."



Curiously, Bombardier’s chief executive conceded the company had been “aggressive” on pricing in order to win, and sources familiar with the deal pegged the discount closer to two-thirds off the nominal list price. It added that it was reviewing the petition and structures its dealings to ensure compliance with all relevant laws.


* * *


In a separate development, Premier Christy Clark of British Columbia, wrote a letter to Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau Wednesday asking him to ban coal shipments from the U.S., sending shares of US coal giant Cloud Peak Energy (among others) tumbling. According to Bloomberg, Clark"s demand was in response to Trump"s lumber tariffs. Trudeau said he would consider the request "carefully and seriously." Some context: a little over 6 million metric tons of U.S. thermal coal were shipped through the port of Vancouver in 2016.


Needless to say, it would be especially absurd if as a result of Trump"s Canadian tariffs, it is the US coal mining industry - the one which the president vowed to reincarnate - that suffers the most.


And now, we sit back and wait for round three in the increasingly hostile trade wars between the US and its peaceful northern neighbor.


Friday, April 21, 2017

The World's Worst Market-Timer

Authored by Kevin Muir via The Macro Tourist blog,



Today’s post is about the recent Canadian government measures to cool the scorching Toronto housing bubble, but the lesson about government ineptitude will be universal, and I am confident, shared by everyone.


By now, most non-Canadians have heard of Toronto’s out of control housing market, but probably won’t know too much about the specifics. I tried to think up a good way to show the magnitude of the rise, so I made up a chart comparing Toronto’s house index to another housing market widely known to be insane. Fueled by the latest tech boom, San Francisco has experienced a breathtakingly stupid price rise over the past few years.


Well, here are the two cities side by side:


http://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/themacrotourist.comTorontoApr2017-3e816d65119711d6f5002300e7e087b90206f069.png


Yup, Toronto housing price appreciation has even outpaced San Francisco! It’s a gong show here in Toronto, no doubt about it.


Last year when Vancouver was facing the same sort of runaway price rise, their government instituted a 15% foreign buyers tax. Like true bureaucrats, they did not think about grandfathering in existing sales that had not yet settled, and instead slapped an out of the blue tax on foreign capital. Not surprisingly, foreigners decided there might be better places to invest than Vancouver.


Many of them came to Toronto.


http://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/themacrotourist.comYYZYYVApr211-5c9889c90f4d248cb50bb3bc2c8364bcbd1506a5.jpg


I am not claiming foreigners are the culprit for Toronto’s out of control rising housing market. I actually think absurdly low interest rates, combined with unscrupulous dealings from companies like Home Capital Group, are more to blame. But Vancouver’s decision definitely sent more money scuttling to Toronto, at a time when supply was already tight. This extra demand sent prices soaring.


Yet this price increase happened in a vacuum. There was so little supply in the winter season that bidders took prices to absurd levels. It’s like when a stock bursts out to new highs and all the stops run in a sickening whoosh.


Real estate moves a lot slower than stock trading, but markets are markets. They all operate on the same basic principles. And what is the best cure for high prices? High prices!


The market would have taken care of this on its own. We were already seeing tons of new supply coming on the market this spring. It just doesn’t happen overnight.


Instead of letting high prices be the incentive for market forces to fix the problem, the government chose to get involved. I can’t say all their initiatives were terrible, but a few of them were beyond brain dead (even for the Wynne government - and that’s saying a lot!). Here’s prominent outspoken critic Garth Turner’s assessment of the situation:





At first blush, it looks like the condo market was the big loser in Thursday’s political assault on the free market. Rent controls on new units will virtually guarantee consistent long-term negative cash-flow for investor-owned apartments. Ouch. And since half of recent condo sales have gone to investors, you can imagine the impact.






The condo trade also relies heavily on assignment clauses – allowing buyers to sell their interest in a unit prior to closing. Given the fact it can be three or four years between making a deposit on an unbuilt unit and actually seeing it registered, assignments make sense. There are whole brokerages dealing in nothing but. So now with intense scrutiny and the CRA involved, any gains are likely to end up being taxed as income. Double ouch.






In case you missed it, Ontario did about what was forecast here. A non-resident (foreign buyer) tax of 15% – or $240,000 on the average detached house. Rent controls on every unit, ensuring landlords cannot stay ahead of inflation. Letting cities tax under-used properties – about $1,400 a month on a 416 SFH.



I am sympathetic to renters who were being priced out of the market, and I understand the frustration of having prices run away from you. But I know that when government gets involved in such a heavy handed manner, it will end badly. The law of unintended consequences will bite them in the ass.


They sat around watching this problem develop for years, and then when it finally spiraled out of control, they rushed in to “fix it.”


It reminds me of the late 90’s when Nortel (and Bell which owned piles of Nortel) comprised more than half of the TSX 60 index and more than 40% of the broader TSX 300 index. Nortel kept exploding higher, and the Canadian stock indexes became an uninvestable farce. Fund managers were getting their ass kicked by the index because most of them could not invest more than 10% in any one stock, yet Nortel kept pushing the TSX indexes to the moon. After the screams from the investing community finally became deafening, TSX index officials acted and created a cap limited index. By the time they got around to implementing it, what do you think happened? You guessed it. Nortel topped and soon that cap weighted index was the last concern on the minds of fund managers.


I suspect the same will happen with the Ontario government’s real estate measures. Prices were already set to slow, and now that the government has intervened, the top is virtually assured. Like your pal that has terrible market timing but you are afraid to tell him because it might ruin your best contrarian signal, governments are the ultimate fade.


Don’t believe me? Have a look at the chart for Home Capital Group. The canary in the coal mine of Canadian real estate has been struggling for air at the bottom of the cage for some time now.


http://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/themacrotourist.comHCGApr2117-2fa92a1b8dce6c555294239d9c14e5c614403aaa.png


It is ironic that the day the Wynne government announced their measures to cool the housing market, Home Capital Group, one of Canada’s largest alternative real estate lenders, was being taken out back and unceremoniously shot on news they were under investigation by the Ontario Securities Commission for misleading investors. Now here’s a thought - instead of putting in all sorts of new rules to curb housing speculation, how about enforcing the existing ones?


I am straying dangerously into the territory of ranting about what should be instead of focusing on trading what will be. In fact, I am pretty sure I have crossed the line.


So in the hopes of redeeming myself, let’s examine whether there is a trade in here. Assuming I am correct in that the Ontario government has just rung the bell at the top of the Canadian housing bubble, then how do we profit from it? As you can see, the market has already sniffed out the highly leveraged stocks like Home Capital Group. Now some will argue that this is Canada’s Bear Stearns hedge fund moment. Remember back to 2007 when two highly levered Bear Stearns hedge funds ran into trouble with their mortgage backed portfolio? Although many argued the problem was contained to Bear, it quickly spread and soon enough become a nationwide contagion.


Many U.S. hedge funds and other speculators who have heard stories of the vast fortunes made by those betting against American real estate are convinced Canada will replay exactly the same way. These hedge funds are shorting Canadian banks assuming the rot will spread throughout the whole economy. Heck, I even heard of one prominent newsletter writer who thinks he will be covering his CIBC short in the single digits.


Although I have learned to never say never, I doubt Canada will repeat the U.S. playbook. There are so many reasons, but at the crux of the matter is that Canadians are boring. We just don’t run from one side of the boat to the other with the same determination as our American neighbours. Real estate cycles are long drawn out affairs. The American boom/bust was the exception, not the rule.


The bursting of Canada’s real estate bubble will be much less of a pop than most expect. Instead of playing for the big dramatic win, I think a safer way to capitalize on these new developments is by shorting the Canadian currency.


Now that the government has released these targeted measures to curb real estate appreciation, it takes a lot of heat off the Bank of Canada to raise rates. At the margin, this allows the BoC to be much more dovish.


There is a lot more to currency speculation than forecasting interest rate differentials, but for a long time, Canada’s economy has been kept aloft through real estate strength. We have come to think our shit doesn’t stink, and that somehow our economy will be magically able to continue to outperform.


As real estate softens, I doubt this will be the case.


http://www.thefringenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/04/themacrotourist.comCADApr2117-0724b2a5081f1d75914e0f4713a5dfc091462776.png


I am a little bit of a US dollar bear, but I am becoming even more bearish on the Loonie. Maybe buying British Pounds, or even Euros, against CAD is the way to play it.


Whatever you do, make sure you keep in mind that the world’s worst market timer (the government) just cried “Uncle.” The proper trade is to assume they will make a mess. A big one.


You know, I thought the Ontario government’s actions were bad news. But now that I reflect on it, maybe it’s not that terrible. When the decline in Toronto real estate comes, the Ontario Liberals will own it. And the public will be furious with them. See, it’s not all bad…

Sunday, March 19, 2017

Mexicans Flood Into Canada As 2017 Border Detentions Surpass All Of 2016

A couple of days ago we noted that Mexican immigrants were suddenly flooding into Canada to avoid deportation from the U.S.  The increase in northern border crossings came, at least in part, courtesy of Canada"s decision to lift visa requirements for Mexican "tourists" as of December 1st.  Per the new rules, rather than a visa, under Trudeau"s administration, Mexicans are now only required to have a so-called Electronic Travel Authorisation (ETA) which can be purchased online for CAD $7.


Unfortunately, while Canada"s relaxed travel requirements were applauded as an enlightened, progressive alternative to Trump"s xenophobic, racist approach to immigration, under the surface, Canada"s policies still function much like Trump"s proposals.  As Mexican immigrants are suddenly finding out, while Canada is happy to host "tourists" from our Southern neighbor, getting a work visa can be nearly impossible and Mexicans with a criminal record are not welcome.


All of which has resulted in a record number of Mexicans being detained by Canadian border officials in the opening months of 2017.  Per Reuters:





The Canada Border Services Agency (CBSA) said it detained 444 Mexican nationals between Jan. 1 and March 8, compared with 410 for all of 2016, 351 for 2015, and 399 for 2014.



The CBSA can detain foreign nationals if it is believed they pose a danger to the public, if their identity is unclear or if they are deemed unlikely to appear for removal or for a proceeding.



The number of Mexicans turned back at the airport has risen, too - to 313 in January, more than any January since 2012 and more than the annual totals for 2012, 2013 and 2014.



Canada



Meanwhile, Canadian border officials are already starting to question Trudeau"s relaxed immigration policies as over 70,000 ETAs have already been issued in a matter of months.





Canada issued 72,450 travel authorizations to Mexican citizens between Dec. 1, 2016, and March 10, 2017 - a significant increase compared with a similar period when visas were required.



Canada"s Immigration and Refugee Minister Ahmed Hussen has said his department is monitoring the situation.



"It would be premature to draw conclusions or to speculate on future policy at this point," Hussen"s spokeswoman, Camielle Edwards, wrote in an email Friday evening.



Don"t you just love it when a beautifully planned out "progressive" policy gets crushed by reality?


* * *


For those who missed it, here is our previous note:


Canada has been applauded in recent months for its decision to lift visa requirements for Mexican "tourists" as of December 1st.  Rather than a visa, under Trudeau"s administration, Mexicans are now only required to have a so-called Electronic Travel Authorisation (ETA) which can be purchased online for CAD $7.


As one media outlet praised, the move "provides a stark contrast to proposed policies from the US president-elect Donald Trump, who has said he will immediately deport between two and three million illegal immigrants and will build a wall along the US-Mexican border."


Not surprisingly, news of the rule changes in Canada quickly made the rounds in the migrant community with one recently-deported Mexican nationalist declaring that "For those without documents, I think (the United States) is over. Now it"s Canada"s turn."


Sure enough, in just the three months since Canada"s visa rules were relaxed, the number of Mexicans interested in "vacationing" in Canada has soared over 300%. Sure, who wouldn"t want to abandon the sweltering 70 degree heat in Mexico for a relaxing vacation in the frozen tundra of our northern neighbor in the dead of winter...it just makes sense. Per Reuters:





Canadian government data shows a tripling of Mexicans seeking to travel to Canada in the three months since the visa requirement was shelved.



It is not a firm indicator as many people could be genuine tourists. But tie it to a surge in calls and emails to immigration lawyers from recently arrived Mexicans looking for work permits, as well as the accounts of deportees like Rita and Mexicans already in Canada, and it suggests a new migration pattern may be emerging.



Seven immigration lawyers, consultants and activists told Reuters that requests for legal advice from Mexicans who had entered Canada since Dec. 1 had roughly tripled compared with the same period in 2015-2016.



Between December and late February, Canada has granted more than 61,500 eTAs (Electronic Travel Authorization forms) to Mexicans, about triple the number of quarterly tourist applications received in the year before the visa requirement was scrapped, official Canadian data shows. The true scale of Mexican immigration will only become fully apparent in June, when early arrivals on these eTAs are due to leave.



Flight bookings from Mexico to Canada also swelled 90 percent in January and February versus the same period in 2016, according to travel analysis company ForwardKeys, which reviews all major travel agency bookings. It is unclear what percentage of those bookings were made by people looking to work illegally in Canada.



Migrants



Of course, the problem with relaxed immigration policies is not attracting additional "tourists" to your country but getting them to go home once their invitation expires.  As one migrant who recently immigrated to Toronto told Reuters, once his time as a "tourist" expires he"ll have no choice but to "stay and work illegally."





In 2015, Victor Avila, a 37-year-old architect from Oaxaca, returned home voluntarily from the United States after five years working illegally in Freehold, New Jersey. Shocked by the low wages in Mexico and traumatized by the local murder of his brother, he applied for an eTA.



Avila arrived in Toronto a few weeks ago and found work in a restaurant. He was in the process of applying for a work visa, but said he would stay on illegally for a year if it wasn"t granted.



"I think for many of us in Canada, there"s no other option but to stay and work illegally," he said.



Unfortunately, while Canada"s relaxed travel requirements were applauded as an enlightened, progressive alternative to Trump"s xenophobic, racist approach to immigration, under the surface, Canada"s policies function much like Trump"s proposals.  As immigration lawyers point out, while "vacationing" in Canada is easy, getting a work visa can be nearly impossible and Mexicans with a criminal record are not welcome.





Many Mexicans believe the eTA is all they need to set up in Canada, but in almost all cases they are wrong, immigration lawyers said. The eTA does not even guarantee entry.



Even if they get past the airport, many low-skilled Mexicans hoping to work illegally are likely to be disappointed, lawyers said, noting that it"s difficult for those entering on tourist visas to get work permits without an employer"s sponsorship.



Some Mexican visitors told Reuters that Canadian immigration officials went through their phones and asked tough questions designed to trip up those seeking to stay and work illegally. While some got through, others were sent home.



Canada says those convicted of crimes, as well as gang members, are inadmissible, making it hard for criminally convicted Mexicans deported from the United States to enter.



Just ask Alejandro Becerra"s how accommodating Canada"s open-minded, progressive immigration policies are..





Alejandro Becerra"s experience is a cautionary tale for Mexicans dreaming of a new life in Canada.



The 30-year-old former bankteller from Mexico City got a job offer to work in construction in Toronto and flew to the city on Feb. 7 on an eTA.



Becerra told a border official at the airport that he was coming as a tourist and showed him his return flight. The official didn"t believe him and examined his phone, where he found messages discussing Becerra"s job in Toronto.



Becerra spent the night in a detention center, and the next morning he was taken in handcuffs to a plane that would return him to Mexico.



Perhaps Mexicans are learning that our "progressive" northern neighbor isn"t so progressive after all...oh well, there"s always California.