Showing posts with label Securities research. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Securities research. Show all posts

Thursday, October 12, 2017

Would You Pay $2,500 For One Hour With An Equity Analyst? This I-Bank Seems To Think So...

Wall Street equity analysts are paid "yuge" salaries to employee the finance skills they picked up from their business school professors to value various corporate securities and asset-backed securitization structures, among other things.  And while their valuations of those securities have served as a frequent source of comic relief for many of us over the years, no bastardization of basic financial concepts tops recent attempts by the financial elites of the world to place a value on their own services.


As evidence of that fact, we present to you "Exhibit A" from a Bloomberg article published earlier today suggesting that Morgan Stanley, who is still trying to figure out how much their equity research is worth to clients after nearly a year of internal cogitation, is considering asking hedge fund clients for $2,500 for the extreme pleasure of spending just one hour with one of their esteemed research analysts.





Fund managers will have to pay about $2,500 for an hour-long, one-on-one meeting with some of Morgan Stanley’s equity analysts once Europe’s MiFID II financial rules kick in, according to people with knowledge of the plan.



The fee is on top of the annual rate Morgan Stanley plans to charge some clients for basic access to its equity research portal once the regulations come into force in January, the people said, asking not to be named as the negotiations are private. The bank also quoted a small client $25,000 annually for five users for basic equity research access and five total hours of analyst time, another person said.



Equity Research


Of course, any I-banking summer intern could easily spot the outlier in Morgan Stanley"s proposed $2,500 hourly billing rate when matched up against comps from the legal industry.  According to the National Law Journal, even the priciest partners at the best law firms can only command hourly billing rates equal to roughly half of what Morgan Stanley wants.



Meanwhile, the "median" partner at any given law firm only gets paid about one-fifth of Morgan Stanley"s proposal.



As McKinsey & Co. recently pointed out, the end result is that new European regulations designed to separate research and trading revenue for investment banks will likely cost them more than $1 billion as clients become pickier about what they pay for. 


Of course, ultimately the market will set a clearing price for the "value add" of equity analysts...and we"re almost certain it"s going to surprise some folks.

Thursday, August 24, 2017

Deutsche Bank Forced To Slash Fixed-Income Research Price By Half On Lackluster Demand

One by one over the past several months, Europe"s largest investment banks have each rolled out their new pricing models detailing how they"ll charge for research in 2018 once the new MiFID II regulations go into effect.  Pricing strategies have varied from expensive all-in packages costing nearly $500,000 a year to pay-as-you-go plans that charge for each research report individually.  Here are a couple of recent examples:


That said, ever since the first pricing plans hit the market we"ve maintained that the finance world"s masters of corporate valuation might ultimately find themselves shocked by the bid/ask spread between what they think their daily pearls of financial wisdom are worth versus the value that asset managers are willing to ascribe to those services.  Here"s how we summed it up in one of our first posts on the topic:





Literally no one knows the true "value" of research, not even the investment banks that are selling it.  Up until now, equity research has been treated as a "freebie" given away to institutional clients in return for trading commissions but that is all about to change thanks to the European Union’s MiFID II regulations, which require asset managers to separate trading commissions from investment-research payments.



Unfortunately, at least for the Investment Banks of the world, while the cost of generating equity research may be substantial, it turns out that the true "value", as defined by institutional clients" maximum willingness to pay for reports, may be much less.  Which is shocking given the creativity required to constantly generate new variations of daily reports politely suggesting that you "Buy The Fucking Dip."



But, as banks try to figure out their "value add", the bid ask spread ranges from about $50,000 for a basic, annual fixed income package up to $600,000.  In other words, at least 1 investment bank thinks their research is worth roughly 6 full-time, dedicated junior analysts.



Of course, as we said before, almost any amount of money seems, at least to us, to be too much to have the same people give you the same advice over and over again, namely "buy more stocks, faster."  There, we just summarized 90% of all equity research that will ever be written for the rest of history in 4 simple words and completely free of charge.  You"re welcome.



Analyst



Now, it turns out that Deutsche has become the first investment bank forced to admit what we"ve known for some time now, namely that the commoditized product they sell into a hyper-competitive, saturated market might not be as valuable as they once thought.  And, to our complete "shock", they"ve been forced to slash their research prices in half as a result.  Per Bloomberg:





Deutsche Bank AG has halved the price of its fixed-income and macro research as competition mounts in the run-up to Europe’s MiFID II regulations, three people with knowledge of its plans said.



The German lender proposes to charge asset managers 30,000 euros ($35,000) a year for up to 10 users, said the people, who asked not to be identified because the information is private. This was cut from the 60,000 euros it had initially planned after other banks revised their prices lower, according to a memo sent to clients. A spokesman for Deutsche Bank declined to comment.



So, what do you get as part of this new 50% off deal?  How about free web access to reports (which is great because the carrier pigeons have been really slow lately) and the ability to actually speak with analysts...is that something that might interest you?





Deutsche Bank’s 30,000-euro package includes web access to written research and contact with analysts, the people said. Deliberations are ongoing and the bank hasn’t made a final decision on the pricing.



The Frankfurt-based lender’s prices are linked to the number of users. Web-only access for up to five people is quoted at 15,000 euros per year, while a package including web access and contact with analysts is 50,000 euros for up to 25 users, one of the people with knowledge of the matter said.



Why do we have a sneaking suspicion that DB isn"t going to be the only bank forced to slash their research prices?

Saturday, July 29, 2017

Spot The Conflict(s): This Strip-Club Operator Pays Sidoti $40,000 A Year To Cover It's Stock

We"ve spent a lot of time of late discussing Europe"s new MiFID II regulations that will go into effect in January 2018 and require investment banks to charge institutional clients separately for trading commissions and research.  As we"ve noted (here and here), initial offer prices are coming in relatively high at around $450,000 per bank...all of which led us to the following conclusions:





Of course, the logical takeaway from these exorbitant offering prices, if they hold, is that institutional clients will ultimately be forced to consolidate their vendors...translation, so long to the small independent research shops.  Meanwhile, investment banks will be forced to control costs by trying to focus on writing reports that people actually read (vs. the 1% hit rate they have today).  All of which means that those shrinking analysts pools are about to completely collapse.



Alas, it seems that we may have been a bit premature in our prediction of an early demise for independent research shops, at least if Sidoti and Rick"s Caberet has anything to say about it.  In light of the new regulations that will undoubtedly disadvantage his research firm, Peter Sidoti has embraced a whole new, fundamental-transformed research business model that he hopes will save his business...charging the companies he covers for research about themselves.  More from Bloomberg:





With the future of equity research looking shakier than ever, one boutique U.S. firm is betting its turnaround on getting paid by a different customer: the company being covered.



As analyst budgets get slashed amid new regulations designed to reduce conflicts of interest, Peter Sidoti hopes that laying those conflicts out in the open with company-sponsored research can bolster his small-cap focused firm, Sidoti & Co. “The wheels came off” Sidoti’s trading-pays-for-research model about a year ago amid shrinking fees and the rise of passive investing, he said. Bring in new rules requiring direct payment for research, “and all hell breaks loose.”



Three companies -- a strip-club operator, a pet products company and a chipmaker -- pay Sidoti $40,000 a year for coverage by the firm’s 25 analysts. Ultimately, he sees one-third of the stocks his firm covers, now around 300, being paying customers. The sweet spot for research sponsored by companies is those with a market capitalization of under $300 million and which have one or no analysts covering them, Sidoti, the founder and CEO of the firm, said in an interview in New York.



Wouldn"t it be ironic if new regulations specifically designed to eliminate banking conflicts actually resulted in an even more conflict-ridden business model?


But, at least Rick"s CEO is happy with his coverage...





Adult entertainment and sports bar company RCI Hospitality Holdings Inc., which pays for Sidoti’s services, said that it is challenging for smaller companies to get quality, independent analyst coverage. “We believe Sidoti has contributed to our overall effort to increase the understanding of our business and financial model,” Eric Langan, RCI’s Chief Executive Officer, said in an email. The company, which operates the Bombshells bar chain, has seen its stock gain 92 percent since Sidoti started coverage. Pet-products company OurPet’s Co. and chipmaker Ixys Corp., which are also paying customers of Sidoti, didn’t respond to multiple requests for comments.





Sidoti defends it"s rather controversial business model by comparing it to Moody"s and S&P which employee similar funding strategies...unfortunately, the weaknesses in those funding strategies were exposed for all the world to see during the mortgage crisis.





“We think equity research is heading the same way as debt research,” Sidoti said, drawing a comparison with how debt-rating companies like Moody’s Investors Service and S&P Global Ratings are paid by issuers to produce reports. While this model has also been fraught with conflicts and controversy, especially in the aftermath of the financial crisis, Sidoti sees a new opportunity for the sponsored-research model arising from the European Union’s MiFID II rules.



While we jest, at least the conflicts in Sidoti"s business model are overt and open for the world to see...unlike the current model which pretends to be "independent" but secretly favors the perpetual advisory fee generating companies they cover and give preferential treatment to their favorite hedge funds.


Finally, since we know that you really only clicked on this post to see a larger picture of the teaser image, here you go...Happy Friday.


Thursday, July 27, 2017

Barclays Seeks $455,000 For 'Gold' Equity Research Package; Includes 'Field Trips' And 'Occasional' 1x1's

Literally no one knows the true "value" of equity research, not even the investment banks that are selling it.  Up until now, equity research has been treated as a "freebie" given away to institutional clients in return for trading commissions but that is all about to change thanks to the European Union’s MiFID II regulations, which require asset managers to separate trading commissions from investment-research payments.


Unfortunately, at least for the Investment Banks of the world, while the cost of generating equity research may be substantial, it turns out that the true "value", as defined by institutional clients" maximum willingness to pay for reports, may be much less.  Which is shocking given the creativity required to constantly generate new variations of daily reports politely suggesting that you "Buy The Fucking Dip."


Be that as it may, with deadlines right around the corner, 2018 offer prices for equity research in Europe are starting to roll in and we suspect there may be a little sticker shock among institutional clients who are used to having unlimited access to all research in return for placing a few trades each year.  Just a few weeks ago we noted that Credit Agricole offered their "Premium Research Package" for the bargain basement price of 400,000 Euros.  Nomura, on the other hand, played the volume game by giving away their "BTFD" reports for just $134,000 a year.


Now, we can add Barclays to the list. Coming in at $455,000 per year for their "Gold" package, it"s hard to imagine how hedgies won"t be knocking down their doors to gain access.  Per Bloomberg:





The firm is proposing three levels of service -- bronze, silver and gold -- with the premium package comprising unlimited reports, field trips and “occasional” one-on-one meetings with analysts and corporate executives, according to a pricing document seen by Bloomberg News. At the bottom end of the scale, read-only access to European research will start at 30,000 pounds.



At Barclays, even if clients stump up 350,000 pounds for the gold “trans-Atlantic” package, they could still end up spending more. “Bespoke” analyst work and corporate access is priced separately, according to the document. Field trips, industry events and company management meetings are also at the bank’s discretion, and analyst one-on-ones are “capped,” it shows.



Prices in the document may not apply to all clients, have been in flux and could still be subject to change, a person familiar with the process said, asking not to be identified discussing the matter. A Barclays spokesman declined to comment.



Banks are scrambling as they enter the last six months before the decades-old practice of sending out free analyst reports as a courtesy and marketing strategy comes to an end. The European Union’s MiFID II regulations, enforced from Jan. 3, require money managers to separate the trading commissions they pay from investment-research fees. This means banks in turn have to be more transparent, providing specific charges for their analysts’ time and work in order to comply.



Of course, the logical takeaway from these exorbitant offering prices, if they hold, is that institutional clients will ultimately be forced to consolidate their vendors...translation, so long to the small independent research shops.  Meanwhile, investment banks will be forced to control costs by trying to focus on writing reports that people actually read (vs. the 1% hit rate they have today).  All of which means that those shrinking analysts pools are about to completely collapse.




In fact, as McKinsey recently noted, up to 30% of research analysts could be at risk of losing their cushy banking jobs as result of Europe"s new regulations.





Europe’s impending ban on free research will cost hundreds of analysts their jobs with banks set to cut about $1.2 billion of investment on the area, according to a report by McKinsey & Co.



The consultancy estimates the $4 billion that the top-10 sell-side banks currently spend on research annually is likely to fall by 30 percent as clients become pickier about what they pay for, McKinsey Partner Roger Rudisuli said in an interview. Investment banks’ cash equity research headcount has fallen 12 percent to 3,900 since 2011 compared with as much as 40 percent in sales and trading, leaving the area facing “big cuts” to catch up, he said.



“Two to three global banking players will preserve their status in the new era, winning the execution arms race and dominating trading in equities around the globe,” McKinsey said in a report Wednesday, which Rudisuli helped write. “Over the coming five years, banks will need to make hard choices and play to their strengths. Not only will the top ranks be thinned out, there will be shakeouts in regional markets.”



Of course, as we"ve said before, almost any amount of money seems, at least to us, to be too much to have the same people give you the same advice over and over again, namely "buy more stocks, faster."