Showing posts with label Political parties in the United States. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Political parties in the United States. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 9, 2017

There Is No "Political Center" In Modern America

Authored by Gaius Publius via Down With Tyranny blog,



An entirely false but constantly sold view of the American electorate


In an April 2016 piece, in the middle of the Democratic primary, I wrote this about modern independent voters and the upcoming general election:





If you look at the swell of new voters in both parties, the increase is for the "change" candidate, not the one promising to retain and refresh the status-quo. The presidential candidate who wins this election will be the one who best appeals to the new "radical independent"...



Today"s independents aren"t "moderates" who want conventional, faux-centrist policies and less "gridlock." Political partisans want less gridlock around issues of disagreement, because it advances individual party agendas and careers in addition to those issues. But in the main and with a few important exceptions — women"s health and rights, racial justice, gun violence — both parties have agreed and cooperated on broad policy goals.



Leaders of both parties, for example, broadly believe in the current military style of policing. Both believe in a justice system that coerces defendants into plea bargains, guilty or innocent. Both believe in the "importance of Wall Street to the economy" and that big financial institutions should be defended, not broken up. Both parties have offered and enacted a long and strong diet of lower taxes, spending austerity, war and more war. We"ve had these policies, delivered in a fully bipartisan way, for decades....



Today"s independents, in contrast, are done with that.



This led to a prediction that "to win, Clinton must win Sanders independents. If she fails, she is likely to lose. The problem for Clinton is, how to do that."


And indeed, Clinton did lose.


There"s more to say, obviously, about why Clinton lost. But it"s certainly true that, if 2016 were not a "change year" election, Clinton would have won by a mile. For example, if Clinton were running for a second term in 2012 instead of Obama, she"d have had no problem beating the Republican. It"s only in a "change year" election — 2008, for example — that a status quo candidate has trouble against a "change" candidate; and indeed, Clinton was defeated by that year"s "change" candidate, Barack Obama.


In 2016, instead of sailing to victory Clinton was nosed out in a squeaker. Even if that win was stolen it could only have been stolen if it were close. To use a football analogy, the refs can"t throw the game to your opponent if you"re winning by four touchdowns. In a hostile stadium with hostile refs, best not be barely ahead with two minutes to go.


In the Center of Nowhere


Confirmation of part of this analysis — that Clinton"s attempt to win by wooing "centrist" voters sloshing undecidely between the parties was an error — comes from a 2016 book, Democracy for Realists, by political scientists Larry Bartels and Christopher Achen. As Eric Levitz writes in a recent New York Magazine article,





"The notion that there is an easily identifiable, median political ideology in America derives from the "spatial model" [i.e., linear] of the electorate, which first gained prominence in the middle of the 20th century."



This "spacial model" of the electorate should be familiar to every American, since it"s sold by every mainstream media outlet. This model posits a single line of policy choices — arrayed in just two dimensions from "left" to "right" — with voters arrayed somewhere along it as well. Thus there are "left" policy choices, "right" policy choices, and voters in a kind of bell-shaped curve arrayed along it as well. "Left" voters prefer "left" policies, "right" voters prefer "right" policies, with the vast majority of voters somewhere in the middle.


Bartels and Achen, as quoted by Levitz, describe the linear analogy this way (my emphasis):





[T]he political “space” consists of a single ideological dimension on which feasible policies are arrayed from left to right. Each voter is represented by an ideal point along this dimension reflecting the policy she prefers to all others. Each party is represented by a platform reflecting the policy it will enact if elected. Voters are assumed to maximize their ideological satisfaction with the election outcome by voting for the parties closest to them on the ideological dimension, Parties are assumed to maximize their expected payoff from office-holding by choosing the platforms most likely to get them elected.



[T]his framework is sufficient to derive a striking and substantively important prediction: both parties will adopt identical platforms corresponding to the median of the distribution of voters’ ideal points.



In other words, if it is assumed that most voters are on the "left," the party to the "right" will drift that way. If it is assumed most voters are on the "right," the "left" party will similarly move. And if voters are in the "center," both parties will tend to move there with them.


What Bartels and Achen discovered was something that should have been obvious from the start — that this is just not the case. What they discovered is that there is no political "center" in modern America.


As Levitz writes:





A 2014 study from Berkeley political scientists David Broockman and Douglas Ahler surveyed voters on 13 policy issues — offering them seven different positions to choose from on each, ranging from extremely liberal to extremely conservative. On only two of those issues — gay rights and the environment — was the centrist position the most common one. On marijuana, the most popular policy was full legalization; on immigration, the most widely favored proposal was “the immediate roundup and deportation of all undocumented immigrants and an outright moratorium on all immigration until the border is proven secure”; and on taxes, the most popular option was to increase the rate on income above $250,000 by more than 5 percent. Meanwhile, establishing a maximum annual income of $1 million (by taxing all income above that at 100 percent) was the third most common choice, boasting four times more support than the national Republican Party’s platform on taxation.



When pundits implore Democrats not to abandon the center, they do not typically mean that the party should embrace legal weed, much higher taxes on the rich, and mass deportation. More often, such pundits call on Team Blue to embrace a combination of moderate fiscal conservatism, a cosmopolitan attitude toward globalization, and moderate social liberalism — in short, to become the party of Michael Bloomberg (minus, perhaps, the enthusiasm for nanny-state public-health regulations). The former New York mayor is routinely referred to as a centrist in the mainstream press, despite the fact that his policy commitments — support for Social Security cuts, Wall Street deregulation, mass immigration, and marriage equality — when taken together, put him at the fringes of American public opinion[.]



Note that this analysis is multi-dimensional. Even a two-dimensional representation couldn"t do it justice.


Why Do Democrats Pursue Non-Existent "Centrist" Voters?


If there are no voters in the political "center," a strategy based on winning them is likely to fail. So why pursue them? Perhaps because voters aren"t what the Democratic Party - or either American political party these days - is pursuing. Perhaps it"s because what both parties are actually pursuing - is money.


Levitz seems to agree. In his article he quotes David Broockman, the study"s co-author, as saying this in an interview:





When we say moderate what we really mean is what corporations want …



Within both parties there is this tension between what the politicians who get more corporate money and tend to be part of the establishment want — that’s what we tend to call moderate — versus what the Tea Party and more liberal members want.



From this we can easily draw three conclusions:


  • The only "center" in modern American politics consists of policies the people who finance elections want to see enacted.

  • The mainstream media and both political parties regularly labels these policies "centrist."

  • The way to be called "moderate" by the mainstream press is to advocate for "centrist" policies.

And yet, one can easily predict a series of "change year" elections stretching far into the future in which "centrist" candidates will fail again and again, since America"s economic problems show no signs of being fixed anytime soon.


This is not because the means of fixing those problems don"t exist, though, and aren"t readily at hand. Levitz closes by saying:





On most of these [economic] issues, effective policy responses aren’t unknown — they’re just considered politically untenable. We know how to reduce inequality and eradicate poverty: you redistribute pre-tax income from the rich to the poor. When America expanded the welfare state, its poverty rate went down; when it scaled back the safety net, the opposite occurred. Nordic social democracies devote more resources to propping up the living standards of their most vulnerable citizens than most other countries, and their poverty rates are among the lowest in the world, as a result.



We know how to reduce student debt: You have the government directly subsidize the cost of higher education. And we know to reduce medical costs while achieving universal coverage — you let the state cap reimbursement rates, and subsidize the medical costs of the sick and the poor until everyone can afford basic medical care, (as they do in virtually every other developed nation on Earth). And while we can’t be certain about exactly what it will take to avert ecological catastrophe, we know that the more rapidly we transition our energy infrastructure toward renewable fuels, the better our odds will be.



It just means that voters" desire to see them fixed will go unfulfilled by any party running a "status quo" candidate.


Radical Independents Are Here to Stay


The day of the "radical independent" is here. Yet by not selling themselves as proponents of economic reform in addition to reform on the numerous "rights" or "identity" issues, the Democratic Party is abandoning the demographic it needs to start winning elections again.


Has anything changed recently with the introduction of the Democrat"s "Better Deal" campaign? Richard Eskow convincingly argues no. It may be time to admit that the reason we have Republicans in power — in a majority of states as well as the federal government — owes less to Vladimir Putin than it does to mainstream Democrats themselves.



Americans have not much ability to "fix" Vladimir Putin. Do American have the ability to "fix" the Democratic Party, to cure it of its need to pursue money instead of voters? Perhaps, but not if the Party doesn"t want to be fixed.

Saturday, July 15, 2017

Most Republicans Say Universities Negatively Impact America

A majority of Republicans think higher education is having a negative effect on the U.S. according to new polling from the Pew Research Center.


As Statista"s Niall McCarthy notes, both Democrats and Republicans are deeply divided about the impact of a whole host of institutions and in many instances, that partisan divide has widened significantly over the past 12 months. The level of division is most evident when it comes to America"s colleges and universities...


Infographic: Most Republicans Say Universities Negatively Impact U.S. | Statista


You will find more statistics at Statista


While 55 percent of the public think U.S. colleges and universities are having a positive effect on the country, Republicans are particularly downcast about higher education. Pew found that an overwhelming 72 percent majority of Democrats think colleges and universities are exherting a positive influence while 58 percent of Republicans say they are having a negative effect.


Republican skepticism of the national news media is no secret so it comes as little surprise that 85 percent say it is having a negative effect on the country. Democrats are more divided on the media with 46 percent saying it is negative and 44 percent feeling it is positive. When it comes to banks and financial institutions, Democrats are more skeptical than Republicans while majorities in both parties are positive about churches and religious organizations.

Tuesday, July 4, 2017

Only 4 House Republicans Say They Would Support "Clean" Debt-Ceiling Hike

With the CBO warning that the Treasury is on track to run out of cash in less than four months, Republicans are facing a difficult internecine struggle to raise the debt limits as both conservatives and moderates demand riders that stipulate how the money can be spent. And while the Trump administration has sought to play down this conflict, as the Hill reports, support for a “clean” debt-ceiling hike – that is, raising the debt ceiling with no strings attached – is dwindling as only a handful of the 16 remaining House Republicans who backed the last clean hike say they would back another. Yet, though Democratic support for a clean bill is far from assured, the Republicans’ much narrower majority in the Senate increases the likelihood of a clean hike.


Only 16 House Republicans who are currently in office backed the last “clean” debt hike, and few of them will say they are certain to support it this year. If the debt ceiling is raised with a clean hike — a distinct possibility given Democratic demands and the narrow, 52-seat majority for the GOP in the Senate, Republicans will need at least 24 members of their own conference to back a clean debt bill in the House.


That could be a tall order. Only four of the 16 Republicans who voted for the clean debt hike in 2014 suggest they will or are open to doing so this fall.



Even Paul Ryan voted against the last debt-ceiling bill in 2014 when he was Chairman of the House Ways and Means Committee. And in the Senate, every Republican opposed the bill the last time around. Given these odds, the chances of another round of downgrade-inducing gridlock are high – and the possibility of raising the US borrowing limit before Congress’s August recess, as Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin has repeatedly urged, are looking increasingly remote. The problem is compounded by the fact that this is the first time in 11 years that the GOP will be in charge of raising the debt ceiling while controlling both chambers of Congress AND the White House, meaning that the optics surrounding who “owns” the bill will complicate the voting process.


Furthermore, the Democratic leadership appears to be standing by its policy of obstructionism, unwilling to do President Donald Trump any political favors, according to the Hill.





That political dynamic puts all of the responsibility for raising the debt ceiling on the GOP, and little if any on Democrats. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) will not want to give slack to vulnerable Republicans who don’t want to back the debt ceiling hike for their own party’s president.



“I don’t see Democrats bailing out Republicans, just like Republicans didn’t bail out Democrats,” said Steve Bell, senior advisor for the Bipartisan Policy Center and a former staff director of the Senate Budget Committee. “They’ll say ‘we’re going to give you the same amount of help you gave us.’”



In the spring, Pelosi and Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) suggested that Democrats could withhold support from a clean debt hike if Republicans separately press for legislation cutting taxes on the wealthy.



They later said that Democrats would back a clean debt hike, but Pelosi will want as many Republicans as possible to support it since their party controls the White House. And the tax talk has given an argument to any liberal who chooses to oppose a debt ceiling hike.



So far, only four of the 16 House Republicans who backed the clean debt ceiling in 2014 suggested they would consider voting for a clean hike – far below the 24 votes needed to pass such a bill. They are: Charlie Dent (Pa.), Darrel Issa (Calif.), Peter King (N.Y.) and David Valadao (Calif.).



Members of the Trump administration have expressed conflicting views on the debt ceiling. Mnuchin supports a clean bill, while Mick Mulvaney, a former House Republican who voted against the last clean debt-ceiling bill, has said there should not be a clean debt hike vote.


Conservative Republicans are already pressing Ryan to tie spending cuts or budgetary reforms to a debt-limit bill, signaling they do not plan on changing their strategy with fellow Republican Donald Trump in the White House. Meanwhile, the official Democratic position is to support a clean bill. If the House could pass a debt ceiling bill that includes provisions backed by conservatives, the Senate would need at least eight Democrats to back it in the Senate to overcome an expected filibuster.


The last time the US infamously shut down due to passing its debt ceiling was in August 2011, when S&P downgraded the US, formerly at a AAA rating, for the first time ever prompting a furious response from then-Treasury secretary Tim Geithner.



Of course, raising the debt ceiling is hardly the only issue where Republicans remain deeply divided. With Congress observing the July 4 holiday, they’re likely to get an earful from governors in the 31 states that expanded Medicaid, who say the Republican plan to repeal and replace Obamacare goes too far, according to the Wall Street Journal. Nine Republicans oppose the legislation in its current form – seven more than Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell can afford to lose.


Here"s WSJ:





Most vocal are governors of states that expanded their Medicaid eligibility under the Affordable Care Act. The bill would phase out that expansion and transform the state-federal safety-net program into one in which the federal government’s share would be capped. In all, the bill would cut $772 billion in funding for the program over a decade.


“It’s a pretty big deal, because in most cases these states have had bitter battles inside the state legislature and [with the] governor about [Medicaid], and it’s been settled in favor of expansion,” said Stewart Verdery, a former GOP Senate aide and founder of Monument Policy Group, a lobbying and public-affairs firm.


For any Republican senator “to blow that up from afar is really dicey,” Mr. Verdery said.


In Nevada, Republican Sen. Dean Heller, who faces a tough re-election fight next year, appeared with GOP Gov. Brian Sandoval at a news conference recently and said he opposes the health bill. Republican Gov. John Kasich of Ohio has said the bill’s opioid-addiction measures don’t go far enough, and he said he has conveyed his worries to the state’s GOP senator, Rob Portman. Arkansas Republican Gov. Asa Hutchinson said he has spoken to his state’s GOP senators, Tom Cotton and John Boozman, almost daily about his concerns with the bill.



And as we noted earlier, Bannon and the populist wing of the Trump administration is considering pushing for higher taxes on the wealthy – an issue that’s anathema to Republicans. With gridlock remaining the status quo in Washington, the Treasury has already begun holding larger cash balances in anticipation of deadlock, hoping to forestall the inevitable market shock should Congress blow past the CBO’s mid-October deadline.



The Treasury breached its debt limit on March 16, when the debt ceiling was reset to $19.8 trillion, however, so far there has been no new borrowing authority to surpass it. Since then the Treasury has been using so-called “extraordinary measures,” to pay bills without technically adding to the debt amount However, as Mnuchin has warned, many worry that waiting until the last minute to act on the debt ceiling could provoke a dramatic selloff in US stocks. Who knows? Maybe the debt-ceiling fight will be the straw that finally breaks the back of our ridiculously overvalued equity market. 

Friday, June 23, 2017

The Passing Of The Pelosi Era

Authored by Patrick Buchanan via Buchanan.org,


In the first round of the special election for the House seat in Georgia’s Sixth District, 30-year-old Jon Ossoff swept 48 percent. He more than doubled the vote of his closest GOP rival, Karen Handel.


A Peach State pickup for the Democrats and a huge humiliation for President Trump seemed at hand.


But in Tuesday’s final round, Ossoff, after the most costly House race in history, got 48 percent again, and lost. If Democratic donors are grabbing pitchforks, who can blame them?


And what was Karen Handel’s cutting issue?


Ossoff lived two miles outside the district and represented the values of the Democratic minority leader, whom he would vote to make the speaker of the house, Nancy Pelosi of San Francisco.


The Pelosi factor has been a drag on Democrats in all four of the special elections the party has lost since Trump’s November triumph.


Prediction: Democrats will not go into the 2018 Congressional elections with San Fran Nan as the party’s face and future. No way. As President Kennedy said, “Sometimes party loyalty asks too much.”


Post-Trump, it is hard to see Republicans returning to NAFTA-GATT free-trade globalism, open borders, mass immigration or Bushite crusades for democracy. A cold realism about America’s limited power and potential to change the world has settled in.


And just as Trump put Bush-Romney Republicanism into the dumpster in the 2016 primaries, Hillary Clinton’s defeat, followed by losses in four straight special elections, portend a passing of the guard in the Democratic Party.


So where is the party going?


Clearly, the energy and fire are on the Bernie Sanders-Elizabeth Warren left. Moreover, the crudity of party chair Tom Perez’s attacks on Trump and the GOP, being echoed now by Democratic members of Congress, suggest that the new stridency to rally the angry left is gaining converts.


Trump’s rough rhetoric, which brought out the alienated working class in the ten of thousands to his rallies, is being emulated by “progressives” — imitation being the sincerest form of flattery.


Nor is this unusual. After narrow presidential defeats, major parties have often taken a hard turn back toward their base.


After Richard Nixon lost narrowly to JFK in 1960, the Republican right blamed his “me-too” campaign, rose up and nominated Barry Goldwater in 1964. A choice, not an echo.


After Hubert Humphrey lost narrowly to Nixon in 1968, the Democratic Party took a sharp turn to the left in 1972 and nominated George McGovern.


A 21st-century variant of McGovernism seems be in the cards for Democrats today. The salient positions of the party have less to do with bread-and-butter issues than identity politics, issues of race, gender, morality, culture, ethnicity and class.


Same-sex marriage, abortion rights, sanctuary cities, Black Lives Matter, racist cops, La Raza, bathroom rights, tearing down Confederate statues, renaming streets, buildings and bridges to remove any association with slave-owners or segregationists, putting sacred tribal lands ahead of pipelines, and erasing the name of the Washington Redskins.


The Democrats’ economic agenda?


Free tuition for college kids, forgiveness of student loan debt, sticking it to Wall Street and the 1 percent, and bailing out Puerto Rico.


And impeachment — though a yearlong FBI investigation has failed to find any Trump-Kremlin collusion to dethrone Debbie Wasserman Schultz or expose the debate-question shenanigans of Donna Brazile.


And where are the Democratic successes since Obamacare?


The cities where crime is surging, Baltimore and Chicago, have been run for decades by Democrats. The worst-run state in the nation, Illinois, has long been dominated by Democratic legislators.


The crisis of the old order is apparent as well across the pond.


Jeremy Corbyn, a Bernie Sanders radical socialist, led his party to major gains in the recent parliamentary elections, as Conservative Prime Minister Theresa May saw her majority wiped out and faces the same seditionist grumbling as Nancy Pelosi.


Western elites are celebrating the victory of Emmanuel Macron, the “youngest French President since Napoleon,” who defeated Marine Le Pen by a ratio of almost 2-to-1 and whose new party, En Marche! (In Motion!), captured the Assembly. But the celebrating seems premature.


For the first time in the history of De Gaulle’s Fifth Republic, neither the center-left Socialists nor center-right Republicans, the parties that have ruled France for 60 years, made it into the finals in a presidential election.


And while the first round of that election saw the ruling Socialist Party’s candidate run fifth, with 6 percent, the votes of the rightist Le Pen and far left-Communist Jean-Luc Melenchon together topped 40 percent. It is the flanks of European politics that seem still to be hard and growing, and the center that seems shaky and imperiled.


Moreover, Macron faces daunting problems. Unemployment is nearly 10 percent, with youth unemployment twice that. Terrorist attacks from within Muslim communities continue to rise, as do the number of boats of Third Worlders migrating from across the Med.


Can anyone believe that, as these trends continue, Europeans will continue to back centrist policies and moderate politicians to deal with them?


Dream on. That is not the history of Europe.

Tuesday, June 20, 2017

Things To Watch As Voters Head To The Polls In Georgia's Special Election

Democrats have gone "all-in" on the 30-year-old documentary film-maker and former congressional aide, Jon Ossoff, to win Georgia"s 6th Congressional district.   Over the past several months, they have repeatedly portrayed the runoff as a referendum on the Trump administration and a preview of the 2018 mid-terms .  Now, as voters head to the polls today, the question is whether their gamble will payoff...certainly, given the amount of money they"ve spent, anything less than a victory will be yet another stinging defeat for Democrats.


The contest for Georgia"s 6th district pits Democrat Jon Ossoff against Republican Karen Handel in a race that has drawn national attention and historic levels of spending.  As The Mercury News has pointed out, this race has been the costliest in the history of Congressional races with Ossoff raising over $23 million.  Ironically, he received nearly 9x more donations from California than from Georgia, a testament to how this special election has morphed into a national contest for Democrats.





Between March 29 and May 31, Ossoff reported receiving 7,218 donations from California, dwarfing the 808 donations he received from Georgia. In the nine Bay Area counties alone, he received 3,063 donations in the same time period.



Those are only a fraction of Ossoff’s total donations, as he doesn’t have to report contributions from people who give less than $200 in total. In addition, many of the individual donations include the same people giving to his campaign multiple times.



According to the Real Clear Politics average, Handel"s support has surged in recent days making the race a dead heat heading into election day. That said, just like last November, we would be shocked if there weren"t some "oversamples" in the polling data. 


RCP



For those not familiar with the district, Georgia"s 6th is located just north of Atlanta and has been controlled by Republicans since 1979.  In fact, it is the same seat that was held by former Speaker Newt Gingrich from 1979 - 1999.  And while the district had been a stronghold for Republican presidential candidates, Trump just narrowly bested Clinton in 2016.


GA



Of course, with Republicans holding a substantial majority in the House, today"s election will have minimal practical ramifications in the near term.  Moreover, while the winning party will undoubtedly cast the results as a perfect predictor of how the 2018 mid-terms will play out, Nate Silver of FiveThirtyEight notes that anything short of a blowout will provide minimal insight into the next election cycle.





“If either Democrat Jon Ossoff or Republican Karen Handel wins narrowly, it will be portrayed as a more important predictive signal than it really is. If either Handel or Ossoff wins by more than about 5 percentage points — which is entirely possible given the historic (in)accuracy of special election polls — you can dispense with some of the subtlety in interpreting the results, especially if the South Carolina outcome tells a similar story. Otherwise, Tuesday’s results probably ought to be interpreted with a fair amount of caution — and they probably won’t be."



With that intro, here are The Hill"s "things to watch" as voting gets underway:





1.  Will the huge turnout trend continue?


While special elections typically convince few voters to head to the polls, the outsized attention on the Georgia special election has led to booming turnout.



During April’s primary election, 194,000 voters cast their ballot, with 57,000 of those votes coming early.



More than 143,000 voters have already voted early for Tuesday’s matchup between Ossoff and Handel, a figure that means the runoff turnout will likely eclipse that of the April primary. Some observers say Tuesday’s figures could even surpass the number of people who voted in the district for the 2014 midterm election.



Strategists in the state expect Handel to do significantly better with the early vote compared to April’s primary, when she was competing against nearly a dozen Republicans.



Ossoff will also need to have strong early-vote numbers, especially since Republicans historically do better with Election Day turnout.



Will GOP strongholds and white women save Handel?



2.  Can Ossoff flip Republican moderates and turn out black voters?


 While Ossoff won easily in April’s first round of voting with 17 other candidates, more voters backed a Republican than a Democrat. So with turnout already looking high, experts believe Ossoff needs to increase his margin by about 6,000 or more votes to be in good shape.



Ossoff also has to turn out black voters, whose enthusiasm flagged in 2016 after being a reliable voting bloc during Obama’s two elections. The Democratic hopeful went to several events on Saturday with Rep. John Lewis (D-Ga.), a civil rights icon, to celebrate Juneteenth, which commemorates the abolition of slavery.



3.  Can Democrats keep outperforming Clinton?


 While Democrats have failed to flip any Republican seats in special elections this year, they have seen one promising trend — candidates keep outperforming Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton’s 2016 margins.



4.  What does the vote mean for Trump’s agenda?


 The record-setting spending, the furious jockeying between national parties and the occasional cameos from Hollywood celebrities are all happening for one reason: Trump.



With few electoral opportunities between Trump’s election and the 2018 midterms, the suburban Atlanta congressional seat has become the closest thing to a referendum on Trump’s agenda.



Democrats want to frame their excitement and fundraising as a result of anti-Trump frustration, so a win for them will be seen as a victory over Trump.



If Ossoff wins, look for Democrats to seize on that message as a warning shot for 2018. An Ossoff victory could dampen the spirits of GOP donors, convince more politicians to break from their president and trigger retirements by Republican lawmakers fearing a tough reelection fight.



So how will it all turn out?  Will Democrats hand Trump his first big loss and a taste of what is to come in 2018 or, just like in November, did the Dems just spend an obscene amount of money for absolutely nothing?

Friday, April 7, 2017

Republican 'Confidence' Surges To 9 Year Highs, Democrat 'Hope' Crashes

Bloomberg"s consumer comfort index continues to rise post-Trump to new cycle highs but not everyone"s happy. There is a very clear - and growing - partisan divergence...


Republicans have not been this comfortable since January 2008, having soared since the election. Democrats, on the other hand, are the most uncomfortable since Dec 2015.



In fact the level of partisan disagreement is the highest since February 2009 and shows no signs of turning around.


Since the election the Republican-Democrat divide has swung from over 14pts in favor of Dems to almost 14pts in favor of Reps - the fastest swing in sentiment in the survey"s history.

Friday, March 10, 2017

Republicans' Consumer Confidence Is At 9 Year Highs (Democrats Not So Much)

Bloomberg"s consumer comfort index surged to the highest level since its peak in February 2007. However, while Republicans are the happiest since 2008, Democrats" confidence is collapsing...




But the divided America is extremely evident. Republican consumers in America have not been this "comfortable" since January 2008, Democrats are the least "comfortable" in 10 months.



The last time Democrats" consumer comfort plunged like this
relative to Republicans was in September 2013, when President Obama
authorized the use of force against Syria (over crossing his chemical
weapons red line).

Monday, March 6, 2017

In Latest Poll, Americans Can't Even Agree What It Means To be An American

As if there was not enough dividing America right now - Left/Right, Male/Female/Other, Black/White, Muslin/Non-Muslim, or Gay/Straight/Other - AP finds in its latest poll that Americans can"t even agree on what it means to be an American.


A new survey from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research finds Republicans are far more likely to cite a culture grounded in Christian beliefs and the traditions of early European immigrants as essential to U.S. identity. Democrats are more apt to point to the country"s history of mixing of people from around the globe and a tradition of offering refuge to the persecuted. While there"s disagreement on what makes up the American identity, 7 in 10 people — regardless of party — say the country is losing that identity.



There are some points of resounding agreement among Democrats, Republicans and independents about what makes up the country"s identity. Among them: a fair judicial system and rule of law, the freedoms enshrined in the Constitution, and the ability to get good jobs and achieve the American dream.


But big gulfs emerged between the left and right on other characteristics seen as inherent to America.


About 65% of Democrats said a mix of global cultures was extremely or very important to American identity, compared with 35% of Republicans. 29% of Democrats saw Christianity as that important, compared with 57% of Republicans. Democrats are far more likely than Republicans to say that the ability of people to come to escape violence and persecution is very important, 74% to 55%. Also, 25% of Democrats said the culture of the country"s early European immigrants isvery important, versus 46% of Republicans.


Respondents answers demonstrate the divisions:





"It"s such stark divisions," said Lynele Jones, a 65-year-old accountant in Boulder, Colorado. "There"s so much turmoil in the American political situation right now. People"s ideas of what is America"s place in the world are so different from one end of the spectrum to the other."



"If you lose your identity," Reggie Lawrence, a 44-year-old Republican in Midland, Texas, who runs a business servicing oil fields, said, "What are we? We"re not a country anymore."



"Our sense of identity is almost inseparable from the subject of immigration because it"s how we were built," said Patrick Miller, a political science professor at the University of Kansas who studies partisanship and polling. "Given what we are and how we"ve come about, it"s a very natural debate."



The poll found Democrats were nearly three times as likely as Republicans to say that the U.S. should be a country made up of many cultures and values that change as new people arrive, with far more Republicans saying there should be an essential American culture that immigrants adopt. Republicans overwhelmingly viewed immigrants who arrived in the past decade as having retained their own cultures and values rather than adopting American ones. Among the areas seen as the greatest threats to the American way of life, Democrats coalesce around a fear of the country"s political leaders, political polarization and economic inequality. Most Republicans point instead to illegal immigration as a top concern.


The results reflect long-standing differences in the U.S. between one camp"s desire for openness and diversity and another"s vision of the country grounded in the white, English-speaking, Protestant traditions of its early settlers.

Friday, February 10, 2017

Federal Judge Just Struck Major Blow Against Two-Party System: Media Silent

Submitted by Carey Wedler via TheAntiMedia.org,


Last week, a federal judge provided a long overdue victory for alternative political parties in the United States. The ruling found the Federal Election Commission (FEC), the institution that oversees the Commission on Presidential Debates, failed to sufficiently examine evidence challenging two-party dominance in national debates.  The judge asserted there was no evidence “that the FEC considered the relevant factors or took a hard look at the evidence.”



The ruling, issued in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia, focused on a 2014 complaint regarding the 2012 election filed by the non-profit organization Level the Playing Field. It also focused on objections from the Green Party and Libertarian Party (which were dismissed by a federal judge last year). According to Buzzfeed News, one of the few mainstream outlets to cover the ruling, there were two main elements:





“The first part involves the FEC’s dismissal of two administrative complaints claiming the debate commission and its directors violated election laws by engaging in partisan activity in support of the Democratic and Republican parties. The Green Party, Libertarian Party, and other challengers presented evidence that commission directors contributed to candidates and made statements supporting particular parties.”



The second part focused on Level the Playing Field’s request “that the FEC revise its rules to block the the commission from using a polling threshold to decide participation in presidential and vice-presidential debates.” The commission requires that a candidate receive 15% support or higher in five national polls in order to be invited to the debates. Level the Playing Field’s request was denied, and in response, the group compiled analysis from experts, who highlighted “the hundreds of millions of dollars a candidate would have to spend to meet the 15 percent polling target, and argued that the rule was not an objective criteria.”


They claimed “it was specifically designed to keep out candidates not affiliated with the Republican or Democratic parties,” Buzzfeed explained.


The Commission on Presidential Debates, a faction of the Federal Election Commission, has been criticized for these biases before. The commission’s board of directors has overt partisan leanings. As the International Business Times has noted:





“The Commission On Presidential Debates board is currently chaired by Frank J. Fahrenkopf Jr. and Michael D. McCurry. Fahrenkopf is a former chairman for the Republican National Committee and McCurry was press secretary under President Bill Clinton.”



As journalist Ben Swann astutely explained during the 2012 election:





“So let’s be clear: a debate commission that’s run by former bigwigs from the Republican and Democrat parties and creates a 15% polling rule in five national polls isn’t trying to create inclusion — they’re trying to prevent it. If you don’t have the money of the two big parties, getting your name out nationally to get into those polls, well, it can only happen if you’re a billionaire like Ross Perot. Aside from billionaires, no one else has a chance.”



Level the Playing Field’s suit further alleged that members of the board had conflicts of interest because of their political contributions. Judge Tanya Chutkan further documented the commission’s biases in her summary opinion:





“Moreover, Fahrenkopf has stated that the CPD was not likely to look with favor on including third-party candidates in the debates, and Kirk has stated that he personally believed the CPD should exclude third-party candidates from the debates.”



She also acknowledged the commission’s inherent commitment to the two-party system:





“The CPD is ‘bipartisan’ by its own description: the press release announcing its formation stated that it was a ‘bipartisan . . . organization formed to implement joint sponsorship of general election presidential and vice-presidential debates . . . by the national Republican and Democratic committees between their respective nominees.’”



Ultimately, she ruled that the FEC “failed to show that it properly considered all of the evidence and arguments presented by the challengers” when it was supposed to review its rules in 2014. She called that rejection “arbitrary, capricious, and contrary to law,” asserting that “the evidence unaddressed – or outright ignored – by the FEC is quite substantial.” She also pointed out the FEC’s “refusal to engage in thoughtful, reasoned decision-making in either enforcement or rulemaking in this case.”


Chutkan ordered the commission to review its previous decision and gave them 30 days to do so. According to Peter Ackerman, Level the Playing Field’s founder, the decision “lays the groundwork for removing the primary obstacle to providing Americans with the independent alternative to the two parties that polls clearly indicate they want.“


Alexandra Shapiro, a lawyer for the plaintiffs, praised the decision, pointing out that it “marked the first time the FEC and CPD have been successfully challenged over debate rules. This is an enormously important ruling.”


“It could pave the way for a new kind of election in 2020,” she said.


In an age where Americans are increasingly dissatisfied with the options the political establishment provides them, this small but vital ruling could signal a turning point when it comes to promoting exposure for presidential candidates who are not members of the country’s two-party duopoly.


Unsurprisingly, according to Buzzfeed, the FEC declined to comment on Judge Chutkan’s ruling.

Thursday, December 15, 2016

Why The Democrats Can't Let Go Of Losing

Submitted by Charles Hugh Smith via OfTwoMinds blog,


The Democratic Party has become everything it once was against.


Let"s get one thing straight right at the start: criticizing the Democratic Party and its ruling elites is not the same as "supporting Trump."


The either-or accusation is a classic propaganda technique to silence dissent. During the Vietnam War, for example, anyone dissenting against the official narratives supporting the war was accused of "supporting the Communists." In other words, criticizing the Powers That Be or their narrative is treason.


This either-or choice was designed to silence dissent by eliminating the possibility that domestic critics had valid reasons to disagree with the war that had nothing to do with Communism and everything to do with America.


Now we hear the same propaganda technique being wielded by Democrats: any criticism of the Democratic Party is "supporting Trump."


Hogwash. Any institution that can"t accept achingly obvious critiques is doomed. Resilient, confident people and organizations welcome fair criticism, as honest criticism (i.e. intended to improve performance and understanding) is essential to the process of successful adaptation to changing conditions.


So now that we"ve got that straightened out--criticism isn"t necessarily support for "the other side," it stands or falls on its own merits--let"s nail down why the Democratic Party didn"t live up to expectations in the election.


And we"re not talking about the presidential race, in which the Democrats scored a substantial advantage in the popular vote--we"re talking to the entire election results: state legislatures, the House of Representatives and the Senate.


The Democrats picked up two senate seats and eight in the House, three of which were vacant. Democrats lost the majority in the Senate in 2014 and in the House in 2010, so the the 2016 election was a continuation of a trend begun six years ago.


United States Congress elections, 2016


Why has the nation turned away from the Democratic Party? Perhaps one reason is that the Democratic Party has become everything it once was against.


George McGovern"s 1972 campaign slogan was Come home, America. The current version of the Democratic Party never met a globalist treaty or agenda that it didn"t approve.


The Democratic Party turned anti-war after Lyndon Johnson"s withdrawal from the 1968 race; the current version of the Democratic Party has embraced endless war via proxies, drones and Special Forces--they support interventions and unlimited violence in other nations, as long as American combat deaths are few and far between.


In years past, the Democratic Party presented itself as the party of "the working people" against the business interests of banks and corporations. The current version of the Democratic Party has embraced big banks, financiers, billionaires and corporations, cozying up to Big Money for hundreds of millions in campaign contributions and Super-PAC funding.


Former President Bill Clinton and his wife Hillary earned $230 million between 2001 (when they left the White House) and 2015. How The Clintons Have Made $230 Million Since Leaving The White House (Forbes). Their foundation has collected some $2 billion, and the foundation"s track record of large donations from non-U.S. players and its modest charitable effectiveness has opened questions about pay-for-play.


As for supporting "the working people"--Hillary"s comment about "deplorables" summed up the unspoken view of the Democratic Party elites.


The Democratic Party has become everything that it once loathed: elitist, globalist, interventionist, self-serving, warmongering and overflowing with hubris.


To avoid looking at their reflection honestly, humans project their own failures and destructive traits onto others, blaming others for their own faults. They justify their self-serving actions, and deny responsibility for their clearly self-destructive behaviors.


This describes the Democratic Party elites to a T. It"s all Trump"s fault, or the Russian hackers, or the "deplorables"--anyone but themselves.


Not that long ago, the Republican Party was being dragged toward a shallow grave -- a party drained of ideas and ideals. Trump"s campaign bypassed the Republican Party"s self-serving, hubris-soaked elites, and whether the party will survive the internecine warfare between the Trump camp and the Old Guard remains an open question.


If the Democratic Party clings to elitism, indignation, denial and self-justification, it will be digging its own shallow grave beside the one awaiting the Republican Party should it fail to embrace practical, affordable solutions to the stagnation of opportunity and rising inequality.