Showing posts with label Furlough. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Furlough. Show all posts

Thursday, August 24, 2017

A Look At US Government Shutdowns Since 1976

Investors and politicians are getting increasingly worried about a potential US government shutdown.


Earlier we showed that following a report by Axios which quoted a republican who put the chance of a shutdown "as high as 75%", the T-Bill market got spooked, and pushed the Oct.12 Bill - the one considered closest to the Treasury"s X-date - to the widest spread on record from the nearest "safe" Bill, maturing on Sept. 28.



And as more traders start asking questions, in the latest report laying out both the threat, and potential consequences from a government shut down and/or debt ceiling crisis, Barclays" Shawn Golhar tried to ease growing concerns and wrote that while Barclays "does not expect" either a shutdown or debt limit breach, he admitted that "the cumbersome legislative process, a limited number of Congressional working days in September, burgeoning tensions between President Trump and Congressional Republicans, and repeated demands by the president that any budget agreement include border wall funding raises the risk of a government shutdown and/or debt ceiling breach that goes against our baseline assumptions."


What makes the upcoming negotiations more complicated is that a potential government shutdown is a discrete event that is different from a debt ceiling breach, i.e. a technical default. In other words, in addition to lifting the borrowing capacity of the Treasury, Congress needs to complete the FY2018 budget process or pass a continuing resolution by October 1, 2017. If that does not happen, the federal government will shut down for the second time in the past four years.


The good news here is that despite the ominous rhetoric, short funding gaps are a regular feature of the budget process, even if they have become more pronounced in length in recent decades.


The Barclays chart below shows that since 1976, the federal government has experienced 18 funding gaps under the current budget process, "although most did not result in a shutdown of operations and a furlough of non-essential employees. Since 1980, following new interpretations of the law, government shutdowns have generally coincided with employee furloughs. This is particularly true during the three most recent lapses in government funding – November 1995, December 1995-January 1996, and September-October 2013 – which are often referred to as true shutdowns. Also, funding gaps do not solely coincide with divided government; five in the late 1970s occurred under one party rule."



Assuming the worst-case, and the government does shutdown on October 1, as it did briefly in September 2013, what then? In short, a shutdown would not have a sudden, adverse impect, but instead would subtract from US output slowly but surely. Barclays estimates that a shutdowns typically reduce real federal government consumption and gross investment 1.5% q/q and annualized GDP about 0.1% per week.


 Which is good news, because while the chart above shows that shutdowns occur with some regularity, their effects are largely political, particularly if the shutdown is short-lived. Furthermore, the lack of current income for millions of government workers and the political outcry to get a deal down at the grassroots level as government procurement contracts are put on halt, crippling downstream private industries, results in political pressure to reach a compromise. As a result, a shutdown would have to proceed for several weeks or more to have sizeable economic effects. Here are the details:





In the NIPA accounts, a government shutdown is primarily reflected in a decline in real compensation of non-essential employees as a result of reduced hours worked. In the 1995- 96 shutdown, approximately 800,000 of 2.04mn federal civilian (non-postal) workers were forced to take leave without pay, or about 39% of employees. In the shutdown of 2013, about 850,000 of 2.19mn federal civilian employees were furloughed (a similar 39%). That said, then-Secretary of Defense Gates ordered about 400,000 civilian military employees back to duty after the first week of the shutdown, leaving 21% of federal civilian employees furloughed in weeks 2 and beyond.



In addition to compensation costs, the effects of the shutdown are felt primarily in services consumption. A temporary government shutdown at the beginning of Q4 could result in shifts in investment spending from one month to the next and increase the volatility of inventory data, but would be unlikely to disrupt federal consumption of fixed capital and gross investment over the quarter as long as the situation were resolved before year-end. However, services consumption is unlikely to be recovered once halted. BEA estimates for non-defense expenditures unrelated to compensation are based on federal budget data, and a shutdown would be unlikely to alter these accounts unless it persisted past year-end or the BEA modified its procedures on applying annual budget data in its quarterly estimates.




So while a brief shutdown, one lasting 2-4 weeks would not cripple the economy, a longer shutdown "could have negative indirect effects on private sector activity."


* * *


What about a debt ceiling breach?


Here things are more serious: according to Barclays, the consequences of a debt ceiling breach as more extreme and, therefore, less likely. First, a quick look at lessons from recent history:





The debt ceiling showdowns in 2011, 2013, and 2015, like many before, have led to the use of extraordinary measures to create borrowing room and prolong the date at which the debt ceiling is reached. Extraordinary measures plus the Treasury’s cash balance left about $280bn in operating capacity as of the end of June, but these measures are only temporary; cash balances at the Treasury have gradually moved lower, and borrowing capacity will eventually reach its limit (Figures 3 and 4). Policymakers are running out of time as the September budget and mid-October debt limit deadlines loom. The exact timing of the end of borrowing capacity is uncertain, and the risk of an unforced error is rising.




While the exact timing of the so-called X-date is still fluid (we will have more on this a subsequent post shortly), one thing is clear: in addition to a potential downgrade by Fitch and Moody"s, it is the conomic consequences that would be most concerning: according to Barclays" calculations, failure to raise the debt ceiling would require an immediate cut in spending equal to about 3.5% of GDP (the federal deficit in percent of GDP in 2016 was 3.2%; the average of the most recent four quarters through Q2 17 was 3.8%).





Yet even cutbacks of this kind would not rule out a default because previous administrations concluded the Treasury does not have the authority to prioritize interest payments above other obligations. Even if revenues match expenditures in aggregate, federal receipts and payables differ in timing and quantity, and Treasury payment systems are designed to pay bills as they are received. Furthermore, even if the Treasury concluded it could prioritize interest and principal payments, it may still be viewed as a technical default since the government would not be meeting all its obligations.



In a separate report, the Bipartisan Policy Center calculated that losing the ability to borrow any more on Oct. 2 would mean approximately 23% of funds owed by the government that month would go unpaid, dealing an immediate blow to the U.S. economy.


Barclays" conclusion: "A contraction of federal spending of this magnitude, the risk of default, sovereign reputational risk, and negative consequences for confidence and private sector behavior would likely push the economy into a recession if the situation persisted. We view the consequences of a debt ceiling breach as extreme and, therefore, unlikely." Then again, a recession just 8 months into President Trump"s presidency may be precisely what all Democrats, and quite a few Republicans, desire, so we are far less sanguine than Barclays about an imminent "happy ending."

Tuesday, July 4, 2017

Chris Christie Signs Budget Bill, Ending New Jersey Government Shutdown

After a three day state of emergency and government shutdown, on Tuesday morning New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie signed a compromise budget bill ending the state shutdown that became an embarrassment for the outgoing governor when he was photographed lounging on a beach that had been closed to the public for the holiday weekend. According to Reuters, Christie ended the state shutdown by signing a $34.7 billion budget measure that included a controversial provision reshaping the state"s largest health insurer, Horizon Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Jersey, which covers 3.8  million people in the state.



Christie said all state parks and beaches would be open on Tuesday for the Fourth of July holiday and state offices would be open as usual on Wednesday, and added that he was happy a resolution had been reached on the budget impasse, but saddened it came three days late.



"This bill is a long overdue significant reform that will have a lasting impact on New Jersey residents," he said before signing it into law.


Separately, NJ State Senate President Steve Sweeney told a news conference: "None of this was easy." Assembly Speaker Vincent Prieto also chimed in, saying the agreement to end the partial government shutdown was reached after long talks in "crisis" mode on Monday with Horizon and state legislators.


As noted yesterday, while Christie was largely a non participant in the bduget standoff, he was ridiculed after NJ.com posted photos of the Republican governor and his family sunbathing on a beach that had been closed to the public over the holiday weekend due to the budget standoff.



In characteristic fashion, Christie downplayed the kerfuffle. "If they had flown that plane over the beach and I was sitting next to a 25-year-old blonde in that beach chair next to me, that"s a story."


While states have mostly recovered since the 2007-2009 recession, their revenue growth has not always kept pace with the national economy.


More than 30,000 state workers who were furloughed on Monday, would get back to their jobs as a result of the new budget.


Elsewhere, just like Jersey, the state of Maine ended also a 3-day government shutdown on Tuesday when Governor Paul LePage signed a budget for the fiscal years 2018 and 2019 following late-night negotiations with legislative leaders, the governor"s office said in a statement. Previously, members of Maine"s State Employees Association rallied outside the State House to demand a budget deal from lawmakers and Republican Governor Paul LePage.


"The Maine state government shutdown is now over. Happy Fourth of July!" LePage said.


"I have signed a budget with no tax increase. I thank the House Republicans for standing strong for the Maine people," he said in a second tweet. Maine state police, parks and offices responsible for collecting revenue had all planned to work through the shutdown, the state"s first since 1991.


While NJ and Maine are back to spending money they don"t have, about 10 U.S. states still do not have budgets for the fiscal year that began on July 1, including Illinois, which is in its third year without an enacted budget.


Earlier today, the Illinois Senate voted to approve the final budget bill passed by the House, however Illinois Governor has vowed he will veto any spending bill, and it was unclear if and how his opinion would be overruled.

Monday, April 24, 2017

What Happens If The Government Shuts Down

Saturday, April 29, marks what may be a bittersweet anniversary for the Administration: it is President Trump"s 100th day in office. It could also mark Day 1 of a government shutdown if Congress doesn"t pass a spending bill authorizing funding, or if the president doesn"t sign it before then. This is a risk the GOP will be eager to avoid, although in recent days chatter has again picked up as a result of Trump"s insistence to add wall funding in the spending bill. As noted earlier today, there is virtual unanimity among Democrats to oppose any bill that budgets for a wall, and since passing a new Continuing Resolution would require 60 votes in the Senate, at least some Democratic support is needed.


So while it remains at best a moderate risk factor - Goldman"s latest estimate puts it at about 1-in-3 chance - the question of what happens if the government does shut down at midnight on Saturday is starting to percolate. Here are some thoughts from Citi.


First, threats of a shutdown are more common than actual shutdowns. The last one occurred in October 2013, and the one prior to that was 1995/96. Those that last have an impact on the economy. In 1995/96 the government shut down for 21 days. In 2013, for 16 days. But not all shutdowns are impactful. During the Regan administrations, there were a total of 8 shutdowns with the maximum lasting 3 days.


What is the economic impact?


  • In 2013, reduction in fourth quarter Gross Domestic Product (GDP)  was estimated to be between -0.2 and -0.6 percentage points. 120,000 fewer private-sector jobs created during the first two weeks of October.

  • A second and important point for markets, federal data collection ceases over this period. Statistical reports will be delayed. This economic uncertainty acts like a tax on confidence. It also makes trading off data releases difficult.

Financial market impacts?


Taking the 2013 market impact as a baseline most of the negative impacts precede the actual shutdown. Rates recover slower than FX.


  • USD – In the three weeks prior to the shutdown the TW USD fell 3%. It set a base 3 business days after the shutdown ended for a total loss of 3.5%. In the following month it recovered ½ of the loss.

  • UST – 5y yields lost a total of 57 bps (1.84%-1.27%), and were slower to recover with yields rising by only 15bps in the next month. 


What happens in a shutdown?


  1. Details of which government functions stop are determined by the Office of Management and Budget.

  2. If it looks like a shutdown will occur, White House budget office works with federal agencies to determine which federal functions and employees are “essential” or "excepted." The White House has latitude in how broadly it defines "excepted."

  3. Agencies and services considered non-essential close. Federal workers will be furloughed without pay. The Federal Government employs over 4-million individuals, so this can be hundreds of thousands of workers affected. Congress may decide after the shutdown to pay them for the time off. Financial disruption is one concern.

  4. "Emergency personnel" continue to be employed, including the active duty military, federal law enforcement agents, doctors and nurses working in federal hospitals, and air traffic controllers. For the Department of Defense, at least half of the civilian workforce, and the full-time, dual-status military technicians in the US National Guard and traditional Guardsmen (those on Title 32 status) are furloughed without pay. Members of Congress continue to be paid, because their pay cannot be altered except by direct law.

Saturday, April 22, 2017

Trump Administration Begins Quiet Preparations For Government Shutdown

Even as Donald Trump is desperate to show to the US population, and especially his voter base, some actual achievement before his first 100 days run out next weekend, prompting him to tell AP that he will unveil a "tremendous" tax ut plan next week (recall he did the same in February), the Trump administration is quietly preparing for the possibility of a government shutdown, even though the president and his staff believe one is unlikely to occur. 


With the Senate reconvening on Monday and the House of Representatives on Tuesday after a two-week recess, lawmakers will have only four days to pass a spending package to keep the government open beyond April 28, when funding expires for numerous federal programs. "I think we want to keep the government open," Trump said on Thursday, adding he thinks Congress can pass the funding legislation and perhaps also a revamped healthcare bill.


Trump"s wish may be problematic: as a reminder, the government will shut down midnight on April 28 if Congress cannot agree on a spending bill. As reported over the past week, the measure hit various snags over Trump"s demands to include funding for Trump’s border wall and a debate over money for an ObamaCare insurer subsidy program, both programs which virtually assure the spending bill will not pass.


As a result, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) has begun to coordinate with government agencies to plan for a possible shutdown. “While we do not expect a lapse, prudence and common sense require routine assessments will be made,” OMB Director Mick Mulvaney said in a statement.


The office set up a phone call to go over the agencies’ shutdown plans, which could include steps such as furloughs for federal workers.  The OMB said the plans were reviewed ahead of a possible shutdown last December and are unlikely to be revised.


As Compass Point analyst Isaac Boltansky, notes, "wall funding is just one of many policy potholes that could disrupt negotiations, including ACA cost-sharing subsidies, coal miner benefits, sanctuary cities."


To be sure, Congress can avoid a full-blown shutdown if it passes a short-term spending measure to keep the government open while negotiations over a broader funding deal continue, but even that process has been put into question.


"I think we"re in good shape," President Trump said when asked about the possibility of a shutdown. “We remain confident we’re not going to have a shutdown,” White House press secretary Sean Spicer told reporters at a separate off-camera briefing, calling the preparation “required steps” for the federal agencies and departments.


Some analysts disagree with the optimistic assessment.


According to Cowen"s Chris Kruger "shutdown theatrics reach fever pitch next week, with one-week punt most likely outcome" however he focuses on the "White House’s misconception they have any leverage with Democrats when it’s the opposite, as Congressional Democrats have less than zero incentive to compromise with Trump and Trump needs them to keep govt from shutting down."


As such unless Trump concedes to all demands, not only is a full spending bill out of the question, but even a short-term agreement appears precarious.


More ominously, Kruger adds that "until this week, shutdown threat seemed very low as Congressional GOP leadership, appropriators hammered out spending agreements, were on same page as Democrats; that went sideways when White House pushed more confrontational approach on ObamaCare, immigration."


Meanwhile, Height Securities" Peter Cohn has noted the House Democrats taking a hard line against even one-week stopgap continuing resolution (CR) "due to unresolved White House demands on funding wall construction, withholding funds from sanctuary cities."


He sees 25% odds for temporary partial shutdown, with path to deal including boost for border "security" funds (not wall), added military funding. Others, such as Goldman see shutdown odds at one in three (and rising).


As Reuters adds, leading House Democrats were voicing skepticism a deal could be reached by the deadline. In a telephone call for House Democrats, Representative Nita Lowey, the senior Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee, said: "I don"t see how we can meet that deadline" and avoid having to pass a short-term extension, according to an aide on the call. The second-ranking House Democrat, Representative Steny Hoyer, told his fellow Democrats that they should only support such a short-term measure if a deal on long-term bill is reached and only finishing touches remained, the aide said.


Republican leaders face a familiar balancing act: satisfying the party"s most conservative members while not alienating its moderates.


Rules in the 100-seat Senate mean Trump"s party also would need the support of at least eight Democrats even if the Republicans remain unified, giving the opposition party leverage. House Republican leaders would need some Democratic votes if the most conservative lawmakers object to the bill, as they did to the healthcare plan championed by Speaker Paul Ryan. With congressional elections looming next year, Republicans acknowledge the stakes are high.


"Even our most recalcitrant members understand that if you shut down the government while you"re running it and you control the House and the Senate, you can"t blame anybody but yourself," said Representative Tom Cole, a senior House Appropriations Committee Republican.


White House budget director Mick Mulvaney said the Trump administration was willing to talk to Democrats about funding for Obamacare subsidies in exchange for their agreement to include some Trump priorities such as the wall, the defense hike and more money for immigration enforcement. "It is ripe for some type of negotiated agreement that gives the president some of his priorities and Democrats some of their priorities. So we think we"ve opened the door for that," Mulvaney said.


Democrats reacted negatively. "Everything had been moving smoothly until the administration moved in with a heavy hand. Not only are Democrats opposed to the wall, there is significant Republican opposition as well,” said Matt House, a spokesman for Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer.


* * *


Should the Trump and the GOP be unable to concede on some of the controversial demands floated in recent days, we expect the shut down odds to rise substantially, and instead of a "massive" tax cut, the most likely outcome may in fact be a closed government starting next weekend, and lasting for the foreseeable future.


The government was last forced to close in October 2013, when Republican Senator Ted Cruz and some of the most conservative House Republicans engineered a 17-day shutdown in an unsuccessful quest to kill Democratic former President Barack Obama"s healthcare law. Meanwhile, the current Congress has passed no major legislation since Trump took office in January. Among his ambitions are hopes for major tax-cut legislation, infrastructure spending and other bills.


A federal closure would shutter National Park Service destinations like the Statue of Liberty, Yellowstone and the Grand Canyon. Government medical research would be suspended. Thousands of federal workers would be furloughed with thousands more working without pay until the shutdown ends, including homeland security personnel. Some veterans benefits could be suspended.

Trump Administration Begins Quiet Preparations For Government Shutdown

Even as Donald Trump is desperate to show to the US population, and especially his voter base, some actual achievement before his first 100 days run out next weekend, prompting him to tell AP that he will unveil a "tremendous" tax ut plan next week (recall he did the same in February), the Trump administration is quietly preparing for the possibility of a government shutdown, even though the president and his staff believe one is unlikely to occur. 


With the Senate reconvening on Monday and the House of Representatives on Tuesday after a two-week recess, lawmakers will have only four days to pass a spending package to keep the government open beyond April 28, when funding expires for numerous federal programs. "I think we want to keep the government open," Trump said on Thursday, adding he thinks Congress can pass the funding legislation and perhaps also a revamped healthcare bill.


Trump"s wish may be problematic: as a reminder, the government will shut down midnight on April 28 if Congress cannot agree on a spending bill. As reported over the past week, the measure hit various snags over Trump"s demands to include funding for Trump’s border wall and a debate over money for an ObamaCare insurer subsidy program, both programs which virtually assure the spending bill will not pass.


As a result, the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) has begun to coordinate with government agencies to plan for a possible shutdown. “While we do not expect a lapse, prudence and common sense require routine assessments will be made,” OMB Director Mick Mulvaney said in a statement.


The office set up a phone call to go over the agencies’ shutdown plans, which could include steps such as furloughs for federal workers.  The OMB said the plans were reviewed ahead of a possible shutdown last December and are unlikely to be revised.


As Compass Point analyst Isaac Boltansky, notes, "wall funding is just one of many policy potholes that could disrupt negotiations, including ACA cost-sharing subsidies, coal miner benefits, sanctuary cities."


To be sure, Congress can avoid a full-blown shutdown if it passes a short-term spending measure to keep the government open while negotiations over a broader funding deal continue, but even that process has been put into question.


"I think we"re in good shape," President Trump said when asked about the possibility of a shutdown. “We remain confident we’re not going to have a shutdown,” White House press secretary Sean Spicer told reporters at a separate off-camera briefing, calling the preparation “required steps” for the federal agencies and departments.


Some analysts disagree with the optimistic assessment.


According to Cowen"s Chris Kruger "shutdown theatrics reach fever pitch next week, with one-week punt most likely outcome" however he focuses on the "White House’s misconception they have any leverage with Democrats when it’s the opposite, as Congressional Democrats have less than zero incentive to compromise with Trump and Trump needs them to keep govt from shutting down."


As such unless Trump concedes to all demands, not only is a full spending bill out of the question, but even a short-term agreement appears precarious.


More ominously, Kruger adds that "until this week, shutdown threat seemed very low as Congressional GOP leadership, appropriators hammered out spending agreements, were on same page as Democrats; that went sideways when White House pushed more confrontational approach on ObamaCare, immigration."


Meanwhile, Height Securities" Peter Cohn has noted the House Democrats taking a hard line against even one-week stopgap continuing resolution (CR) "due to unresolved White House demands on funding wall construction, withholding funds from sanctuary cities."


He sees 25% odds for temporary partial shutdown, with path to deal including boost for border "security" funds (not wall), added military funding. Others, such as Goldman see shutdown odds at one in three (and rising).


As Reuters adds, leading House Democrats were voicing skepticism a deal could be reached by the deadline. In a telephone call for House Democrats, Representative Nita Lowey, the senior Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee, said: "I don"t see how we can meet that deadline" and avoid having to pass a short-term extension, according to an aide on the call. The second-ranking House Democrat, Representative Steny Hoyer, told his fellow Democrats that they should only support such a short-term measure if a deal on long-term bill is reached and only finishing touches remained, the aide said.


Republican leaders face a familiar balancing act: satisfying the party"s most conservative members while not alienating its moderates.


Rules in the 100-seat Senate mean Trump"s party also would need the support of at least eight Democrats even if the Republicans remain unified, giving the opposition party leverage. House Republican leaders would need some Democratic votes if the most conservative lawmakers object to the bill, as they did to the healthcare plan championed by Speaker Paul Ryan. With congressional elections looming next year, Republicans acknowledge the stakes are high.


"Even our most recalcitrant members understand that if you shut down the government while you"re running it and you control the House and the Senate, you can"t blame anybody but yourself," said Representative Tom Cole, a senior House Appropriations Committee Republican.


White House budget director Mick Mulvaney said the Trump administration was willing to talk to Democrats about funding for Obamacare subsidies in exchange for their agreement to include some Trump priorities such as the wall, the defense hike and more money for immigration enforcement. "It is ripe for some type of negotiated agreement that gives the president some of his priorities and Democrats some of their priorities. So we think we"ve opened the door for that," Mulvaney said.


Democrats reacted negatively. "Everything had been moving smoothly until the administration moved in with a heavy hand. Not only are Democrats opposed to the wall, there is significant Republican opposition as well,” said Matt House, a spokesman for Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer.


* * *


Should the Trump and the GOP be unable to concede on some of the controversial demands floated in recent days, we expect the shut down odds to rise substantially, and instead of a "massive" tax cut, the most likely outcome may in fact be a closed government starting next weekend, and lasting for the foreseeable future.


The government was last forced to close in October 2013, when Republican Senator Ted Cruz and some of the most conservative House Republicans engineered a 17-day shutdown in an unsuccessful quest to kill Democratic former President Barack Obama"s healthcare law. Meanwhile, the current Congress has passed no major legislation since Trump took office in January. Among his ambitions are hopes for major tax-cut legislation, infrastructure spending and other bills.


A federal closure would shutter National Park Service destinations like the Statue of Liberty, Yellowstone and the Grand Canyon. Government medical research would be suspended. Thousands of federal workers would be furloughed with thousands more working without pay until the shutdown ends, including homeland security personnel. Some veterans benefits could be suspended.