Showing posts with label Chinese Wall. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chinese Wall. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 28, 2017

Banks "Gag" Analysts From Discussing Politics On Air

In what may be a welcome change to what is already an overly politically charged financial atmosphere, Reuters reports that major banks are cracking down on market analysts talking publicly about politics over concerns of appearing partial with HSBC going so far to take its main global currencies commentator off air in an intensification of the financial "gag order." HSBC, which has seen its share of political cross-currents in recent years, especially when it comes to money laundering and funding quasi-legal regimes, said that currency strategists at HSBC"s global research division would not be making "unsupervised" public appearances due to concerns about commenting on political events which have been seen to drive prices.


HSBC is not alone: a Reuters source said that Credit Agricole strategists had been similarly instructed not to talk about the details of the French presidential campaign, which has moved the price of the euro currency. Other major banks including Citigroup, Barclays and Bank of America already have tight controls in place aimed at keeping comments by strategists politically neutral, "but a blanket ban on public appearances is unusual."


As part of the crackdown, HSBC"s David Bloom, and other currency analysts from the bank, would not be appearing on television for some time. As HSBC"s chief currency strategist, Bloom was among the most outspoken commentators on the impact on sterling of the British vote to leave the European Union. He correctly forecast a dramatic fall and then dubbed the pound the government"s "de facto official opposition" as it sank after the vote last June. That said, Bloom and other currency strategists would continue to meet clients and write regular research.





"We are still engaging with the media. Our economists are engaging, our equity strategists are engaging," one source at HSBC said, asking not to be named.



"But politics is something the bank does not want to talk about and currencies are probably the front line of where we could actually be drawn into something that we would want to avoid. This is a temporary thing."



HSBC has enforced a global crackdown on bankers" interactions with the media over the past two years, other sources at the bank told Reuters, including reducing the number of staff approved to talk to the press and requiring bankers to notify public relations whenever they meet with a reporter.


While perhaps welcome, the enforced gag is also troubling and reeks of censorship imposed by forces from outside the bank"s corner office: the HSBC move follows a number of European banks tightening up on how freely currency market analysts are allowed to speak to the media and in public situations in the past three years. Part of that has been driven by a tightening of regulation after several of the world"s biggest banks were fined billions for manipulating the $5 trillion a day global currencies market. Banks are also preparing for changes imposed by Europe"s MiFID II banking regulations at the end of this year.





But several banks also told strategists not to comment publicly on the Scottish independence referendum in 2014, and there were widespread limits on how freely analysts could discuss last year"s Brexit vote for fear of breaking electoral rules and alienating customers.



Of course, with a wave of political events on the horizon, including French, German, Dutch, and possibly Italian elections in the coming months, and seen as carrying similar risks for the euro this year to the waves of selling that have hit the pound in the past 12 months, very soon not a single European currency strategist may be left speaking.


The anti-media blowback may be only just starting: as Reuters adds, strategists from several banks said that following the surprise election of U.S. President Donald Trump and last year"s Brexit shock it was now standard practice to be told to steer clear of discussing the details of what was positive or negative for markets in the political sphere, for fear of being seen to make unqualified judgements on policy or politics.


"It is very common now for there to be limits," said a strategist with one European bank. "What the market thinks about (French presidential candidate) Marine Le Pen is not purely about economics, it"s about the broader political risks, which then might play out in demand, growth and so on. Am I qualified to talk about that?" the strategist added.  The answer is unclear, especially after Bloomberg reported last week that top advisers to French presidential candidate Marine Le Pen have met with strategists and analysts from BlackRock Inc, Barclays Plc and UBS Group AG, among other firms to explain their economic program and plans to withdraw France from the euro. As such, previously porous Chinese wall between financial commentary and inside knowledge into politics may soon become insurmountable.


"Is it really clear what is moving the market? It is obviously shaky ground" the (soon to be gagged) Reuters source added.

Saturday, January 28, 2017

Pension managers are next

Pension Funds represent the retirement accounts for basically 99% of the working class.  Because they don"t have many choices, unlike Ultra High Net Worth Individuals.  Global Pension Assets stand at a staggering $35 Trillion according to Willis Towers Watson:



  • At the end of 2015, total pension assets were estimated at USD 35.4 trillion, which represents a decrease of 0.5% compared to USD 35.6 trillion at the end of 2014

  • Pension assets relative to GDP reached 80% in 2015, which represents a decrease of 4% from the 2014 ratio of 84%

  • The largest pension markets are the US, UK and Japan with 62%, 9% and 8% of total pension assets in the study, respectively

USD 35.4 Trillion is a lot of assets, no matter how you look at it.  In any systemic analysis we often forget about such huge pools of capital.  Mostly, these assets are sitting in stocks and bonds, some real estate - all traditional.  They don"t invest in alternatives (because of regulatory rules, mostly).  


Well, recently Harvard Management Company, the unit that manages Harvard"s USD 35 Billion endowment, fired half of its staff:





In what may be the most stunning move in the asset management space in years, the WSJ reports that Harvard University’s endowment, which manages just shy of $36 billion, will undergo a "radical overhaul" in the way the world’s wealthiest school invests its money by outsourcing management of most of its assets and lay off roughly half the staff in the process.


According to the WSJ, about half of the 230 employees at Harvard Management Company will leave as part of a sweeping change by the university’s new endowment chief, N.P. “Narv” Narvekar. This means that the endowment will shut down its internal hedge funds and let go traders by the middle of the year. Additionally, the internal team in charge of direct real-estate investments is expected to spin out into an independent entity that Harvard is expected to invest with. Only management of Harvard’s natural resources portfolio and passively managed exchange-traded funds will remain in house.



Is this a sign of things to come?  Well, yeah - Pension Funds like Calpers for example have struggled in recent years... REALLY STRUGGLED.  "Struggled" is an understatement - they lost $30 Billion in 2015.


Many fund managers and traders often scratch their heads at how something can be possible, when there is an apparent sea of consistent strategies offering moderate, if not conservative, returns (like 20% per year.)


But such funds like Harvard and Calpers are rife with politics, and staffed with people that generally don"t understand markets.  Of course there are exceptions - but having a $30 Billion loss without any hedging in place - well, that"s really unprofessional, to say the least.


Of course, once again, who suffers?  It"s not going to be the Pension managers, or the hedge funds they "outsourced" to manage the funds - it"s the beneficiaries - working people.  Retirement plans, pension plans - can blow up.  Or in the best case, as is the case now, they can dwindle down so poorly to the point that retirees get only a fraction of what they are expecting.


There"s really no solution to this problem, except for working people to stand up to their pension managers - which they do from time to time, but the Pension Funds are staffed with a political Chinese Wall of staffers with "quick answers" to shut down their inquiries.  


With the renovations Trump is doing to the system of American Government - is the public pension system next?  Harvard"s move may be a sign of things to come.  And it needs reform, losing $30 Billion like Calpers is at best, shameful.  At worst, illegal.


For a great book to learn about how the markets REALLY work, checkout Splitting Pennies, or see some more great books on the markets here.


To learn how to trade and invest checkout Fortress Capital Trading Academy